Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Upset over partners mortgage AIBU

285 replies

Mfsf · 21/03/2022 22:30

My partner moved in 2 years ago , prior to this I lived alone with my 2 kids and paid all my bills and consider myself quite independent financially .
When he moved in it meant he had to leave his job abroad . He found a job straight away but he earns half of what I do . So basically I kept paying everything as I already did it anyway and he pays some food shopping when he comes shopping with us . I have a ok wage but I don’t have much after paying for everything myself and now 3 children , with covid some months I even struggled this year , but normally enough to visit my family abroad and a small holiday that my kids love and got used too and that we have always done .
We have since had a baby together .
I actually do not mind the financial burden is mostly on me all of the time , with his wages he is paying his mortgage and child support for his child ( obviously this last is 100% fine and essential) .
My issue now is he cannot afford to go on holiday , even if I pay for it he will still have his mortgage and it would mean he would not earn for those weeks .
This has really upset me , this is not something I want to take away from my kids . Why should I stop myself from giving my kids what they are used too so he can have a empty house that he pays mortgage for? He refuses to let it too .
He has this “ idealistic idea “ that it’s something he can leave his son , which is fine but not only he still has 20 years of mortgage to pay but his ex wife is still in the mortgage despite not paying for it since they divorced 7 years ago . So I’m expected to never be able to go on holiday or even contemplate a place together simply because he likes the idea to have a home ?
I love him , the kids love him but I admit the fact he pays towards this completely separate life to us and expects me to make sacrifices is really starting to make me resent him .
To make it “ worse “ my youngest eventually will need some childcare and I’m pretty sure he is assuming I will pay for it or just work with her at home ( I do work from home but I have constant meetings and we did discuss I would need at least a few days a week of childcare as I have meetings and constant phone calls )
Am I being unreasonable to fell upset ?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SmellyOldOwls · 25/03/2022 16:48

Haven't RTFT but sounds like he's still married and wife and child happily residing in the family home.

Mum2b1g · 25/03/2022 16:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

RachaelN · 24/03/2022 17:12

Yikes. He is mooching off you big time. Is he paying the entire mortgage. Should his ex not be paying half if she is on it to?

user1481055867 · 24/03/2022 15:26

@Mfsf
1.Absolutely take your kids on holidays!
2.Ask him to rent, air bnb or sell his property
3.Calculate his contribution towards the place he is living now, household expenses and his 1 child and illustrate the gap in your expectations, which effectively his debt to you.The property income+his low wage can help close the gap and repay the debt.
I ve been there, when a woman is a high earner and comfortable men just become so emasculated, dependent and relaxed about the whole thing.Of course you will resent him, stop letting him near you and you probably know how it ends.Act now, but dont deprive your kids.

Mirw · 24/03/2022 14:55

He is sponging off you. What happens if for some reason you lose your job? No job is for life even if you work for yourself. He is working so no help from the state for you and your children. You have to make that clear to him. And get him to sort out his priorities. If his child is staying in the house, he should be paying rent to cut the mortgage burden. If the house is empty, he should be selling it.

ChairCareOh · 24/03/2022 11:36

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

Coffeepot72 · 24/03/2022 11:32

all of his eggs are in one basket. And it’s not with his current partner and their shared children. It’s like he’s saying - I’ll take care of my former life, you take care of my current one. I don’t doubt he’s a good dad in some ways. But he’s very stuck in rigid thinking.

This is so true. He probably hasn't deliberately set out to do this, but that's how it's ended up.

Inwiththenew · 24/03/2022 11:09

There’s something odd about this and I can’t help feeling he is lying to you. Has he mentioned giving anything to the child he has with you as well as his older child? I mean, who would pay towards an empty house when they can’t really afford to, and when getting tenants in would be an easy remedy. Why would he still have his ex wife’s name on the house? Doesn’t make any sense at all, sorry.

Roo4u · 24/03/2022 07:55

@Realbecca I thought the same and even if his ex wife's abroad and living there mortgage free too

Mummyoflittledragon · 24/03/2022 05:21

Didn’t you say his ex sings his praises? Looking at it from her pov, he is a good dad and ex. He sends child support, pays the entire mortgage on their joint property and treats the dc well, visits them, including her first child.

But all of his eggs are in one basket. And it’s not with his current partner and their shared children. It’s like he’s saying - I’ll take care of my former life, you take care of my current one. I don’t doubt he’s a good dad in some ways. But he’s very stuck in rigid thinking.

Then there’s the safety net aspect of the house. Whether or not he cares to admit it, that house is his safety net. You said yourself you think he will leave if you split.

He moved to the U.K. to be with you, didn’t he? That shouldn’t be an excuse to live off you long term and it is ridiculous to envisage this going on until the house is paid off in 20 years. And has he thought about the depreciation on an empty house? It will date and decay if not maintained and kept warm. Costs. Costs. Costs.

SarahDippity · 23/03/2022 23:14

I know this is off your main point @Mfsf but why doesn’t he get holiday pay?

How long has he been in his low income job? What prospects are there?

What does your joint long look like in five years time? You have no capacity to save, individually or jointly, for a deposit on a house to build or buy. You can’t afford holidays. You will struggle to fund childcare, after school activities, and the expensive teenage years. Can he not see the current situation, that it won’t improve for your family unit, unless he digs his head out? What if you became ill or incapacitated? It is your security that is in jeopardy, as he retains a valuable asset that is costing your family now, to no appreciable benefit.

The house is the obvious key to unlock this, but his commitment to the family is weak and coloured because unfortunately you’ve got trapped in the role of financing everyone to your personal detriment.

Honestly, deal-breaker territory for me, unless he commits to working out an exit plan for his own poor prospects and downright mad attachment to this empty city-centre-somewhere-in-a-third-country-where-none-of-his-children-live apartment.

mrbreezeet1 · 23/03/2022 22:07

@Mfsf

My partner moved in 2 years ago , prior to this I lived alone with my 2 kids and paid all my bills and consider myself quite independent financially . When he moved in it meant he had to leave his job abroad . He found a job straight away but he earns half of what I do . So basically I kept paying everything as I already did it anyway and he pays some food shopping when he comes shopping with us . I have a ok wage but I don’t have much after paying for everything myself and now 3 children , with covid some months I even struggled this year , but normally enough to visit my family abroad and a small holiday that my kids love and got used too and that we have always done . We have since had a baby together . I actually do not mind the financial burden is mostly on me all of the time , with his wages he is paying his mortgage and child support for his child ( obviously this last is 100% fine and essential) . My issue now is he cannot afford to go on holiday , even if I pay for it he will still have his mortgage and it would mean he would not earn for those weeks . This has really upset me , this is not something I want to take away from my kids . Why should I stop myself from giving my kids what they are used too so he can have a empty house that he pays mortgage for? He refuses to let it too . He has this “ idealistic idea “ that it’s something he can leave his son , which is fine but not only he still has 20 years of mortgage to pay but his ex wife is still in the mortgage despite not paying for it since they divorced 7 years ago . So I’m expected to never be able to go on holiday or even contemplate a place together simply because he likes the idea to have a home ? I love him , the kids love him but I admit the fact he pays towards this completely separate life to us and expects me to make sacrifices is really starting to make me resent him . To make it “ worse “ my youngest eventually will need some childcare and I’m pretty sure he is assuming I will pay for it or just work with her at home ( I do work from home but I have constant meetings and we did discuss I would need at least a few days a week of childcare as I have meetings and constant phone calls ) Am I being unreasonable to fell upset ?
No! He should pay more
teej11 · 23/03/2022 21:55

I'm not going to be harsh because I think you've received enough of that.

But what I'd say, as someone who has a partner from another country, your relationship shouldn't be transactional. You shouldn't feel like you owe him something because he moved to the UK. He made that decision, he wanted to be with you too, he's got a partner and a family out of that. And that's enough. It's not your job to make up for that for the rest of your lives together.

Hmm1234 · 23/03/2022 21:31

Goodness me you seemed to of picked up a waster! Tell him to stop using you as a base for somewhere to stay in the UK. Is it too late to get out of this situation or is he the kids dad

N1no · 23/03/2022 21:16

From the day your joined child was born his child support might have reduced due to his small income.

Don’t get married to him without a prenuptial!

Macaroni1924 · 23/03/2022 21:15

Ok so lots of comments regarding your choices etc which isn’t really needed or deserved because whatever choices you have made, rightly or wrongly, have led you to where you are now and that’s what you are looking for help with. I don’t think you need to explain yourself.
If he is anything like my husband who can also shut down when discussing things he is uncomfortable with he will just need some time to let it sink in and then discuss at a later date. I don’t think you should rush anything as with a newborn you will be emotional just now. Try not to get emotional, which is very hard as he will probably just get his back up. Try to be calm and make your very valid points. Although is all sound quite complicated the great thing is that when the house is sold that mortgage payment is in his pocket so he can contribute half/half with ur bills. If that was the case the additional money would mean more fun family times together and a chance to enjoy life outside of work and home. Maybe try and push the positives of him not having that responsibility and what it would mean for your family together. I’m sure with some conversations and understanding on both your parts it is something that can be sorted.

N1no · 23/03/2022 21:13

I think your problem is bigger than your holiday this year. You need a financial advisor or even a solicitor specialising in family law.
Paying the mortgage for an empty house is pointless as the value of the house will reduce with every year it’s empty (I speak from experience). The only choice he has is to either sell it or let it. This will depend on the country and region the house is in. In some rural areas of countries in the east houses can’t be let. In any case he’ll needs a solicitor to tell him what percentage of the house or of the rent belongs to him and what to his ex wife.
The solicitor can also tell you how much he should contribute towards living expenses and how much rent he pays you. Since h is not on the mortgage he is technically your lodger (be careful with your building insurance and mortgage).

Acheyknees · 23/03/2022 20:33

Put it this way OP. You are supporting someone who is paying child support and a mortgage on a low salary. He isn't making much effort to share the financial load. It's not much of a partnership is it? He seems to be prioritising financial commitments that have absolutely no benefit to you. Only him.

KimikosNightmare · 23/03/2022 20:18

Oh Dear. His insistence on paying for a house on a Mortgage which isn't occupied makes absolutely no sense

Zero sense. Yes it might increase the mortgage interest and yes there would be tax to be paid on the rent but it's still producing an income rather than being a drain on income.

Oh and I wonder if he has proper buildings insurance on it? Most insurers will limit cover or increase premiums in this situation.

Notmrsfitz · 23/03/2022 20:15

I e read a lot of the replies but admittedly not all, if he is still paying a mortgage- he doesn’t own it, so it’s not really an inheritance as such.

He now has obligations financially and morally to you and the family you have together.

Only you know if this relationship is tangible and if you really want to live like this.
If you do then you need to resolve the issues as you can’t subsidise him at cost of your lifestyle - he CHOSE to come and live here, you have subsidised him all this time -you haven’t forced him to do anything.
If you don’t then you need to get rid off him and live the life you can with your dc.

Yayhelen · 23/03/2022 20:14

Just read some more of your posts OP.

Sounds like you’re a great mother and you obviously love him and he is a good Dad in many ways.

Re: His comment about changing the mortgage (from experience) this isn’t a big thing. You just ask them for permission to let and they say yes or no. If yes, everything is essentially the same except you rent the house. The tax is also minimal and it’s not hard to do an annual tax return (if it’s in the U.K., not sure if it is).

If he has a sentimental attachment to the property this is a good way to get it to wash its own face so to speak, so that he can put some resources into his new partnership with you.

Hope it all works out for you OP. Take care.

Silvers11 · 23/03/2022 20:10

Oh Dear. His insistence on paying for a house on a Mortgage which isn't occupied makes absolutely no sense. I believe you when you say he is a good dad and not a bad person and you clearly love him.

It sounds to me as if there is something more going on in his head than 'wanting to leave something for his son/stepson' - something maybe he isn't aware of himself, because to most people what he is doing with regard to his house is crazy.

Taking the Mortgage payments out of it, for the moment, can I suggest that you start off by looking at the divsion of financial burden between you and rejigging it. You say he earns about half what you do, so I would suggest that you draw up a budget by looking at all the regular expenditure you as a couple incur ( including your rent Council tax etc but not his mortgage) and also including what he pays in child support and work out what the budget for all that expenditure equates to per month, and you agree to pay 2/3 and he agrees to pay 1/3 of all of them. )You can adjust the percentages depending on the actual difference between your income). You can include a holiday budget in that, or not, and also a clothes budget, or not. Lots of different ways to deal with it, but your current arrangement, while I can see it made sense in the beginning needs to change for both your sakes.

This is only fair and if he's not prepared to do that then I do think he is maybe not as committed to you as you are to him.

Once that has been worked out, you will be able to see more clearly how much 'free money each of you has to spend as you each see fit. That may very well show him that he can't afford the Mortgage.

Even if it doesn't let him see that, and even if he now decides to sell the house It seems to me this would be a good thing to do, regardless as it would be fairer and less likely to cause you resentment now or in the future. At the moment he isn't paying his fair share which is why you are resentful and I would be too. A fair share does not need to be 50% each as I said above but a fair share of expenditure vs income - like 66% vs 33%.

At the moment, your partner is making it so that you cannot actually afford the things you did before he moved in with you - when in fact a second income ought to help a bit, so something is seriously wrong financially - and maybe not just the Mortgage payments

Good Luck

EMUKE · 23/03/2022 19:57

I know it seems hard but any decent upstanding man would not be doing this to you. I’m sure your not in the final stages of your relationship, this sounds like maybe the start of the end. You would be so much better if without him reading the comments I’m sure you will get the just that this isn’t ok. Deep down maybe you know yourself but in all honesty I don’t think this will change it will be the continuous argument. Sometimes live isn’t enough…. You need to do what’s best for you and your children and by the sounds of it your better of without him and the stress.

Dnaltocs · 23/03/2022 19:46

Mmmm! A Dad who decided to have another child, can’t contribute to his family and has an empty property abroad.

Think about it in plain terms. Time to put YOUR thinking head on. He put his thinking head on long long ago.

Tomitma111 · 23/03/2022 19:41

WOW!! he has certainly taken you for a ride. DITCH HIM