Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents smacking and slapping children should become illegal in England

164 replies

JC544D · 21/03/2022 22:19

Today Wales has joined more than 60 nations in outlawing physical punishment of children. The new law means people will be committing a crime if they smack, hit, slap or shake a child in their care.

We don’t allow adults to be hit by another person, nor do we allow adults to hit animals.

I think it's more than time England followed suit in outlawing the physical punishment of children by their parents.

What is your view?

OP posts:
JesusInTheCabbageVan · 22/03/2022 12:41

For example, TAKE THE PEN OFF THEM.

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 22/03/2022 12:40

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

To play devils advocate what do you do when a child say won’t stop drawing on the walls, or kicking their sibling?
Well I wouldn't hurt them in an attempt to teach them to stop hurting someone.

Depending on age, I would either supervise them better, or come up with a sanction that doesn't involve pain, fear and humiliation.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 22/03/2022 12:37

To play devils advocate what do you do when a child say won’t stop drawing on the walls, or kicking their sibling?

DrSbaitso · 22/03/2022 12:31

Actually children who smack (but aren’t beaten) aren’t afraid of violence. This is why smacking tends to get worse as kids get older because it starts losing its effect the older the child gets & in many cases can cause worse behaviour.

Yep.

Amazing how quickly parents find alternative coping methods once the kid smashes them right back.

Ozanj · 22/03/2022 12:23

@Massivecoffeecake

It's not just the smacking that the issue. It's the environment of fear it generates for the child. The fear someone will smack them if..... Thats massively psychologically damaging.

It should definitely be illegal in England. There are too many old school parents who were hit who think it's fine to hit because they aren't doing as bad as they received.

It's disgusting behaviour and no way to raise children.

Actually children who smack (but aren’t beaten) aren’t afraid of violence. This is why smacking tends to get worse as kids get older because it starts losing its effect the older the child gets & in many cases can cause worse behaviour. It’s why in communities where there are gang issues parents (especially single mothers) are being counselled to stop smacking / not start it & to encourage emotional closenes so their kids can open up to them.
Massivecoffeecake · 22/03/2022 12:17

@Fairylightsongs

Smacking works because it is painful and/or embarrassing and/or degrading to the child.

What a disturbing thing to write. Why would any decent person wish to degrade, embarrass or cause pain to a child? Ever? There is nothing a child can do that an adult should wish to cause them to feel these things.

And as well as causing the child this, it causes any adult watching a parent do this to a child to feel nothing but utter disgust for them. They are degrading themselves, showing themselves to be violent thugs who lack the ability to parent, so resort to choosing violence.

I could not agree more with the above @Fairylightsongs

MarshaBradyo · 22/03/2022 12:16

@Fairylightsongs

Smacking works because it is painful and/or embarrassing and/or degrading to the child.

What a disturbing thing to write. Why would any decent person wish to degrade, embarrass or cause pain to a child? Ever? There is nothing a child can do that an adult should wish to cause them to feel these things.

And as well as causing the child this, it causes any adult watching a parent do this to a child to feel nothing but utter disgust for them. They are degrading themselves, showing themselves to be violent thugs who lack the ability to parent, so resort to choosing violence.

That is disturbing I agree. What a thing to think and do.
Fairylightsongs · 22/03/2022 12:10

Smacking works because it is painful and/or embarrassing and/or degrading to the child.

What a disturbing thing to write. Why would any decent person wish to degrade, embarrass or cause pain to a child? Ever? There is nothing a child can do that an adult should wish to cause them to feel these things.

And as well as causing the child this, it causes any adult watching a parent do this to a child to feel nothing but utter disgust for them. They are degrading themselves, showing themselves to be violent thugs who lack the ability to parent, so resort to choosing violence.

Massivecoffeecake · 22/03/2022 12:05

It's not just the smacking that the issue. It's the environment of fear it generates for the child. The fear someone will smack them if.....
Thats massively psychologically damaging.

It should definitely be illegal in England. There are too many old school parents who were hit who think it's fine to hit because they aren't doing as bad as they received.

It's disgusting behaviour and no way to raise children.

horseymum · 22/03/2022 11:53

You will only get an echo chamber on this topic as anyone with a different view won't post. I'm happy for people not to smack if they have other more effective methods of discipline. Many people use no discipline ( ie training) at all and it's obvious. 'No' should be used more often by some parents and children should believe they mean it.

avocadotofu · 22/03/2022 11:50

I totally agree! It's dreadful parenting and makes me really sad that it's still happening in some households.

EarlGreywithLemon · 22/03/2022 11:49

@SoupDragon

I wonder what difference it would actually make.

I don't think it would stop any of the cases that are clearly prolonged and abusive and they are already illegal anyway.

I know was smacked as a child although I genuinely can not remember any individual incidents so clearly I wasn't damaged by it. I also grew up in a time when kids got "the slipper" in school (primary - by secondary it was not allowed). There is a huge difference between what I remember and what others have gone through which is clearly abusive.

Oh, I remember! I was only smacked a few times, and I remember every time very well - and not in a good way. I was absolutely terrified of my parents. You may think that's a good thing, but in my book, it's not.

My grandparents looked after me in my early years though and, ironically, they were dead set against smacking. Especially my grandfather who taught child psychology and education.

zoemum2006 · 22/03/2022 11:47

Parents only really hit kids because they are frustrated or at the end of their tether.

I've never seen someone calmly discipline a child by hitting so I don't think children learn anything good from it.

We'd be much better off supporting parents with the really tough job of parenting and dial down the judgement when kids are misbehaving.

DrSbaitso · 22/03/2022 11:42

It's shit parenting, always. "Didn't do any harm" is a low bar even on the rare occasions that it's true. And if it's left you thinking it's ok to hit children, it harmed you.

beattieedny · 22/03/2022 11:41

One of the few things that I think it's good to outlaw tbh. Children can be disciplined without physical abuse.

LizDoingTheCanCan · 22/03/2022 11:40

@EnglishGirlApproximately

I think it should be illegal in England too. My (godawful) MP has run a poll on his FB page today and the comments are depressing- vast majority in favour of smacking and lots of 'it didn't do me any harm' and 'kids today have no respect nonsense. I'm in my late 40's and wasn't smacked, grew up perfectly well and I don't smack DS who is a great, polite, respectful kid - it's ridiculous to suggest kids need physical punishment to become responsible adults.
I'm guessing Lee Anderson or one of the new 'red wall' Tory MPs? They ban anyone that disagrees with them, so their pages are an echo chamber of nastiness.
MarshaBradyo · 22/03/2022 11:39

@Auvergnewater

Weird how running into the road is always the thing that justifies a smack.

You pull them back, not hit them, surely.

When parents hit children, they do it because they enjoy it. Not in “that” way - they may feel awful afterwards- but for the briefest of moments it allows them to relieve the tension.

It’s an awful thing to do.

Yes it is weird. Why smack them?

And agree with the rest of it.

MarshaBradyo · 22/03/2022 11:38

Yanbu

SoupDragon · 22/03/2022 11:36

I wonder what difference it would actually make.

I don't think it would stop any of the cases that are clearly prolonged and abusive and they are already illegal anyway.

I know was smacked as a child although I genuinely can not remember any individual incidents so clearly I wasn't damaged by it. I also grew up in a time when kids got "the slipper" in school (primary - by secondary it was not allowed). There is a huge difference between what I remember and what others have gone through which is clearly abusive.

Auvergnewater · 22/03/2022 11:30

Weird how running into the road is always the thing that justifies a smack.

You pull them back, not hit them, surely.

When parents hit children, they do it because they enjoy it. Not in “that” way - they may feel awful afterwards- but for the briefest of moments it allows them to relieve the tension.

It’s an awful thing to do.

balalake · 22/03/2022 11:24

I don't expect it will be extended to England.

Making it illegal will reduce perhaps stop it in public, but not in private. As well as the issue about school withdrawal, I'd be concerned that false allegations could be made by children either as a form of blackmail, or to be used by one parent in a custody/access battle.

Ozanj · 22/03/2022 11:01

If you make smacking illegal then it’s possible there are knock on impacts like parents not taking / withdrawing vulnerable kids to school (this has started to happen in Scotland) and kids feeling unable to open up to teachers / adult role models. Since Covid a lot of vulnerable kids have disappeared from school - so until that gets sorted we shouldn’t be giving parents yet another excuse to keep kids away from school.

Changemaname1 · 22/03/2022 10:59

I thought it already was !

No need for it though ever , I was smacked the odd time as a child and honestly it just made me angry

Have never and would never hit my DC it achieves nothing positive and likely the opposite

Fairylightsongs · 22/03/2022 10:57

@Quitelikeit

Smacking your child in England is illegal unless it is reasonable to do so.

If you decide to do so you must not leave any mark on your child at all.

So as much as a tap if that

I agree with a pp - parents who have a propensity to smack their child will do so regardless of the law

You’re missing the point. It is never ever reasonable to hit your child, your friend, your partner, your boss. No one.
EarlGreywithLemon · 22/03/2022 10:56

I would never ever ever smack my child. I don’t understand what it’s supposed to achieve anyway.

And quite apart from anything else - if you smack your child, how can you ever tell them not to hit another child, or someone else, or even you? If you do it, why shouldn’t they?

Either violence is completely unacceptable, for anyone, or it’s fair game for everyone.