Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents smacking and slapping children should become illegal in England

164 replies

JC544D · 21/03/2022 22:19

Today Wales has joined more than 60 nations in outlawing physical punishment of children. The new law means people will be committing a crime if they smack, hit, slap or shake a child in their care.

We don’t allow adults to be hit by another person, nor do we allow adults to hit animals.

I think it's more than time England followed suit in outlawing the physical punishment of children by their parents.

What is your view?

OP posts:
Roses1221 · 22/03/2022 17:34

Who are these people who are still smacking their kids in 2022?! Shame on them. It should be illegal, I agree.

MarshaBradyo · 22/03/2022 17:25

@SoyaChai

Don’t you think someone who is smaller, less able to leave and powerless needs more protection in law not less?

Yes. I just don't think drawing comparisons to what you're allowed to do to adults is helpful in anyway as justification that's all. Surely using arguments arguing about the harm it causes children psychologically etc. and for no benefit to them is the better justification?

Why is hitting someone vulnerable ok up to a point? Ie we’re fine if it’s an adult to a child

I never claimed it was OK though. So, I don't know what your argument against me is.

It’s just coming at it from different perspectives

I think that it is logical to say adults get protection, and children need more.

Others will look at it from another angle. If it’s banned then fine.

I do think that given there is an argument from some that well I get to choose clothes or food (in pp) so I get to choose re hitting makes changing the law even more necessary, as a signal that it’s not ok.

SoyaChai · 22/03/2022 17:22

To be fair, that's pretty much what prison is. Grounding for adults. grin

True! I guess I meant in a domestic relationship, within a family etc. Either way, banning it is the way forward regardless of whether I agree with that particular reasoning above.

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 22/03/2022 17:18

We don't allow adults to ground each other and take away privileges either, that would be emotional and mental abuse.

To be fair, that's pretty much what prison is. Grounding for adults. Grin

SoyaChai · 22/03/2022 17:14

Don’t you think someone who is smaller, less able to leave and powerless needs more protection in law not less?

Yes. I just don't think drawing comparisons to what you're allowed to do to adults is helpful in anyway as justification that's all. Surely using arguments arguing about the harm it causes children psychologically etc. and for no benefit to them is the better justification?

Why is hitting someone vulnerable ok up to a point? Ie we’re fine if it’s an adult to a child

I never claimed it was OK though. So, I don't know what your argument against me is.

MarshaBradyo · 22/03/2022 17:06

@SoyaChai

Why is hitting someone vulnerable ok up to a point?

Did you not see the part where I said I want it to be banned? Confused

Yes but I don’t agree with your this is illogical part of the post
SoyaChai · 22/03/2022 17:03

Why is hitting someone vulnerable ok up to a point?

Did you not see the part where I said I want it to be banned? Confused

MarshaBradyo · 22/03/2022 17:01

@SoyaChai

I'm all for banning it.

But, never understood the following argument:

We don’t allow adults to be hit by another person, nor do we allow adults to hit animals.

We don't allow adults to ground each other and take away privileges either, that would be emotional and mental abuse.

I don't understand why the logic of "if it would be illegal to do to an adult, it should be illegal to do to a child" doesn't follow through.

Doesn't mean it is OK. Just, I think it's a bad justification for banning it personally.

Don’t you think someone who is smaller, less able to leave and powerless needs more protection in law not less?

Why is hitting someone vulnerable ok up to a point? Ie we’re fine if it’s an adult to a child

It seems counterintuitive and societally excused to me, hence the need for a change in law to signal it’s not ok.

SoyaChai · 22/03/2022 16:57

I'm all for banning it.

But, never understood the following argument:

We don’t allow adults to be hit by another person, nor do we allow adults to hit animals.

We don't allow adults to ground each other and take away privileges either, that would be emotional and mental abuse.

I don't understand why the logic of "if it would be illegal to do to an adult, it should be illegal to do to a child" doesn't follow through.

Doesn't mean it is OK. Just, I think it's a bad justification for banning it personally.

MarshaBradyo · 22/03/2022 16:55

@Fairylightsongs

I’d agree rhe comments of well it didn’t harm me are concerning. So what it didn’t harm you. It’s harmed plenty of others and it doesn’t make it acceptable.

Violence, be it adult on adult is wrong. A smack, a slap, a belting. It’s wrong. And it’s even worse when it’s adult on child. A small child whose whole world is that parent., who can’t hit back, who can’t leave, who is totally impotent and has to take it is worse, it’s worse being the person who would hit a child and it’s worse being the powerless child being hit.

The type of person who does it, does it because they can. Because no one stops them. Because the child is powerless and can’t hit them back, because the trust the child won’t tell anyone what the parent is doing to them.

It’s abuse. If you hit your child you are abusing your own child.and we as a society need to stand up and tell these abusers you can’t hit your child or any child, by changing the law, just like Scotland has done, just like wales are done.

And schools need to talk to children about this. To tell them it’s never ok for someone to hit you, Inc your parents and if they do, you need to tell a teacher, or Give a way for the child to report.

The only acceptable level of abuse and assault is none. And this includes parent on child.

Well said.
Fairylightsongs · 22/03/2022 16:53

I’d agree rhe comments of well it didn’t harm me are concerning. So what it didn’t harm you. It’s harmed plenty of others and it doesn’t make it acceptable.

Violence, be it adult on adult is wrong. A smack, a slap, a belting. It’s wrong. And it’s even worse when it’s adult on child. A small child whose whole world is that parent., who can’t hit back, who can’t leave, who is totally impotent and has to take it is worse, it’s worse being the person who would hit a child and it’s worse being the powerless child being hit.

The type of person who does it, does it because they can. Because no one stops them. Because the child is powerless and can’t hit them back, because the trust the child won’t tell anyone what the parent is doing to them.

It’s abuse. If you hit your child you are abusing your own child.and we as a society need to stand up and tell these abusers you can’t hit your child or any child, by changing the law, just like Scotland has done, just like wales are done.

And schools need to talk to children about this. To tell them it’s never ok for someone to hit you, Inc your parents and if they do, you need to tell a teacher, or Give a way for the child to report.

The only acceptable level of abuse and assault is none. And this includes parent on child.

tearsforfears72 · 22/03/2022 16:52

A smacking ban is well overdue in the UK!
I know many kids of my generation (70s/80s) were smacked, including myself, and I can say it didn’t do me any good, it was painful, humiliating and traumatising. Smacking is abuse and instils violence in children.

Drivingish · 22/03/2022 16:49

@Kanaloa

I also don't hit my children, mainly because I can hold my temper better than my parents, my own children aren't assholes like I was

Huh. Almost like hitting and humiliating your kids doesn’t improve their behaviour. Odd when so many of the defenders of smacking are insistent that there’s simply no other way to raise well behaved kids.

True - even when children are badly behaved there's no set correlation between smacking and good behaviour.

All studies aside, I hate it when people say 'kids today are..... they just need a good smack'. My sister was smacked routinely, she's an over dramatic snowflake but fairly well behaved, my daughter doesn't get smacked at all and is also an over dramatic snowflake who is fairly well behaved, there's not even a side behavioural benefit to hurting kids!

Kanaloa · 22/03/2022 16:43

I also don't hit my children, mainly because I can hold my temper better than my parents, my own children aren't assholes like I was

Huh. Almost like hitting and humiliating your kids doesn’t improve their behaviour. Odd when so many of the defenders of smacking are insistent that there’s simply no other way to raise well behaved kids.

ToxicBuns · 22/03/2022 16:35

Definitely should be made illegal. Whatever the age it's still assault. Think about that.

Kanaloa · 22/03/2022 16:29

@Nicholethejewellery

I thought it was illegal already tbf. Certainly people round here seem to disapprove of it if you do it in public. I'm not sure how I feel about outlawing it to be honest, on the face of it it sounds like a good idea but there isn't another suitable punishment that gives the same effect. Smacking works because it is painful and/or embarrassing and/or degrading to the child. It's these things that children fear from a punishment, it's these things that make them think about their behaviour in a way that sitting on the "naughty step" or getting a "timeout" or not being allowed to watch their favourite TV programme doesn't.

Berlinbabylon's "well thought out psychological punishment" sounds quite disturbing in comparison to a smack, messing with a child's head sounds more damaging long term.

There ‘isn’t another punishment’ that causes your child pain and degrades them Confused that’s not ‘making them think about their behaviour’ that’s making them think about their parent hurting and humiliating them. The only thing that will make them think about their behaviour is taking the time repeatedly to talk to them and waiting for them to emotionally mature until they can understand why they mustn’t do whatever they’re doing, as well as teaching them other ways to deal with it.

For example, if my son leaves his room all messy, me hitting and humiliating him won’t really ‘make him thing about his behaviour,’ it will just hurt and humiliate him. However, if I set aside time to talk to him about the importance of a clean and tidy environment and help teach him how to tidy it, as well as giving him tips to keep on top of it, then he will be able to evaluate that behaviour and change it.

Popcornriver · 22/03/2022 16:23

There's better ways to discipline a child than physically hurting them. And those that take offence and say it doesn't hurt, yes it does. You're lying to yourself. A quick hit to the back of the hand or leg usually causes a sharp, short sting. It's socially unacceptable for a reason. Keep your hands to yourself.

MarshaBradyo · 22/03/2022 16:22

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

I just drift off when people start going on about it I understand, it’s hard for your rationale to hold up when the most obvious counter argument is explained to you, better you drift off
It doesn’t matter how insulting you are, although I get it might be some kind of get back that makes you feel ok about stuff.

I can’t agree with hitting children and think it’s a big shame some justify it

And hope the law changed soon.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 22/03/2022 16:20

I just drift off when people start going on about it I understand, it’s hard for your rationale to hold up when the most obvious counter argument is explained to you, better you drift off

MarshaBradyo · 22/03/2022 16:17

Choose..

MangyInseam · 22/03/2022 16:17

@Whitewhitewalls

Quite a large % of the vote is YABU, I wish those people would comment as well so we can see other POV.
I think there are probably a few reasons people might think it's a bad idea, likely it will be a few of these things taken together:
  • they don't think it will be an effective law.
  • they don't really buy the "I wouldn't hit another adult" thing, because there are lots of other instances where we treat children differently.
  • there isn't actually a lot of empirical evidence that shows that societies where smacking/spanking happens have poorer outcomes than societies where it does.
  • They see it as imposing bourgeoisie morality on other cultural groups or class groups.
  • they may also argue that it's disingenuous to conflate smacking with hitting or abuse, even if they are ready to agree that some people will excuse abusive behaviour as if it is just discipline.
MarshaBradyo · 22/03/2022 16:17

@Catalinka

I hate when people say if it's not ok for for a husband to hit his wife it's not ok to hit a child I hate it when people give lame justifications for assaulting children. Hitting a child is worse than hitting a woman due to the size difference and the child's inability to escape.
Exactly

And it gets murky when adults justify it with well I chose their clothes and food, so I can do this too

A change in law, as other countries have done, would signal that it is not the same

Catalinka · 22/03/2022 16:12

It's good that 75% of us are against assaulting children. Hopefully the other 25% will catch up eventually as in other countries.

Catalinka · 22/03/2022 16:09

I hate when people say if it's not ok for for a husband to hit his wife it's not ok to hit a child
I hate it when people give lame justifications for assaulting children. Hitting a child is worse than hitting a woman due to the size difference and the child's inability to escape.

Catalinka · 22/03/2022 16:03

Should it be outlawed, i don't know, it seems a bit pointless, are we going to throw people into jail if they break that law, or punish them in any way, if not what's the point?
It can be dealt with as with any other safeguarding issue. Are parents immediately thrown into jail anytime a safeguarding issue is raised? No of course not. But as with other safeguarding causes for concern, assault of children shouldn't be ignored. Smacking in sweden has massively reduced following it being made illegal. No one needs to worry that Swedish prisons are packed with hitting parents as they are just less likely to be in favour of it or do it. A great thing for Swedish children

Swipe left for the next trending thread