Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's another in-laws post birth thread

434 replies

LittleGwyneth · 22/03/2022 10:12

I have genuinely tried to find other threads to get answers to this, but couldn't find any.

Having a baby in a few weeks, via planned section - only really relevant as it means we will know the date the baby is going to be born.

We live in central London, my parents live about an hour outside of London and my siblings live about half an hour away. My DH's family live about a 4-5 hour drive away.

My MIL is a lovely, practical, kind person. But I don't know her that well. She doesn't really come to London, so in the nearly ten years I've been with my husband I've probably spent 2-3 days with her, twice a year. I like her, but it's certainly not like having a second mum. Her husband, my FIL, is not my husband's father and is fairly irritating. The type to share politically incorrect memes on Facebook.

They want to come and visit us 'as soon as possible' when the baby is born. They're very happy to stay in a hotel nearby, which is good as we won't have a spare room by the time the baby is born. My question is: AIBU to want to wait a bit?

My husband is fairly clueless on all this (and I'm absolutely no expert) so when we talked about it he suggested 'about five days' after the baby is born. To me that sounds very soon, in terms of the fact that I'll presumably be bleeding and lactating a lot.

If PIL lived an hour away they'd pop down, meet the baby, then go home, and I'd be very happy with that. But because it's a big journey and they're spending two nights in a hotel (which won't be cheap), it seems like they're going to be around a lot. And I just don't know at what point you have to put your big girl pants on and accept that there are people you don't know that well in your space, holding your baby, or whether it's fair to say look, I need a couple of weeks?

I don't want to be that woman who lets her own mum meet the baby on day 3 of life and holds off the in-laws. But equally I don't want them to travel all the way to London and then be upset that they only get to see the baby for an hour a day - or that I'm not 100% sure how I'll feel about other people holding her at that stage.

Does anyone have any insight as to when they would have been ready to have visitors? Or how many hours a day would be reasonable to expect to receive people who've made a big journey and spent money to visit you?

OP posts:
LemonDrop22 · 01/11/2022 15:52

I didn't realise it was an old thread and was going to say 4/5 days was way too soon in my experience. Was going to say at least a fortnight

crosstalk · 01/11/2022 15:43

I really can't see the imperative of anyone seeing any baby so soon after birth and not after a C section or difficult birth. What on earth is the race? You can have pictures. Fine if both parents welcome it and visits are agreed. It's up to them. And a loving supportive family doesn't start in the first weeks - even after months - if they are loving and supportive they will understand.

I certainly agree the best advice so far is to ask anyone hoping to see a baby who needs to stay over is that they go for refundable tickets and hotels.

Janey3090 · 01/11/2022 14:17

This is really useful OP - just FYI I never saw your thread at the beginning of the year but I would have voted YANBU. DH and I are expecting our first baby in January, and though I'm not concerned about MIL or my parents (as they are all super helpful), I have already decided no other visitors for a couple of weeks until we feel settled. There's no need for 'great aunty June', '2nd cousin Mary' etc to come around who I would need to host because they won't feel comfortable enough in my home to help themselves to drinks etc. They can wait a couple of weeks to see the baby.

DH and I want to take the time to get to know our baby and get in our own routine. I'm sorry that your experience was so bad, and time you should have been resting/getting to know your baby was made difficult x

OverTheHillAndDownTotherSide · 01/11/2022 13:52

LittleGwyneth · 01/11/2022 13:10

A little update, some months later. I let them come four days after my daughter was born. It was dreadful. At one point while I was alone with them MIL (who has a very bad leg so can't get about much) and FIL (no excuse) sat at the table and watched me get all the cutlery out and put all the food on the table, four days post section, in massive pain. When I finally sat down to eat FIL asked me to get him a glass of water. It was awful. If you're reading this and having the same dilemma I would urge you to prioritise yourself.

Why on earth did you allow any of that to happen?

Sapphire387 · 01/11/2022 13:37

OP, I started reading the first page of this, all the posters saying YABU, and I thought no way, you have no idea how you will feel, you don't 'have' to let them come ASAP!

Now I have seen your update, I really feel for you. So sorry that happened. I guess it sets the tone for the relationship going forwards... doesn't sound like they are going to be 'hands on' grandparents at all.

MinnieGirl · 01/11/2022 13:32

Thank you so much for coming back to update us!
Your in-laws sounds horrendous…. And extremely lazy.
But you now have their measure…. And I hope your husband does too. Didn’t he say anything? At least if you have another baby, you can limit their visit to an hour with no guilt… and if they moan your husband can blooming well tell them why!

diddl · 01/11/2022 13:27

That sounds absolutely dreadful.

Hope you told FIL to get his own bloody water!

Can't believe that your husband either didn't warn you that they expect to be waited on, didn't make sure he was there to help or tell them that that wouldn't be happening!

Well you know for the future!

As for this episode-try not to dwell on it as you'll be the only one getting in a knot about it!

LittleGwyneth · 01/11/2022 13:10

A little update, some months later. I let them come four days after my daughter was born. It was dreadful. At one point while I was alone with them MIL (who has a very bad leg so can't get about much) and FIL (no excuse) sat at the table and watched me get all the cutlery out and put all the food on the table, four days post section, in massive pain. When I finally sat down to eat FIL asked me to get him a glass of water. It was awful. If you're reading this and having the same dilemma I would urge you to prioritise yourself.

OP posts:
charlottecruz · 17/04/2022 22:01

@Dorathedragon

Yabu. I had most of the family come to the hospital! I’d never make grandparents wait 5 days. Your mum and mil have had babies so will know how you’re feeling.
remember your decision isn't everyone's decision. i was super overwhelmed by how many people decided to show up the day my baby was born.

i had been in hospital for three days, had stitches and a catheter bought home for the next two days, i was in pain and wanted nothing more than to come home and be away from the hospital, but i didn't want a sea of people coming.

partner and i weren't expecting a baby, and weren't living together, so he moved in to my parents until housing became available (which due to the pandemic is a nightmare). this meant when i came home my parents would see the baby instantly, so it sounded only fair for my in-laws to come round.

however i just wanted rest, i wanted to be with my baby, and not really showing anyone my baby, i wanted to lay in bed with him and cuddle him and just enjoy the first couple of days, not have my baby being passed from arm to arm between 5 people, 7 with my partner and i.

i was too lenient with allowing them to visit, yes they're in laws and have as much right as our own parents, but when you're the one who's just birthed a baby, in pain, and wanting time alone, that's perfectly reasonable. part of me wishes i didn't let so many people see him so often, i needed more alone time with him. do what feels right to you. hold off another week or so if that's what you feel is right.

DarcyBlue · 03/04/2022 07:38

I think you are projecting on to the OP a lot. You're suggesting she calls her partner's mum, who he sees infrequently and makes some polite conversation with a couple of times a year, and 'assures' her she will be part of the baby's life? Isn't that down to the relationship that the future grandparents already have with their adult son?

ispepsiokay · 03/04/2022 04:18

Personally I'd invite her to stay close by while you're in hospital so that the FIL doesn't come (covid restrictions) and she can meet baby straight away, then see how things are going when you get home before arranging the next visit at maybe 2/3 weeks.

Marzipan44 · 03/04/2022 03:23

@Holly60

OP as a granny myself I can tell you that your MIL will just be delighted to be included in any way you choose. If you invite them over for an hour, she will be pleased. If you ask her to pick up some supplies on the way over, she will be delighted. If you ask her to make you a cuppa, she will feel like she is of some use. Just let them be a small part of the beginning of the journey with your new little one. There are years and years to work out the rest.

Of course you don’t have to entertain them. Get your husband to chat to them and explain how you are feeling- gently. I’m absolutely sure she will totally understand.

@Holly60 New granny here. Agree wholeheartedly with your post, and it made me cry. We’re going through a period of anguish and bewilderment as we’ve been largely excluded from our first grandchild’s life. We would have been so grateful to be included in any small way, rather than being treated as a problem that has to be held at bay. Every week we send a message asking how they are, offering to help, and saying how proud we are of them but these are usually ignored. More recently we’ve had a few phone calls and some photos so we’re hoping our daughter in law may start to allow us into her babies life, but it is so painful that her friends and family know our little grandchild so much better than we do, and have been allowed to help out in the house, send gifts, and give home cooked food, none of which we were allowed to do. We’re also not allowed to mention anything about our son’s childhood, and none of the books and toys that were important to him as a child are being given to his son. We don’t know when our grandchild started smiling, when he started cooing, or even how he was born. Heartbreaking.

Our second grandchild is due soon and we were fearful that as paternal grandparents we would be excluded again, but thankfully this daughter in law has made it clear that she would like both sets of grandparents to bond with the baby and be involved in their life, and we’ve had some lovely meet ups with our in laws to celebrate our impending joint grandchild. Bittersweet though, because we feel so close and bonded to this child, but distant from the other one even though he’s our grandson and we love him.

@LittleGwyneth
I don’t think you’re being unreasonable to wait until after your baby is born before making arrangements for visitors. If you have time for a quick kind phone call before the baby arrives to reassure your in laws that they’re very much wanted in their grandchild’s life, that you’ll allow them to see the baby once things have settled down after your CSection, and that you’ll send them some photos and snippets about the baby while they’re waiting for an invite, I’m sure that would be much appreciated :)

LBFseBrom · 24/03/2022 20:00

@FateHasRedesignedMost

The mother of the person giving birth will naturally want to be there for her child, this has nothing to do with being a grandparent

Not necessarily. My MIL is travelling halfway round the world to be here before the birth. My mum is too worried about covid to take a train to see us any time soon!

I couldn't quote both posts but your in laws sound great! I'm glad you have them. Congratulations on your impending birth (not very elegantly put but hopefully you get my drift :)), and all the very best to you and your family.
user1471481356 · 24/03/2022 08:14

I think it’s totally fine to wait for visitors. But it would need to be all visitors, or just the in laws. You may feel totally fine and really want visitors! I would get your husband to suggest to sr you need to wait and see how you feel. Ask him to suggest morning and afternoon visits so that you’ve got space too

mummabubs · 24/03/2022 07:40

[quote LightDrizzle]@AngelinaFibres
God forbid your son has major surgery or a debilitating illness and wants his mum around while he recovers with stitches, constipation and leaking orifices.
It is only fair his MIL is there as much as you.

Can’t the “fair sharesies” brigade get their heads around the fact that the mother’s mum, possibly dad, is supporting their recovering child, not getting first dibs on the grandchild? Yes they may therefore be around the grandchild more as a result but that isn’t their purpose or focus.

Have they not the empathy to compass the fact that someone might feel more comfortable being tearful, knackered and sore and ratty around their own mum than they would around their partner’s mum? Our relationships with our own parents are normally more resilient than with our in-laws and less likely to be damaged permanently by stress and fatigue related snappiness or retreating to the bedroom for hours.

Thank god my in-laws weren’t like this. Thank god my daughter’s future in-laws won’t be like this. They live closer so will probably see future grandchildren more than me but I can’t imagine lovely Debbie putting her bottom lip out if DD1 needs me around more in the first weeks. I won’t be putting my bottom lip out if DD1 doesn’t need me around more in the first weeks. Our relationships with our grandchild will be the work of months and years, not a sprint to “win” the first few weeks when the baby itself is oblivious.

It’s not a competition.[/quote]
Absolutely this, in spades, all of it.

FateHasRedesignedMost · 24/03/2022 07:07

The mother of the person giving birth will naturally want to be there for her child, this has nothing to do with being a grandparent

Not necessarily. My MIL is travelling halfway round the world to be here before the birth. My mum is too worried about covid to take a train to see us any time soon!

FateHasRedesignedMost · 24/03/2022 07:05

I get the impression it is more because they live so far away that visiting would be an 'event'

My in-laws live in another country and are coming to stay for a few weeks either side of the birth. Yes it’s an ‘event’ as in a family reunion, and they’re staying in our home, but they’re treated very much as family members not guests. They did the same to help us move house. Eg they cook, shop, clean, help with school runs, and help themselves to food and drink (and offer to make food and drink for others too). We don’t wait on them like they’re distant friends visiting.

I set up their room with all the essentials (including spare linen and towels) and leave them to get on with it.

I’m having a c-section so they’ll bring our older DC to visit on the ward after (yes when I’m at my most vulnerable, but I’m looking forward to seeing them hold their grandchild for the first time. They missed seeing our other DC as a small baby due to visa issues so this is the first time MIL has cuddled a newborn since my DH was a baby over 40 years ago!) I trust her not to drop her or kiss her face or do anything risky.

Once home I’ll be out of action for a while (focused on baby, recovering from surgery) so PILs can help DH run the household. And believe me if your baby has colic or cries a lot it’s really helpful to have someone to hold baby so you can have a break. Or even if baby’s fine, it’s an extra pair of hands so you can shower and nap.

First time round I had my mum stay instead, and tbh we irritated each other as we’re closer. Eg she’d come into our bedroom (MIL doesn’t) and chat to me when I was half asleep then ask me why I hadn’t made the bed! And she didn’t help as much as I’d hoped.

phoenixrosehere · 23/03/2022 23:03

@phoenixrosehere so you wouldnt kiss your new baby?

Not if I suffered from something that is highly contagious and could harm or kill them like OP does.

I also kissed my babies’ hair, temples, nuzzled their cheeks or touched their nose with mine because I knew of the dangers and why you’re not supposed to kiss newborn babies faces. It’s not rocket science and it has been repeated by health professionals for years on the dangers. No baby is going to feel less loved because they weren’t kissed all over their face when they were born.

Dietcokeaddiction · 23/03/2022 22:50

This is your husband's mum. She's probably sad she sees so little of her son - of course she'll want to meet her grandchild. If she's kind and practical then let her come and cuddle the baby but also maybe help you out. If it was me I'd be happy to do some washing/cooking/shopping etc. I wasn't hugely mobile 5 days after my planned section - but I had a constant stream of visitors.
The fact is - they'll be gone after 3 days and you'll be just the 3 of you lots and lots of times. For the first few weeks the chances are that your baby will only sleep and feed so having other people around isn't likely to feel such an imposition as when they're a little older.
I would let them come all day for the two days they're here and just accept it for your husband's mum desperately wanting to meet her son's firstborn.

Moodycow78 · 23/03/2022 22:45

[quote LittleGwyneth]@JenniferBarkley When you say more than an hour a day - how much time per day seems reasonable? I sort of want it to just be me, DH and the baby for the first week or so, but if that's unreasonable I'd like to try and set some boundaries which are fair.[/quote]
I made the rule that I'd give my MIL the same amount of time/consideration as my own mum, they got treated the same (but visited at different times). My MIL is lovely though and I think I'm probably closer to her that you are as we see them regularly.

uptonogoode · 23/03/2022 22:38

@phoenixrosehere so you wouldnt kiss your new baby?

SnackSizeRaisin · 23/03/2022 20:18

If they have never bothered to visit you in 10 years and are only now coming because of the baby, I wouldn't rush to have them to be honest. They will only be interested in baby and you will probably end up feeling resentful of them hanging around all the time, especially as you dislike the FIL.

Most people are exhausted and sore and emotional after a c section. It's a time for privacy and rest. Unless you specifically want visitors then treat it like any other major surgery. You won't want people visiting for 2 entire consecutive days. It would be completely different if they wanted to come for a couple of hours only. I would suggest they wait 2 weeks and then plan to go out and about with them rather than sit in your flat. By then you should be ok to go for walks or cafés etc.

I do think that you must not try to stop the baby's grandmother holding the baby - no kissing fair enough, but as long as grandma is a non smoker and hasn't got a cold, let her hold the baby. Obviously get the baby back if it's crying or needs a feed

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 23/03/2022 20:14

The mothers parents are there for their daughter first, not the baby. The in laws can wait their turn when mum feels comfortable. Of course no women is going to treat their in laws the same as their actual parents whilst they’re so vulnerable and the expectation that we should is just horrible. Mostly off other women too, most of you should be ashamed.

Amen. Women count. Their feelings matter, and do not have to be brushed to one side 100% of the time so that others can feel more comfortable at our expense.

It's okay to say 'no'.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 23/03/2022 20:12

You are the patient who's just been through major abdominal surgery. This should be your call. This is one time in life when your needs and your feelings absolutely should, and rightly, take precedent. This time is important to aid your own recovery and establish feeding, etc. I would also make it clear to my husband that I fully expected him to support me and have my back, or the consequences for him would be far more serious for upsetting me than for upsetting his parents.

Your baby isn't going anywhere. Her grandparents will be her grandparents for life; they have that lifetime to forge a bond with her. She also won't remember who sees her in the first days of her life, but it's crucially important she bonds in a calm way with her parents and especially the mother. In the scheme of things, a few days makes no difference whatsoever.

YANB in the least U.

Staryflight445 · 23/03/2022 19:26

‘ They may be equally grandparents to the baby but they're not equally her parents. It seems very easy to sweep aside the needs of the woman who's just had major surgery by solely focusing on the relationship to the baby, rather than to her. It's all about the grandparents and what's fair to them. ’

That with bells on.

It concerns me that all people are bothered about is the baby, not the mum or what she’s been through or how she may be feeling. All they’re interested in, is seeing the baby.

It doesn’t sit right with me at all. It’s so nice when you get that odd visitor that actually treats you as a human being when they come visit to the point it actually makes you well up.

This whole grandparents must meet the baby at the same time or around the same day is ridiculous. The mothers parents are there for their daughter first, not the baby.
The in laws can wait their turn when mum feels comfortable. Of course no women is going to treat their in laws the same as their actual parents whilst they’re so vulnerable and the expectation that we should is just horrible. Mostly off other women too, most of you should be ashamed.