Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbour issue ....

62 replies

Trisaratops · 22/03/2022 08:41

Three years ago my neighbours back garden fence blew down (separates our gardens). 3/4 panels of 6 foot fencing ... It's her side, not mine.

I'm very house/garden proud and when I look out my window and see 3 panels gone and a broken up 4th that I've tried my hardest to manipulate into something that resembles a piece of fencing... It just makes my lovely garden look shit!

I know she's not poor, so it's not a money issue, it's a she can't see it because her shed is situated in a way that it's not in her sight line - but it's entirely in mine.

We get on fine, chat all the time, but for things like this, she's not approachable ... so I can't really say anything..

Am I being unreasonable to want the fence fixed now?

My fence blew down out the front recently when we had those really strong winds (currently our front gardens are one big garden and I hate it) and I'm having it replaced imminently with a bigger and better one... why can't she do the same?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ItsSnowJokes · 22/03/2022 11:54

You don't have to have a fence, so she is probably not bothered about it. You have the option of putting up your own fence, or asking her again to fix it, but she has no legal obligation to fix it, if she is happy as it is.

ClaudiaWankleman · 22/03/2022 11:44

Legally, it is as much your responsibility to keep you dog off her land as it is for her to enclose her land to trespassing dogs

It's not the neighbour's responsibility at all to enclose her land to trespassers. The responsibility is all on the part of the dog owner.

Mummyoflittledragon · 22/03/2022 11:00

Could your dog escape through the front of her property or either side of her fences if you allowed it on your garden (and potentially on to hers)? If not, you could allow your dog to roam. Legally, it is as much your responsibility to keep you dog off her land as it is for her to enclose her land to trespassing dogs.

Maybe that will force her hand.

Knittingchamp · 22/03/2022 10:46

@Trisaratops

It's HER fence - on HER property. She's told me she'll fix it ..... many times, but nope.

Talking to her like an adult - that comment is absurd since you do not know her!

I am not expecting her to fix MY fence why would I go ONTO her property and pay someone to fix something that isn't mine!????? Is that really a thing... dishing out for someone else's fence? Don't think so. It's an eyesore .... it's looks shit.... surely after 3 years she'd naturally want it fixed?

I mean, you are totally right OP but do you want the eyesore gone? Sadly the reality might be that (even though it is ridiculous) you pay for it. It's a what's right vs what you need (a new fence) and ultimately which one outweighs the other.
FlissyPaps · 22/03/2022 10:33
  1. Ask her to fix it as it’s annoying you.
  2. Don’t ask her to fix it and fix it yourself
  3. Put your own fence up around your side
  4. Don’t do anything about it and live with a broken fence that pisses you off

You say you don’t like confrontation, but how do you know it’ll turn into confrontation? Have you had arguments over silly things in the past?

TenoringBehind · 22/03/2022 10:32

Just ask her politely if she plans to fix it in the near future. It may be one of those things she’s been meaning to organise but hasn’t got round to because other things in her life have been more important. It’s not necessarily about the money - and you are only guessing as to the state of her finances - more the hassle of getting quotes etc.

You’ve got nothing to lose by talking to her. She might decide to get it fixed. She might say she’s not going to, but you’re no worse off than at the moment and will know whether you need to make your own arrangements on your side of the boundary. Chicken wire is a good cheaper alternative to dog proof your garden on a temporary basis.

canicross · 22/03/2022 10:30

Well, obviously don't do this, but what you could do if you were a confrontational trouble maker would be put up a really cheap unsightly fence that land grabs a chunk of her garden. She will either shell out for a solicitor (unlikely), or she'll take it down and put up her own in the correct place.

People go crazy over boundaries. I reckon she'd have a new fence in place in days.

Better idea would be to talk to her.

Cookiecrumble22 · 22/03/2022 10:24

[quote Trisaratops]@Cheeserton

It's very obvious. Her clothes. Her car. Her job! You don't work in London and earn pennies.... we don't live in London so it's cheaper here! So don't be confused that she's paying London house prices .. The woman is very very comfortable! Comfortable enough to replace fence panels. Comfortable enough to be driving around in a brand new BMW series 8! [/quote]
I'm bit confused. Do you mean she works in London? But lives outside of London?

The car could be on finance. Working in London does not always mean your well paid . (Why do people think that )? She could have a lot of debt. You don't know what she needs to pay out .

Popopopo · 22/03/2022 10:21

It's her fence, if she doesnt want to or can't be bothered to fix it, there's literally nothing you can do

Lots of people work in London and earn pennies Confused do you think there are no low paid jobs in London?

incognitoforthisone · 22/03/2022 10:02

I don't do confrontation/animosity. Nothing to do with not being an adult. She's very fiery and I don't want to piss her off. It's called wanting to remain living in a peaceful environment.

So what exactly are you suggesting the solution is, then? She isn't legally obliged to put up a fence on her boundary if she doesn't want to, regardless of how ugly it looks, and if it's been three years she clearly doesn't care about it looking crap. The two potential solutions are for you to tell her very firmly that you do care and that you would really like assurance over when it will be fixed, or for you to put up a fence that is to your liking on your side of the boundary. Neither of those solutions are acceptable to you, though, and that's on you I'm afraid.

Useranon1 · 22/03/2022 09:59

Why not just tell her you've got someone coming to do yours, and would she like them to do hers at the same time. And if so, it'll cost X amount and you'll need it in advance.

Philisophigal · 22/03/2022 09:55

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at the user's request.

PAFMO · 22/03/2022 09:45

@Trisaratops

I don't do confrontation/animosity. Nothing to do with not being an adult. She's very fiery and I don't want to piss her off. It's called wanting to remain living in a peaceful environment.
From your posts on this thread, you sound like you'd be pretty good at both confrontation and animosity tbf.
ClaudiaWankleman · 22/03/2022 09:39

It's very obvious. Her clothes. Her car. Her job! You don't work in London and earn pennies.... we don't live in London so it's cheaper here! So don't be confused that she's paying London house prices .. The woman is very very comfortable! Comfortable enough to replace fence panels. Comfortable enough to be driving around in a brand new BMW series 8!

You're too invested.
She doesn't care about the fence, and she doesn't have to. You care about the fence so you should fix it. The cheaper prices in your area should soften the blow.

LIZS · 22/03/2022 09:37

If you have a dog it is up to you to contain it, as you seem to have done on the patio. If she works in London and has a shed in front it won't be priority. Dh was never interested until he wfh. We have a double fence at bottom of ours. Our boundary but we don't really see it. Neighbour behind garden is at a much lower level and she has put her own where hers finishes. Gap between acts as a wildlife corridor.

MrsMinge · 22/03/2022 09:34

@ivykaty44 how dare you be the voice of reason Grin

Trisaratops · 22/03/2022 09:33

Thank you everyone for your replies.

I get I'm being unreasonable expecting too much.

:-)

OP posts:
Kego · 22/03/2022 09:30

She doesn’t care about the fence. You do. So get your own fence.

Trisaratops · 22/03/2022 09:30

@Cheeserton

It's very obvious. Her clothes. Her car. Her job! You don't work in London and earn pennies.... we don't live in London so it's cheaper here! So don't be confused that she's paying London house prices .. The woman is very very comfortable! Comfortable enough to replace fence panels. Comfortable enough to be driving around in a brand new BMW series 8!

OP posts:
FAQs · 22/03/2022 09:29

I’ve replaced two lots of fences involving two sets of neighbours and we have always gone halves no matter who owns it because we both benefit, maybe I’m lucky?

MrMrsJones · 22/03/2022 09:28

She doesn't have to fix her fence.

If it bothers you, just put one up on your property

ivykaty44 · 22/03/2022 09:27

Is it really too much to expect the same from others?

Yes, because there legally doesn't have to be a fence separating properties.

Your neighbour could take the rest of her fence down if she so choose and there is nothing you can do about it

If you want a fence then put one on your land, though im not sure why you've stated you can't do this?

Canigooutyet · 22/03/2022 09:24

Over the past 3years I've had lots of various tradespeople cancel on me often on the day due to corona.
At times their waiting lists have been astronomical unless I want to pay exorbitant fees.
do as another poster suggested next time you talk give her the details of the person who is fixing yours. Or out something just inside your border, and this way it will fit in more with your garden.

And just because on the outside of appears she is loaded, doesn't mean she is cash rich.

girlmom21 · 22/03/2022 09:24

[quote Trisaratops]@girlmom21

No animosity at all. Smile

[/quote]
Maybe the way you write just comes across differently to the way you intent Smile

I would hint at the replacement rather than ask her to do it. If you do the hard work of finding the workman she might be willing to replace them.

Our elderly neighbour left a panel space empty between her and us for ages because she couldn't be arsed to replace it and our little dog couldn't get through because we have a rose bush in the way. As soon as DP said he has a friend who can replace it for x price she agreed to get it done.

RatherBeRiding · 22/03/2022 09:23

Sounds like she's really got no intention of fixing it as she can't see it, and it obviously doesn't bother her. In your position I'd get some big screening plants in pots and stick them in the gap, even the hateful but very fast growing leylandii. At least you won't have to look out at an eyesore any more and as they are your plants you can move them and trim them as you see fit.

Swipe left for the next trending thread