Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents smacking and slapping children should become illegal in England

164 replies

JC544D · 21/03/2022 22:19

Today Wales has joined more than 60 nations in outlawing physical punishment of children. The new law means people will be committing a crime if they smack, hit, slap or shake a child in their care.

We don’t allow adults to be hit by another person, nor do we allow adults to hit animals.

I think it's more than time England followed suit in outlawing the physical punishment of children by their parents.

What is your view?

OP posts:
IncompleteSenten · 22/03/2022 14:39

Well that last sentence just reads like I hit my child! It should have put those ' round it. 🙄

IncompleteSenten · 22/03/2022 14:38

It should be illegal.
Many people manage to raise their children to adulthood without ever laying a finger on them. Are they just better people? No. They're just normal same as everyone else. Nobody has to hit their child. If they choose to they should own it. I choose to hit my child because I want to.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 22/03/2022 14:37

When you read these in context of a man hitting a woman it brings home how awful it is an adult can still legally hit a child
So then you would allow your child to entirely decide everything from their diet to their clothes because if a man told you what to eat and what to wear they would be controlling?

MarshaBradyo · 22/03/2022 14:35

@Glassesmare

I can't believe it's still legal. To think that DH could hit me and I could have him arrested, but he could hit tiny 5 yo DD and that would be ok Confused I can't stand it when people say that it did them no harm. In what world is it ok to hurt others, especially the smallest and most vulnerable.
I know. When you read these in context of a man hitting a woman it brings home how awful it is an adult can still legally hit a child.
cornflakedreams · 22/03/2022 14:33

The only people who think it should be legal to hit children are abusers.

mymindisamuckingfuddle · 22/03/2022 14:31

@Auvergnewater

Weird how running into the road is always the thing that justifies a smack.

You pull them back, not hit them, surely.

When parents hit children, they do it because they enjoy it. Not in “that” way - they may feel awful afterwards- but for the briefest of moments it allows them to relieve the tension.

It’s an awful thing to do.

I agree with this. It's a nonsense excuse.

My three year old very very nearly ran into the road the other day. I caught her by her coat hood to stop her, crouched down to her level (in a total panic and feeling very upset with her) and really, really told her off.

I was raging with her to be honest, and absolutely frightened at 'what could have happened'. She never runs off, she's not a bolter. I don't know what got into her.

I didn't hit her. Even with that impulsive, naughty, frankly very dangerous behaviour, I didn't hit her.

The telling off was enough. She has to hold my hand at all times now whereas normally she's allowed to potter along next to me (it's a very quiet village, hardly any traffic). So she's learned that 1) Don't run off or Mum will be really cross and tell you off and 2) Because you ran off now you have to hold hands always instead of being allowed to walk like a big girl.

Would hitting have achieved this? No.

pointythings · 22/03/2022 14:14

devpatelslaughingeyes I am so sorry you went through that, and what an incredibly poignant and eloquent way of making the point.

I'm 54. My mum smacked me and my sister (my dad did not). I had a good childhood, but decided a very long time ago that I would not hit my children. And I haven't. And when my mum watched me parent my DDs, she came right out with it and told me that she wished she had had the patient and insight to handle things the way I was doing back when we were little. I've nver loved and respected her as much as I did when she said that, and she was a great mum. Who had a very dysfunctional and damaging childhood herself and made ours better than hers had been - my sis and I were just the next step.

Smacking is always, always bad.

VampireMoney · 22/03/2022 13:38

I completely agree OP. I'm disgusted that it's still allowed in this country.

Devpatelslaughingeyes · 22/03/2022 13:28

@Hospedia

I also remember the feeling of lying in bed after a smack and feeling so unloved and unwanted. Crying, quietly so I didn't get the speech about "I'll give you something to cry for/you're only crying for yourself", feeling hateful about what had been done to me, hateful towards my dad, hateful towards towards to myself, angry at myself for feeling hateful because its wrong to hate, sad about being hateful and angry, sad because I was obviously hated, sad because I was useless and bad or else why would I keep acting in ways that got me smacked, stupid too as I didn't learn, and that brought us back around to unloved and rejected.

It's not a feeling I ever want for my DC.

This. 100%. Been there, done that, and got a wardrobe full of Tee shirts.

In our house it was never just a smack or a tap. It was a full on beating and followed the pattern of a battering around the head before the belt came off. If you were lucky it would be the leather strap, if not it was the buckle end and he stopped when he had burnt himself out leaving me stiff and aching for several days after. I used to go to bed at night and pray that he wouldn’t wake up in the morning. It certainly didn’t make me love him or respect him. The other parent offered no protection whatsoever. The savageness of those beatings, the pain unnecessarily inflicted, the injustice, the rejection, the feelings of self loathing, confusion, and fear. No, I would never want to, and never did, inflict any of that on my children. I am in my 70s now and still suffer physically, emotionally, and mentally from that treatment in my childhood.

Without battering the living daylights out of my children or ‘knocking some respect’ into them they have grown up into decent human beings who understand reason and kindness and give out both in ample measure. They have never known what it is like to be smacked and, in turn, have never ever smacked their own children. It is never necessary.

My father would say that ‘a hiding’ never did him any harm. It did. It turned him into an abusing parent who beat the crap out of his kids and fucked them up for life.

This law can’t come in quick enough. An abusing parent is always going to be an abusing parent and children who are abused will continue to hide the abuse out of fear and shame but it may make some people think twice. Anything that makes home safer for children has got to be a good thing.

Soangrywithmyself · 22/03/2022 13:18

@Coulddowithanap

Trouble is making it illegal will do nothing. People who smack their children still will.

Same as its illegal to murder but that doesn't stop some people.

Should murder be legal then? Is murder very common?

I think it will make a difference. If nothing else it sends a message in very clear terms that this is unacceptable in society. Too many people still seem to think it's a valid parenting technique or no big deal.

I also assume it would make a difference to custody cases or in cases where ss are involved.

Glassesmare · 22/03/2022 13:18

I can't believe it's still legal. To think that DH could hit me and I could have him arrested, but he could hit tiny 5 yo DD and that would be ok Confused I can't stand it when people say that it did them no harm. In what world is it ok to hurt others, especially the smallest and most vulnerable.

Caffeineandcarbs · 22/03/2022 13:13

@Sandinmyhooves

I cannot imagine a worse thing to do as a parent than teach your child that the ones who love them most can and will hurt them. How to really fuck up your kids.
100% agree with this.
HeckyPeck · 22/03/2022 13:07

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

I’m not agreeing with smacking but comments like this “If your child is NT and you’ve parented so poorly thay they totally ignore you when you ask them to stop and you have no control” tells me that most on this thread don’t have difficult testing children- you think bad behaviour is solely down to how a child is brought up. Having a well behaved vs a naughty child is mostly down to luck- and if you’re child doesn’t care about losing a toy or a naughty step then some parents have less avenues to turn. Now I never felt unloved or abused by my parents who occasionally smacked me/ those who did I would say didn’t have a happy childhood with an occasional smack but rather an unhappy childhood where they were also smacked
I agree with this.

I was smacked occasionally, but never in anger or hard. It was done as a consequence I suppose and to me it was no different to other punishments. I don't think it did me any harm, but I still don't agree with smacking as it clearly has done others harm.

I don't think banning it would be a cure-all of course because the parents that were abusive will still be abusive. If they smack less or not at all they'll probably ramp up other areas of abuse to compensate. I still think it should be banned as that then sends a message to non-abusive parents to use other methods.

Hospedia · 22/03/2022 13:06

"Didn't do any harm" is a low bar even on the rare occasions that it's true.

Things from my 80s/90s childhood that "didn't do me any harm".

  • no carseat as a baby/toddler
  • no seat belts in the backseat of a lot of cars even after they became law
  • piling 5-6 kids in the back of a car, sitting on knees, even sitting in the boot
  • being babysat by my cousin who was 11 and sensible
  • once I was 11 and sensible the babysitter baton passed to me and I became the family babysitter, I looked after my four cousins for hours at a time and the youngest was only around 6mo
  • playing out from breakfast to dinnertime then dinnertime to teatime with next to no supervision. We used to roam for miles and our parents would only have the vaguest idea of where so long as we were home by tea/before dark
  • smoking allowed indoors absolutely everywhere. Top deck of the bus was smoking, smoking sections in cafes, you could smoke in the shopping centre, you could even smoke in the waiting room at the hospital because I remember once knocking over an ashtray in one
  • going for rides in the back of my dad's work van, sitting on the toolbox because there were no seats
  • being sent to the shop with money and a note from around the age of 5, my aunt used to give us a permission slip so we could get her cigarettes
  • being left in the holiday apartment at night while the adults went out, holidays camps even offered a listening service
  • as a baby I was put down to sleep on my tummy to prevent me getting a flat head, I also had a pillow and a quilt for comfort

And a lot more besides only that short selection.

None of it did me any harm, although plenty of other children were harmed by these things, and the majority of it would be considered harmful and/or neglectful by today's standards.

Smacking is the same.

Banning it won't entirely stop it, there will still be parents who do it, but it will begin a cultural shift away from it being acceptable (although not ideal) to completely unacceptable.

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 22/03/2022 13:00

@OnlyFoolsnMothers if a child is already naughty (and mine was incredibly challenging at times when younger) and doesn't care about other consequences, I imagine the parent would have to hurt them pretty badly for them to take any notice of that.

ForcingSmiles · 22/03/2022 12:59

I was slapped by my mother almost daily for the smallest things (Dropping a mug, spilling milk, being 5-10 minutes late home).

I've been happily no contact with her for almost four years now.

It did leave lasting damage and i'm constantly paranoid of being hit again (even though my partner has never and would never do that).

She's the one who's going to live the rest of her life never meeting or knowing her grandchildren due to the choices she made. And when I do have children I will NEVER EVER hit them, there's other ways to discipline children without resorting to physical violence.

And for context my partner was never hit during childhood, he has a loving, close open relationship with his parents now. Not sure if thats a direct link but it was a big factor in me deciding to shut my mother off.

justandfair · 22/03/2022 12:54

OP , 💯 💯💯Agree with you fully.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 22/03/2022 12:54

I’m not agreeing with smacking but comments like this
“If your child is NT and you’ve parented so poorly thay they totally ignore you when you ask them to stop and you have no control” tells me that most on this thread don’t have difficult testing children- you think bad behaviour is solely down to how a child is brought up. Having a well behaved vs a naughty child is mostly down to luck- and if you’re child doesn’t care about losing a toy or a naughty step then some parents have less avenues to turn.
Now I never felt unloved or abused by my parents who occasionally smacked me/ those who did I would say didn’t have a happy childhood with an occasional smack but rather an unhappy childhood where they were also smacked

BodgertheJogger · 22/03/2022 12:52

@AnneLovesGilbert

lots of 'it didn't do me any harm'

The only response to this is “it did, you think it’s okay for adults to hit children.”

100% this. Smacking a child is a sign that a parent has lost control. Smacking is classed as assault and rightly so if someone hits an adult.
LaLoba · 22/03/2022 12:51

@AnneLovesGilbert

lots of 'it didn't do me any harm'

The only response to this is “it did, you think it’s okay for adults to hit children.”

My parents used to say this. It did them a lot of harm, and me too when they passed the violence on.
Babadook76 · 22/03/2022 12:50

@JC544D

I agree 'Idontwanna'. A change would make it very clear that's it is simply unacceptable.

I think with time this is one of those things that people will look back on in shock saying 'I can't believe it was still allowed only so many years ago', 'I can't believe it was still allowed in 2022' etc

I agree. People look back in horror at when teachers were allowed to smack children. Yet parents are still allowed to
purpleboy · 22/03/2022 12:47

I was smacked as a child, it didn't have any long term or long lasting effect on me, I appreciate parenting was done differently then and I have no doubt my parents loved me. I don't feel unloved, or uncared for, it didn't make me cry.
It didn't turn me into a violent child, I still knew hitting others wasn't acceptable, but is was acceptable as a form of punishment from parents to children.

I also don't hit my children, mainly because I can hold my temper better than my parents, my own children aren't assholes like I was, and I also as I said think parenting has moved on and it isn't an acceptable form of punishment.

I completely accept that some children who get smacked come from chaotic homes where love is maybe not freely given and I think in those situations the response felt can be very different.
Also everyone is different, so just because snacking didn't affect me, it obviously from this thread affected many others, and I don't think any child should have to grow up feeling like some of the posters on this thread.

ClariceQuiff · 22/03/2022 12:46

As someone who was extensively smacked and beaten in my childhood, I 100% agree.

The moment you say it's OK to smack as long as it doesn't leave a bruise (or whatever) you legitimise the concept of corporal punishment and for every person who would never give their child more than a 'tap' there will be someone who (to use my father's phrase) will 'thrash the living daylights' out of their offspring.

EarlGreywithLemon · 22/03/2022 12:46

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

To play devils advocate what do you do when a child say won’t stop drawing on the walls, or kicking their sibling?
Tell them to draw on paper and to use words not violence! If you smack them, you have zero authority to tell them not to hit their sibling anyway.
Fairylightsongs · 22/03/2022 12:43

Amazing how quickly parents find alternative coping methods once the kid smashes them right back

Totally agree when the child gets big enough that there’s a real risk they will hit the parent back and it will be a fight they stop hitting them immediately.

To play devils advocate what do you do when a child say won’t stop drawing on the walls, or kicking their sibling?

If your child is NT and you’ve parented so poorly thay they totally ignore you when you ask them to stop and you have no control, then there are much bigger issues at play and resorting to violence and assaulting the child isn’t the answer.

You use your words. You can remove them from the scene without assaulting them, you then explain the impact of their behavuour, give repercussions and you reward good behaviour.

Swipe left for the next trending thread