Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's another in-laws post birth thread

434 replies

LittleGwyneth · 22/03/2022 10:12

I have genuinely tried to find other threads to get answers to this, but couldn't find any.

Having a baby in a few weeks, via planned section - only really relevant as it means we will know the date the baby is going to be born.

We live in central London, my parents live about an hour outside of London and my siblings live about half an hour away. My DH's family live about a 4-5 hour drive away.

My MIL is a lovely, practical, kind person. But I don't know her that well. She doesn't really come to London, so in the nearly ten years I've been with my husband I've probably spent 2-3 days with her, twice a year. I like her, but it's certainly not like having a second mum. Her husband, my FIL, is not my husband's father and is fairly irritating. The type to share politically incorrect memes on Facebook.

They want to come and visit us 'as soon as possible' when the baby is born. They're very happy to stay in a hotel nearby, which is good as we won't have a spare room by the time the baby is born. My question is: AIBU to want to wait a bit?

My husband is fairly clueless on all this (and I'm absolutely no expert) so when we talked about it he suggested 'about five days' after the baby is born. To me that sounds very soon, in terms of the fact that I'll presumably be bleeding and lactating a lot.

If PIL lived an hour away they'd pop down, meet the baby, then go home, and I'd be very happy with that. But because it's a big journey and they're spending two nights in a hotel (which won't be cheap), it seems like they're going to be around a lot. And I just don't know at what point you have to put your big girl pants on and accept that there are people you don't know that well in your space, holding your baby, or whether it's fair to say look, I need a couple of weeks?

I don't want to be that woman who lets her own mum meet the baby on day 3 of life and holds off the in-laws. But equally I don't want them to travel all the way to London and then be upset that they only get to see the baby for an hour a day - or that I'm not 100% sure how I'll feel about other people holding her at that stage.

Does anyone have any insight as to when they would have been ready to have visitors? Or how many hours a day would be reasonable to expect to receive people who've made a big journey and spent money to visit you?

OP posts:
WeDontShutUpAboutBruno · 22/03/2022 12:20

To dictate only an hour a day is a little bit harsh.

Its not harsh to 'dictate' how long visitors can stay in your home when you're recovering from major abdominal surgery, getting to grips with having a new baby and breastfeeding and feeling vulnerable.

Op isn't an incubator there to provide them with a grandchild they must see at their leisure. She is a person, going through something pretty traumatic and not knowing how she will feel afterwards, and is, understandably, nervous about it all. Its unfair for her to be under any additional pressure due to the wants of others.

Staryflight445 · 22/03/2022 12:20

It’s actually quite normal @BellatrixOnABadDay

It’s not controlling, or a sign of PND or anything else.

A womens just gone through labour and birth, it’s quite normal to just want to sit and stare at your newborn and not wanting visitors straight away whilst you feel so protective and are adjusting.

phoenixrosehere · 22/03/2022 12:19

Grandparents don’t need to be there instantly to form a bond.

Exactly. By such logic, both my parents and in-laws shouldn’t have a bond with our sons whatsoever especially my father. Even though he couldn’t hug them, he calls every week since birth to talk to them so they would know his voice.

BellatrixOnABadDay · 22/03/2022 12:19

- Some people have said you can breastfeed discretely with nursing clothes so that shouldn’t be an issue, but if you have a baby like mine that is not the case. Every feed was a battle and I spent half the day with my boobs out and there was nothing discreet or calm about it. It was definitely not a visitor friendly activity.

I always went into a different room if I wanted to feed my babies though? I didn't find it a hardship and gave me a chance for some peace/time with the baby.

ivykaty44 · 22/03/2022 12:18

WellNotReally

I feel very fortunate, I was with dd in labour before she left for hospital at 6 cm, then she wanted me at home for when she returned the next day - along with in laws who came round to meet baby on her return home. we all left the new family to get on with stuff but have been on hand to help with hoovering, laundry etc. to us its how families behave, get together to celebrate and roll sleeves up to help out

godmum56 · 22/03/2022 12:17

If you like your Mil and get on well with her can you be tactfully honest with her? Say that you understand that she is longing to meet her grandchild but as its a CS and your first child, you don't know how things will be and you would hate for them to make a long journey for a 30 minute visit if things haven't gone well so can you talk abiut the visit once you are home and settled. BUT I think you have to hold off your own family as well or at least say the same thing to them. If your Mil says oh one 30 minute visit over two days is fine at least you have managed her expectations. When they are there, if it all gets too much then say so....and excuse yourself and baby to bed. You haven't mentioned baby's dad but I think its really important for you to get him on board with the plan. He is your and the baby's defender.

RedHerring24 · 22/03/2022 12:17

Personally i dont think you are being unreasonable, you may change your mind after birth, but everyone is different.

We recently had our first child and first grandchild in the family.
Post birth recovery was not simple for me. I was very unwell (no c-section) post birth and couldnt function well.
The thought of anyone visiting filled me with dread.
My mum who is local visited on day 5, literally for a couple of hours before I was wisked away back to hospital. She was happy with that. I was happy with that as I just needed my mum for a bit. DH was also very happy with this.
Inlaws live 3 hours away and would stay in a hotel. They visited in possibly week 3. They stayed with us for 2 hours and left. They did this on 2 different days.
They then didnt come back for another month and a half.

Everyone is different and will recover and bond with their baby at different rates.
I dont think its fair for people to say you are being unreasonable to wait for people to see baby. Its your shout at the end if the day, just do what is best for you as a family.

BellatrixOnABadDay · 22/03/2022 12:16

@Staryflight445

‘ Babies at that age love a cuddle, regardless of who is giving it so you might be relieved to have your hands free for a while!’

I know there’s many women who absolutely hate this. Me included, I just wanted to bond with my baby.

What, and it's impossible to bond with your baby if you let someone else hold them for half an hour?

Genuine postnatal depression/baby blues/PTSD issues aside, this kind of attitude always strikes me as very controlling, and hiding behind 'bonding with the baby' to be like that

Staryflight445 · 22/03/2022 12:15

@WellNotReally

This thread has made me even more grateful for my wonderful DiL and SS. I'm only a step grandparent but they welcomed us into the delivery room after the birth. It was a huge honour, one we had never expected.

Whilst I wouldn't expect that from many new parents (not even my own DC!), their attitude from the start was that their new baby is fortunate to have so many people who love her in her life. The grandparent grandchild relationship can be so precious.

You can have that attitude but still wish for space after experiencing labour and birth.

Goodness me. Some absolutely appalling comments here.
Grandparents don’t need to be there instantly to form a bond.

KiwiDramaQueen · 22/03/2022 12:15

P.S. two more things:

  • Some people have said you can breastfeed discretely with nursing clothes so that shouldn’t be an issue, but if you have a baby like mine that is not the case. Every feed was a battle and I spent half the day with my boobs out and there was nothing discreet or calm about it. It was definitely not a visitor friendly activity.
  • My mum is going to meet my baby for the first time today at 5 weeks and 1 day old. She lives overseas and would have jumped on a flight first thing, but as she’d be staying with us for an extended period we decided that might be a bit full on in the early days esp as she and my partner have never met (because Covid). So we decided she’d come later on, when we would all be more capable of enjoying each other’s company. She’s been a trooper about it and not once has she put pressure on to come earlier.
Theflamingnerd · 22/03/2022 12:14

As someone who had post section complications that resulted in going back into hospital for DS's first week of life I'm a big advocate for not planning the visit in advance.

I'd be having a conversation along the lines of "I don't know what sort of state I'll be in, how long I'll take to heal. We want to have some time to settle into a new routine but would love to arrange for you to visit once the baby arrives. Can we play it by ear and get dates booked in once she's arrived?" DH should be having this conversation with them though as they're his parents.

Best to manage expectations, but I wouldn't agree with excluding them. As other posters have mentioned this is their grand child and they're understandably excited. You never how you'll feel once the baby arrives, you could be desperate for the few hours break they'd be able to provide you.

ChloeHel · 22/03/2022 12:14

@ZoeCM

You get a lot of threads like this on here.

And also a lot of threads along the lines of "my partner's parents are closer to his sister's children than to ours, isn't that horrible?"

Hmm. How mysterious...

Wow, never really thought of this before. But yes!
ChloeHel · 22/03/2022 12:13

I think YABU. To dictate only an hour a day is a little bit harsh. They are travelling all that way for you to tell them they can only see the baby for an hour a day, and you aren’t sure if you want them to hold the baby? Why on Earth not?

When I had DD I had my parents down for a week (we live 2 hours away). MIL came down 2 days after she was born and was allowed to stay and hold DD for as long as she wanted. It was nice for me to get a little alone time to wash and look after myself! Don’t forget that you will want a few minutes alone here and there, and DH may want his parents around when he has the baby alone.

You may find them being there helpful. They can always pop out for a walk if you wanted a bit of alone time to feed or do private things I.e toilet etc.

Staryflight445 · 22/03/2022 12:12

‘ Babies at that age love a cuddle, regardless of who is giving it so you might be relieved to have your hands free for a while!’

I know there’s many women who absolutely hate this. Me included, I just wanted to bond with my baby.

ZoeCM · 22/03/2022 12:11

You get a lot of threads like this on here.

And also a lot of threads along the lines of "my partner's parents are closer to his sister's children than to ours, isn't that horrible?"

Hmm. How mysterious...

saraclara · 22/03/2022 12:11

I don't think the idea of having some boundaries is that wild. I've already told my family that I don't want to pass the baby around, no-one kissing her.

No kissing is fine. But letting a grandmother hold a new grandchild is not 'passing around' and you really need to allow that. The bond that begins there is going to be valuable to all of you.

My kids are in their 30s now, but the looks on each grandparent's face when they held their grandbabies is still burned on my mind. And now that two of those grandparents are dead and another has advance Alzheimers, the photos that my DH took of them holding them are very much treasured.

But answering your question, I was in hospital for a week after my emergency caesarian. The inlaw GPs (from 2.5 hours away) visited probably 48 hours afterwards. They were very good about taking themselves off for chunks of time and recognising that I needed privacy to feed.

Sally872 · 22/03/2022 12:10

If MIL is reasonable person generally she is probably also worried about imposing on you, but also not wanting to look like she isn't keen to come either. A chat to let her know your thoughts (from you or dh) will probably help her too.

WellNotReally · 22/03/2022 12:10

This thread has made me even more grateful for my wonderful DiL and SS. I'm only a step grandparent but they welcomed us into the delivery room after the birth. It was a huge honour, one we had never expected.

Whilst I wouldn't expect that from many new parents (not even my own DC!), their attitude from the start was that their new baby is fortunate to have so many people who love her in her life. The grandparent grandchild relationship can be so precious.

Staryflight445 · 22/03/2022 12:08

Newborn cuddles for everyone come AFTER mothers comfort and wishes, all day everyday.

It is a headfuck having a child, if a women wants space she is absolutely not being unreasonable. Everyone else can bloody wait.

phoenixrosehere · 22/03/2022 12:07

YANBU

I was in a similar position as you. Barely saw my in-laws, maybe 3 times a year before our oldest was born. My DH mentioned they were coming but he didn’t mention nor realise that they planned to stay with us!!! I had a 3-day induction that failed which let to an emer c-sec. My care was poor and both DH and I were traumatised by the experience, him to the point of not wanting another child. My milk didn’t come in til around day 5 which is when they arrived and it was awkward to say the least. I was traumatised, bleeding, nursing and highly uncomfortable in my own home. I couldn’t nurse in front of them so I had to go upstairs to our bedroom to nurse, still healing from the c-sec. We only had one bathroom and having two people with IBS didn’t help matters so showers were late in the evening or when they had gone out so I could do so without being rushed. My DH used most of his paternity leave with the induction so I was left with his parents which I had never spent time with them together alone before so that made things more awkward. It also didn’t help matters with MIL telling me about her natural births and wonderful care with her three when mine was so sh*t and she knew this even made a joke about me being teary eyed over being traumatised on his first birthday. I felt utterly suffocated with them around and when they left I cried in relief because I was finally left alone with our baby and can get on with things. When I’m in pain or uncomfortable, I want to be left alone, not entertaining people. My DH apologised later for allowing them to come down so soon and especially for them staying with us. We did have a second (after much discussion) and with him it was two weeks before we had visitors and it was amazing and necessary since I spent most of the time in the hospital anyway due to a need for iron transfusions. I had a way better experience with him. In-laws didn’t see him until he was four weeks old which worked out well since he was active and smiling.

Before anyone wants to say anything about unfairness, my parents live in the States so my mother didn’t meet our oldest til he was 6 weeks old and my dad til he was 11 mo. With our second, it was after the two weeks for my mother and 5 mo for my dad so in-laws got plenty of time before my own parents did.

Timeturnerplease · 22/03/2022 12:06

Babies at that age love a cuddle, regardless of who is giving it so you might be relieved to have your hands free for a while!

Blinkingbatshit · 22/03/2022 12:06

Why don’t you suggest that, given you have no idea how you’ll feel/how quickly you’ll recover, it would be prudent for them to come for a couple of days towards the end of your DH’s paternity leave? Post c section with baby no1 you may have sore nipples, bleeding and I had terrible constipation too - did not want anyone in my space and found it quite intrusive when people wanted to come over! I think it’s really unfair that everyone expects a piece of mother and baby after what is such a massive life change, of course many will embrace being the centre of attention, if others don’t want to be respect it.

AintNoPartyLikeANumber10Party · 22/03/2022 12:06

I’m amazed by some of the messages here. Have you forgotten how unpredictable giving birth can be? Have you forgotten what it’s like to be a first time mum?

@LittleGwyneth I think they need to wait until baby is born before booking anything.

Because - and I am sorry to say this and genuinely hope everything will go brilliantly for you - the reality is you cannot possibly know if that’s a good time or not. My first birth, we were unexpectedly both in hospital for over a week - me in ICU and him in NICU (no visits allowed). If my In-laws had travelled the several hundred miles to visit, they wouldn’t have been allowed to see either of us. Neither would my parents. Whereas with DC2 I was happy and able to have anyone visit in the first week (although again, I wasn’t home until day 6).

I think you should gently tell everyone to hold off booking anything until they get the call. And remind your DH that a cs is major surgery, pregnancy and breastfeeding are tough, and newborns are unpredictable. The visitors can wait until you are ready. Good luck.

Staryflight445 · 22/03/2022 12:06

Yanbu op. You’re not just having a baby but a big operation and the recovery is hard.

I’m really shocked by the YABU responses. If you don’t feel up for visitors or feel comfortable and want to wait a couple of weeks, that’s absolutely fine.
Your mum is there for you, as your parent first.

LittleGwyneth · 22/03/2022 12:05

@DarcyBlue That is actually a really interesting point. We are very close to my family, but I would never expect my DH to be 'looked after' by either of my parents. He would be mortified by the idea of being waited on by them. Thank you for saying that - it's made me feel a bit less guilty for not wanting my MIL to make me tea (I don't drink tea) and look after me.

OP posts: