Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The Queen and a Wheelchair

213 replies

Nellielephant · 21/03/2022 17:50

AIBU to be annoyed that the newspapers are reporting that the Queen does not want to be seen in a Wheelchair? For those of us who have no choice I find this attitude upsetting as if it is something to be ashamed of.
Giylrs Brandreth has said it would be undignified for her to use one!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CounsellorTroi · 22/03/2022 10:07

I’m sure it’s hard for the Queen to come to terms with using mobility aids. This is a woman who never even leaned on her husband’s arm. However it’s ironic to hear her described as “fiercely independent”. She has been dependent on servants her whole life. There will be plenty of 95 year olds still more truly independent than she has ever been.

AllOfUsAreDead · 22/03/2022 09:54

@Hellocatshome

I'm sure if she wasn't Queen and wouldn't get splashed all over the media in her wheelchair with people speculating when she will die she would be more than happy to be seen in her wheelchair. Surely you can see how her circumstances are different to that of members of the public who use wheelchairs.
I think this is more the issue. When we the public use a wheelchair for whatever reason, we aren't put on the front pages of newspapers with essentially a giant clock ticking down to our death. The media will be almost, or will be, putting bets on when she dies from the moment they get that picture. Pretty horrific way to end your life.
SartresSoul · 22/03/2022 09:47

I suspect she just wants to be left alone in general at this point so the media should respect her wishes (fat chance, I know). She’s 96, husband died last year and she’s frail so probably feeling quite vulnerable. I don’t think she’s setting out to insult wheelchair users.

Belladonna12 · 22/03/2022 09:43

@shouldhestay

It is not the wheelchair that she will dislike but what it signifies for her.

I think there is a big difference between a younger person having a wheelchair and someone in their 90s getting to the stage of needing one.
It signifies something different.
For a younger person, the wheelchair is an aid to continue living a full life. This is not the same for someone in their 90s. At that age it becomes a symbol of their body declining.

I agree. I think that's often true for younger people with progressive conditions too.
CrotchetyQuaver · 22/03/2022 08:37

She's a very proud independent woman who doesn't feel ready to sit in a wheelchair in public yet. Fair enough. My parents were exactly the same. They are both gone now. I did get my DDad into one of those awful hospital wheelchairs about 3 weeks before he died. It took some persuasion but he was pleased he did afterwards. So was I - we were late for his blood test, and he walked so slowly! He liked it so much that the following week when we went back for a CT scan he actually asked to go in one. Then 2 weeks later he died. Scan has diagnosed stage 4 pancreatic cancer Sad

That proud attitude/mind over matter is what keeps them so good for so long, but of course the day will come where mind over matter is not enough to keep walking. Very sad.

shouldhestay · 22/03/2022 06:18

It is not the wheelchair that she will dislike but what it signifies for her.

I think there is a big difference between a younger person having a wheelchair and someone in their 90s getting to the stage of needing one.
It signifies something different.
For a younger person, the wheelchair is an aid to continue living a full life. This is not the same for someone in their 90s. At that age it becomes a symbol of their body declining.

colouringfoxes · 22/03/2022 00:04

Thanks Seneca and Thoosa ! I've had a lot of time to reflect on these things lately.
OP thank you so much for listening to the different opinions. Agree on Brandrith!

Nellielephant · 21/03/2022 23:37

Thank you all for all your different viewpoints. You have changed my mind about how I think about it all now with regards to the Queen.
Still think Gyles Brandreth is an idiot!

OP posts:
Thoosa · 21/03/2022 23:35

@colouringfoxes

I think something that isn't coming through on this thread is why people don't wish to be seen using a wheelchair. It's because of the ableist view that disabled people, or those that use an aid, are somehow less than. This view is unconscious in most people, rather than being something expressed out loud. But ultimately, people getting older or otherwise becoming physically disabled see using an aid as showing weakness, or as a loss of independence. Over the past year I have gone from needing no aids to using a rollator to using a powered folding wheelchair to leave the house. I too have avoided using my chair on occasion due to ableism, both from other people and internalised. I worry about the stares, the questions, people grabbing my chair to move me out of the way. And I also worry that people won't take me seriously, and have to deal with infantilisation on a regular basis. However, it is essential that we recognise the unconscious biases that go into this kind of mindset. That way, we can work on them, both individually and as a society. And maybe one day using a wheelchair or other mobility aid will be a natural part of life, and won't need to be seen as something shameful or a sign of weakness by those of us who need it, either through age or the onset of a physical disability. After all, people who are born with physical disabilities requiring aids are not less than, so there should be no logical reason why we feel we don't want to look like them.
Extremely well put.
SenecaFallsRedux · 21/03/2022 23:29

@colouringfoxes

I think something that isn't coming through on this thread is why people don't wish to be seen using a wheelchair. It's because of the ableist view that disabled people, or those that use an aid, are somehow less than. This view is unconscious in most people, rather than being something expressed out loud. But ultimately, people getting older or otherwise becoming physically disabled see using an aid as showing weakness, or as a loss of independence. Over the past year I have gone from needing no aids to using a rollator to using a powered folding wheelchair to leave the house. I too have avoided using my chair on occasion due to ableism, both from other people and internalised. I worry about the stares, the questions, people grabbing my chair to move me out of the way. And I also worry that people won't take me seriously, and have to deal with infantilisation on a regular basis. However, it is essential that we recognise the unconscious biases that go into this kind of mindset. That way, we can work on them, both individually and as a society. And maybe one day using a wheelchair or other mobility aid will be a natural part of life, and won't need to be seen as something shameful or a sign of weakness by those of us who need it, either through age or the onset of a physical disability. After all, people who are born with physical disabilities requiring aids are not less than, so there should be no logical reason why we feel we don't want to look like them.
Well said.
maeveiscurious · 21/03/2022 22:57

@Nellielephant

AIBU to be annoyed that the newspapers are reporting that the Queen does not want to be seen in a Wheelchair? For those of us who have no choice I find this attitude upsetting as if it is something to be ashamed of. Giylrs Brandreth has said it would be undignified for her to use one!
Isn't this the papers projecting. She has had a rough year and probably not well. I imagine she would like a quiet life.
colouringfoxes · 21/03/2022 22:36

I think something that isn't coming through on this thread is why people don't wish to be seen using a wheelchair. It's because of the ableist view that disabled people, or those that use an aid, are somehow less than. This view is unconscious in most people, rather than being something expressed out loud. But ultimately, people getting older or otherwise becoming physically disabled see using an aid as showing weakness, or as a loss of independence.
Over the past year I have gone from needing no aids to using a rollator to using a powered folding wheelchair to leave the house. I too have avoided using my chair on occasion due to ableism, both from other people and internalised. I worry about the stares, the questions, people grabbing my chair to move me out of the way. And I also worry that people won't take me seriously, and have to deal with infantilisation on a regular basis.
However, it is essential that we recognise the unconscious biases that go into this kind of mindset. That way, we can work on them, both individually and as a society. And maybe one day using a wheelchair or other mobility aid will be a natural part of life, and won't need to be seen as something shameful or a sign of weakness by those of us who need it, either through age or the onset of a physical disability. After all, people who are born with physical disabilities requiring aids are not less than, so there should be no logical reason why we feel we don't want to look like them.

Thoosa · 21/03/2022 22:34

Thankfully my new kitten has already learnt to avoid me.

Animals are more intelligent than humans.

Unforgettablefire · 21/03/2022 22:33

@Hellocatshome

I'm sure if she wasn't Queen and wouldn't get splashed all over the media in her wheelchair with people speculating when she will die she would be more than happy to be seen in her wheelchair. Surely you can see how her circumstances are different to that of members of the public who use wheelchairs.
My first thought.
colouringfoxes · 21/03/2022 22:29

@NeverDropYourMooncup

She wouldn't have the upper body strength to self propel, so she'd be pushed round by a minion all the time, trusting that they wouldn't tip her out onto the pavement.

And don't forget that so many places are still inaccessible to the disabled, particularly historic ones - can you imagine the fuss if she gets somewhere to find that the wheelchair ramp doesn't work and two burly bodyguards have to hoist her up and downstairs? Or being bumped over grass/catching the wheels in the shit uneven surfaces that seem to pass for pavements, courtyards and buildings that have half steps where none is necessary?

It could be argued that she would do more for accessibility if she did choose to be seen encountering those issues that every disabled has to endure as a daily reminder that they don't belong in society - but she isn't obliged to be the token/sacrificial lamb by being photographed as she's being caught by an official with her drawers on show.

I don't have the upper body strength to self-propel either as an ambulatory (part-time) wheelchair user. I use a powerchair, like many others. And if historic buildings are inaccessible to the Queen, they'll have to make it accessible! And maybe that way us normal people will have more of a chance
KittenKins · 21/03/2022 22:28

Thoosa,

That year of using a manual chair taught you muscles you didn't know existed, yeah? wink

My new one should intimidate people out of the way, but because my legs cannot bend they stick out in front of me, people just walk into them.

Not helped by the (accidentally) colour choice of 'pretty in pink', blah, just terrible, I look like a pink transformer! Seriously.

Thankfully my new kitten has already learnt to avoid me.

Creameggs223 · 21/03/2022 22:26

@Thefrenchconnection1

Yanbu, some people don't have a choice, should they hide?
Who said anything about them having to hide it, everyone has a choice just like I don't like wearing my glasses so don't when I go out that doesn't mean other people shouldn't wear theirs.
Myee · 21/03/2022 21:58

I agree with others that HM using mobility aids including a wheelchair would be a very positive signal to others of her age/generation that it's ok to use them in order to enhance your life. I know many are resistant, my own dear mother was one of them, but when the chips were down and she got fed up not being able to get around, she used one and ended up like the Formula 1 granny!

The easiest way out of all this would have been a family only service citing Covid or something, televised with HM already seated. It's a religious service so forget about looking at frocks and shoes, pray you heathens!

JenniferAlisonPhilipaSue · 21/03/2022 21:52

I suspect its an exaggeration. I don't think she cares much about using a wheelchair. Princess Margaret used one - and I don't think she cared about being seen in one as in the video she's waving. She's standing beside the QM and Prince Charles and they don't seem to mind.

QM used a golf buggy and alternated between that and her walking sticks. So I don't think the Queen cares. I think the issue is more deciding whether she needs to use one for the full duration of the service and journey, and when she could potentially use her stick instead.

lljkk · 21/03/2022 21:48

FDR example is not appropriate -- he went to huge lengths to hide his physical decline during his last few years. If anything, FDR example proves why QEII wants to avoid being seen as feeble.

BogRollBOGOF · 21/03/2022 21:31

It's not exactly novel for an elderly person (or indeed of any age) to resist mobility aids as a symbol of lost mobility/ health. MiL has largely rejected mobility aids to the point where the only place she really goes is to health appointments. No more garden centres or gossip at the village shops. Mobility aids could have helped her to maintain her routines and social contact, but she resisted and that window of independence has passed.

The advantage that youth tends to have is more capacity and time to adapt, choice or not.

Accepting and adapting to the need for mobility aids is hard anyway. The Queen will have additional concerns about publicity and protocol.

ittakes2 · 21/03/2022 21:28

I don't tend to believe everything written in the press.
But regardless - people are allowed to have opinions on how they like to be seen. My lovely 96 year old grandfather refused an electric scooter as he felt it would make him look too old. :)
It's her life and I think she should be allowed to live out this chapter of her life making choices that she feels suits her best.
You have to remember she is very frail - if she was in a chair she would have to reply on someone to push her. My best friend at uni was a quadriplegic but she was still able to push herself in a manual chair which she preferred to being pushed.

Shuuu · 21/03/2022 21:25

I can’t really comment as I don’t need a wheelchair so I can’t put myself in your position or even relate. Only thing I can say is, my friend would benefit sometimes from a wheelchair but won’t use one. She’d rather have falls every week than use one. Don’t forget the queen has been through a lot this past year or two, perhaps after all she’s lost she refuses to lose her independence too

MammaMacgill87 · 21/03/2022 21:23

Old independent lady doesn't want to use or be seen in a wheelchair
People in wheel chairs are now offended
She's 96 she doesn't want to use one, the media have made up their own narrative as to why. I could understand if she'd issued some damning statement slating people in wheelchairs but that hasn't happened. I think everyone maybe needs to just settle down and maybe have a cuppa 😂 I get mighty pissed off at the 75year old bloke that jogs past my house every day, because I'm jelous and frankly can't be arsed running anywhere, but I'm not going to attack him for his choice to jog it's none of my feckkin buisness 😂😂

AnguaResurgam · 21/03/2022 21:23

She might be perfectlymhappy to use it, but not for the first time in public to be the Duke of Edinburgh's memorial service.

She'll want the day to be about him.