Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's another in-laws post birth thread

434 replies

LittleGwyneth · 22/03/2022 10:12

I have genuinely tried to find other threads to get answers to this, but couldn't find any.

Having a baby in a few weeks, via planned section - only really relevant as it means we will know the date the baby is going to be born.

We live in central London, my parents live about an hour outside of London and my siblings live about half an hour away. My DH's family live about a 4-5 hour drive away.

My MIL is a lovely, practical, kind person. But I don't know her that well. She doesn't really come to London, so in the nearly ten years I've been with my husband I've probably spent 2-3 days with her, twice a year. I like her, but it's certainly not like having a second mum. Her husband, my FIL, is not my husband's father and is fairly irritating. The type to share politically incorrect memes on Facebook.

They want to come and visit us 'as soon as possible' when the baby is born. They're very happy to stay in a hotel nearby, which is good as we won't have a spare room by the time the baby is born. My question is: AIBU to want to wait a bit?

My husband is fairly clueless on all this (and I'm absolutely no expert) so when we talked about it he suggested 'about five days' after the baby is born. To me that sounds very soon, in terms of the fact that I'll presumably be bleeding and lactating a lot.

If PIL lived an hour away they'd pop down, meet the baby, then go home, and I'd be very happy with that. But because it's a big journey and they're spending two nights in a hotel (which won't be cheap), it seems like they're going to be around a lot. And I just don't know at what point you have to put your big girl pants on and accept that there are people you don't know that well in your space, holding your baby, or whether it's fair to say look, I need a couple of weeks?

I don't want to be that woman who lets her own mum meet the baby on day 3 of life and holds off the in-laws. But equally I don't want them to travel all the way to London and then be upset that they only get to see the baby for an hour a day - or that I'm not 100% sure how I'll feel about other people holding her at that stage.

Does anyone have any insight as to when they would have been ready to have visitors? Or how many hours a day would be reasonable to expect to receive people who've made a big journey and spent money to visit you?

OP posts:
Holly60 · 22/03/2022 12:54

OP as a granny myself I can tell you that your MIL will just be delighted to be included in any way you choose. If you invite them over for an hour, she will be pleased. If you ask her to pick up some supplies on the way over, she will be delighted. If you ask her to make you a cuppa, she will feel like she is of some use. Just let them be a small part of the beginning of the journey with your new little one. There are years and years to work out the rest.

Of course you don’t have to entertain them. Get your husband to chat to them and explain how you are feeling- gently. I’m absolutely sure she will totally understand.

AngelinaFibres · 22/03/2022 12:53

[quote Staryflight445]@AngelinaFibres do you have like… a driving hours card type set up or something?
Ooh you spent an extra minute with the grandchild I’m soooo devastated.

🙄[/quote]
No idea what you mean. Sorry, off to see my grandson. Byeeee

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 22/03/2022 12:53

@2022HereWeCome

It is not your concern to treat everyone fairly OP. You need to do what's best for you, DH and your new arrival. And for those posters who think distance is not an issue - it can be. Where I live, you cannot leave booking accommodation until the last minute because there's either no availability or it's hundreds of £s a night
Totally agree.

Was also going to say this is clearly making you anxious. You have to fully discuss that that you have to play it by ear, you don't know how you will feel, what breastfeeding will be like etc.. so get your DH to agree that you will go with the flow,
If you find you are feeling great and want visitors, that's fine, but if you feel that's the very last thing in the world that you want, then that's fine too, but he has to be there to support you and stand up for you and not leave it all to you to be the "bad guy" Agree with him up front that for example you won't want them taking the baby out in the pram without asking you first (if that is a thing) and that they must respect your wishes.
Basically if you are fretting and worrying about things that might happen, have a chat with DH and give him a chance to understand. If he knows that's one of your concerns he can stand up for you. Knowing that he would is sometimes all you need to be more relaxed about everything and would stop you worrying. Nothing unnatural or precious about feeling protective of a new born, but also nothing wrong with talking through these issues and finding solutions in advance between the two of you so that you are both on the same page for any visitors.
Maybe a tactful chat with the in laws upfront with so that they understand you are playing it by ear, seeing what the birth is like and how you feel afterwards would help them be understanding
talk to your MIL about what it was like for her to jog her memory.
Equally I think the idea that your DM had two hours with the baby on Monday at 10 am so the MIL must have two hours with baby at the same time the next day, is more about people pleasing rather than focusing on your needs and baby's needs in the immediate aftermath of the birth.
You can also reassure all of them that they won't be missing out as of course you will be sharing pics and videos or zooms of the baby as soon as they arrive. I think that your worries and issues can be solved with communication and support from your DH being on the same page as you. Best of luck and congrats

Staryflight445 · 22/03/2022 12:53

@AngelinaFibres everyone’s experience of a c section is different. Just because your close to your dil it doesn’t mean you get treated the same as her actual mum does. Nor does it mean you can empathise more with her c section because you had one.

Why you’d feel more entitled to that just because you had a c section and her own mum didn’t I have no idea.

Dixiechickonhols · 22/03/2022 12:51

I do think you are sensible to think how post birth will look. Does husband have any idea how it might be eg if he’s thinking baby just needs feeding every 3 hours he might have no idea. Also he might think taking baby is a break but not realising in early days it’s last thing you want to be separated and you need to get breastfeeding established.
You’ll be skin on skin/boobs out a lot/feeding. How does he see that working with step dad there.
You’ll be recovering from surgery and tired.
I’d communicate with him then work out a plan.

Doboopedoo · 22/03/2022 12:51

Flowers @beginnerwitch on the loss of your MIL.

I agree with your sentiment, you just don’t know what’s ahead in life. Did I want to spend three hours in a car a few days post-section to visit my dying parent? No, but that’s what life throws at you sometimes.

And that’s not to make you feel bad OP, but I think especially with pregnancy and birth we feel the need to over-plan every aspect - but it’s just not possible sometimes. Breastfeeding may not work - that’s totally fine. You may feel up for long visits, you may not. (Bringing food is always welcome, especially if they tidy up!). They will have the exact same focus as you - your new baby.
Hopefully your DH and MIL will ‘read the room’ sufficiently to know when you are over having visitors - maybe get him to set up some conversations about great things to do in London that they can go to as well as visit you all.
And yes, take yourself off to bed if it’s all too much! Best of luck x

AngelinaFibres · 22/03/2022 12:49

[quote Staryflight445]@AngelinaFibres in laws are not equal to the parents of the person who has just given birth. Their priority is their daughter, if you can’t understand that, that’s your problem.[/quote]
My DiL had a cesarean. I had a cesarean in order to deliver the man who is her husband . Her mother didn't. I am very close to my DIL. I live 10 minutes walk away. I don't expect to be treated any differently. I know exactly how a cesarean feels and what the recovery is like.

7eleven · 22/03/2022 12:48

I think you can tell on here who is a paternal grandparent Grin

MayMorris · 22/03/2022 12:48

[quote LittleGwyneth]@JenniferBarkley When you say more than an hour a day - how much time per day seems reasonable? I sort of want it to just be me, DH and the baby for the first week or so, but if that's unreasonable I'd like to try and set some boundaries which are fair.[/quote]
An hour seems really stingy.
I think you need to get your DH to discuss expectations with each other and then them. E.g You will have baby unless it’s sleeeping or DH is holding. They can have a cuddle when it is ok with you- but allow quite a lot of short occasions of that.
Take baby with you to your bedroom for BF or nursery or even sittingroom but state it is not a spectator sport- they shouldn’t come in and watch. If they’re in sittingroom where you want to feed they go somewhere else till you’re done.
They mustn’t disturb baby during sleeping times. But if you need a rest while baby is awake then DH in charge and they can take their lead form him.
They need to be prepared to muck in with chores. Help prep lunch and tea meal, clearing up, running a vacuum if needed. Clean the loo/handbasin just before they leave. Give them a time to arrive (after breakfast and once you’ve had chance to wake up properly though being there to “help” DH could give you the chance for a lovely long shower or even bath) and a time to leave e.g. after tea but we’ll before your early bed time .

If they look like they’re taking to it ok, go out for a walk with them and pushchair- let them push the pram.
Take lots of photos 😉
It is their chance to begin to bond with their GC. 5 days isnt too soon for that.unless you are not well or it’s been a particularly difficult birth- they need to be a bit flexible with their travel plans,

To be honest I expect you will be pretty knackered, pretty obsessed with new born, and not really aware of what they’re up to. If you leave 3 weeks you could be at an even more vulnerable time - DH just gone back to work, trying to cope on your own, more sleep deprived.

If they are absolute pains, then you’ll know not to allow them to visit again in near future. But they may surprise you…and be absolutely prepared to muck in and actually help you.

I didn’t know my MIL well before I had dc. They lived 6 hours drive away and I saw them for a couple of days twice per year. She was a pain at times and we did have some clashes in our personalities. But as grandparents it was a delight. They were overjoyed and so very obviously proud in having GC. My FIL at 80 would get down on the floor and really play and engage with them. Had to have a lot of help getting back up 😱🤣Even though they were miles away, my MIL particularly was excellent in sending lots of letters and mini parcels of little books, or random toy to the kids at random times , she never forgot their spelling tests, dentist appointments and would always be on phone to them to ask them how it went. We didn’t have zoom back then- it’s a real shame ..but they did everything they could to have a strong long distanced relationship.

Staryflight445 · 22/03/2022 12:47

Absolutely don’t feel guilty for having your mum around op, she’s your mum. She’s there for you first and foremost.

Staryflight445 · 22/03/2022 12:45

@AngelinaFibres do you have like… a driving hours card type set up or something?
Ooh you spent an extra minute with the grandchild I’m soooo devastated.

🙄

LittleGwyneth · 22/03/2022 12:44

I think the upshot is that it's best not to make any commitments to anyone or any visitation until the baby is born. As lots of people very sensibly pointed out, things can change.

Thanks so much for the supportive comments. Probably best I don't get into replying to the people who said that I'm selfish or that they're glad I'm not their daughter in law! Suffice to say I'm trying my best here.

OP posts:
BeanyBops · 22/03/2022 12:43

I don't think YABU at all and I do think that grandparents can have very odd ideas about a 'right' to see a baby.

Those early days are very difficult to predict, expecially with your first. You just don't know how you will feel, whether you will want to enjoy the newborn bubble just the three of you for the first week or whether the first hour is enough before you'll be wanting to show the baby off!!

I told all family not to expect immediate access, exactly because we wanted to play it be ear and see what we felt up to.

Maybe you could offer to PIL- 'we don't know what to expect or how we will be feeling, so you can book a visit early on now and take a chance that you might not get to spend a lot of time with us, or we can wait and see how we all get on and possibly book something in a bit later but perhaps with a bit more time and headspace to entertain'.

That said, those early weeks are crazy and you could well be glad of a friendly face and a helping hand.

Staryflight445 · 22/03/2022 12:43

@AngelinaFibres in laws are not equal to the parents of the person who has just given birth. Their priority is their daughter, if you can’t understand that, that’s your problem.

MarvelMrs · 22/03/2022 12:43

I also think you sound lovely and kind and that you are trying to consider your MIL’s feelings. You wouldn’t have posted for advice if you didn’t care.

BellatrixOnABadDay · 22/03/2022 12:41

[quote Staryflight445]@Peaseblossum22 if a grandparent can’t understand that a c section is incredibly difficult to recover from and who doesn’t remember how difficult it is a transition from going from no child to having one, and insist on visiting straight away and don’t have any respect to wait. I’d say the parents have had a lucky escape anyway.[/quote]
1- C-sections aren't always difficult to recover from - especially if ELCS. Mine weren't. My iron was low during pregnancy and after birth and I had baby blues around day 4-5.
2- I think a week is perfectly reasonable to ask people to wait- and longer if need be depending on how things have gone, but also, 5 days or whatever is hardly demanding to see the baby immediately.

OP can't possibly know how it will go yet. I find these threads often whip up such hostility- particularly towards paternal grandparents. I say that as someone who never got on with my now thankfully ex in-laws.

7eleven · 22/03/2022 12:41

I think it’s really important that the grandparents get treated equally. Don’t make your mil wait any longer than your mum.

MarvelMrs · 22/03/2022 12:41

I think you are absolutely fine to ask them to wait and come a week or so after the birth. That will not harm any future relationship. You may not feel like visitors until that stage and it is better to be prepared than have a disastrous visit too early.
I would talk to your MIL and explain how nervous you are feeling and ask if they could book some things to entertain themselves as well as visiting so you don’t feel burdened with entertaining. So perhaps they visit for coffee in the morning, go out for lunch and then visit for the afternoon then go to the theatre or the cinema. That sort of thing.
Communication is the key here.

2022HereWeCome · 22/03/2022 12:40

It is not your concern to treat everyone fairly OP. You need to do what's best for you, DH and your new arrival. And for those posters who think distance is not an issue - it can be. Where I live, you cannot leave booking accommodation until the last minute because there's either no availability or it's hundreds of £s a night

Chloemol · 22/03/2022 12:40

[quote LittleGwyneth]@Chloemol We are much, much closer to my family. We spend one weekend a month at their house, whereas we see PIL 2/3 times a year. So I do think that makes a bit of a difference. It's also v different because my parents can pop down for an hour and then leave, and I can tell them to bugger off when I feel like it. I'd also be able to get my boobs out in front of my mum or tell her I want her to leave because I need to use the loo in privacy. None of which is true of the in laws.

All of that said, I'm not trying to favour my parents anymore than we already do because we're closer to them, and if PIL are willing to make the long drive for short visits then they will be welcomed as often as they want. I just don't think I can do hours and hours on end.[/quote]
So glad you are not my daughter in law

You are being very nasty to your in laws who will no doubt want to see their grandchild for more than an hour before being kicked out

Staryflight445 · 22/03/2022 12:39

You don’t even need to justify that op.

People are being ridiculous.

LittleGwyneth · 22/03/2022 12:39

@AngelinaFibres I think it's more that my mum lives close so can come and go, so she will only stay an hour or two at a time but she can do that twice a week for the next year if she wants, whereas MIL won't have that option so will understandably want to spend longer chunks of time here.

OP posts:
AngelinaFibres · 22/03/2022 12:39

[quote LittleGwyneth]@angelinafibres I don't think asking for a week - ten days to adjust is keeping people away, per se. And I have said I'd be very happy for them to visit in the hospital, if they're willing to make that very long journey for just an hour a day of visiting. But if we do ask them to wait ten days I won't be keeping 'everyone' away. I want/need my mum around, which I think is a bit different. Of course we won't have loads of friends and distant family to visit if we're not having PIL.[/quote]
Nope. As the mother of a son whose wife has just had baby ,that would break my heart. It would be absolute agony to know that the other granny was there for hours on end and I was allowed one visit in the hospital and then nothing. Your husband's parents have just become grandparents. They are absolutely equal in this

Crunched · 22/03/2022 12:39

What a lovely post Peaseblossum22.

I sort of want it to just be me, DH and the baby for the first week or so
As long as this is equally applied to your parents as well. Don't start a lifetime of your IL's feeling second best.

Chloemol · 22/03/2022 12:39

[quote LittleGwyneth]@angelinafibres I don't think asking for a week - ten days to adjust is keeping people away, per se. And I have said I'd be very happy for them to visit in the hospital, if they're willing to make that very long journey for just an hour a day of visiting. But if we do ask them to wait ten days I won't be keeping 'everyone' away. I want/need my mum around, which I think is a bit different. Of course we won't have loads of friends and distant family to visit if we're not having PIL.[/quote]
Sorry I disagree with this

Either no one comes, so you are fair to everyone, or you accept visitors

As it is it’s likely your parents will see this grandchild more due to the fact they live nearer, so you will have to be prepared for longer visits to or from his parents

You may have given birth to the child, but it’s not just yours, it’s also your partners and he may want his parents to see the baby just as soon as your parents

Your mil may also be ablr and willing to help out as well