Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents smacking and slapping children should become illegal in England

164 replies

JC544D · 21/03/2022 22:19

Today Wales has joined more than 60 nations in outlawing physical punishment of children. The new law means people will be committing a crime if they smack, hit, slap or shake a child in their care.

We don’t allow adults to be hit by another person, nor do we allow adults to hit animals.

I think it's more than time England followed suit in outlawing the physical punishment of children by their parents.

What is your view?

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 22/03/2022 16:01

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

i get it irks people who want to justify hitting children but those who’d like to see it stop would prefer the law catches up, as it has already in many countries you really do struggle with the concept of an argument don’t you. The poster in question is not pro smacking but pointing out the absurdity of comparing to the treatment of adults. Or do you take your husbands electronics off him if he’s spent too much time on them?
Tbh I just see people using it as an argument to keep the law as it is.

I hope they don’t get that and society moves on wrt hitting children.

I don’t really care about your ‘argument’ much more than that other than it sounds like a justification for awful parenting. Fine you do you.

I still hope it changes and we don’t need to hear oh but I don’t take my husband’s phone or whatever - I just drift off when people start going on about it.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 22/03/2022 15:58

i get it irks people who want to justify hitting children but those who’d like to see it stop would prefer the law catches up, as it has already in many countries you really do struggle with the concept of an argument don’t you. The poster in question is not pro smacking but pointing out the absurdity of comparing to the treatment of adults. Or do you take your husbands electronics off him if he’s spent too much time on them?

EarlGreywithLemon · 22/03/2022 15:44

@SoupDragon I’m afraid saying that you weren’t damaged by smacking and that “there is a huge difference between what I remember and what others have gone through which is clearly abusive” looks like justifying smacking.

Smacking of any kind should be classed - by law - as always abusive. Because it is.

MarshaBradyo · 22/03/2022 15:38

@Deadringer

I hate when people say if it's not ok for for a husband to hit his wife it's not ok to hit a child. Parents have authority over their children, they have to teach them how to behave, and sometimes they have to punish bad behaviour, the one has nothing to do with the other. Really irks me. Anyway, slapping in our society is frowned on, as it should be, it is abusive and pointless, and it doesn't work as a punishment imo. Should it be outlawed, i don't know, it seems a bit pointless, are we going to throw people into jail if they break that law, or punish them in any way, if not what's the point? I was slapped occasionally as a child, in school and at home, i am one of those people who would say it didn't do me any harm, but then it was considered normal at that time, so completely different to now.
I get it irks people who want to justify hitting children but those who’d like to see it stop would prefer the law catches up, as it has already in many countries.
Deadringer · 22/03/2022 15:26

I hate when people say if it's not ok for for a husband to hit his wife it's not ok to hit a child. Parents have authority over their children, they have to teach them how to behave, and sometimes they have to punish bad behaviour, the one has nothing to do with the other. Really irks me. Anyway, slapping in our society is frowned on, as it should be, it is abusive and pointless, and it doesn't work as a punishment imo. Should it be outlawed, i don't know, it seems a bit pointless, are we going to throw people into jail if they break that law, or punish them in any way, if not what's the point? I was slapped occasionally as a child, in school and at home, i am one of those people who would say it didn't do me any harm, but then it was considered normal at that time, so completely different to now.

SoupDragon · 22/03/2022 15:17

Oh, I remember! I was only smacked a few times, and I remember every time very well - and not in a good way. I was absolutely terrified of my parents. You may think that's a good thing, but in my book, it's not.

@EarlGreywithLemon please point out where I said it was a good thing.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 22/03/2022 15:08

I’m not justifying hitting a child- I’m happy to make it illegal to eliminate the risk of some abuse falling through the cracks but I do think there is a grey area for most parents who have used smacking as a form of punishment- it’s not always uncontrolled abuse

Catalinka · 22/03/2022 15:07

Given that it's been illegal to smack children in sweden since 1979, what is it that people are worried about happening if we join the dozens of countries who've also banned it? What advantages of it do people think sweden and the dozens of other countries are missing out on? The enjoyment of assaulting vulnerable, small people?
The fact that it being illegal to hit your wife doesn't stop domestic abusers means we should make it legal to hit your wife does it? Confused
If you can't cope with a child without being allowed to assault it you should have remained childless. It just makes kids more aggressive and can sometimes make them grow up thinking it's OK for an adult to assault a child. It's not.
If smacking was illegal at least child abusers would no longer be able to justify it in their head as being legally allowed.

Potatoesdonthavefaces · 22/03/2022 15:01

Agreed.

And I also think we need to clamp down on children hitting other children. I see so many threads on here about children being hit in schools with little consequence that I am seriously considering home education.

MarshaBradyo · 22/03/2022 15:01

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

i find your example baffling tbh as said by pp my example is not to justify smacking but to dismiss the idea you can say smacking is always bad because my husband can’t touch me
To you as you’ve justified hitting children a few times

But to others they find it strange and would prefer the law to catch up as it has in Scotland and Wales, thankfully

I very much hope England will follow.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 22/03/2022 14:59

i find your example baffling tbh as said by pp my example is not to justify smacking but to dismiss the idea you can say smacking is always bad because my husband can’t touch me

Drivingish · 22/03/2022 14:58

@OnlyFoolsnMothers - but you remove a phone, in your example, because the child in question isn't yet either mentally or emotionally competent to make a sound decision for themselves so you need to show them how to manage certain things and enforce it until they're mature enough to make the decision for themselves, even if they then make bad decisions, as they'll then understand the decisions they're making and are mature enough to take the consequences. If your husband was mentally incompetent and having a phone was hurting him somehow I hope you WOULD take it from him, so the comparison doesn't work.

Smacking though is not helping an immature child manage anything though so why would you, same as you wouldn't hit an adult, mentally competent or not.

Hadalifeonce · 22/03/2022 14:54

Unfortunately, it won't stop people who beat/abuse their children.

MarshaBradyo · 22/03/2022 14:51

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

Hitting a child stands out as particularly bad don’t you think? I’m not pro smacking but I can separate the idea of a smack on the bum being used as a consequence punishment vs an out of control adult giving a child a beating. Do I think other punishments are necessarily better and less psychologically damaging, not always. I also think comparing to how adults should treat one mother as pointless, it’s apples and oranges
I find your example baffling tbh as said by pp.

In your mind diet etc is comparable to hitting

What is good parenting to you? Eat anything they want and hit them?

Obviously peopls make decisions on diet etc for their children and also don’t hit them, I’d prefer the non hitting to be legally backed. As many adults think it’s ok and justify it.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 22/03/2022 14:50

[quote Liverbird77]@OnlyFoolsnMothers you can't be for real? Of course I decide what my children eat and what they wear. They are too young to make good choices so they rely on me to do so on their behalf. Of course when they are older they can make these choices for themselves, armed with the knowledge of what's healthy and appropriate.

They also rely on me to protect and defend them, hence why I'll never lay a finger on them.

What you've said doesn't make sense.[/quote]
I’m pointing out the absurdity of comparing a spouse to a child- would I hit my husband? No but neither would I remove his phone if he did something I didn’t want him to

ClaudineClare · 22/03/2022 14:49

I had a friend whose father used the belt on them. I was really scared of him, even though he was never nasty to me.

Hitting children is abuse. I am glad Wales has made this move.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 22/03/2022 14:49

Hitting a child stands out as particularly bad don’t you think?
I’m not pro smacking but I can separate the idea of a smack on the bum being used as a consequence punishment vs an out of control adult giving a child a beating. Do I think other punishments are necessarily better and less psychologically damaging, not always.
I also think comparing to how adults should treat one mother as pointless, it’s apples and oranges

mnnewbie111 · 22/03/2022 14:48

Gosh no idea why I thought this was already illegal here. How weird. Must have been discussed and then not agreed maybe. 🤔

Liverbird77 · 22/03/2022 14:46

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

Drivingish · 22/03/2022 14:43

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

When you read these in context of a man hitting a woman it brings home how awful it is an adult can still legally hit a child So then you would allow your child to entirely decide everything from their diet to their clothes because if a man told you what to eat and what to wear they would be controlling?
I would give my child choice in the context that they are able to use that choice. If I was an adult but had the understanding of a 3 year old I would also expect to be guided on diet and appropriate clothes to wear.

Exactly what though is needed by smacking, whether you're 2 or 50?

Liverbird77 · 22/03/2022 14:43

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

MarshaBradyo · 22/03/2022 14:41

@IncompleteSenten

Well that last sentence just reads like I hit my child! It should have put those ' round it. 🙄
Ha at this good save. I agree with you btw

There will always be those who try to justify it - on this thread too.

Drivingish · 22/03/2022 14:41

@Glassesmare

I can't believe it's still legal. To think that DH could hit me and I could have him arrested, but he could hit tiny 5 yo DD and that would be ok Confused I can't stand it when people say that it did them no harm. In what world is it ok to hurt others, especially the smallest and most vulnerable.
Completely! Just did conflict training for work and we're told, rightly, that even a poke in the shoulder by a client is common assault and how we don't have to put up with abuse but then smacking kids is still legal, it makes no sense.
MarshaBradyo · 22/03/2022 14:40

A child..

MarshaBradyo · 22/03/2022 14:39

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

When you read these in context of a man hitting a woman it brings home how awful it is an adult can still legally hit a child So then you would allow your child to entirely decide everything from their diet to their clothes because if a man told you what to eat and what to wear they would be controlling?
Hitting a child stands out as particularly bad don’t you think?

Or do you see it as ok?

Yes I do separate it out and think child should be protected by law from adults who think it’s ok to hit them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread