Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Upset over partners mortgage AIBU

285 replies

Mfsf · 21/03/2022 22:30

My partner moved in 2 years ago , prior to this I lived alone with my 2 kids and paid all my bills and consider myself quite independent financially .
When he moved in it meant he had to leave his job abroad . He found a job straight away but he earns half of what I do . So basically I kept paying everything as I already did it anyway and he pays some food shopping when he comes shopping with us . I have a ok wage but I don’t have much after paying for everything myself and now 3 children , with covid some months I even struggled this year , but normally enough to visit my family abroad and a small holiday that my kids love and got used too and that we have always done .
We have since had a baby together .
I actually do not mind the financial burden is mostly on me all of the time , with his wages he is paying his mortgage and child support for his child ( obviously this last is 100% fine and essential) .
My issue now is he cannot afford to go on holiday , even if I pay for it he will still have his mortgage and it would mean he would not earn for those weeks .
This has really upset me , this is not something I want to take away from my kids . Why should I stop myself from giving my kids what they are used too so he can have a empty house that he pays mortgage for? He refuses to let it too .
He has this “ idealistic idea “ that it’s something he can leave his son , which is fine but not only he still has 20 years of mortgage to pay but his ex wife is still in the mortgage despite not paying for it since they divorced 7 years ago . So I’m expected to never be able to go on holiday or even contemplate a place together simply because he likes the idea to have a home ?
I love him , the kids love him but I admit the fact he pays towards this completely separate life to us and expects me to make sacrifices is really starting to make me resent him .
To make it “ worse “ my youngest eventually will need some childcare and I’m pretty sure he is assuming I will pay for it or just work with her at home ( I do work from home but I have constant meetings and we did discuss I would need at least a few days a week of childcare as I have meetings and constant phone calls )
Am I being unreasonable to fell upset ?

OP posts:
wtfwasthatmate · 22/03/2022 02:41

So he's building up an asset while you provide for two extra people. Nice. Sounds like a great guy.

PiperPosey · 22/03/2022 02:13

PS... sell the house...Period... Wine

PiperPosey · 22/03/2022 02:11

OP.. My husband was divorced and had to pay his ex through the roof...she is an alcoholic and so she showed 0 income and could qualify for disability ( Yes in USA) she could get disability because of her alcoholism but refused. Angry

He had to give her 1/2 of his income (58-65 when he retired) I resented it... but finally decided... ( Why is alimony so expensive? because it is worth it) and I signed up for it...( marrying him) she gets his Social Security ( but it doesn't affect him) He gets it too.

She also got 1/2 of his retirement...blah, blah, blah...
But I have him. Ride or die. It just is what it is... He is 74 now and enjoys working to get out of the house.

It was worth every penny he had to spend on her. Your husband sounds like a good man. [ flowers] but I can understand how you feel...I totally understand it.. 100%... I would rather him a husband who is loving me and taking care of past responsibilities...if that's what HE signed up for...

NeverChange · 22/03/2022 01:49

Call me cynical but leaving a house overseas empty just doesn't add up?

Surely for security, insurance & upkeep reasons alone it would be rented our, even temporarily?

Are you sure he isn't also in receipt of rental income as well as making the mortgage?!

Also why would he want to hold in to a non income producing asset in a country he no longer has a connection with to kept for 1 son's inheritance,even though he has 2, when neither son has an connection with the country either. Surely disposing of it and using the sale proceeds for a more profitable investment would make more sense?

None of this adds up unless he is pure stupid, like really dim. I suspect he isn't or certainly not as much as he would like you to think.

Speakuptomakeyourselfheard · 22/03/2022 01:41

OP can I ask, does his ex wife still have any stake in the house that he's hanging on to, or has he paid her off completely? If she does still have a stake in it, you do realise don't you, that not only are you subsidising his continuing ownership, but will eventually be contributing indirectly to putting money into her pocket when he is forced to either sell it or give her half the value? Clearly, as you have now said, you need to have a serious conversation with him, but under no circumstances would I cancel the holiday plans that your children look forward to, just because he can't or won't contribute enough to the household. Insist he sells the other house or tell him it's time he moved back to it would be my advice. Good luck, and please come back and tell us how things go after the chat.

DontLookBackInAnger1 · 22/03/2022 01:27

Can he retrain/qualify to earn more? Does he have plans to increase his salary?

Walkingalot · 22/03/2022 01:17

So he's paying all the mortgage on a property that he only half owns with his ex wife and intends on leaving his share to his other child, not even your child with him. While you subsidise him over your children and child together. I could maybe understand him keeping hold of it if there were only a few yrs to go but this isn't the case. This isn't fair on you. I'd question his true motives for keeping an empty house and his commitment to you and your child and definitely do not marry him.

Fossilsmorefossils · 22/03/2022 01:17

Why isn't he renting it out?

BringOnTheOtherWorlders · 22/03/2022 00:51

Is he planning on moving back and that's why he won't sell it or even rent it out? Is it his escape plan?

He can buy a life insurance policy and make the first son beneficiary instead of hanging on to this asset for what could be DECADES.

Or is housing scarce in that country and he is sitting on a gold mine?

youvegottenminuteslynn · 22/03/2022 00:40

Why isn't he renting out his home abroad to cover the mortgage?

He sounds either stupid, stubborn or both.

caringcarer · 22/03/2022 00:38

He needs to sell the overseas house as he can't afford to keep it. He has 2 children so needs to contribute to both. Point this out to him. Go on holiday with your children and let him stay home alone. It might make him think a bit. Tell him he needs to pay half of your child together nursery fees too. Point out it is unfair he provides for one of his kids but not the other. If he does not sell house or rent it out I would be ditching him and making him pay child maintenance.

Zilla1 · 22/03/2022 00:33

It sounds like you have got where you need to and the holiday issue was more a trigger to discuss the fundamental issue. To give him the benefit of the doubt, it may be residual guilt together with a NMW job that has led to his preference to keep the house for his eldest to inherit and not to want to let it but it sounds like you need to talk and he needs to think through the consequences of his preferences which might be manageable if well-paid but less so if a NMW job means you are subsidising him and his DC at the cost of all your children. It will be interesting if he can make the changes or if push will come to shove. Your DC, both the elder and your youngest need him to be on board and contribute.

Good luck.

Zilla1 · 22/03/2022 00:27

HNRTT OP but while you are thinking things through, have you thought about estates and wills with having a young child and a DP. He might have a claim against your estate if a DP and more so if married and it sounds like residual guilt? about his eldest might mean he might not definitively have your youngest's back let alone your elder compared with his eldest though I hope he'd have his priorities sorted.

Good luck with the conversation about his financial commitment.

Mfsf · 22/03/2022 00:18

Because work meant he had to go abroad ? His son is a teen and they have a great relationship. He visits and they talk daily . That’s a bit unfair

OP posts:
toomuchlaundry · 22/03/2022 00:14

Why does he live in a different country from his eldest child, that doesn’t scream good dad to me? Is it possible he might do that to your child one day?

Mfsf · 22/03/2022 00:11

I agree with you , hence me saying he is not a bag person , we probably should have had this chat early on and achieve some boundaries .

OP posts:
HellToTheNope · 22/03/2022 00:07

You have chosen poorly, chose to have a baby with him, and now have to live with the consequences. What can any of us advise? You either end the relationship or decide to live with things the way they are.

whynotwhatknot · 22/03/2022 00:00

Why isnt his house he so wants to keep being left to both his children

NumberTheory · 21/03/2022 23:56

It doesn't sound fair that he's building up an asset while you pay all the living costs but...

You seem to indicate in your OP that he gave up a more lucrative career to move to the country you live in. That's a big sacrifice. I'm not surprised he thought it wise to maintain a nest egg.

Your current arrangement doesn't seem balanced, but I'm not so sure the chorus of what boils down to "cocklodger" is entirely valid. You should sit down and talk about how to balance all your financial needs, including both your needs for financial nest eggs and enough to cover a reasonable standard of living.

Rummikub · 21/03/2022 23:56

What was his job there? Could he do it here?

Mfsf · 21/03/2022 23:55

Thank you all one way or another . I will be having a hard chat and will need to make some life changing decisions .
I guess part of the reason why this was not discussed was because I felt bad he heft a job abroad to come here , a well paid one so I guess without realising I felt guilty . But it’s been 2 years and if his life is to be with us then his commitments including financial should be here .

OP posts:
BlueSummerBaby · 21/03/2022 23:53

Kick him out, don't get financially entwined with him, don't marry him. He's a user. Claim child maintenance from him. You'll be quids in without another adult in the house using electric/gas/water/food and pushing up the council tax bill. If your wages aren't good any more you could be eligible for some government assistance too.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 21/03/2022 23:48

He's gaining everything he wants from this arrangement. Indirectly you are paying his mortgage and housing him now
What are you gaining from your relationship?

Sswhinesthebest · 21/03/2022 23:43

At the very least he should be paying half the bills and living expenses eve n if you pay the mortgage. If he can’t afford his share of the living costs then he can’t afford his mortgage,

Radyward · 21/03/2022 23:42

Its not an equal partnership at all and i dont mean financially equal.his priorities are so skewed..it feels like he is keeping a safety net should ye break up and he has a base abroad still. Not v committed .if my kids suffered after me having a new baby and
a partner who just rolled along dropping me a few quid for the groceries i would be fuming and if he didnt change sharpish. Ge would be out the door. Great dad / crap partner just doesnt gel well