Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents smacking and slapping children should become illegal in England

164 replies

JC544D · 21/03/2022 22:19

Today Wales has joined more than 60 nations in outlawing physical punishment of children. The new law means people will be committing a crime if they smack, hit, slap or shake a child in their care.

We don’t allow adults to be hit by another person, nor do we allow adults to hit animals.

I think it's more than time England followed suit in outlawing the physical punishment of children by their parents.

What is your view?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Kanaloa · 07/04/2022 23:03

@Sometimeswinning

Anyone who claims they were not damaged by smacking has very clearly been damaged

So, anyone as a child who was smacked, in your opinion is damaged and if they disagree you would say their whole character is a write off?? I think you may need to question your own critical thinking, empathy and intelligence.

Well if they use it as an excuse/justification for hitting children then they’ve obviously been damaged because they think it’s ok to hit children.

Anyone who hits other people is damaged in some way. No happy and healthy person wants to physically harm others, especially those most vulnerable.

Sometimeswinning · 07/04/2022 22:50

Anyone who claims they were not damaged by smacking has very clearly been damaged

So, anyone as a child who was smacked, in your opinion is damaged and if they disagree you would say their whole character is a write off?? I think you may need to question your own critical thinking, empathy and intelligence.

venusmay · 07/04/2022 21:50

I'm totally against smacking but am always astounded that so many people are still in favour. My friend is a primary teacher and has always smacked her son. He's now 9 and she smacked him once in our garden when they visited. Poor lad was mortified and so were we!

JC544D · 07/04/2022 21:47

Sadly there's absolutely no mention of stopping it from the current government.

OP posts:
sweetbellyhigh · 23/03/2022 20:08

Anyone who claims they were not damaged by smacking has very clearly been damaged. For starters they have are demonstrating a lack of ability for critical thought. Also empathy and intelligence. Very sad.

Sandinmyhooves · 23/03/2022 17:43

I always wonder, if I was someone who hit my kids and my grown up DD came home one day to tell me her DH had hit her, what leg would I have to stand on?

Iamkmackered1979 · 23/03/2022 17:37

As a child my mum smacked me, she was quite awful and used wooden/metal spoon!! She had quite a temper I think she’s forgotten but it clearly worked that’s why it happened a lot…….

My dad then attacked me several times he was a nasty evil man, the pair of them are honestly vicious and should never have had kids.

So no, you shouldn’t need to raise your hand to anyone - child, adult, animal to ‘discipline’ them in any way. I’ve never smacked any of my 4 and never will, however they do sometimes drive me to distraction and push my buttons but you do need to learn how to parent effectively so your kids listen and understand why you want them to do (or not do) certain things. And have effective & measurable punishments for behaviour that falls short. It can be exhausting and youngest has sen so I have to adjust expectations and discipline to the child but fairness and consistency is very important. I would not want my kids to be in fear of me, nor would I want to cause them physical pain

VampireMoney · 23/03/2022 17:00

The point of smacking is to make the child afraid of the smack so they won’t do the bad/dangerous behaviour

So instead of learning WHY they did something wrong, teaching them a valuable life lesson, they learn to be afraid of getting a smack rather than afraid of being hit by a car. Yeah makes total sense. Not.

Children should not be slapped or smacked for any reason. Period.

EnglishGirlApproximately · 23/03/2022 16:46

@lizdoingthecancan just seen your comment re Lee Anderson. Very close, his lovely neighbour Mr Bradley

sweetbellyhigh · 23/03/2022 13:51

Blows my mind that people actively campaign for the right to hit children.

You have one job as a parent, to keep your child safe. With every smack/shove/flick, you destroy that.

Hospedia · 23/03/2022 13:29

The point of smacking is to make the child afraid of the smack so they won’t do the bad/dangerous behaviour

If it works so well, why does it need ti be repeated?

And also, why in the blue fuck would I want my DC to be afraid of me and what I might do them!? That's a horrible way for them to live and a horrible dynamic for our relationship to have, DC whonare afraid of what their parents will do won't them confide in those same parents when they're in difficulty and need help. If my DC are in a shitty situation I don't want them to try and hide it because they're worried that if they tell me then I'll hit them (and all the humiliation and degradation that goes with it). I want them to know that I might be angry or disappointed but I won't hurt them.

britneyisfree · 23/03/2022 12:44

Oh. I thought it was illegal. It bloody well should be.

No wonder people think it's okay. Ffs. Ridiculous that it would be legal for adults to hit children but we can't hit each other?

shreddednips · 23/03/2022 12:43

Absolutely agree. Only my father smacked, and it absolutely terrified me. He didn't do it very often but it made me wary of him, I never felt quite relaxed with him. It was more the sight of someone so much bigger and out of control with anger that made it frightening, more so than the actual pain. He also used to shake us, which hurt less but was even more terrifying. He used to be a heavy drinker and that sometimes meant that he'd misinterpret things we did or said as rudeness or naughtiness when we were really just being children.

My mother wasn't so much a smacker, she would occasionally reach into the back seat and swat around at our legs if we were arguing while she was trying to drive. But it never hurt us and we weren't scared of her like we were our dad.

The problem with smacking being legal is that it creates a grey area where child abuse becomes harder to identify. If it's legal but there are caveats (not too hard, don't leave a mark) then it creates doubt as to what constitutes 'acceptable' hitting and what is something that needs flagging. I'd characterise what I experienced as a child as abuse. But because the word used was smacking, I doubt anyone would have thought anything of it if I'd said anything, because parents are 'allowed' to smack.

ldontWanna · 23/03/2022 12:34

@Catalinka

I can see that people who have smacked their own children have got a vested interest in it not being made illegal. Then they have to face the fact that something they did was wrong enough to have been outlawed. Their kids will know this too. Really though, we need to do what's right and it's only a matter of time before it becomes illegal as it is in more than 60 countries now.
I have smacked DD 3 times. Only once was actually necessary. She was in my arms,she bit my lip and wouldn't let go until I smacked her on the leg,she gasped and I could pull her away. It would've been awkward and uncomfortable as fuck to have a discussion about it and explain it, but I doubt anyone would've taken it further. I agree with it being made illegal for two reasons. It never really works in the way parents think it does, and it's too easy to fall into a pattern of behaviour where smacking becomes the go to solution that is easily justified(parent was stressed,scared ,frustrated, what the child did was unacceptable,dangerous etc).
JesusInTheCabbageVan · 23/03/2022 12:25

@DrSbaitso

It’s seldom to never some well considered form of punishment in the child’s best interests that the parent has carefully considered.

I don't even know why that's supposed to be better. You actually thought about it, considered all possibilities, and this was the best thing you could come up with? So what, you called your child over so you could hit them in cold blood?

And that's BETTER?

If I hadn't experienced it myself, I would not have believed that a child could hate their parents as much as smacking made me hate mine.

Agreed. Few things are more disturbing (in my view) than posters trying to justify their parents hitting them on the grounds that it was always done in a calm and calculated manner.
Catalinka · 23/03/2022 12:13

I can see that people who have smacked their own children have got a vested interest in it not being made illegal. Then they have to face the fact that something they did was wrong enough to have been outlawed. Their kids will know this too.
Really though, we need to do what's right and it's only a matter of time before it becomes illegal as it is in more than 60 countries now.

DrSbaitso · 23/03/2022 10:04

It’s seldom to never some well considered form of punishment in the child’s best interests that the parent has carefully considered.

I don't even know why that's supposed to be better. You actually thought about it, considered all possibilities, and this was the best thing you could come up with? So what, you called your child over so you could hit them in cold blood?

And that's BETTER?

If I hadn't experienced it myself, I would not have believed that a child could hate their parents as much as smacking made me hate mine.

Fairylightsongs · 23/03/2022 07:23

The point of smacking is to make the child afraid of the smack so they won’t do the bad/dangerous behaviour

I don’t understand this or why other posters are insistent on telling posters what the point of hitting a child is.

This is not the case that the parent intellectualises, considers all options then chooses violence as the best method to sanction or stop a child.

Hitting is nearly always an emotional response. Anger, annoyance, irritation, frustration, or from shitty people who do it because they can.

It’s seldom to never some well considered form of punishment in the child’s best interests that the parent has carefully considered.

Just like any other scenario where someone gets hit, it’s usually an emotional response.

prescribingmum · 22/03/2022 21:42

I was in the 'it did me no harm' camp until I had children of my own. At that point, I came across gentle parenting and not humiliating children. Also got to know and understand children's brain development and age appropriate behaviour, how they are unable to control emotions at certain ages or rationalise like we can. I certainly don't practise all of gentle parenting but it was an eye opener to learn the psychology.

On reflection, I can now see that hitting did do me harm. Firstly, it gave me the attitude as a child that physically fighting was acceptable (99% of the time it would be with siblings but far far more than my children hit each other), also taught me not to express emotions, to be ashamed when others hurt me (a teacher physically hit me once and my parents only found out because another child complained - I didn't dare complain as I thought I'd get punished again at home. As an adult, I can see I did nothing to deserve being hit by that teacher), parents did not know a lot about what happened at school as I always thought I deserved any injustice. It brings tears to my eyes to think of my children having similar experiences and not telling me. Hitting took away the open relationship and communication and created shame and humiliation. It definitely has no place in discipline today.

AfraidToRun · 22/03/2022 21:25

Smacking taught me many things:

Only men punish and they punish you physically (wait until your father gets home)

I had to wait indefinitely for the punishment to arrive often long after the 'crime'

It wasn't just a smack, it was humiliation having my trousers pulled down etc.

There's an interesting report done by a charity which asks children about their experiences and it's heart breaking. They say things like adults hit children because they are big and children are small etc. You can rationalise as an adult in a way that a child can't.

It's only very recently that I've connected with that part of myself. I used to be a "it did me no harm" camp too.

Qazwsxefv · 22/03/2022 20:49

I don’t smack my dd and don’t plan to. I think it probably should be illegal in modern day UK.

However I think claiming that those that cannot mange to patent without smacking are just lazy bad parents comes from a place of privilege. All of the alternatives suggested - talking about feelings, removing the child from the situation, closer supervision all require time and resource.

The point of smacking is to make the child afraid of the smack so they won’t do the bad/dangerous behaviour . Children have little concept of danger. Here in our nice safe world we can keep our children out the road/away from the hob/river etc. If I was a Victorian mother with five kids under five and an open fire and well and had to do all the housework by hand I can well imagine I’d resort to smacking if my kid kept on trying to kill themselves because I simply would not have the time to protect them from all the dangers in the world and not smacking them but letting them drown/burn is not excellent parenting either. Smacking makes the child realise that a certain action (such as touching the fire) will hurt without exposing them to the risk of the fire. If I was a modern day parent who also lived in a similar situation I would maybe decide the same.

I remember being smacked once as a child after running into the road. My mum couldn’t afford childcare so I played out and loved it. I didn’t look one day and nearly got squashed and she smacked me. I didn’t do it again because I was scared of being smacked - I don’t think I could comprehend being run over so logic wouldn’t have worked - maybe shouting at me until I cried would also have worked but I’m not sure that’s worse than a smack. She could have kept me inside and not needed to smack but I think I preferred the smack and my free range freedom to roam than a life locked up until I understand the consequences of being run over - probably not till my teens I would guess. I’m not smac

The comparison to adults is not valid in my mind. We strap our kids into car seats even if they scream - we pick them up and carry them away from danger or things they like but can’t have - this would be illegal restraint and kidnap if you did it to an adult. We all use physical control on our children when they are too small to understand reason.

This never excuses physical abuse - hitting of a child that is done to humiliate and shame with no purpose other than to dominate. That’s horrid and I’m so sorry for the people who have gone through it.

Giraffesandbottoms · 22/03/2022 18:46

100% needs banning. Went to a friend’s house recently and they smacked their 3 year old as he was hitting his sister. It was just shocking, sad and completely counterproductive. Awful.

Fairylightsongs · 22/03/2022 18:41

@SoyaChai

To be fair, that's pretty much what prison is. Grounding for adults. grin

True! I guess I meant in a domestic relationship, within a family etc. Either way, banning it is the way forward regardless of whether I agree with that particular reasoning above.

To be fair to the poster you said you didn’t understand it, so they are just explaining to you why people are saying that.

So they have explained It’s becayse it’s illegal to hit an adult, but it’s not illegal to hit a more vulnerable person, a child.

As such the law should afford more protection to those who are vulnerable. Not less. We should all be protected from those who abuse and children are the most vulnerable becayse it’s their parents who do it. Often behind closed doors.

They’d shit themselves though if the child told.

This adult v child legalities is only one of many many reasons being put forward by many many posters.

However you asked, you said you couldn’t understand it, and it was explained clearly. I think that’s fair enough.

VampireMoney · 22/03/2022 18:14

@Roses1221

Who are these people who are still smacking their kids in 2022?! Shame on them. It should be illegal, I agree.
I was outside my local shop a couple of weeks back and saw a woman hit a small child round the head a few times with her open hand - I'm assuming his mum. He looked maybe 3yo. I said something to her and she responded in a different language so obviously I don't know what she said and she probably didn't understand what I said either! All I could think was if she's cocky enough to hit him like that in public it doesn't bear thinking about what she does when he's in the home. It really bothered me that I couldn't just report her to the police on the spot.
WingingItSince1973 · 22/03/2022 18:02

I hope this law is passed in England. I had a terribly violent childhood. Regular beaten with wooden spoon or a belt. Mainly because I couldn't finish all that was on my plate, and other minor reasons, also I was terrified to sleep on my own after sexual abuse a few years earlier so I was locked in the cupboard under the stairs or tied to my bed with rope. I prayed every night for help and always wished another family would adopt me. Tragically this was the 70s and although a teacher new, nothing was done. As a teen my dm and df didn't change their discipline and we all had beatings, I remember coming home early to find my younger brother being beaten in the kitchen. I grew up to be very angry and sadly disciplined my eldest harshly as my mother always encouraged slapping a child. I will always be mortified that I did this to my dd, I didn't understand gentle parenting as it was always built into me the parent is the absolute authority, what a parent says goes, children should be seen and not heard etc. Now almost 30 years later I have 3 dds and 1 dgs. I have learned so much over the years that children should never ever be smacked even for so called 'their own good'! My dgs has some issues that all the smacking in the world wouldn't solve. Even now at nearly 50 he's taught me so much about children and how to help them rather than discipline and even if they are being defiant there are much gentler ways to help them. I'm so ashamed at my parenting of my eldest dd. She has alot of anxiety as an adult even though she's an absolutely amazing woman. So please don't smack your children, it can leave a lasting legacy of emotional problems. I was terrified of going home after school and even as a young adult that fear was still there and I couldn't wait to leave home. So after all that writing (sorry) I am absolutely 💯 for the ban!

Swipe left for the next trending thread