Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Upset over partners mortgage AIBU

285 replies

Mfsf · 21/03/2022 22:30

My partner moved in 2 years ago , prior to this I lived alone with my 2 kids and paid all my bills and consider myself quite independent financially .
When he moved in it meant he had to leave his job abroad . He found a job straight away but he earns half of what I do . So basically I kept paying everything as I already did it anyway and he pays some food shopping when he comes shopping with us . I have a ok wage but I don’t have much after paying for everything myself and now 3 children , with covid some months I even struggled this year , but normally enough to visit my family abroad and a small holiday that my kids love and got used too and that we have always done .
We have since had a baby together .
I actually do not mind the financial burden is mostly on me all of the time , with his wages he is paying his mortgage and child support for his child ( obviously this last is 100% fine and essential) .
My issue now is he cannot afford to go on holiday , even if I pay for it he will still have his mortgage and it would mean he would not earn for those weeks .
This has really upset me , this is not something I want to take away from my kids . Why should I stop myself from giving my kids what they are used too so he can have a empty house that he pays mortgage for? He refuses to let it too .
He has this “ idealistic idea “ that it’s something he can leave his son , which is fine but not only he still has 20 years of mortgage to pay but his ex wife is still in the mortgage despite not paying for it since they divorced 7 years ago . So I’m expected to never be able to go on holiday or even contemplate a place together simply because he likes the idea to have a home ?
I love him , the kids love him but I admit the fact he pays towards this completely separate life to us and expects me to make sacrifices is really starting to make me resent him .
To make it “ worse “ my youngest eventually will need some childcare and I’m pretty sure he is assuming I will pay for it or just work with her at home ( I do work from home but I have constant meetings and we did discuss I would need at least a few days a week of childcare as I have meetings and constant phone calls )
Am I being unreasonable to fell upset ?

OP posts:
MrKlaw · 22/03/2022 09:40

he needs to get his ex wife off the mortage and let it out to cover the mortgage - or sell it. Paying the mortgage with an empty house is lovely if he has the luxury of an income to support that - which he doesn't.

AllOfUsAreDead · 22/03/2022 09:37

I dunno what advice to give you, this should have been sorted before you had a kid with him, but too late for that now. He's showing you who he is, he's happy to let you pay all bills for your children and his, happy to let you pay for him to go on holiday, and happy to leave a house to his first son, ignoring his other child with you entirely.

If none of that is enough to prove to you that no, he isn't a nice person and isn't a good dad, I don't know how to help you. Frankly with his attitude, I'd be telling him to sell the house ASAP or he's getting kicked out and that's another failed relationship for him, plus another child he won't see often. Great role model if he decides leaving is the best option.

Sswhinesthebest · 22/03/2022 09:36

I guess the issue with renting it out is that his wife will also have to pay tax on her half. It gets confusing and she may not want anything to do with it.
If he really does want a bolt hole then the above is probably why he won’t rent it out. She probably wouldn’t mind selling it but tgen he wouldn’t have a bolthole.

Op, a compromise would be sell it and reinvest the proceeds to benefit his son. That releases the mortgage payments for your own family.

But I suspect it’s more the safety net if the bolt hole he wants.

Quitelikeit · 22/03/2022 09:28

It is very worrying also this his ex is in the mortgage.

I think his actions have shown you all you need to know but now you have given him the chance to improve the situation to everyone’s benefit that should also tell you more about him.

Although he made a sacrifice to come here and be with you it feels like he is keeping his options wide open hence his property in the other country.

People can have different attitudes to money but who was his role model? Where is his father? What did he do and what example did he set his son.

You seem very clear and level headed so I think you will be ok

Mfsf · 22/03/2022 09:23

You are right it has but that because I realised I was being an even bigger mug than I though . Please do not think for a second any of what I put down was written easily . Everything that’s going through my head now is how I let my children down and to someone that really prides myself of always putting my kids first that is probably the worst thing o have ever done in my life

OP posts:
Mfsf · 22/03/2022 09:20

I believe he would go back to his home country as let’s be how st he wouldn’t e able to afford being here and having a home there if it wasn’t for me

OP posts:
Franklin12 · 22/03/2022 09:07

Why oh why do women choose to make these decisions? You sound switched on. Why did you choose to have a child with this man. You will be tied to him forever.

notanothertakeaway · 22/03/2022 09:06

I’ve looked at the legal side it would involve changing his mortgage to allow him to rent it and would then mean any income from it would be taxed on him and his ex . So basically a ton of issues

That's not a ton of issues. That's all standard stuff for someone renting out a house. Bit of hassle in exchange for (hopefully) a rental income

This thread has escalated quickly from "great dad, I'm just a bit peeved about not going on holiday" to "relationship probably over"

Thewindwhispers · 22/03/2022 09:05

OP when asked any relationship question, Mumsnet will always, always, tell you to end your relationship. Please don’t take too seriously the comments you have had here, we are just a bunch of internet strangers. You have a newborn baby with your partner, don’t fall out over a house and don’t have emotional conversations about family money at midnight when there’s work at 5am. Calm down, step away from the internet, and don’t think about it for a couple of days. Then have a “how can we fix this situation, long term” chat with him.

As to the house, options are:

  1. He gets in touch with his ex and the bank to sort the paperwork so that he can sell it, or rent it out.

Or:

  1. He continues to pay the 100% mortgage on an empty property in which he only owns 50% equity, which causes financial problems for his new family.

If he chooses to keep the house, then he should work out the legal position (and change his job so he can financially support his new child). I don’t know where the house is, but if he owned a house in England jointly with his ex, and he suddenly died, the ex would own 100%. Not the son. If he wants to leave his equity to the son, then in England he’d need to make sure the property is held as tenants in common, and have a clear will on it. Even then, with the ex owning the other 50%, she could force a sale: there is no guarantee that the son ends up with the actual house. So your DP needs to get his head around that and speak to a lawyer in the country where the house is located.

If he won’t sell it then I suspect that the way forward is for them to remortgage with a mortgage that allows the property to be let, for the mortgage to be paid from the rent, (possibly involve a local property management company) and for the equity to be left 50% to the son by the dad and he can only hope thet his ex does the same with her 50%.

(The son may not actually want this house where his parents split up 😬)

WisherWood · 22/03/2022 09:03

I admit I was hoping for actually helpful advise

I think you've been given some good advice. But that was always going to come with a certain amount of incredulity. I genuinely do not know why so many women choose to have children with men who quite patently are shit dads, and then claim that they're great dads. I think people are confusing 'great' with 'Disney' or 'doesn't hit them'. It seems as if these men are fine with the easy bits of parenting. They hang out with their kids, do the nice things with them. But they're shit at the actual graft. They don't make time to do the difficult things. They don't provide the financial support, they don't alter their work to look after children, they don't prioritise their children but assume that that side is the mothers' responsibility (note the grammar).

If they just do the easy bits and pass on the actual hard work, they are not great dads. They are shit. I do hope it works out for you OP but you do need to read him the riot act. He chose to move here so don't feel guilty about that. But it does sound to me as if holding on to the house is more about him having a bolt hole than about keeping an investment.

Sswhinesthebest · 22/03/2022 09:00

So if he’s paying £500 mortgage then £250 of that is automatically his wife’s (going indirectly to her) - on top of the maintenance he pays her.
If they decide to keep it as a joint marital asset, her half of the mortgage should be paid out of her maintenance.

If he wants to keep an investment/foot on the property ladder, then sell it and buy something here that you can actually rent out and make an income from.

Quartz2208 · 22/03/2022 09:00

Is the home just sitting empty?

But yes they are really your options

mushroom3 · 22/03/2022 08:59

could he let out the home so that the mortgage is paid?

HowlongWillThisTakeNow · 22/03/2022 08:56

@Mfsf

I’ve asked him this and I’ve looked at the legal side it would involve changing his mortgage to allow him to rent it and would then mean any income from it would be taxed on him and his ex . So basically a ton of issues . His best option is to sell it , he has paid interest and gained equity even if his ex was to have 50% . He knows this , I know this . The real question at this stage is does he accept the unfairness of this all on me and my kids or does he choose to keep being selfish ? In which case he will need to go , even if it breaks my heart and above all the kids because they are so attached to him and even if it means our newborn will be without a dad . It’s my responsibility to do what’s best for the kids future and I’m well aware of it . This thread just helped me confirm it . Unfortunately saying it and going through it are 2 different things so emotionally I’m really upset
That all sounds pretty crappy, I suppose selling would be the best option, he could ring fence the profit from his part of the sale for his own kids, then use use the freed up money from his income to support his new family
Namelessnancy · 22/03/2022 08:33

OP you've mentioned one of the problems with renting would be permission from the .
mortgage provider. Surely this would be less of a problem than leaving it empty. Most residential mortgages (UK at least) don't allow for the property to be left empty for extended periods do they? Likewise insurance?

Cocomarine · 22/03/2022 08:33

How is it even a sensible decision to leave it empty for years, in a separate country to both owners, him and his wife?
Is not likely to be targeted by squatters, vandals, or just degrade over time with no airing and attention?
Money from letting aside (and not all counties have a lucrative lettings market) it seems the more sensible security option anyway.

girlmom21 · 22/03/2022 08:25

even if it means our newborn will be without a dad

If he's the brilliant dad you say he is this wouldn't happen. Do you honestly believe it would?

billy1966 · 22/03/2022 08:22

OP,

You sound like a great woman who works hard.

Unfortunately you have brought a using loser into your childrens lives and had a baby with him.

Having a baby with a man who only buys a bit of shopping is absolute madness.

Get rid of him.
He may be nice, of course he is, he's living off you.

You are being used here.
I'm so sorry, but you need to make better decisions.
Flowers

Quitelikeit · 22/03/2022 08:20

There’s only one person in a comfortable position here and that is him!

You have been very kind and generous not to mention patient- he has took a lot from you and he likes things that way.

I admire your boundaries - put the boot in today. Don’t let this drop. Keeping his house for his son?! What about his other child - his pride should be enough to seek better employment so he can contribute more to you and your life together.

Does he treat you at all?

You are by all means subsidising him enormously whilst he maintains and invests in his own and his sons future. This really is to the detriment of your own self and family.

Take action

Therealjudgejudy · 22/03/2022 08:20

Hes not your partner, he is a cocklodger.

Hes not a good dad because he is using you and treating you like a total mug.

PriestessofPing · 22/03/2022 08:19

It does sound as though he hasn’t released his ties to his marriage totally. He also may be thinking he has that house as a kind of insurance in case it doesn’t work out with you. If he sells it and goes all in with you where wound he be if you didn’t work out? It’s sort of understandable given he already got divorced once, but he should have thought through the consequences of his actions moving to another country and the commitment he made by choosing to have another child.

Frankly, he needs to decide - is he all in with you or is he still hedging his bets emotionally and holding out so he has a property and investment to return to if you guys don’t work out?

BluebellsGreenbells · 22/03/2022 08:06

Have you been to the house OP?
Have you visited that country and had a holiday there?

Just worth checking

DogInATent · 22/03/2022 08:01

After seven years he hasn't completed the divorce and resolved the issue of shared marital assets?

Depending which EU country the property is in, the tax issues around renting out can be 'interesting'. But so can the issues of owning property as a non-resident. He may see it as an investment, but has he really looked at what the property is worth, how much he's paying, and what the rate of return is? Mortgages on properties generally only create wealth when there's a benefit from living in the property or an income from rent. Long-term mortgages in empty property are usually a loss vs. other forms of genuine investment.

Namelessnancy · 22/03/2022 07:42

Surely a rental income he has to pay tax on is better than no income at all? Who on earth can afford to pay a mortgage to keep a house empty? Aside from the financial issues by the end of the mortgage a house which has been left empty for years could be in a terrible state.

GabriellaMontez · 22/03/2022 07:40

@sunlovingcriminal

I can't see that you've answered a basic question that has been asked: why doesn't he rent it out?

Then he doesn't have to sell it, but can cover some or all of his mortgage from the income.

Or use it as an air b n b let then he could still use it.