Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get my neighbour to repair my car through her insurance?

57 replies

JillBob · 21/03/2022 17:40

Long story short, my elderly neighbour has managed to crash into the side of my parked car and taken off the wing mirror and scratched the driver side door and wing.

She came around to apologise with her son in tow and when I asked if it was going through insurance she said she would rather pay for the damage.

Before she came round I was adamant that it would go through her insurance but on hearing her explanation it sounds like her husband is currently in hospital and she was rushing there. Hence the crash…

I’ve wasted all today trying to get quotes with very little success other than one from a BMW dealership for at least £1500. I can’t drive the car anywhere as it has no wing mirror and if I’m honest I haven’t got the time to be running around trying to get my car fixed when trying to hold down a full time job and sorting kids.

I also need a car to get me to and from work which I obviously won’t have if it doesn’t go through the insurance.

AIBU to go round and tell her it needs to go through her insurance?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheyCallMeJune · 21/03/2022 21:28

Definitely go through your insurance!

JaceLancs · 21/03/2022 21:24

I made the mistake of trying to be kind to someone who hit my car in a car park in December and said they could pay private
Now nearly April and I’m going through insurance and taking them to small claims court for extra expenses and inconvenience they are now claiming I hit them!
Thankfully I have screenshots of all their messages originally apologising and admitting liability

skodadoda · 21/03/2022 21:22

[quote Badbadbunny]@skodadoda

Or, if she wants to pay for the damage herself, she can. She can’t be forced to claim on her insurance, but she must tell them about the incident.

It's not her choice, it's not her car. The OP can choose to claim via her insurers who WILL claim against the neighbour's insurance, whether neighbour likes it or not. Only if it were the neighbour's car would she have the choice to repair her own car herself or claim for her own car.[/quote]
👍 I think that’s what I was attempting to say in a muddled sort of way 🤔

BluebellsGreenbells · 21/03/2022 20:51

MargaretThursday

Then it makes more sense to use the insurance, saves the brig our all the hassle of dealing with several companies to look at quotes arrange payment arrange a hire car etc

That’s why you pay insurance companies, to do the leg work.

MargaretThursday · 21/03/2022 20:39

@BattledoreAndShuttlecock

The fact that she's elderly and she as visiting her husband in hospital has no bearing whatsoever on whether you should go through insurance. It should be much easier and less stress for her to go through insurance, and once she realises how much it's going to cost she should realise that.
However I can understand from OP's side that it feels mean to push it at this time. I was a witness to an accident where an elderly gentleman hit a car on the side, careered over the wrong side of a roundabout and stopped firmly against a sign. I stood in front of the car as he showed signs of driving off, and he shortly had an indignant group round him. He then told us that he'd had a call saying his wife had only a short time left to live and he was dashing to the hospital to see her one last time. Everyone's anger fell away, including the person whose car had been badly damaged, and when the police appeared, we were far more concerned with getting him (safely) to hospital than dealing with the accident.

I did phone the hospital once he'd gone and asked them to send a doctor round to check on him when he'd arrived.

However I did also do a witness statement for the person who was hit for their insurance where I was clear that it was his fault-as the gentleman in question had told me to say.

So I can totally understand Op's reluctance to go round and demand at the moment. However that doesn't let the other person off paying.

OP, why don't you pop a note through the door, saying that you hope her dh gets better soon, and say that you do need a car asap so would she mind going through insurance as it will be easier (and cheaper almost certainly) for both of you.

JillBob · 21/03/2022 20:09

I let my insurers know the day after the damage and let them know that initially my neighbour wants to settle outside her insurance. I did think that maybe she does think it will be a couple of hundred quid so mentioned that to my insurers too and their could be a potential claim on her insurance

OP posts:
TheWeeDonkeys · 21/03/2022 19:54

Ours was hit on boxing day, rang our insurance and because we weren't in it at the time we went through the 'not at fault' claim they have, they contact the other party & put us through to the dept that organises the repair. Ours was drivable just a bit battered so it took 2 months before it even went in & 2 weeks to fix.

BluebellsGreenbells · 21/03/2022 19:27

Don’t delay and contact your insurers. Let them get the hire car and pay for repairs. Otherwise you’ll be stuck.

She may have no claim bonus protection. She may not be insured. She may have lost her license. None of that is your concern.

WrongWayApricot · 21/03/2022 19:23

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

You drive a BMW and use the mirrors?
Grin
Chely · 21/03/2022 19:19

Let insurance handle it.
They may think they'll be happy footing the bill until they realise just how much it actually costs to have what looks like minor damage repaired and the hire car on top.

SeasonFinale · 21/03/2022 19:11

Also invariably once its in there is part they can't get hold off from Germany. I was 12 weeks without my car for a simple thing but fortunately the insurance paid for the courtesy car.

Ellie56 · 21/03/2022 19:02

When she finds out how much it will cost she'll go through the insurers.

Somebody reversed into me in a car park and was going to pay herself until we got the quote for the repair and then she changed her mind.

Jaxinthebox · 21/03/2022 18:56

Personally I would go via insurance - you need a hire car, and it is all dealt with without you faffing around.

It was an accident, but you shouldnt be inconvenience because of it.

Badbadbunny · 21/03/2022 18:56

@skodadoda

Or, if she wants to pay for the damage herself, she can. She can’t be forced to claim on her insurance, but she must tell them about the incident.

It's not her choice, it's not her car. The OP can choose to claim via her insurers who WILL claim against the neighbour's insurance, whether neighbour likes it or not. Only if it were the neighbour's car would she have the choice to repair her own car herself or claim for her own car.

whynotwhatknot · 21/03/2022 18:55

Yes insurance for that 1500 is going to shock her anyway i reckon plus excess and hire car

just say you cant possibly afford to lay out for one

Badbadbunny · 21/03/2022 18:54

She won't realise how much it's going to cost. She'll think it'll be a few hundred pounds. Body shops are crazily busy at the moment, so are charging full whack without any competitive quotes for quiet periods.

When a neighbour pranged ours in November, it looked just a few dents and scratches, but we got quotes varying from £1500 to £2750 but what was worse was 2-3 MONTH timescales for doing the repairs. We finally got it back at the end of January, so basically, just over 2 months without a car for something pretty simple.

If you can't manage without it, tell her not just the quote, but also that she'll have to finance a hire car - she won't pay all that, so just cut to the chase and get her insurance details. If she won't give you them and insists on paying, just claim on your own insurance and they'll use the database to contact her insurance to make the claim on your behalf.

chocolatesaltyballs22 · 21/03/2022 18:54

I work in insurance. Go through insurance 100%.

GetOffTheTableMabel · 21/03/2022 18:53

Someone drove into my parked car and drove away. I thought they had just taken off the wing mirror and scraped the drivers side but actually the wheel and axel were also damaged but I couldn’t tell without driving it. It cost thousands - and that was in 1990!
There may be damage you don’t know about yet.

Brideandprejudice · 21/03/2022 18:51

She no doubt thinks it's going to be about £200 worth of damage. Go through the insurance or you'll regret it.

skodadoda · 21/03/2022 18:51

I also need a car to get me to and from work which I obviously won’t have if it doesn’t go through the insurance

You will if it goes through your insurance. They make a claim against her. How she pays is up to her. There’s also the possibility that the repairs must be done by someone of whom your insurer approves.

eldora · 21/03/2022 18:49

The longer you delay calling your insurer, the more they will wonder why it took so long.

AngelinaFibres · 21/03/2022 18:47

Co tact your insurer. Explain what happened. Give them her name,address and car registration. They will take it from there.

skodadoda · 21/03/2022 18:42

@Dillydollydingdong

You ring your insurance company and tell them what's happened. Hopefully you've got comprehensive insurance and they'll arrange for repairs, apart from your excess which you pay yourself. Your insurance company will then claim from HERS.
Or, if she wants to pay for the damage herself, she can. She can’t be forced to claim on her insurance, but she must tell them about the incident.
eldora · 21/03/2022 18:32

@sayanythingelse

Insurance definitely. She probably thinks it will be a couple of hundred quid repair and forgotten about.

If it makes you feel any better, our elderly across the road neighbour managed to crash their car off the drive, over the road, into another car, through our front garden and straight into our living room. It was an impressive display of bad driving.

Shock

Were they sorry? In shock?

eldora · 21/03/2022 18:31

Insurance may be better for her as well, she may have good NCB and therefore may cost her less overall.

Plus hopefully they will alert the DVLA to her dangerous driving.