Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can't afford to fix fence

113 replies

mommaneedssleep · 22/03/2022 19:50

Been going through a tough time financially recently (like many people!). Our electricity bill has more than doubled, nursery and school club have both put their prices up. Basically we are being stretched further than we can manage. We've been trying to cut down where we can and have done some drastic measures to bring bills down such as getting rid of one car ect.
Our fence broke in the bad storms we had in February, we live in a long line of Victorian terraced houses and the fence that has broken is our responsibility. With everything else currently going on we just can't afford to get it iced. It requires 2 new fence panels and 3 of the posts. Neighbour has come round tonight asking when we are getting it fixed. I explained that at the moment we aren't able to but will try to do it over the summer. They said that as the weather is getting nicer they now need to paint their side and get their trellises planted ect so need it doing asap.
I understand that it must be annoying for them, but I really can't afford to do it at the moment. To be clear there is no gap or fallen fences ect, the fence is still standing but is just bowed (if that's the right word??) to one side.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Factsmatter · 16/02/2024 15:29

The neighbours need YOUR permission to paint YOUR fence or attach anything to it! Make sure they’re aware of that! So the other option could be that if THEY offer to fix the fence, you’ll let them paint the side facing them.. :)

Doris86 · 06/04/2022 13:15

Buy two fence panels and 3 posts, and you’ll have change from £100. Easy DIY job, and massively cheaper than getting a fencing company to do it.

That said you’re under no obligation to fix it if you don’t want to. Your neighbours can sort it if it bothers them so much.

MuggleMadness · 23/03/2022 17:36
Do nothing. You're not obliged to!

Sorted for £0

Lillyhatesjaz · 23/03/2022 15:59

You can get things called fence buddies. They are strips of metal you put in either side of the broken post and it supports the old post to prevent buying a new one. They are really good and much cheaper than replacing fence

whynotwhatknot · 23/03/2022 12:10

I just love that they want you to pay for a fence so they can paint it there side

bloody cheeky fucks

Like i said its not a legal requirement so just ignore

Madmog · 23/03/2022 10:41

Some homes don't have walls or fences on their boundary. I'd go back and explain you're not being awkward but just haven't got the money. If you've still got the old fence and posts if there any way they can work with you to get them temporarily into place. If they keep going on, I'd be tempted to get some strong wire and hooks and define the boundary that way. You are not obliged to provide a fence so they can have trellising.

Chely · 23/03/2022 10:35

Unless they are willing to pay for it doing they will have to wait until you can afford to do it.
I would understand the urgency if the fence was in such a state it was likely to fall and injure someone.

Kaibashira · 23/03/2022 10:26

Urgh fence wankers.

If they won't pay for it (because not their fence), they don't get to paint it or fix anything to it. You can stop that very clear- "even if we replace the fence it belongs to us and you may not paint it".

There is nothing to stop them from putting up their own fence within their boundary and doing whatever the fuck they like with it.

Ariela · 23/03/2022 09:49

Oops sorry I priced for 3 panels, not 3, so taking off the excess = £245 & post set

FloBot7 · 23/03/2022 09:49

If it bothers them that much, they can pay to fix it. Our neighbours were going through a tough time financially when our fence was damaged so we just asked if they'd mind if we got someone in ourselves as all three sides needed replacing anyway. I wouldn't have dared put them under pressure when they were already struggling with essential bills.

Ariela · 23/03/2022 09:47

We always replace fence panels ourselves, it is by far the cheapest way.

Over the years we now have one of these for removing the soil from the hole
www.wickes.co.uk/Wickes-Post-Hole-Digger---1480mm/p/190347

We use these concrete slotted fence posts: www.wickes.co.uk/Wickes-Slotted-Concrete-Fence-Post---100-x-60mm-x-2-4m/p/540063
with these concrete gravel boards:
www.wickes.co.uk/Wickes-Recessed-Concrete-Gravel-Board---50mm-X-300mm-X-1-83m/p/151501

The key is to measure correctly, and it does need 2 of you - one to hold the post - use the concrete gravel board in situ to get the correct spacing and a , the other to measure carefully and reposition post if needed then to shovel post set in the hole, but once done these concrete posts last forever!

Then for fence panels, it does need 2 of you to lift in, as you have to lift above the post to get into the slot - but once in place, they stay in place for years as the posts don't rot and sag.
Wickes do fence panels from £29.50 for 6ft ones. So 3 panels , 3 gravel boards, 4 posts and a post hole digger total £336.50. Plus a couple of bags of post set (about £6 each), plus a spirit level - but you can download one and use your phone, not as good as it is shorter so less easy to use. Should take you 3 hours max. If you could get an extra helper, then even easier/quicker.

Hathertonhariden · 23/03/2022 09:12

Take the panel out replace it with a couple of small hedging plants. If they ask say that as funds allow you are going to replace the fence panels with hedges as it's greener, better for wildlife and as a hedge won't blow down in a storm it will stop this happening in the future.

At some point in the future when you have the money available you may of course change your mind but you don't tell them that.

nettie434 · 23/03/2022 08:27

@Leftbutcameback

Insurance basically never covers fences. Which is annoying. Around our way after the storms there is no fencing available and everyone is booked up for ages so you wouldn't be able to do it even if you could afford it. We're in a very similar situation but it's a joint fence.
Was going to say this too. Storm damage is normally specifically excluded.
queenMab99 · 23/03/2022 08:27

My neighbours don't like my fence, it is fairly old, some mismatched panels, which doesn't suit their garden which they have recently had 'landscaped' at great expense, however it keeps my dog in my garden, and on my side is covered in roses, and clematis. They requested that I get it replaced, I refused as it would cost well over £1k, so I just replace/repair any storm damage as it happens. I am in my 70s and have some savings, but not enough to splurge on fencing so that their newly built garden room and bar have opulent surroundings🧐

HomeHomeInTheRange · 23/03/2022 08:24

“Hi neighbours, we’ve been looking into the fence issue and will fix it when we are able. But just to let you know that you would understand able to paint or put trellis on our fence anyway, so if you want to get on with your garden works you might be best sorting that out on your side of the boundary”

Sistanotcista · 23/03/2022 08:11

@IncompleteSenten

Stay firm. I cannot afford it. I will be doing it if and when I can but my children have this nasty habit of needing food and they are a bit more important than a fence.
GrinSmile
billy1966 · 23/03/2022 08:10

@rwalker

Tell them you are doing without a fence and will be taking it down shortly
This.

Tell them you will be replacing it as it falls down with hedge.

To emphasis the point buy a couple of TINY hedge plants and place them near fence.

They shouldn't be hanging trellises on your fence weakening it.

They probably have damaged it.

Dont apologise, they are CF's.

stuntbubbles · 23/03/2022 08:09

@saleorbouy

I'd be weary of neighbours putting up another fence on their own land as some have recommended. Moving the boundary line can cause havoc when selling a property especially if the deeds are not amended and the fence is not erected on the original boundary division. As a scenario, moaning neighbour erects fence on their property and puts up trellis but it is not legally recorded. OP removes their fences as it dilapidates. Over the years the boundary between the properties naturally moves to the new fence erected and owned by the neighbour. OP wants to sell but boundary line is not correct on the drawings, they also state that OP legally owns fence, not the neighbour. House sale flounders as boundary, land and ownership are not clearly defined. Solicitors make lots of money as boundary and fence ownership are contested. Please ensure any boundary and fence, wall hedge ownership are correctly recorded.
Realistically most title deeds don’t show boundaries down to the millimetre, or even down to the foot – it’s a smudged endlessly photocopied and scanned old drawing; a fence that follows the same line, an inch to the left of where it used to be, isn’t even going to be noticed. Even less so a hedge as the stems may have been planted to follow the boundary but hedges grow!
THisbackwithavengeance · 23/03/2022 08:03

I think it's nice to plan all these scenarios of revenge and tit for tat... we all do it.

However, given that you have to live next door to these people and potentially declare disputes if you move, I would steer clear of deliberately trying to piss them off.

I would nod and smile and explain that money is tight and there is a shortage of workmen available; do they have any suggestions as you are conscious that the boundary looks unsightly? Perhaps they have a workman friend or know someone who is handy?

However, I would recommend getting the best fence you can possibly afford. We used to have shitty cheap fences that came down at every minor gale. We invested in some concrete implanted motherfuckers at ££stupid but they've survived 6 years of gales and storms so far so it's been a long term financial win.

PlumpAndDeliciousFatcat · 23/03/2022 08:02

They have very foolishly shot themselves in the foot with the painting and trellis thing.

I would write back, thanking them for clarifying ownership of the fence with the deeds. You will replace the fence panels at some point but as this is your fence you expressly do not give them permission to paint it or attach anything to it. Should they want a fence which they can paint and attach trellis to, you suggest that they erect their own on their side of the boundary.

Reastie · 23/03/2022 07:38

Tell her it is still providing an effective barrier and you will replace once you have the funds. If it’s not to their suiting, they are welcome to pay for a replacement themselves.

KosherDill · 23/03/2022 07:38

@FangsForTheMemory

I would tell them you're actually planning to plant a hedge as it's better for the environment and that if they specifically want a fence, they can put it in themselves.

This!

I'd remove the panels just to thwart them.

gazprom · 23/03/2022 07:37

yes, I have done fences myself and I've found Wickes the best price (the local timber yards are weirdly much more expensive) for the lapped panels whereas Toolstation is the cheapest for post fixings.

Seriously, a mallet and a post driver and a ladder and decent spade and pickaxe should do the job

burnthur5t · 23/03/2022 07:33

If you leave it until you can afford it you never know, they might get so pissed off in the meantime that they replace it!