Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's another in-laws post birth thread

434 replies

LittleGwyneth · 22/03/2022 10:12

I have genuinely tried to find other threads to get answers to this, but couldn't find any.

Having a baby in a few weeks, via planned section - only really relevant as it means we will know the date the baby is going to be born.

We live in central London, my parents live about an hour outside of London and my siblings live about half an hour away. My DH's family live about a 4-5 hour drive away.

My MIL is a lovely, practical, kind person. But I don't know her that well. She doesn't really come to London, so in the nearly ten years I've been with my husband I've probably spent 2-3 days with her, twice a year. I like her, but it's certainly not like having a second mum. Her husband, my FIL, is not my husband's father and is fairly irritating. The type to share politically incorrect memes on Facebook.

They want to come and visit us 'as soon as possible' when the baby is born. They're very happy to stay in a hotel nearby, which is good as we won't have a spare room by the time the baby is born. My question is: AIBU to want to wait a bit?

My husband is fairly clueless on all this (and I'm absolutely no expert) so when we talked about it he suggested 'about five days' after the baby is born. To me that sounds very soon, in terms of the fact that I'll presumably be bleeding and lactating a lot.

If PIL lived an hour away they'd pop down, meet the baby, then go home, and I'd be very happy with that. But because it's a big journey and they're spending two nights in a hotel (which won't be cheap), it seems like they're going to be around a lot. And I just don't know at what point you have to put your big girl pants on and accept that there are people you don't know that well in your space, holding your baby, or whether it's fair to say look, I need a couple of weeks?

I don't want to be that woman who lets her own mum meet the baby on day 3 of life and holds off the in-laws. But equally I don't want them to travel all the way to London and then be upset that they only get to see the baby for an hour a day - or that I'm not 100% sure how I'll feel about other people holding her at that stage.

Does anyone have any insight as to when they would have been ready to have visitors? Or how many hours a day would be reasonable to expect to receive people who've made a big journey and spent money to visit you?

OP posts:
JassyRadlett · 23/03/2022 19:06

I think you've been reading a different thread. Most people have answered with OP's welfare in mind as well as the GPs, so there's been nothing "horrible" going on there. The only real disagreement between posters (not the OP) has been about whether the two sets of GPs should be treated differently from each other.

To be honest, it's in part those posts I was referring to. Horrible in the casual erasure of the OP. They may be equally grandparents to the baby but they're not equally her parents. It seems very easy to sweep aside the needs of the woman who's just had major surgery by solely focusing on the relationship to the baby, rather than to her. It's all about the grandparents and what's fair to them.

(For the record, my own parents met both my kids well after my PIL did, for good reasons. Before I'm accused of things. And with one of my kids I was chirpily welcoming visitors of all sorts on day 5; with the other it was an utter low point.)

saraclara · 23/03/2022 18:44

@JassyRadlett

Gosh, this thread is quite horrible in how the potential emotional and physical needs of a woman who's just had major abdominal surgery, may be getting fuck all sleep, will be at the peak of physical and emotional hormonal disruption and will be trying to establish breastfeeding are treated as so much less a priority than the emotional needs of grandparents around when they would like to meet their grandchild.

I'm not saying that the latter aren't real, or very strong emotions. It's just that the balance of relative needs seems very different to me here.

I think you've been reading a different thread. Most people have answered with OP's welfare in mind as well as the GPs, so there's been nothing "horrible" going on there. The only real disagreement between posters (not the OP) has been about whether the two sets of GPs should be treated differently from each other.
phoenixrosehere · 23/03/2022 18:36

I mean you seem to be a bit uptight as you're apparently not even going to kiss your own newborn

And you either have never heard of the dangers of kissing a newborn when one is suffering from cold sores or lack reading comprehension as to the valid reason why. Newborn babies have become very ill and have died from people kissing them when they have cold sores. Their immunity is not ready for such things.

JassyRadlett · 23/03/2022 18:12

Gosh, this thread is quite horrible in how the potential emotional and physical needs of a woman who's just had major abdominal surgery, may be getting fuck all sleep, will be at the peak of physical and emotional hormonal disruption and will be trying to establish breastfeeding are treated as so much less a priority than the emotional needs of grandparents around when they would like to meet their grandchild.

I'm not saying that the latter aren't real, or very strong emotions. It's just that the balance of relative needs seems very different to me here.

uptonogoode · 23/03/2022 18:10

I mean you seem to be a bit uptight as you're apparently not even going to kiss your own newborn Hmm

Shrekles20 · 23/03/2022 17:51

YABU especially as they will be staying in a hotel. It’s a big thing becoming a grandparent and not really fair to make them wait x amount of days when your own family have early access.

I understand concerns though and I wouldn’t want visits lasting longer than a couple of hours. Just take yourself and possibly baby off for a sleep and they’ll hopefully get the message and even if they don’t your partner can deal with them.

Staryflight445 · 23/03/2022 17:48

@saraclara

I’m surprised by the comments about treating grandparents equally. How many couples can you count that both have a similar relationship with their parents?

We're talking about meeting their grandchild. Of course there will be differences in relationships that might well show themselves in the future. But there should not be a large disparity in the timing of invitations to each set of grandparents, to actually meet their grandchild.

The mother of the person giving birth will naturally want to be there for her child, this has nothing to do with being a grandparent. It’s not a competition of who gets to meet the grandchild first or ‘oh you met the baby a week before’.
Songbird21 · 23/03/2022 17:43

Watching this with interest! 36 weeks pregnant with first baby, I have a similar relationship with my in laws. They’re fine, (and they raised DH who I’m pretty keen on!) but we only see them a couple of times a year and we aren’t close. His mum is excited about the baby and I’m hoping it might bring us closer.

My mum and PILs both live a distance away. My mum will likely come and stay for a couple of nights as soon as she can. We’re close and I don’t have to ‘host her’. Eg when we were renovating, my mum came down regularly and helped out. PILs visited for the day when it was all finished and I cooked lunch. That’s completely fine, we had a nice day and it was nice to show off the house. It’s just a different relationship!

I’m open to PILs visiting for a bit around the same time to meet the baby. But they definitely wouldn’t want to stay over (they never have) so will automatically spend less time with the her. We also couldn’t have them all to stay at the same time because there’s only one spare room!

It never even occurred to me that this could be seen as really unreasonable! Of course I’m much happier to be around my own mum when I’ll be vulnerable rather than my MIL who I make polite conversation with 2 times per year. The relationship is just different and that’s ok! This in no way effects the long term relationship I hope the baby will have with all her grandparents in the long term.

LBFseBrom · 23/03/2022 17:24

@ChickenStripper

It is so sad and disappointing to read that the father's mother is not as welcome as the mother's mother by some people. That is a really painful statement and I do wonder what is happening to society.
In the op's case, I get the impression it is more because they live so far away that visiting would be an 'event'. It would be the same the other way around.

If they lived nearby they would be popping in, hopefully lending a helping hand, then popping out. I can see her point in this case and, let's face it, she doesn't know how she will feel straight after the birth. I hope she is fine and buzzing around but many women are not.

This wasn't a problem for me because both sets of grandparents lived fairly nearby. They took it in turns to help out. It would have been different had they needed to travel far and stay somewhere if not with us. I was happy to have either but I honestly did not want other visitors for a while (they turned up anyway).

saraclara · 23/03/2022 16:34

I’m surprised by the comments about treating grandparents equally. How many couples can you count that both have a similar relationship with their parents?

We're talking about meeting their grandchild. Of course there will be differences in relationships that might well show themselves in the future. But there should not be a large disparity in the timing of invitations to each set of grandparents, to actually meet their grandchild.

Staryflight445 · 23/03/2022 16:08

Have you got a daughter @ChickenStripper?

You not going to visit your daughter after birth (regardless of what state she’s in after) unless the MIL is there too? Cause you know… you wouldn’t want first dibs on the grandchild hey?

Or do you think a parent should be allowed to see their daughter as soon as their daughter is ready (even if that means she’s not ready for other people yet which is absolutely fine) because primarily she is invited there as a parent to be a parent and the grandchild is an accessory to that?

Staryflight445 · 23/03/2022 15:53

@ChickenStripper

It is so sad and disappointing to read that the father's mother is not as welcome as the mother's mother by some people. That is a really painful statement and I do wonder what is happening to society.
Yeah it’s exceptionally hard to understand why other women can’t understand the logic of why a new mum might want her mum around her whilst she’s feeling vulnerable.

Mil isn’t OPs mum, OP doesn’t feel comfortable around MIL as doesn’t know her very well.
However she came out of her mums body, and doesn’t feel this way with her own mum.

Really difficult understanding that isn’t it?

ChickenStripper · 23/03/2022 15:46

It is so sad and disappointing to read that the father's mother is not as welcome as the mother's mother by some people. That is a really painful statement and I do wonder what is happening to society.

Staryflight445 · 23/03/2022 15:44

[quote saraclara]@Staryflight445 you remind me of those women who haven't yet had children and proclaim confidently exactly what kind of parent they'll be (with barely disguised criticism of the parents around them).
The reality is that if in the future you have a DIL who has just given birth to your first grandchild, if you are not bursting with excitement and impatience to see it every bit as much as its other grandma, you'll be quite the oddity. Like any GP, whatever side, hopefully you'll be considerate of the mother. But the baby is of equal importance, and will be loved equally by both sets of GP s.

The new generation is about everyone in the two families, to some degree. It's primal. I didn't get it until it happened to me, any more that most people don't get what parenthood is like until it happened to me.

Fortunately it was my DD who gave birth, but the other grandma was treated equally, which I was as keen to see happen as my DD was.[/quote]
You can be excited you know without disrespecting someone’s wishes or expecting things to happen a certain way.

My childrens feelings on things come first and that will not change when they become parents. Of course I’ll want to meet the baby but my excitement will firstly come off seeing them as parents, the baby is an extension to that.

I’m surprised by the comments about treating grandparents equally. How many couples can you count that both have a similar relationship with their parents?
Grandparents relationships with their grandchildren will naturally be based off their own parents relationships with those grandparents.

‘ The new generation is about everyone in the two families, to some degree. It's primal. I didn't get it until it happened to me, any more that most people don't get what parenthood is like until it happened to me.’

If you’re old enough to be a grandparent why are you finding it difficult to understand that everyone’s perception of being a parent and grandparent is different? Every family is different and the issues attached to this thread are not directly related to how you perceive parenthood?

You can request time after birth to recover in peace with your new baby and partner without that meaning you don’t respect or regard your wider family.
Those relationships come with time.

GoodnessTruthBeauty · 23/03/2022 15:21

Do you think you could have a private conversation with your MIL (in person if at all possible) and explain that as much as you really want them to meet the baby asap, would they mind waiting until after the birth for you to decide how soon as you know you won't know how you will feel and just want some flexibility? I don't think this is unreasonable at all. I really don't like the idea that the mother and her recovery comes last in the decision. I think talking about it ahead of time would mean she could understand your anxieties and not take it personally if you aren't ready for visitors within the first week. I hate that some new mothers get bullied and treated like they are terrible for just asking for some consideration.

saraclara · 23/03/2022 15:12

@Staryflight445 you remind me of those women who haven't yet had children and proclaim confidently exactly what kind of parent they'll be (with barely disguised criticism of the parents around them).
The reality is that if in the future you have a DIL who has just given birth to your first grandchild, if you are not bursting with excitement and impatience to see it every bit as much as its other grandma, you'll be quite the oddity. Like any GP, whatever side, hopefully you'll be considerate of the mother. But the baby is of equal importance, and will be loved equally by both sets of GP s.

The new generation is about everyone in the two families, to some degree. It's primal. I didn't get it until it happened to me, any more that most people don't get what parenthood is like until it happened to me.

Fortunately it was my DD who gave birth, but the other grandma was treated equally, which I was as keen to see happen as my DD was.

phoenixrosehere · 23/03/2022 15:09

All this 'DH and I need time to bond with the baby ' bollox is all very precious naval gazing .
Parenthood is hard enough without alienating the grandparents from the get go. They don't need 'managing' or 'boundaries' - if , as you say - they are normal pleasant people.

And grandparents needing to be there the moment the baby pops out with little to no consideration of the woman who gave birth is entitlement at its finest!

One can care about family and express that they want space after having a baby and if such family members have such an issue with it than they’re not really family.

Staryflight445 · 23/03/2022 12:33

@FateHasRedesignedMost

I think it’s very unfair to give one set of grandparents unlimited access and time with the family and new baby, then try and set rules and time limits for the other set (unless you don’t get on with them).

They might be helpful and supportive. You may value their company and help when the time comes.

They’re only in the area for 2 days so I’d just play it by ear and let them know if you need a break or take yourself off to your room if you feel unable to say that to them.

You think it’s unfair for a new mum to want her mum around unless she lets her partners mum be around the exact same amount of time?

Right.
If my daughter wants me around when she’s had a baby, I’ll be there and support her.

Equally if my sons partner has a baby and wants her mum, I’ll completely understand and be ready to support her when she’s ready.

Because funnily enough, when I become a grandparent, it isn’t about me.

DonnyBurrito · 23/03/2022 11:13

@secretsqizzle

It just really depends upon how important family is to you and if you value your husbands family as equal grandparents.

All this 'DH and I need time to bond with the baby ' bollox is all very precious naval gazing .
Parenthood is hard enough without alienating the grandparents from the get go. They don't need 'managing' or 'boundaries' - if , as you say - they are normal pleasant people.

The baby won't break if someone else holds him .

I agree, it's so weird when parents want to spend uninterrupted, quality time with their baby as a brand new family. Where I come from, new parents just fling their babies into the street so everyone can play dollies with them! It's just so much better for the community that way.
FateHasRedesignedMost · 23/03/2022 10:59

I think it’s very unfair to give one set of grandparents unlimited access and time with the family and new baby, then try and set rules and time limits for the other set (unless you don’t get on with them).

They might be helpful and supportive. You may value their company and help when the time comes.

They’re only in the area for 2 days so I’d just play it by ear and let them know if you need a break or take yourself off to your room if you feel unable to say that to them.

Staryflight445 · 23/03/2022 10:53

‘ The baby won't break if someone else holds him’

Lol.

Grandparents won’t break being asked to wait a week either.
Family can be important to you, as well as having the ability to be strong enough to say that you want some space after giving birth. It’s not one or the other.

Your comment about equal grandparents is ridiculous too.
Grandparents can be equal, but when someone’s child has just had a baby, they’re there primarily as that womens parent.

Some of you are horrible.

secretsqizzle · 23/03/2022 09:08

It just really depends upon how important family is to you and if you value your husbands family as equal grandparents.

All this 'DH and I need time to bond with the baby ' bollox is all very precious naval gazing .
Parenthood is hard enough without alienating the grandparents from the get go. They don't need 'managing' or 'boundaries' - if , as you say - they are normal pleasant people.

The baby won't break if someone else holds him .

Foundmy · 23/03/2022 06:14

Take your time. For people who naturally feel fine with the idea of people visiting so soon it won’t seem like a thing. But for those of us who need more space, that’s perfectly fine too. It’s a huge deal having your first baby & it sounds like you know yourself & your preferences - it’s perfectly okay to have these. I felt the same & was glad I ring fenced that time for it to be just us. There’s no rush & the biggest priority is yourself & your partner having time to bond with your baby & recovery physically & emotionally.

Superhanz · 23/03/2022 02:25

I had my first baby 4 months ago by planned section. I was out of hospital the next day and couldn't wait for visitors as I wanted to show her off and I am definitely not the hosting type, I normally don't like people calling.

Let them come, they'll be staying in a hotel but don't put yourself out at the same time. My DHs biological dad and wife I don't know very well or some of his family on that side, but when they came I stayed in my pj's and wasn't up scrubbing the house, I just said to people they'd have to take us as they found us.

If you're tired, sore, emotional etc just be honest. If they are decent people they'll gave you space if you ask.

You may find you recover quite quickly from your section. By day 5 I was out walking the dog (well DH had the dog, I pushed the pram) and I'm no spring chicken either.

Congratulations and enjoy this lovely time!

Underfrighter · 22/03/2022 23:02

I think ask them to book tickets they can amend up to 24 hours before. It will take the pressure off.

I was having massive hormone crashes then and sobbing at everything, couldn't walk or sit and was pissing myself, as well as being so weak from blood loss and anaemia I was having to be helped around. I was really vulnerable and I would have felt absolutely awful if I'd been expected to see people outside immediate family because of fairness. If you have a less than perfect birth experience you do need to ensure you balance your need to recover with their wish to see the baby asap. Saying that if I hadn't been in such a state then I would have been ok with it, the tiredness and breastfeeding will be a thing for a lot longer than a few days or weeks