Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP Stops Me From Helping Others

280 replies

MySaturday · 22/03/2022 11:05

I like to think that I am a pretty generous spirit and will offer to help people out when I feel I am able to, even if it inconveniences me (within reason).
I always put my family's needs first and would not offer to do anything that causes them unreasonable disruption, but find that DP gets into a massive sulk if I offer to assist anyone in a way that could possibly disrupt usual service (I do all of the cooking, most of the housework and we share childcare duties but I do more because I work PT).

For example, I am on a list of people to take care of a friend's 2YO when she goes into labour with second child. This could happen soon and DP has just started worrying that we might have to take 2YO overnight (even though this is very unlikely and I have said that I will do everything and expect nothing from him if that is the case). This is quite an extreme example, he has sulked over far less.

He is always volunteering me to bake things for family get togethers, give lifts to people (he does not drive) and I always accommodate these things the best I can.
I genuinely can't work out who is being unreasonable here - so please let me know your thoughts!

YABU - you should not offer assistance to others
YANBU - if it is causing DP minimal disruption he shouldn't sulk over it

OP posts:
2Hot2Handle · 22/03/2022 13:05

If your long-term plan is to stay with your DP, then surely now is the time to make your position clear, before you put down roots/have DC and you’re stuck with the situation, as it currently is.
Sit your DP down and tell him that you love helping other people and will always help where you can. Reassure him that he needn’t worry; that you will ensure your welfare, mental health and relationship are looked after, but that you have room in your life for both.
Tell him that this includes doing things to help his family too, but that you’d expect him to check with you first, before volunteering your time (use a couple of examples regarding lifts and cooking, where this hasn’t been the case). After all, you’d never volunteer him for something without checking with him first, because it’s the decent thing to do and you’re a team.
These are all reasonable points and his reaction, will say a lot, as to whether he is capable of changing his behaviour.
If he sulks in future situations, remind him of your conversation and say you don’t like the sulking, as you’re allowed to spend your time how you like.

If he volunteers you again without asking, remind him of your conversation and ask him to apologise to the person he promised, for not checking with you first, as you’re unable to help them in this instance.

Basically, tell him he needs to change, then retrain him and see how you get on!

MySaturday · 22/03/2022 13:01

The default position is very much that DP does the washing up - I hate it and he does it every night. It is not a bonus and not exclusively for me, but I appreciate him doing it. I think it is important to appreciate things our other halves do for us.
He appreciates my cooking - he hates cooking and cannot do it, so if I am out he has a ready meal. He thanks me for doing the cooking (and other things that I do).

OP posts:
thebabynanny · 22/03/2022 13:00

@MySaturday

"The washing up isn't "for you" hmm Neither is getting a takeaway for the family because he doesn't like cooking!

So you are doing the housework, the driving, most of the childcare, going the extra mile to ensure his needs are all met and his routine isn't disrupted, doing favours for his family...
And he sometimes writes you a nice card?"

I don't think that your comments are very fair when I have clearly said that I am happy with how he shows affection.

Also, when I am doing the housework, cooking etc you make it sound like I am doing all of this for him but when he does the washing up or gets a take away this isn't something nice he does for me?

You said yourself, your DP doesn't want you to do anything for anyone else that would disrupt his usual service.

You do the majority of the work to keep your household running. You go the extra mile to ensure his needs are met. You always accommodate the favours he requires of you the best that you can.
In return, his contribution to the family is washing up, and occasionally a takeaway because he won't cook.

In what ways does he accommodate your needs? What does he do to go the extra mile for you?

You're his partner and the best you can say about him is that when he's not sulking about you not doing what he wants, he sometimes writes you a nice card.

andysgirl22 · 22/03/2022 12:59

Can i just say op you sound lovely natured please don't go changing yourself for the worse. X

Viviennemary · 22/03/2022 12:58

I wouldn't be happy with a random two year old landing at my house for an overnight stay. This needs to be agreed first.

Thelnebriati · 22/03/2022 12:58

Is he taking steps to manage his anxiety, or change in other ways? Would he learn to cook?

D0lphine · 22/03/2022 12:58

Sulking IS a means of control OP

whynotwhatknot · 22/03/2022 12:56

why is doing the washing up a favour he does bugger all else

D0lphine · 22/03/2022 12:55

@MySaturday

I definitely envisage a future together and generally speaking I just keep doing what I want to do and ignore the sulks. I am hoping that if I do this he will just get used to it! He is an anxious person who highly values a strong sense of routine and I think the sulking comes from a place of panic - but I always go the extra mile to ensure that his needs are met and his routine is not disrupted.
Fuck me this sounds like hard work!

You sound like you're talking about a child OP!

What does he do to look after you? Anything?

DisforDarkChocolate · 22/03/2022 12:53

Do, he's generous with your time when it makes him look good?

He sounds like a self-centered insecure arse hole to me.

arethereanyleftatall · 22/03/2022 12:53

I'd leave this thread if I were you op. You clearly cannot see anything wrong in your husband, and since everyone else can, all you're going to get is umpteen messages which will upset you. I don't think there's any way anyone can write it at the moment for you in a way you will understand.

Nanny0gg · 22/03/2022 12:52

@MySaturday

"The washing up isn't "for you" hmm Neither is getting a takeaway for the family because he doesn't like cooking!

So you are doing the housework, the driving, most of the childcare, going the extra mile to ensure his needs are all met and his routine isn't disrupted, doing favours for his family...
And he sometimes writes you a nice card?"

I don't think that your comments are very fair when I have clearly said that I am happy with how he shows affection.

Also, when I am doing the housework, cooking etc you make it sound like I am doing all of this for him but when he does the washing up or gets a take away this isn't something nice he does for me?

Because the default position is that you do it.

So when he does it, it's a bonus, not expected.

Nanny0gg · 22/03/2022 12:50

@MySaturday

I was expecting to get the bashing for not putting my DP above others all the time but it seems that he is getting the bashing here and I am a refrigerator / doormat Wink I appreciate that pretty much everyone agrees I should carry on helping others as and when I want to and not pay attention to DP's mean spirit less generous tendencies. I genuinely don't believe he is trying to control me. I should be clear that he does not actually stop me from doing what I want to do, I just get a bit fed up at being met with a wall of sulking (even if it is through anxiety) every time I am trying to help others on my own terms.
Does he sulk every time you go against his wishes?
Keepitonthedownlow · 22/03/2022 12:49

When women offer to do things for others it is part of being in a community and seeking connection with others. So the less you do the more socially isolated you can become. It's no different to a man saying you can't see your friends. You have needs and wants and he shouldn't dictate what you do with your time.

MySaturday · 22/03/2022 12:47

"The washing up isn't "for you" hmm
Neither is getting a takeaway for the family because he doesn't like cooking!

So you are doing the housework, the driving, most of the childcare, going the extra mile to ensure his needs are all met and his routine isn't disrupted, doing favours for his family...
And he sometimes writes you a nice card?"

I don't think that your comments are very fair when I have clearly said that I am happy with how he shows affection.

Also, when I am doing the housework, cooking etc you make it sound like I am doing all of this for him but when he does the washing up or gets a take away this isn't something nice he does for me?

OP posts:
arethereanyleftatall · 22/03/2022 12:46

And here we have Yet another woman who has to wait X number of years before the scales fall from her eyes, so she can finally divorce, and think 'why on Earth didn't I do that X years ago.'

aloris · 22/03/2022 12:46

It needs to be a balance. I know a couple of adult women who, when they were children, had mothers who did for everyone except their own family. These women were seen as "saints" by friends and the community, because they did so much for others, but their own children felt a little forgotten. So I think it's important to be open to evaluating, am I doing too much for people outside of my family, and not doing right by my family as a result?

Then other factors you would put into that, are (IMO) that women kind of have this underground network of helping each other that makes the world go around. When I had my youngest child, I had no family support, but I had a friend who was willing to care for my older children while I was in labor, so my husband could be with me. In return, when she had HER child, I did the same for her. This sort of thing appears to be invisible to many men, from what I can see. They think the children just watch themselves, I don't know, or they think women's magic will handle it (and it does!). So that is a way that helping others is also helping yourself: by supporting the other woman, you enable them to support you when YOU need it.

Your husband volunteering you to do things for people he has chosen as beneficiaries is "cheap grace" for him (you do the work, he gets the credit, and in addition people think of you as his servant) and I wouldn't put up with that.

So I think it's a balance, we should pay attention to how helping others affects our families, but also recognize that sometimes helping others is also building up good karma for when we need it ourselves, and the decision rests with us, not with our spouse.

Marvellousmadness · 22/03/2022 12:45

You do you . he can't stop you

But do realise most babies are born at night. So a big possibility that you will have the 2yo in the middle of the night yeah

JacquelineCarlyle · 22/03/2022 12:44

@oldestmumaintheworld

He sounds like a selfish whiney arse. And I don't care if he is anxious. Being anxious doesn't give you the right to be a sulky manchild.
This!
Traumdeuter · 22/03/2022 12:43

Not remotely surprised that he “can’t” cook tbh.

GabriellaMontez · 22/03/2022 12:42

What else does his anxiety stop you doing? How is he treating it?

GatoradeMeBitch · 22/03/2022 12:42

YANBU. He is being unreasonable to farm you out but get mad when you do something by your own choice.

And washing up is only a favour to you if the dishes are all yours.

Shinyandnew1 · 22/03/2022 12:41

Ask him why he volunteers your time out but you can’t volunteer your own

Momicrone · 22/03/2022 12:40

It can be annoying if something needs doing in your own house

ComeSailAway · 22/03/2022 12:40

The sulking would be a red flag for me. Does he do the "silent treatment"? If so I would tell him to do one!