Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My partners mum wants our baby to call her mama? AIBU?

362 replies

Lily1992 · 22/03/2022 07:13

My partner (m) and I (f) are trying for our first baby. My partners mum wants the baby to refer to her as ‘mama’. She already has other grandchildren which do this, which makes her feel as though she’s justified in wanting this. Adding to this, my boyfriends family called his grandma ‘mama’ and his great grandma ‘great mama’. He’s a mummy’s boy and I feel bad breaking family tradition but I’m really not comfortable with this. I’m the bad guy in this situation and they keep reassuring me that there is a subtle pronunciation difference but I can’t hear it and saying I will ruin tradition and confuse the grandchildren if they all use different names to refer to their grandmother. They’ve made it clear it’s not open to discussion but I can’t get my head around it. AIBU?

OP posts:
PinaColada123456 · 22/03/2022 18:31

@girlmom21

How is she getting 100% say when the father said it's non-negotiable?

If he says it's non-negotiable and then they 'compromise' he hasn't had his say has he. That would make her controlling and abusive, by your reckoning.

No we don't know if she has parents. We don't know if the pronunciation she says she can't hear is very obvious either. We're making assumptions based on the information we have to hand.

@girlmom21 If they compromise then that's 50-50, is it not? Because if they are both compromising, then they've both had their say and compromised. Do you understand what it means by compromise? an agreement or settlement of a dispute that is reached by each side making concessions. It means both sides meet in the middle. So it would be 50-50. Not sure how that makes her 50% more controlling and abusive than his 50%.....
notanothertakeaway · 22/03/2022 18:31

@Bananabutter

I’d tell them to get fucked. It’s your child - they don’t get to make anything clear.

I would be very firm and up and upfront and tell them they can be grandma/Nan/granny etc but not mama. Repeat like a broken record.

If they refuse and cannot respect you as a parent then they don’t get to see the baby. It’s that simple.

@Bananabutter

It's not that simple

Her DP wants the baby to call his DM Mama. I wouldn't like that, but it's not just OP's choice

And would be a ridiculous reason to try to prevent a child have a relationship with their grandmother

PinaColada123456 · 22/03/2022 18:27

@BanjoKnockers

'The sisterhood' doesn't exist. You got that right. It used to. It doesn't exist anymore.

Good riddance! Why should it? It sounds like the freemasons. Sometimes women are wrong. (Eg the mother in law, according to you Grin)

@BanjoKnockers So women shouldn't be each other's support systems? 'Good riddance' to women's support? How to say you're an MRA and femphobic without saying you're an MRA and femphobic. The chauvinism and loathing seeps into your posts.
yikesanotherbooboo · 22/03/2022 17:29

What will your child call you?
If it isn't Mama and in the baby's father's family Mama is the usual name for Grandmother I don't understand the problem. I also don't think it is up to you to choose names for your parents and in laws. Any more information?

lunar1 · 22/03/2022 16:44

Your child isn't going to mix you up with their grandparent. I wonder if you knew the family tradition before deciding to have children?

I really don't think it's worth making this the line in the sand.

BanjoKnockers · 22/03/2022 16:41

'The sisterhood' doesn't exist.
You got that right. It used to. It doesn't exist anymore.

Good riddance! Why should it? It sounds like the freemasons. Sometimes women are wrong. (Eg the mother in law, according to you Grin)

caringcarer · 22/03/2022 16:35

When my dd was pregnant she asked me and DH what we wanted to be called. I said nanny X and DH said his surname as lots of people call him that. Her mil wanted marmar z, so marmar followed by Christian name. As long as not Mummy I don't see the problem and if her other grandchildren call her a name you are sort of stuck with it really.

user1471538283 · 22/03/2022 16:27

I want to be Mama! Partly in recognition of the wonderful woman who was my DGGM and was Mama to everyone! I bet I end up with one of the unflattering names my DS calls me!

It never felt or feel confusing. My DGM on both sides had a different names.

girlmom21 · 22/03/2022 16:25

How is she getting 100% say when the father said it's non-negotiable?

If he says it's non-negotiable and then they 'compromise' he hasn't had his say has he. That would make her controlling and abusive, by your reckoning.

No we don't know if she has parents. We don't know if the pronunciation she says she can't hear is very obvious either. We're making assumptions based on the information we have to hand.

PinaColada123456 · 22/03/2022 16:20

[quote girlmom21]@PinaColada123456 but if says it's non-negotiable and she says it's not happening isn't she getting 100% of the say? [/quote]
How is she getting 100% say when the father said it's non-negotiable?

I also forgot to say that we don't know if the OP has her parents still alive or is in contact with them if they are, so the 'they have 100% say with their side' therefore doesn't work and is unfair. It should be 50-50 for each side, not the father laying down the law saying this is how it is going to be, be silent, end of discussion. You're not going to make your wife/partner happy if you speak to them like that! That's guaranteed to get any woman's back up (or man's back up if the situation is reversed).

girlmom21 · 22/03/2022 16:14

@PinaColada123456 but if says it's non-negotiable and she says it's not happening isn't she getting 100% of the say?

PinaColada123456 · 22/03/2022 16:11

[quote girlmom21]@PinaColada123456 she gets to decide what her parents are called. That's 50/50 [/quote]
It should be 50/50 for both sets of grandparents. It should never be one parent deciding for one set.

Wedonttalkaboutrats · 22/03/2022 16:10

@PinaColada123456
In this specific case, yes, I do honestly think it’s fair that the father’s wishes trump the mother’s on what to call the father’s mother. As I would think it fair the other way around. Which perhaps it is. But we don’t know. We know very little about the op’s relationship. It’s misguided to jump to such serious conclusions with so little knowledge. I think perhaps you are projecting.

girlmom21 · 22/03/2022 16:04

@PinaColada123456 she gets to decide what her parents are called. That's 50/50

PinaColada123456 · 22/03/2022 16:02

[quote Wedonttalkaboutrats]@PinaColada123456
I’m not sure why you’ve turned this into a whole male v female oppression discussion. Maybe that’s just your thing? But you seem to be glossing over the fact that the grandmother (a woman, presumably) is also involved. How does that fit with your ‘men oppressing women’ tirade?[/quote]
@Wedonttalkaboutrats Perhaps because that is what it is? How is it not oppression if the mother has no say? You bring the grandmother into the equation yet conveniently ignore that only 50% of the couple are allowed a say.

I asked a question in good faith. Please tell me do you honestly think it's fair that the father has 100% say and the mother has 0%?

Wedonttalkaboutrats · 22/03/2022 15:50

@PinaColada123456
I’m not sure why you’ve turned this into a whole male v female oppression discussion. Maybe that’s just your thing? But you seem to be glossing over the fact that the grandmother (a woman, presumably) is also involved. How does that fit with your ‘men oppressing women’ tirade?

PinaColada123456 · 22/03/2022 15:50

[quote girlmom21]@PinaColada123456 I don't agree with your aggression or most of what you're saying. 'The sisterhood' doesn't exist. Women can disagree with women and call out unnecessary behaviour, just like we can about men and men can about us and each other.

Having a vagina doesn't mean we have to all sit around singing kumbaya [/quote]
@girlmom21 There is no aggression from me, only incredulity. If you read aggression into it that's not my doing, though tone is hard to read in print.

'The sisterhood' doesn't exist.
You got that right. It used to. It doesn't exist anymore.

PinaColada123456 · 22/03/2022 15:46

@BanjoKnockers

So you agree that a father has a say, but a mother has no say?

Just want clarity on that, that you believe the mother has no say at all. But the father has all the say?

Hi there @PinaColada123456

I think the mother does not have control over every aspect of a child's life. It is a separate person, with its own relationship with other members of its family.

@BanjoKnockers I think the mother does not have control over every aspect of a child's life.

That's fine but why then does the father have control then? If the mother has no say, why is the father saying he has all the say and 'end of discussion'? Why doesn't the father treat the child as a separate person? After all, he is the one dictating what the child will call it's grandfather. So why does he get any say then, either?

girlmom21 · 22/03/2022 15:45

@PinaColada123456 I don't agree with your aggression or most of what you're saying. 'The sisterhood' doesn't exist. Women can disagree with women and call out unnecessary behaviour, just like we can about men and men can about us and each other.

Having a vagina doesn't mean we have to all sit around singing kumbaya

Nillynally · 22/03/2022 15:44

We call one of our grandmothers mama. It's pronounced "mom-ar". Is it the same?

Kinsters · 22/03/2022 15:44

Was there a name change? Couldn't see any posts from op except the first one.

Are your in-laws Chinese? The Chinese word for paternal grandmother is mar-mar so that could explain it. I wouldn't get worked up about it tbh - your baby will know that MIL is not it's mother no matter what she's known as.

PinaColada123456 · 22/03/2022 15:43

[quote girlmom21]@PinaColada123456 read my comments and you'll see I do see the problem.

I also think if a couple can't discuss something this basic they shouldn't even consider trying for a baby, because there's a whole range of issues so much bigger than this where children are involved. [/quote]
Then a bit of support and agreement with me would have been nice instead of attacking me, but it does prove my point about the sisterhood not backing each other up. Sad

PinaColada123456 · 22/03/2022 15:42

[quote Wedonttalkaboutrats]@PinaColada123456 calm down. I have read and I fully comprehend. I simply disagree with you labelling someone as controlling and abusive when the only information we have does not necessarily indicate anything of the sort.[/quote]
@Wedonttalkaboutrats So you don't believe a man telling a woman she has no say at all, only he does, and there is to be 'no discussion', she has no say at all is controlling and abusive? Just for clarity sake, you are saying the man making all the decisions and telling the woman she has no say whatsoever is 'not controlling'.

Is that what you're saying?

BanjoKnockers · 22/03/2022 15:42

So you agree that a father has a say, but a mother has no say?

Just want clarity on that, that you believe the mother has no say at all. But the father has all the say?

Hi there @PinaColada123456

I think the mother does not have control over every aspect of a child's life. It is a separate person, with its own relationship with other members of its family.

Wedonttalkaboutrats · 22/03/2022 15:34

@PinaColada123456 calm down. I have read and I fully comprehend. I simply disagree with you labelling someone as controlling and abusive when the only information we have does not necessarily indicate anything of the sort.