Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The Queen and a Wheelchair

213 replies

Nellielephant · 21/03/2022 17:50

AIBU to be annoyed that the newspapers are reporting that the Queen does not want to be seen in a Wheelchair? For those of us who have no choice I find this attitude upsetting as if it is something to be ashamed of.
Giylrs Brandreth has said it would be undignified for her to use one!

OP posts:
grannybiker · 21/03/2022 19:19

As a reasonably young Granny I truly grieve the loss of my mobility, balance and co-ordination.
That said, a mobility scooter has opened many freedom opportunities.

AngelinaFibres · 21/03/2022 19:18

@cranberryhaddock

YABU for caring about anything Gyles Brandreth says. removes tongue from cheek Seriously though, the only person who should care about whether the Queen is seen in a wheelchair or not is the Queen. She should do exactly what she is most comfortable doing.

She is the Queen. She is our head of state. She can't be seen looking frail ,under a blanket, in a wheelchair. She would need a flunky to wheel her about. It doesn't look statesman like.

Maybe you need to change your mindset on wheelchairs. And on what does and doesn't look 'statesmanlike'.

President Obama in a wheelchair whizzing around the corridors of power in his day, totally statesmanlike. Poor, frail, hunched ,very, very old woman covered by a blanket to stop her freezing to death in Westminster Abbey. Far, far less convincing as a head of state.
ajandjjmum · 21/03/2022 19:18

@YanTanTetheraPetheraPimp

My mother missed out on so much by refusing to use a wheelchair, including her granddaughter’s wedding and great grandchildren’s christenings. She effectively made herself housebound for at least 5 years before she needed to be. And then complained bitterly how she couldn’t get to these or a number of other family occasions. Really sad. She happily used one however for hospital and doctors appointments.
The first time my mother agreed to use a wheelchair was so that she could attend DS's graduation. Smile Pushing it around Sheffield was not fun!
NeverDropYourMooncup · 21/03/2022 19:17

@SenecaFallsRedux

The ableism on this thread is astounding. I think some of you need to visit the Franklin D. Roosevelt memorial in Washington DC and see the statue of him seated in his wheelchair. And then also see the children in wheelchairs rolling up to have their picture taken next to the president.

Of course, it is the Queen's choice. But it would be a much better choice for her to be willing to be seen in a wheelchair.

The president who didn't want to be seen in a wheelchair?
EthelTheAardvark · 21/03/2022 19:16

My mother, who was a similar age, hated using a wheelchair even though it made life much easier. It's completely up to the person concerned, and really doesn't have any impact on other people's choices.

Unsureaboutit9 · 21/03/2022 19:16

@CapMarvel

"That reads like you think she should be pushed out of her position as the queen because she now needs a wheelchair sometimes? Yet people wonder why she’d rather keep her health private…"

No, it reads like someone who thinks that at some point everyone has to accept that they need to retire.

We all know the Queen thinks she is appointed by God and is not going to abdicate, but the UK does need a HOS who is capable of filling the role and if she isn't willing to accept that then maybe there should be legislation that says that past a certain age all responsibilities of the monarch need to pass down the tree.

Maybe on some random royalist thread, but this thread is literally about her needing a wheelchair and you are saying she needs to retire now…. It totally does read like that. They are a family and the other members are helping fulfil engagements that she can’t make, which is absolutely as it should be, no need to change the law to hide the old people and wheelchair users away.
rifling · 21/03/2022 19:15

I think it's up to her. When my MIL had a stroke she point blank refused to go out in her wheelchair. The Gyles Brandreth comment is a bit crass though.

Fairyflaps · 21/03/2022 19:14

My mother hates being in a wheelchair or mobility scooter. She's too low down and people talk over her head and ignore her.

Thoosa · 21/03/2022 19:14

@museumum

Is the queen not supposed to always be higher than everyone else or something weird like that? I mean it’s not “normal” being queen is it?

Although I think commentators should be more careful about what they are implying about other wheelchair users when they discuss this.

I think it’s metaphorical. Grin

Bless her. She’s not tall (being polite here) so she’s not literally higher and she’s worn specs for decades, so we know she has human frailties. Honestly, much though we’re all describing the adjustment that losing our mobility was, it’s just like needing glasses, ramped up a few degrees, made difficult by the built environment and the attitudes of the ignorant.

The more I read these comments, the more I think, old lady or not, her courtiers really should put it to her that she is role model, including in the field of disability visibility.

A580Hojas · 21/03/2022 19:13

I understand you OP. There should be no shame or stigma in using a wheelchair, whatever your age or whatever the reason for needing to use it. The Queen is nearly 96 and although she has always been seen as in robust health, she should now be able to use a wheelchair without comment or eyebrows raised. It's a shame IF she is hiding it away.

Blimecory · 21/03/2022 19:13

Can you think of any other leader who is pushed around in a chair.

Roosevelt. He was paralysed from the waist down. But he managed to keep that fact well hidden. It’s the reason the desk in the Oval Office has a fascia to the front - to hide it.

Ohbuggeritsme · 21/03/2022 19:12

When it boils down to it we don't actually really know what the Queen's thoughts are on wheelchairs and whether or not she has one - if she chooses not to have one for whatever reason, that is her valid reason that she has a right to have.

I don't know her personally, but I'm sure whatever her feelings are, it is certainly not meant as a slight on people who need them or that they ate embarrassing.

My mother needs one to help with her failing mobility, fairly refuses to use one as she sees it as giving up when she is still able to get around and feels if she has one whatever mobility she has now will be gone - totally valid point/feeling and nothing at all to do with how she perceives wheelchairs.
My cousin is in a wheelchair following an accident and absolutely hates it with a passion, but is slowly coming around to it - again another valid point/feeling. We don't know the conversation that took place, the reasons etc, so to surmise its like she's embarrassed is unreasonable

CapMarvel · 21/03/2022 19:12

"That reads like you think she should be pushed out of her position as the queen because she now needs a wheelchair sometimes? Yet people wonder why she’d rather keep her health private…"

No, it reads like someone who thinks that at some point everyone has to accept that they need to retire.

We all know the Queen thinks she is appointed by God and is not going to abdicate, but the UK does need a HOS who is capable of filling the role and if she isn't willing to accept that then maybe there should be legislation that says that past a certain age all responsibilities of the monarch need to pass down the tree.

nocoolnamesleft · 21/03/2022 19:11

I think Roosevelt is an amazing role model. Sadly, I suspect he would have found it much harder to be elected in the era of wall to wall TV.

AngelinaFibres · 21/03/2022 19:11

@NoSquirrels

It would be marvellous if the Queen felt she wanted to be a proud representative for wheelchair users but she’s only human, she’s 95 and perhaps by 95 you can be allowed some compassion if you’re not up for that as well as your existing figurehead responsibilities?
I doubt she would be seen as a proud wheelchair user though. If someone like Prince William needed to use one it would be seen as someone who is otherwise fit and healthy but has a serious issue with mobility. The Queen would be seen as an increasingly frail ,very, very old lady who is desperately trying to get through her Jubilee celebrations without dying. She's not a wheelchair using paralypian by any stretch of the imagination.She isnt going to make it sexy.
cranberryhaddock · 21/03/2022 19:10

YABU for caring about anything Gyles Brandreth says. removes tongue from cheek Seriously though, the only person who should care about whether the Queen is seen in a wheelchair or not is the Queen. She should do exactly what she is most comfortable doing.

She is the Queen. She is our head of state. She can't be seen looking frail ,under a blanket, in a wheelchair. She would need a flunky to wheel her about. It doesn't look statesman like.

Maybe you need to change your mindset on wheelchairs. And on what does and doesn't look 'statesmanlike'.

Hummingbirdcake · 21/03/2022 19:10

It’s her choice but it would be good for other people who use wheelchairs if she was seen in one. My grandmother refused to use a wheelchair and it limited what she could do quite significantly.

Thoosa · 21/03/2022 19:09

I think some of you need to visit the Franklin D. Roosevelt memorial in Washington DC and see the statue of him seated in his wheelchair. And then also see the children in wheelchairs rolling up to have their picture taken next to the president.

Oh how lovely. I hadn’t heard of that.

Do you think an adult politics nerd could wheel up and do the same?

museumum · 21/03/2022 19:08

Is the queen not supposed to always be higher than everyone else or something weird like that? I mean it’s not “normal” being queen is it?

Although I think commentators should be more careful about what they are implying about other wheelchair users when they discuss this.

Unsureaboutit9 · 21/03/2022 19:08

@CapMarvel

Surely there needs to be a point that the state goes "actually, you are too old for this" and the whole role goes to Charles whether she likes it or not.
That reads like you think she should be pushed out of her position as the queen because she now needs a wheelchair sometimes? Yet people wonder why she’d rather keep her health private…
SenecaFallsRedux · 21/03/2022 19:07

The ableism on this thread is astounding. I think some of you need to visit the Franklin D. Roosevelt memorial in Washington DC and see the statue of him seated in his wheelchair. And then also see the children in wheelchairs rolling up to have their picture taken next to the president.

Of course, it is the Queen's choice. But it would be a much better choice for her to be willing to be seen in a wheelchair.

AllPowerfulLizardPerson · 21/03/2022 19:05

@eddiemairswife

Would a sedan chair solve the problem?
I think a small carriage drawn by Shetland ponies would be fitting
Boxowine · 21/03/2022 19:05

I do think in her case it has much to do with the constant speculation about her state of health, and by extension her expected longevity. Which I find to be disgusting and offensive.

Thoosa · 21/03/2022 19:05

Well if they do the thing that been reported of having a long covered tunnel or row of screens to smuggle her in through, that will excite more comment than matter of fact wheelchair use.

CapMarvel · 21/03/2022 19:05

Surely there needs to be a point that the state goes "actually, you are too old for this" and the whole role goes to Charles whether she likes it or not.