Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS food intake

34 replies

Maxter · 22/03/2022 13:58

My DS7 (nearly 8) is very slim. You can sort of see shoulder blades, ribs, spine etc). He is picky eater. My ex (DS') dad is arguing that he must be taken to the GP immediately. I know for a fact that DS' actual weight is ok because he was weighed recently at a hospital appointment for something else and they said it was fine.

Could anyone shed any light on how much their 7/8 year olds eat in any one day?

I don't know if I'm being unreasonable by saying to my ex that I don't think he needs to go to the GP, but it would be helpful to see what other people think / how much their children eat.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Notimeforaname · 23/03/2022 14:51

Nothing wrong with seeing some rib or shoulder blades.
I hear lots of people nowadays commenting that seeing any sort of bone is wrong and absolutely means underweight. Hmm

Your child sounds fine. Your ex can start making medical appointments if he wishes but all sounds good on your end. Carry on as you are. Smile

Idiotintraining · 23/03/2022 14:43

Breakfast nutrigrain bar
Lunch school
After school fruit or chocolate
Dinner cooked or sandwich depending on day
Pudding ice cream or youghurt or fruit

Try and talk him out of anything else as he had already eaten loads as it is

I will add he dosent like vegetables won't even try them. Even hidden ones. And yes before anyone says anything I have tried and tried but he has a crying fit and won't eat anything no matter how much I try. Last one lasted for an hour.

Heckythump1 · 22/03/2022 19:23

[quote Maxter]@PinkyU No his dad has never attended any medical appointment.
DS weight was 24kg and height 128cm which I believe is ok.
Yes have told his dad the measurements but he's not accepting it because DS is very slim and doesn't eat much. [/quote]
At that height and weight he's not remotely underweight! Perfectly healthy weight for his height :)

My 6.5 year old is 122cm and 19.5kg, she's just on the edge of underweight and healthy weight. She's very slim and willowly, but I don't think she looks unhealthly thin.

redbigbananafeet · 22/03/2022 19:15

[quote Maxter]@Krakenchorus He's insisting that I take him. [/quote]
Tell him to take him. If he doesn't believe what you're telling him the hospital said he won't believe what you tell him the GP says either. "If you want DS to see a GP then take him." Every time. Rinse, lather, repeat. There's zero point in ask what other kids eat.

Krakenchorus · 22/03/2022 16:26

[quote Maxter]@Krakenchorus He's insisting that I take him. [/quote]
Sorry- What a tool he sounds. Ignore him, then. Hand him the GP's contact details and tell him to crack on if he is concerned.

SkankingMopoke · 22/03/2022 16:15

DD1 is nearly 8 and very skinny. There's no fat on her at all (she gets very cold very quickly as a result), but she's quite muscly and very active (you can see a six pack in the morning before she's had breakfast). Like your DS you can see her ribs/spine/shoulder blades very clearly, but the most noticeably skinny parts are her arms and legs. They are like very thin twiglets! She's not much into snacks, but eats really well at meals, so I just make sure she's getting plenty of calories in each meal.
A typical school day would be:
Bowl of cornflakes, a bagel with cashew butter, a kiwi, and half an apple for breakfast.
Cheese, avocado and pickle sandwich, crisps, a carrot, a chunk of cucumber, satsuma, and a jam tart for lunch.
A few crackers after school.
2 x fajitas with peppers, kidney beans, fried tofu, sour cream, salsa, and cheese for dinner followed by a yoghurt.

She is naturally skinny, but I know when that drops to 'worryingly skinny' IYKWIM - I'm sure you're the same OP. If you are confident all is OK, I'd suggest exH takes him to the GP.

HectorGloop · 22/03/2022 16:14

DD is 7, 132cm and about 27 kg, so roughly 91st and 75th centiles. Slim but not skinny.

She's hungry in the morning so big bowl of cereal, sometimes a piece of toast too.
Lunch is small sandwich, an apple or piece of cucumber, small yoghurt, bag of crisps/other savoury snack, 1 biscuit.
Dinner is usual spag bol/chilli/meat & 2 veg type fare. She doesn't eat much meat but will have veg/carbs. Usually has a side plate sized portion. Dessert is a yoghurt or chocolate mousse.
She would eat snacks all day if allowed, but usually has a bagel or piece of toast after school.

Maxter · 22/03/2022 16:06

@Krakenchorus He's insisting that I take him.

OP posts:
Krakenchorus · 22/03/2022 16:03

If his Dad wants the child to see a GP, then he should absolutely take him. Why object? It seems reasonable for Dad to ask the GP if he has a concern.

It's not on you to take him if you aren't worried.

SpottyStripyDuvet · 22/03/2022 15:57

My DS is younger but is 23kg and 124cm so similar proportions. I think that you are supposed to be able to see their ribs.

Google the centre charts if you don't have his red book.

NewJersey · 22/03/2022 15:47

It’s sounds fine, not particularly skinny. Have you checked the centiles he’s on?

My kids would have ate a full sandwich for lunch and more for dinner at that age but all children eat different amounts. Assuming the sandwich and his dinner are nutritious most days and he seems well, I wouldn’t worry.

MaizeAmaze · 22/03/2022 15:31

He sounds like a great height and weight.
Double check on some centile charts or the NHS bmi thing, but I think your Ex has lost sight of what a healthy child looks like.

CheekyTanuki · 22/03/2022 15:00

DS is 7, 134cm and 26kg
I think he eats a lot.
Breakfast: 1 bowl of cereal, porridge or oatmeal smoothie. If we have bread he eats 3 pieces of toast with ham or jam or egg
Snack before lunch: 1 apple and a pack of darvida crackers
Lunch: this is our main meal because everyone comes home to eat. Usually a piece of fish or meat with potatoes or rice, plus vegetables and salad. DS eats the same or even more than me most days.
Then he snacks all afternoon. Mainly fruits or raw vegetables, salty pretzels, crackers, sweets, cookies etc.
Dinner: pasta dish or casserole. He has a big adult plate.
He eats like this almost every day, im not sure where it goes Smile

SallyWD · 22/03/2022 14:55

My son has just turned 9. He's very skinny compared to his friends. He doesn't have an ounce of flesh on him. He's a fussy eater and there are only a few things he'll eat. This is what he eats in a typical day (I know these food choices aren't ideal but I just need to get food in to him. Most food options he'll reject) :

Breakfast:
He'll have both a pain au chocolate and a couple of slices of toast or crumpets with Nutella

Lunch at school:
A couple of crackers with butter
A fruit yoyo
Some crisps
A Frube yogurt

After school snacks:
He's always starving after school. He'll have a couple of chocolate brioche or
pistachios and dried mango
Some dark chocolate

Dinner:
It's very hard to find meals he'll eat but he will have
Beans and cheese on toast with a boiled egg (not the yolk!)
Rice and chicken goujons
Yorkshire puddings, chicken and gravy
He'll very reluctantly have half a bowl of home made vegetable soup
1/4 pizza with olives

Desserts:
He'll eat an apple and yogurt
Sometimes I give him babies fruit puree and yogurt just to get some vitamins in to him

takealettermsjones · 22/03/2022 14:52

@Maxter

I'd say in one day DS eats

A brioche or one slice of toast for breakfast
An oat bar or some fruit for a snack
Half a sandwich / some crackers and small packet of crisps for lunch
A yoghurt and a biscuit for a snack
About 1/3 of an adult sized plate of dinner, no matter what it is
A yoghurt or something similar for a snack

My DD would eat that at nearly 2. I know that sounds judgemental but I'm not trying to be! I would accept GP/nutritionist advice in your position, just to be on the safe side!
SickAndTiredAgain · 22/03/2022 14:46

I would just tell his dad that he’s welcome to take him to the GP if he’s concerned, just as you would.
If he doesn’t want to take him himself and expects you do it, he’s clearly not that concerned and since you’ve been told recently that it’s fine, I’d ignore him.

Climbingthelaundrymountain · 22/03/2022 14:42

My 8 year old is extremely slim. Much more so than his siblings were at his age. They are and always have been healthy weights (as is ds2) but he is just much leaner.

For breakfast he has a bowl of shreddies or 2 slices of toast with peanut butter.

Snack is a banana or apple or satsuma.

Lunch will be a ham/cheese wrap, crisps, cucumber/pepper/carrots, fruit of some kind, a biscuit/cake/yoghurt. He usually eats all of this.

After school he has rice cakes or a bagel or something like that.

Dinner he eats whatever, he's not fussy but doesn't eat a lot for dinner. A small portion of spag Bol, chilli, roast dinner, enchiladas, halloumi pita. Something like that.

Maxter · 22/03/2022 14:35

@PinkyU No his dad has never attended any medical appointment.
DS weight was 24kg and height 128cm which I believe is ok.
Yes have told his dad the measurements but he's not accepting it because DS is very slim and doesn't eat much.

OP posts:
ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 22/03/2022 14:35

It's irrelevant what other children eat. They don't all need the same intake, even if they're the same age.

Let your ex take him to the GP and hear it from a qualified doctor that your son is fine.

redbigbananafeet · 22/03/2022 14:32

@Maxter

My DS7 (nearly 8) is very slim. You can sort of see shoulder blades, ribs, spine etc). He is picky eater. My ex (DS') dad is arguing that he must be taken to the GP immediately. I know for a fact that DS' actual weight is ok because he was weighed recently at a hospital appointment for something else and they said it was fine.

Could anyone shed any light on how much their 7/8 year olds eat in any one day?

I don't know if I'm being unreasonable by saying to my ex that I don't think he needs to go to the GP, but it would be helpful to see what other people think / how much their children eat.

Has the ex offered to take your son to GP? Let him. And the GP will hospital findings. End of time wasted discussion with ex.
PinkyU · 22/03/2022 14:28

What were his height and weight at the hospital appointment? Did his dad attend, have you told him what his measurements were at the appointment?

In reality very few parents have an accurate perspective of their child’s size so asking on here won’t necessarily help you.

Crimesean · 22/03/2022 14:23

DS is skinny, we were told by the paediatrician that as long as he's following the same trajectory on the centile chart, he's probably fine (unless it's over 90% apparently, which is almost always overweight). DS has followed the 25th for weight and 99th for height all his life, so we're not worried.

Can you check your DS's red book or medical records?

Maxter · 22/03/2022 14:23

He also refuses to eat anything that's not completely plain!

OP posts:
Maxter · 22/03/2022 14:21

I'd say in one day DS eats

A brioche or one slice of toast for breakfast
An oat bar or some fruit for a snack
Half a sandwich / some crackers and small packet of crisps for lunch
A yoghurt and a biscuit for a snack
About 1/3 of an adult sized plate of dinner, no matter what it is
A yoghurt or something similar for a snack

OP posts:
Wellthisiscrapeh · 22/03/2022 14:20

I’ll never forget when I was doing some paediatric top up training years ago, we were shown a photo of “undernourished children on a beach” from the 1950s.

Everyone nodded about how thin they looked, wasn’t it awful.

Then the paediatrician leading it said, “actually those children were the picture of health,” (it was from a medical textbook, “you are supposed to be able to see those bones in a healthy child, we’ve just become accustomed to seeing overweight children.”

Always stuck with me.