Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents smacking and slapping children should become illegal in England

164 replies

JC544D · 21/03/2022 22:19

Today Wales has joined more than 60 nations in outlawing physical punishment of children. The new law means people will be committing a crime if they smack, hit, slap or shake a child in their care.

We don’t allow adults to be hit by another person, nor do we allow adults to hit animals.

I think it's more than time England followed suit in outlawing the physical punishment of children by their parents.

What is your view?

OP posts:
Fairylightsongs · 22/03/2022 10:56

I agree absolutely it should be made illegal. Hitting your children is totally and utterly fucked up and anyone who does it should be prosecuted.

Now of course it won’t stop everyone, people break the law every day. They rape, murder, assault, rob. But that doesn’t mean those things shouldn’t be illegal.

TheDolphinHotel · 22/03/2022 10:37

Oh, @Hospedia, I can relate so much to everything you have said. And I'm sorry that you went through that. My Dad would, if we 'misbehaved', make us stand with our hands out, palms up, and whack them with a wooden spoon. I used to feel so bad and useless and ashamed. I still feel anxious being alone with a man, any man now, 30 years later (other than my husband, and my Grandad when he was still alive). I also did the crying quietly as otherwise I'd get 'I'll give you something to cry about'.

It was so damaging. I can't stand the 'it did me no harm' shite. I was an anxious wreck as a child, still am as an adult. It definitely did me harm.

Quitelikeit · 22/03/2022 10:24

Smacking your child in England is illegal unless it is reasonable to do so.

If you decide to do so you must not leave any mark on your child at all.

So as much as a tap if that

I agree with a pp - parents who have a propensity to smack their child will do so regardless of the law

LemonsLimes · 22/03/2022 10:20

Yanbu. It's embarrassing that all our neighbours have banned it but we haven't. The tories show in their actions that they are anti young people and only care about pensioner voters though. They know many pensioners smacked their kids so won't want to piss them off by admitting it's wrong.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 22/03/2022 10:19

In all fairness, you can see why people are defensive about it if they were smacked growing up.

My dad was and he has always had a very close relationship with his parents. Any suggestion that they did something wrong or to hurt him or bad he gets very defensive about it and tried to protect them and what they did by claiming that it was absolutely fine and taught him how to be better man etc.

I know he doesn't really believe this but he can't face the idea that his parents weren't perfect, especially now they've passed.

Rather than dig into what psychological trauma he probably went through, his warped view of the world and parenting etc as a result doesn't change anything. He happily accepts that I won't have anyone raise a hand to my child though so we have no problems there.

Nicholethejewellery · 22/03/2022 10:18

I thought it was illegal already tbf. Certainly people round here seem to disapprove of it if you do it in public. I'm not sure how I feel about outlawing it to be honest, on the face of it it sounds like a good idea but there isn't another suitable punishment that gives the same effect. Smacking works because it is painful and/or embarrassing and/or degrading to the child. It's these things that children fear from a punishment, it's these things that make them think about their behaviour in a way that sitting on the "naughty step" or getting a "timeout" or not being allowed to watch their favourite TV programme doesn't.

Berlinbabylon's "well thought out psychological punishment" sounds quite disturbing in comparison to a smack, messing with a child's head sounds more damaging long term.

Hospedia · 22/03/2022 10:13

I also remember the feeling of lying in bed after a smack and feeling so unloved and unwanted. Crying, quietly so I didn't get the speech about "I'll give you something to cry for/you're only crying for yourself", feeling hateful about what had been done to me, hateful towards my dad, hateful towards towards to myself, angry at myself for feeling hateful because its wrong to hate, sad about being hateful and angry, sad because I was obviously hated, sad because I was useless and bad or else why would I keep acting in ways that got me smacked, stupid too as I didn't learn, and that brought us back around to unloved and rejected.

It's not a feeling I ever want for my DC.

DillDanding · 22/03/2022 10:11

Of course it should be illegal. It’s shocking that it’s not.

Smacking/hitting/slapping & the ridiculous ‘tapping’ that people claim to do is just rubbish, lazy parenting and all children deserve better.

Hospedia · 22/03/2022 10:08

I was the same as a child @Jumperlark. It also made me fearful of making any mistakes just in case those mistakes resulted in a smack. I felt an enormous amount of pressure to be perfect in all areas of my life which meant I took any failings personally, even those outside of my control, and it really affected my confidence. If I didn't think I could do something without any mistakes then I just didn't attempt it in the first place. I was bad at decision making and being independent, I had to check everything with an adult first because if I checked and they said it was okay then I wasn't making any mistakes.

I was scared of my dad, who smacked, and would intentionally hide things from him and not tell him stuff because if he didn't know then he couldn't get angry about it, even so far as lying to his face to try and avoid a smack. My mum didn't smack and I did cinfide things in her, I could go to her when I'd done something I shouldn't and I always told her the truth even if it would get me in trouble as I had no fear she'd smack me.

Fear is not the same thing as respect.

Jumperlark · 22/03/2022 09:44

My parents smacked me daily and I'm sure it definitely did me harm! Not the mention the fact it clearly wasn't working if they had to do it every day, I was impeccably behaved at school where of course I was not smacked.

I did have a major fear of anything being reported home as I was scared of a resultant smack, but it was very much anxiety after the event and did not moderate my behaviour.

I was an anxious child, and as an adult i only really developed a healthy self-esteem or personal boundaries well into my 30s.

I would never do it to my children, I don't want them to be controlled by fear. My parents weren't evil, they suffered their own issues, but they did damage me (they did other things very well, people aren't black and white)

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 22/03/2022 09:34

Smacking is what parents do when they haven't given any thought into how to disapline effectively, they do it on autopilot I disagree, my parents never lashed out and smacked me impulsively, it was a punishment if I miss behaved “if you do this you will get a smack”- and then hours later my dad would get home from work and smack me on the back of the legs- it wasn’t an act of direct anger if was a form of repercussion for one’s actions.
Now I’m not necessarily pro smacking- I do however think some parents who say “I would never smack” have generally well behaved children. I have seen children push and push their boundaries and I’ve witnessed the removal of toys and talking to them and it can go on for hours with an argumentative stubborn belligerent child- I’m not entirely sure it’s better for all concerned than a smack

DetailMouse · 22/03/2022 09:27

Just to put an alternative view.

We didn't smack. My DC were small in the Suppernanny phase. We used the naughty step and time out (occasionally).

My dad always argued that a short sharp smack in the context of a loving and supportive home was far less harmful than "banishing" kids. Obviously out and out beating is completely different and already abuse.

Bottom line though, any punishment you need to use more than very occasionally, whether that withholding gold stars, taking a favourite toy, removing screen time or smacking, isn't working.

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 22/03/2022 09:21

@Coulddowithanap

Trouble is making it illegal will do nothing. People who smack their children still will.

Same as its illegal to murder but that doesn't stop some people.

I'm not sure this is quite right. For one thing - there would be a lot more murders of it were legal!

Corporal punishment used to be really common. At one time, parents who didn't do it were unusual. Then leaving marks was made illegal, and over time, it became far less common for parents to hurt their kids that badly. Eventually it became socially unacceptable (in most of society) to hit kids at all, and this alone led to a further decrease in smacking.

Banning it won't lead to a massive overnight change, but it absolutely will make a difference.

berlinbabylon · 22/03/2022 09:19

I will say though, that as a kid I would prefer a quick smack to some sort of well thought out psychological punishment, like missing a treat.

berlinbabylon · 22/03/2022 09:18

Smacking is what parents do when they haven't given any thought into how to disapline effectively, they do it on autopilot

yes it's something people do when they lose their tempers

I can understand why it happens eg if a toddler is about to run into the road and you only just grab them in time but it's still a loss of control by the parent.

Does it need to be a criminal offence when it is so frowned upon? I guess it might make people think twice in the sort of scenario I've outlined above.

Plumbear2 · 22/03/2022 09:03

I agree. Smacking is what parents do when they haven't given any thought into how to disapline effectively, they do it on autopilot. My teenaged have never been smacked and are kind thoughtfull well rounded teenagers. Proves my point.

JC544D · 22/03/2022 08:30

I agree 'Idontwanna'. A change would make it very clear that's it is simply unacceptable.

I think with time this is one of those things that people will look back on in shock saying 'I can't believe it was still allowed only so many years ago', 'I can't believe it was still allowed in 2022' etc

OP posts:
ldontWanna · 21/03/2022 23:12

@Coulddowithanap

Trouble is making it illegal will do nothing. People who smack their children still will.

Same as its illegal to murder but that doesn't stop some people.

The difference is it would get rid (in my opinion) of sliding scales,justifications,excuses and minimising.

No more "it was just a tap" when it was a punch. Because the tap is illegal to begin with.

Whether the system (justice,police,SS etc) would actually be able to cope or be willing to follow through it's a whole different issue.

AHungryCaterpillar · 21/03/2022 23:11

Not necessarily and even if it always was, SS would do fuck all for a smack that left no bruising or marks and everything else was otherwise "fine".
There have been cases when parents are separated,one smack ,the other doesn't and when it was brought up in court it was put down to "differences in parenting " and contact still awarded.

Personally I’ve known of people to be reported for this so it definitely isn’t acceptable.

Coulddowithanap · 21/03/2022 23:08

Trouble is making it illegal will do nothing. People who smack their children still will.

Same as its illegal to murder but that doesn't stop some people.

ldontWanna · 21/03/2022 23:01

@AHungryCaterpillar

Isn’t it already frowned upon though anyway even if it’s not illegal? for example if a child told the school their parents had hit them they would be reported to ss so it’s already unacceptable.
Not necessarily and even if it always was, SS would do fuck all for a smack that left no bruising or marks and everything else was otherwise "fine". There have been cases when parents are separated,one smack ,the other doesn't and when it was brought up in court it was put down to "differences in parenting " and contact still awarded.
Nightlystroll · 21/03/2022 22:49

nor do we allow adults to hit animals.

Er, yes we do.

Mushypeasandchipstogo · 21/03/2022 22:41

Totally agree with you. Hitting a child is abhorrent and just poor parenting.

MurmuratingStarling · 21/03/2022 22:41

Agree it should be outlawed here too.

When you have to resort to physically abusing and assaulting a small child - who does not know right from wrong - to 'teach them a lesson/to be good/to behave better,' then it shows you have failed as a parent.

You wouldn't use physical violence against another adult for not behaving how you see fit, so why on earth do you think it's OK to physically assault a small child?

And the 'it never did me any harm' brigade just boil my piss. Just fuck off with that! Hmm There is never EVER a reason to physically assault your child.

KilmordenCastle · 21/03/2022 22:41

@AnneLovesGilbert

lots of 'it didn't do me any harm'

The only response to this is “it did, you think it’s okay for adults to hit children.”

This is a good one!

Every time I see an article on smacking on fb it the comments are always full of "it didn't do me any harm", "we're raising a generation of snowflakes", "the government can't tell me how to parent my child" etc. Facebook really makes you realise how many idiots there are in the world.

To answer your question OP, yes of course it should be illegal. It's a cruel, lazy way to parent. I will never understand how a parent can inflict needless physical pain on their child on purpose Confused