Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Upset over partners mortgage AIBU

285 replies

Mfsf · 21/03/2022 22:30

My partner moved in 2 years ago , prior to this I lived alone with my 2 kids and paid all my bills and consider myself quite independent financially .
When he moved in it meant he had to leave his job abroad . He found a job straight away but he earns half of what I do . So basically I kept paying everything as I already did it anyway and he pays some food shopping when he comes shopping with us . I have a ok wage but I don’t have much after paying for everything myself and now 3 children , with covid some months I even struggled this year , but normally enough to visit my family abroad and a small holiday that my kids love and got used too and that we have always done .
We have since had a baby together .
I actually do not mind the financial burden is mostly on me all of the time , with his wages he is paying his mortgage and child support for his child ( obviously this last is 100% fine and essential) .
My issue now is he cannot afford to go on holiday , even if I pay for it he will still have his mortgage and it would mean he would not earn for those weeks .
This has really upset me , this is not something I want to take away from my kids . Why should I stop myself from giving my kids what they are used too so he can have a empty house that he pays mortgage for? He refuses to let it too .
He has this “ idealistic idea “ that it’s something he can leave his son , which is fine but not only he still has 20 years of mortgage to pay but his ex wife is still in the mortgage despite not paying for it since they divorced 7 years ago . So I’m expected to never be able to go on holiday or even contemplate a place together simply because he likes the idea to have a home ?
I love him , the kids love him but I admit the fact he pays towards this completely separate life to us and expects me to make sacrifices is really starting to make me resent him .
To make it “ worse “ my youngest eventually will need some childcare and I’m pretty sure he is assuming I will pay for it or just work with her at home ( I do work from home but I have constant meetings and we did discuss I would need at least a few days a week of childcare as I have meetings and constant phone calls )
Am I being unreasonable to fell upset ?

OP posts:
Mfsf · 22/03/2022 14:21

It’s a city apartment , not where we normally go on holiday :-)

OP posts:
Kuachui · 22/03/2022 14:07

hes being selfish. kick him out and move on. hes taking away from you and your kids so that his kid ends up with a nice house when he dies. its not on

PrtScn · 22/03/2022 13:47

Maybe go on holiday and stay in his house abroad. Use it as a holiday home - will be cheaper for you!

HelenWick · 22/03/2022 13:42

He's not your partner. He's lodging with your for free and using you whilst building up a next egg and inheritance for his family - his ex-wife and children.

Mfsf · 22/03/2022 13:18

@MigsandTiggs

Here are some financial facts to consider..
  1. Depending on the type of house ownership, ie joint ownership or tenants in common, the ex-wife can own the house if the man dies, even if he paid 100% of the mortgage as joint ownership gives survivor rights over the entire property.
  2. Buying a house is more than buying a home. It is also acquiring an asset that will appreciate in the long term. No one takes out a 20 year mortgage and sticks to the same deal, so don't concentrate on the length of a mortgage. The mortgage is financing an asset acquisition while renting means that you are in effect paying for someone else's asset acquisition. Nowadays, people buy properties as an alternative to investing in a stocks and shares pension.
I do not have a issue with him having a property , I do have a issue that sending money for that mortgage is taking away from our home income . And have a issue that he is as you say basically paying for someone else’s property . Renting is complicated because it involves changing mortgages and increases the actual mortgage by a lot on this case and it would mean both him and his ex wife would have to declare it . I doubt she will be ok with it and honestly I doubt he would too . Selling it is the only viable option here , or he can make the sacrifice to pay for a empty home while his ex pay nil and the house gains equity but he should not expect me to do it and he will need to do it on his own while still contributing to our household .
OP posts:
MigsandTiggs · 22/03/2022 12:50

Here are some financial facts to consider..

  1. Depending on the type of house ownership, ie joint ownership or tenants in common, the ex-wife can own the house if the man dies, even if he paid 100% of the mortgage as joint ownership gives survivor rights over the entire property.
  2. Buying a house is more than buying a home. It is also acquiring an asset that will appreciate in the long term. No one takes out a 20 year mortgage and sticks to the same deal, so don't concentrate on the length of a mortgage. The mortgage is financing an asset acquisition while renting means that you are in effect paying for someone else's asset acquisition. Nowadays, people buy properties as an alternative to investing in a stocks and shares pension.
BambinaJAS · 22/03/2022 12:41

@AChocolateOrangeaday

Yeah she was in denial for years too.
In OPs defense,

Its really tough to see you are in a dysfunctional situation because you tend to normalise the behaviors of the people involved.

Thats why an external source (mumsnet in this case) can give you a perspective you may lack.

Beautiful3 · 22/03/2022 12:34

Just realised that you rent. That's really unfair as there's nothing to leave your children, but he lives a subsidised life, to leave a house to his wife and son?

AChocolateOrangeaday · 22/03/2022 12:34

Yeah she was in denial for years too.

Mfsf · 22/03/2022 12:27

[quote AChocolateOrangeaday]@Franklin12 I agree. I think I am going to come off MN for a bit as it is just relentless how many women do this to them selves.

I can only imagine that they are so desperate for a "DP" and or another child that they will literally put up with any old shite and be grateful for it.

He and his family really saw you coming OP, so I have voted YABU as you knew all this before you proceeded.

At what point exactly did you expect him to "change?"

And all this "Oh my DC's adore him" is just bollocks to justify poor life choices.

My DSis is like this and it is only now with all 3 kids in therapy is it starting to dawn on her just how much her selfish actions have impacted on that.[/quote]
I’m not and was never desperate for a partner ! My son is 19 and this is the first partner I moved in my house apart from his dad , I’m not scared of being alone and I’m completely capable of being alone . So keep your rudeness to yourself !!! I do not care what your sister did or does , my kids know I have their back and I’m a good mother
You must be a perfect mother that never did a bad choice ! Shame on you trying to bring my parenting down

OP posts:
BambinaJAS · 22/03/2022 12:26

@Holskey

Oh you rent? This makes it so much worse. You're paying his living costs so he can pay his mortgage (so you're pretty much paying his mortgage) so that he has property to leave to his kids and you have nothing to leave to your kids? You could be saving what you spend on him for your children's inheritance.

How lovely can he possibly be that has made you think this is okay? What's done is done but please don't allow it to continue. He's taking advantage of you. You might not see it that way because he's lovely etc, but it's a fact. You are putting money aside for his kids at the expense of your own. And he wants you to.

Agree with this.

Its worth it to see it this way:

If he was contributing to the rent and not his mortgage payments abroad, you could be in the position of saving for a deposit for a house in the UK.

That is the opportunity cost for you & your kids right now.

The reality is that your DP had engineered the situation so that he benefits, while you simply stagnate.

This is not ok. And the relationship will be doomed eventually as the issue of childcare costs goes front and center. He will also nou doubt revert back to type, which is do nothing so as to nudge you to pay, while shutting down when you confront him.

People like that (conflict avoidant types) need to fully understand that there are consequences to not doing A, B, and C. You absolutely cannot bluff here. They will simply keep doing their thing, irrespective of their effect on you.

AChocolateOrangeaday · 22/03/2022 12:21

@Franklin12 I agree. I think I am going to come off MN for a bit as it is just relentless how many women do this to them selves.

I can only imagine that they are so desperate for a "DP" and or another child that they will literally put up with any old shite and be grateful for it.

He and his family really saw you coming OP, so I have voted YABU as you knew all this before you proceeded.

At what point exactly did you expect him to "change?"

And all this "Oh my DC's adore him" is just bollocks to justify poor life choices.

My DSis is like this and it is only now with all 3 kids in therapy is it starting to dawn on her just how much her selfish actions have impacted on that.

Quitelikeit · 22/03/2022 12:19

I agree that this guy isn’t all bad but your gut is telling you the situation is not fair or right and you must do something. Especially if it is preventing you from purchasing a property yourself.

Beautiful3 · 22/03/2022 12:18

Can he rent out his house? If not, can you go away on holiday without him?

SleepingStandingUp · 22/03/2022 12:14

Why isn't he at least renting it out? Leaving it empty, costing money in maintenance, what happens when his Dad is too old? Also he can give his kids part of a house in a random country in 50 years time

BambinaJAS · 22/03/2022 12:11

@SleepingStandingUp

Sorry, his son will get 3/4 of a decrepit home because his mother is entitled to half, so your baby will get 1/4, presumably?
If its the country that I think it is...

Ex and DP own 50% each (both names on mortgage)

If DP dies, and given that this is not his primary residence (or his exs)

The 50% goes towards his direct kids, even without a will.

That means first child with ex and child with OP.

But also worth mentioning. This property is not mortgage free, so the amount of equity each person has will have to be determined by a valuation.

Holskey · 22/03/2022 12:10

Oh you rent? This makes it so much worse. You're paying his living costs so he can pay his mortgage (so you're pretty much paying his mortgage) so that he has property to leave to his kids and you have nothing to leave to your kids? You could be saving what you spend on him for your children's inheritance.

How lovely can he possibly be that has made you think this is okay? What's done is done but please don't allow it to continue. He's taking advantage of you. You might not see it that way because he's lovely etc, but it's a fact. You are putting money aside for his kids at the expense of your own. And he wants you to.

BeanStew22 · 22/03/2022 12:07

@Walkingalot

So he's paying all the mortgage on a property that he only half owns with his ex wife and intends on leaving his share to his other child, not even your child with him. While you subsidise him over your children and child together. I could maybe understand him keeping hold of it if there were only a few yrs to go but this isn't the case. This isn't fair on you. I'd question his true motives for keeping an empty house and his commitment to you and your child and definitely do not marry him.
^ I agree with this and what @Squeezita and others have said

Ultimately, by enabling him to live so cheaply, YOU are the one paying for this house but have no rights to it!

I’d be asking him:

  • what his plans to increase his income long term are (I know there may be difficulties re qualifications and experience being recognised but there is a big difference between a high earning job & minimum wage)
  • why he thinks it’s ok to prioritise his eldest son not your child together
  • what his plan for the house is/when he plans to settle things financially with his ex

I think if I moved overseas, I’d LOVE to mothball my home and retain the option of moving back in if things didn’t work out … but he is keeping that option open only at your choice

Re guilt about him giving up his job: entirely his choice, the world is full of women, he could have met one in his own country but he is an adult and chose to move overseas

Definitely get him to pay for childcare… does he think he pays for his first child & you pay for this? How will that make your youngest feel?

girlmom21 · 22/03/2022 12:06

But you also said you have three children (one of which, I presume, is the baby). Is he leaving the house to the two stepchildren he has with you as well? It seems like he isn’t. Why does he value his ex wife’s child with another man more than your children who is living with?

She already said he raised the other child as his own from the age of 3

Mfsf · 22/03/2022 12:06

@DifficultBloodyWoman

You said he now wants to leave the house to his son, his stepson and the baby you have together.

But you also said you have three children (one of which, I presume, is the baby). Is he leaving the house to the two stepchildren he has with you as well? It seems like he isn’t. Why does he value his ex wife’s child with another man more than your children who is living with?

Seriously, you have very different values and goals. Decide EXACTLY what you want from him. Tell him. And then leave him immediately when he can’t produce.

The alternative is years of festering bitterness and wasting money subsiding his choices when you could spend it on yourself or your children or whatever charity of your choice!

My children are older than his stepson was when they meet ( he was less than 3 years old and now 21 ) so he has been a huge part of his life most of his life . The house was also bought by him and his ex when they had both kids , so I would not hold that against him . I will however old the fact that by doing this regarding keeping the house it will prevent us from having one of our own and that is another issue to add to the pile . The reality is even if it was fir my kids too it’s not something I agree with . I believe kids deserve time and attention now with quality time more than s inheritance in 30 or 40 years time . If he wants to make sure he is prepared in case something happens he should do what I do and have a good life insurance and will for the kids imo .
OP posts:
DifficultBloodyWoman · 22/03/2022 11:56

You said he now wants to leave the house to his son, his stepson and the baby you have together.

But you also said you have three children (one of which, I presume, is the baby). Is he leaving the house to the two stepchildren he has with you as well? It seems like he isn’t. Why does he value his ex wife’s child with another man more than your children who is living with?

Seriously, you have very different values and goals. Decide EXACTLY what you want from him. Tell him. And then leave him immediately when he can’t produce.

The alternative is years of festering bitterness and wasting money subsiding his choices when you could spend it on yourself or your children or whatever charity of your choice!

Mfsf · 22/03/2022 11:40

Thanks you are right , absolutely right .
I rent and eventually want to build ( as I’m 40 a long mortgage was never a option it appealed ) .
I don’t expect him to contribute the same as me as I know his earning potential will be less even if it improved a bit . But I don’t want to be making financial sacrifices, specially regarding my he kids so he can keep a empty home for whatever reason he is wanting to keep it .
As you say I guess the future of our relationship will depend on his decisions .

OP posts:
MigsandTiggs · 22/03/2022 11:38

Why is the ex-wife still on the mortgage? She would be unable to get another mortgage if her name is already on a mortgage. Being able to leave property to your children is nice, but unrealistic if you can't really afford it. He is living with you, and unless you have a tenancy agreement in place, he is building up a right to part ownership of YOUR house if he has done any diy etc that he can claim contributed to the value of the house.
A house is a money-pit and his will be deteriorating all the time it isn't used. All the seals in the water pipes will rot if they remain dry. Why won't he rent it out?
I get that you might feel some guilt because he had to give up his job to move in with you, but if he still works abroad why did he change jobs? Does the country he is from not have paid annual leave?
If he doesn't like confrontation you could itemise your concerns and ask him to write down his answers. Honestly, your situation rings so many warning bells.

AllOfUsAreDead · 22/03/2022 11:38

@GabriellaMontez

Who inherits the house is a distraction.

The main issue is that he's not contributing fairly (hardly at all) to your life and family now. Because he owns a house that sits empty and this is his priority.

This.

I'm sorry op, but a parent who goes to work and yet still contributes almost nothing financially besides sometimes buying food is not a good parent. He's spending all his money on a house that he says is for inheritance, but it is just a distraction. He needs to cut the cords tying him to his ex and get over the fact she left him. He could be paying towards the inheritance of a bigger house to accommodate your family together that could then be split between all children when you both die. His way is just stupid.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 22/03/2022 11:27

I don't know his country of origin, but I don't think much of his regard for you and his child you have together. Surely he must realise keeping his property for his son isn't possible after a divorce? In an ideal world it's what he wants. Wouldn't we all?
He might say he loves you, but he has a foot in his past and makes no effort to help pay his way
I feel for you, but his actions haven't matched his words and he needs a reality check
I hope you manage to get through to him.

Swipe left for the next trending thread