Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP Stops Me From Helping Others

280 replies

MySaturday · 22/03/2022 11:05

I like to think that I am a pretty generous spirit and will offer to help people out when I feel I am able to, even if it inconveniences me (within reason).
I always put my family's needs first and would not offer to do anything that causes them unreasonable disruption, but find that DP gets into a massive sulk if I offer to assist anyone in a way that could possibly disrupt usual service (I do all of the cooking, most of the housework and we share childcare duties but I do more because I work PT).

For example, I am on a list of people to take care of a friend's 2YO when she goes into labour with second child. This could happen soon and DP has just started worrying that we might have to take 2YO overnight (even though this is very unlikely and I have said that I will do everything and expect nothing from him if that is the case). This is quite an extreme example, he has sulked over far less.

He is always volunteering me to bake things for family get togethers, give lifts to people (he does not drive) and I always accommodate these things the best I can.
I genuinely can't work out who is being unreasonable here - so please let me know your thoughts!

YABU - you should not offer assistance to others
YANBU - if it is causing DP minimal disruption he shouldn't sulk over it

OP posts:
MsMarch · 22/03/2022 14:58

I have only read your posts and it seems everyone agrees that your DP is being mean (you seem to think they think he's being too mean) but I will just say, as the partner of someone who has a habit of volunteering to help other people quite often, it can be extremely frustrating when he disappears off to help someone move house, leaving me with two DC, multiple kids activities and all the normal chores for a day. And yet I am the bad guy because I don't want him to help someone?

There are the times DH has offered to help people with something that involves his equipment - at our house, out of hours. So not only do I get landed with all the childcare duties, I have to either rush around tidying up etc OR he does (while I then do other stuff).

Or he will be working late on a project for someone else, making him tired and cranky and it's me and the DC who suffer.

It's not constant and it's a LOT better these days, but if any of this is true for you and your DP, then I sympathise with him (the once off 2 year old overnight because a friend is going into labour is absolutely NOT an example I'd ever take issue with. But ironically, it's the kind of thing that my DH would moan about at first.... then be the one who does all the hard work when the 2 year old turns up! Grin )

MySaturday · 22/03/2022 14:57

Okay.
His cleaning and cooking are below par so I should just bin him off. Even though we have been together for 14 years and have a 3YO together.
This thread has gotten completely out of hand.
I thank all of you that have voted - it has helped me to be determined to continue as I am. So long as helping others is not at detriment to my family I will do so.
My DP is not abusive or coercive. I am bored of saying this now. It is actually quite odd that so many PPs think they know my life better than I do.
I will deal with his sulking and lack of housekeeping skills however I see fit.

OP posts:
implantreplace · 22/03/2022 14:53

14 years together

Have you recently started helping people?
Or has he always had a problem with it? (In which a little optimistic in your “hope” that he will change)

How old are your children?

springtimeishereagain · 22/03/2022 14:53

It also sounds like he needs to adult better: learn to drive, clean and cook.

Ragruggers · 22/03/2022 14:50

I feel this thread has opened your eyes a little.You are a kind and generous person I am sure but his sulking must stop.He is an adult and knows what he is doing,try the food box idea,he needs to learn to cook as should all adults who are capable.He needs to dd chores in the house without being told.Please don’t treat hm like a child you are not doing any favours.Teach him how to make cakes for his family it’s not hard why should you do it? Good luck and continue with helping others when you want.

springtimeishereagain · 22/03/2022 14:50

YANBU at all. So he's happy to volunteer you to do things (does he ever offer to make a cake or do any of the things he volunteers you for?? ) but he's not ok with you deciding for yourself who you want to help?

He sounds mean-spirited and controlling.

You are an adult. You get to decide things for yourself. And him sulking if you do something he doesn't like? Controlling and deeply unattractive.

diddl · 22/03/2022 14:49

"clear instructions to follow and everything weighed out ready - that could be a good start? When he asks what needs doing around the house I could give him the appropriate equipment and let him get on with it instead of expecting him to guess how best to do things he has never been expected to do before?"

Say what now?

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 22/03/2022 14:49

Tell him to bugger off. He isn't even your husband.
If he wants you to put him first maybe he should put a ring on it (in common parlance0.

TatianaBis · 22/03/2022 14:48

[quote MySaturday]@Strictlyfanoftenyears
Yes, DP's cleaning skills are a little bit like those of a person who has just left home. It isn't great, you are correct.
How would you change it if your DP was similar? Or would you just divorce him because he wasn't born able to dust and nobody had ever taught him?[/quote]
No such thing as 'cleaning skills' you can either be arsed to do it properly or you can't.

MySaturday · 22/03/2022 14:48

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz
He can't drive.
He can boil pasta and microwave a potato, but my culinary skills stretch beyond this and I would rather cook myself than eat some spaghetti and a jar of sauce every night.
Maybe I should amend my comments to "he cannot cook well"

OP posts:
TatianaBis · 22/03/2022 14:47

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz

Can he drive?

I never understand how people (without SEN) can maneuver a big, complicated metal box around our road networks at speed, factoring in pedestrians, roundabout etc yet apparently can't boil spaghetti or bake a potato.

It's strategic incompetence.

It seems he can't do either to be fair.
MySaturday · 22/03/2022 14:46

@Strictlyfanoftenyears
Yes, DP's cleaning skills are a little bit like those of a person who has just left home. It isn't great, you are correct.
How would you change it if your DP was similar? Or would you just divorce him because he wasn't born able to dust and nobody had ever taught him?

OP posts:
BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 22/03/2022 14:44

Can he drive?

I never understand how people (without SEN) can maneuver a big, complicated metal box around our road networks at speed, factoring in pedestrians, roundabout etc yet apparently can't boil spaghetti or bake a potato.

It's strategic incompetence.

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 22/03/2022 14:42

Being married to a child is not a good thing.

"When he asks what needs doing around the house I could give him the appropriate equipment and let him get on with it instead of expecting him to guess how best to do things he has never been expected to do before?"

Eugh.........

TatianaBis · 22/03/2022 14:41

There's a lot overuse of the words bullying and abuse on here.

What they're getting at is that sulking isn't just an unfortunate character trait it's an intentional control mechanism.

I don't think your DH is abusive though.

AnnesBrokenSlate · 22/03/2022 14:38

I'm a bit on the fence because my DH can sometimes get caught up in helping others in a way that does inconvenience DC and I, but DH would probably say it didn't impact us.

Monr0e · 22/03/2022 14:38

OP, what are the changes in his routine that he doesn't like? Do you ever go out in the evenings and do your own thing or does he expect you to be around evenings and weekends?
Does he have hobbies and friends he sees that take him out?
How long does his sulking last for?

You do sound kind and caring. You also sound as if you have convinced yourself he struggles because of anxiety, just exactly how disrupted can he be by you helping someone else?

Also, definitely tell him no more offering your services without asking you first. Just because you usually don't mind shouldn't mean he gets to decide for you

MySaturday · 22/03/2022 14:35

I have been with DP for 14 years. If he was the coercive and controlling mastermind that many of you suspect I think it would be quite visible to everyone in RL by now?
The fact is that I am closer with my family now than I was before we got together and I have met and maintained friendships with some absolutely lovely people during that time. He has supported me in leaving a career that I hated and taking jobs that pay far less so that I can have a better work/life balance.
Of course, there have been times that I have supported him too. We are a partnership.
He fears change in his own day to day life and this can make him hesitant when there is a scenario that he cannot plan for. Often, this hesitance can take the form of obsessive planning for every eventuality but when that is not possible I am confronted with the sulking. He is mainly sulking with the universe, but of course I feel it is aimed at me if my choices lead to the sulking.
When it comes to the basics of cooking / housework - yes he should learn. He actually feels sheepish about not being able to cook and I constantly insist that it is fine. Maybe I should see what he suggests about learning. Perhaps a regular recipe box thingy so he has clear instructions to follow and everything weighed out ready - that could be a good start? When he asks what needs doing around the house I could give him the appropriate equipment and let him get on with it instead of expecting him to guess how best to do things he has never been expected to do before?

OP posts:
RachelGreeneGreep · 22/03/2022 14:27

Very long running thread here about a sulker. It is a control mechanism, not to mention deeply unattractive.

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/relationships/4125147-Divorcing-sulking-DH-it-WILL-happen-in-2021

soootiredddd · 22/03/2022 14:23

Sulking in any way shape or form, about anything or because of anything, is an extremely unattractive behaviour. Sulking is what small children and occasionally teenagers do and even then I don’t tolerate it. It’s rude and passive aggressive. Pull him up on it every time. If he is anxious then as an adult he is fully capable of saying “I’m a bit worried about XYZ” not sulking around like an 8 year old.

LBFseBrom · 22/03/2022 14:17

Husband doesn't sound very nice, frankly. I know a lot of people feel that they 'don't owe anyone anything', but it isn't about that. It's good to help others, as quietly and discreetly as possible and as long as your own loved ones are not overly inconvenienced, there should be no problem. Any one of us could need a helping hand at some time.

You carry on doing what you do. You're setting a fine example to your children of being unselfish and we need more of that.

Anyone who sulks is, frankly, childish. He's probably jealous, wants you all to himself but tell him to get over it.

implantreplace · 22/03/2022 14:16

How Old are your children OP?

DameHelena · 22/03/2022 14:16

To those of you concerned that I am in a controlling and abusive relationship: I can assure you that this is absolutely not the case. I know that you will not believe this
The thing is, by your own comments, you are. Sulking is controlling and abusive behaviour. It just is. Obviously what you choose to do about that is up to you, but there's no point trying to say it's not the case.

implantreplace · 22/03/2022 14:15

And how often and what sort of hell are we actually talking about

Have you always done lots of “helping”? I ask becuae you say that you hope he will change. So can’t have been going on for years?

implantreplace · 22/03/2022 14:14

@MySaturday

I have had a chance to read more of the comments on here, but forgive me if I do not have time to respond to them all individually. I thank you all for taking time out of your day to offer your opinions. This thread did not go the way I was expecting it to.

To those of you concerned that I am in a controlling and abusive relationship: I can assure you that this is absolutely not the case. I know that you will not believe this and it is not for me to spend any more time trying to persuade you.

I don't consider myself a doormat, but I can see that I have enabled DP's behaviour by trying to shield him from anything that he will find challenging. I am seeing clearly for the first time that this is actually not helpful in the long term. In fact, it is making it more upsetting for him whenever there is a disruption. I can't possibly make things always run smoothly for him and it is not my job to do so - as much as I would like him to never feel discomfort. I am effectively treating him like a child in this regard.

I have realised in the course of this thread that the need to help other people is inherently within me. I feel completely connected when I am able to help others and without doing it I would be completely adrift. This doesn't mean I am a saint, it is just something that gives me purpose and satisfaction. I need to make that clear to DP and explain that he can trust me to always put our family first but his support (and not resistance) would make my life a lot more fulfilled.

All the people you help

How do you find the time? Full time job?!

Genuinely curious!

Swipe left for the next trending thread