Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is poor from DS’ college?

81 replies

kzaurm · 21/03/2022 14:50

DS has ADHD and ASD and mental health issues (anxiety and depression), he self harms and we are trying to get help for him. He has a 1:1 at his college as he was struggling a lot without it, the college also knows about his mental health but we all agreed for him to go in as his anxiety would be made worse by not attending as he wouldn't go out (this has happened previously when he was off school a few years ago due to anxiety) and also because DP works and I work a few days a week so there wouldn't be anyone to keep an eye on him.

DP called me and told me that he had a call from the college and asked him to pick him up, he was told that DS’s 1:1 teacher wasn't in and he had broken a ruler and when he was asked what he was going to do with it he replied that he didn't know. They sent him home as he was a danger to himself and they couldn't keep him safe.

Aibu to think this is poor? I know that the college has other students but we can't afford to miss work to keep an eye on DS everyday which is why him attending college is important

OP posts:
whyayepetal · 21/03/2022 18:16

OP, perhaps finding out (from both college and your DC) what led up to the ruler being broken in this instance might help you to put together a clearer picture of events.

Until you know this, you and the college won’t be able to help DSbuild the coping strategies to help him deal with this sort of situation another time.

This is about all of you (including DS) working together to make sure DS has the support he needs. I guess if he is at college then he is 16+, so being very involved in managing this rather than being managed will help to bridge the school to adulthood gap.

Imitatingdory · 21/03/2022 18:11

He was not illegally excluded.

You do not know that, the OP hasn’t clarified. Even if there was a lawful reason for an exclusion unless the college followed the formal process it would be illegal.

Closing whole year groups isn’t the same situation.

JustOneMoreStep · 21/03/2022 18:08

He was not illegally excluded. What a ludicrous thing to suggest. Educational establishments (like all workplaces) have a legal obligation to ensure that all patrons and employees are safe. The college, through there assessment of risk decided that they were not able to ensure your son was safe and so sent him home. Schools are regularly closing whole year groups as they are unable to staff them (and therefore cannot guarantee student safety) due to covid. Do you think whole year groups are being illegally excluded (or suspension which is different to an exclusion)

Imitatingdory · 21/03/2022 17:56

Hercisback Now you are adding to your scenario, your original post did not say in the middle of the day.

Dear the college should have followed the law and their own exclusion policy, even if that meant formally excluding, which would have provided the OP with evidence of unmet needs.

DearMallorie · 21/03/2022 17:52

If the school genuinely can’t rearrange staff, nor get anyone to cover the LA should provide alternative arrangements for educating said child. Which does happen via medical needs tuition.

Right. But how should they do that? ^
^
In the moment, on the day. Without resorting to travelling back through time and the OP doing some paperwork what should they have done on the day?

Hercisback · 21/03/2022 17:51

No one at the LA is going to be available in the middle of the day to come out and educate. Don't be ridiculous.

Imitatingdory · 21/03/2022 17:49

You come across as rude, unsympathetic and with no idea quite how hard some people are working in schools right now.

There is no need for this. I have not been rude to you, nor have I been unsympathetic and I have said on this thread when you accused me previously of this I understand those difficult things are at the moment.

That is a different scenario. If the school genuinely can’t rearrange staff, nor get anyone to cover the LA should provide alternative arrangements for educating said child. Which does happen via medical needs tuition.

Hercisback · 21/03/2022 17:43

Right so we have a student who needs a 1:1 for medical reasons. We cannot currently get anyone to cover. What should we as a school do?
Exclusion isn't the right thing in that scenario.
However it isn't safe for the child to be in school and the parents want them at home if no one trained is in school. Parents don't want an exclusion on record.

I'm going to bow out. You are correct on the points of law. You come across as rude, unsympathetic and with no idea quite how hard some people are working in schools right now.

50DaysAF · 21/03/2022 17:38

I think the college did the right thing.
Worst case scenario he hurt himself there without the agreed supervision. They felt they couldn’t keep him safe. Not sure what else they should have done.

Imitatingdory · 21/03/2022 17:37

Hercisback no it doesn’t. Funding does not explain a school illegally excluding rather than following formal exclusion protocol. A lack of funding would not be an excuse if the parent pursued provision specified and quantified in F not being provided.

It is a sad fact pupils whose parents know the law, can advocate for them and enforce their rights where necessary get better support. It shouldn’t be like that, support should be purely based on the needs of the child, but it is. Arguably it is the children of parents who can’t do this who need the support the most. Parents need to know the law and the system. I make no apologies for posting factual posts about the law to counteract posters excusing unlawful behaviour be LAs and schools, that is not confrontational, it is fact. That’s nothing against school staff themselves, and is not ”sticking the knife in”. I have/had a very good relationship with the schools my DC are/have been in. Neither have I claimed my DC’s needs aren’t being met, they are, they have excellent EHCPs. Your post come across as though you have a personal vendetta.

Onceuponarainbow I never said OP’s DS did have an EHCP, in my first post I asked whether he did or not, and when OP said he didn’t I said she should apply. Although not having one doesn’t mean the college don’t have to follow the law and their exclusion policy or that they shouldn’t have applied for an EHCNA long before now. None of us know if OP’s DS was excluded lawfully or illegally as OP hasn’t clarified whether the exclusion was formal or not. Even if they have a lawful reason to exclude unless they follow the formal, lawful process it is unlawful.

Prinnny · 21/03/2022 17:21

Sorry but no OP YABU. If it’s further education not childcare he doesn’t have to be there and they don’t have to keep him there for you to work. They did the right thing, safeguarded the other students from someone snapping a ruler and potentially making a weapon.

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 21/03/2022 17:21

@Imitatingdory

But OPs son doesn’t have an EHCP. They could easily say they can’t meet his needs if he’s deemed to be unsafe at school; but they seem to be trying hard to help him. I can’t name one kid in my huge school with a 1-1 without an EHCP.

He wasnt suspended illegally today.

Hercisback · 21/03/2022 17:17

A lack of funding does not explain, nor excuse, LAs and schools acting unlawfully.
It literally does. Schools can't meet EHCP requirements if they can't afford to. We have TAs off and cannot fill their positions. Not even funding can help when there are no actual people available.

Being a parent of a child with SEN is difficult and I know you have to fight for everything. Perhaps you aren't confrontational in real life but on here you are coming across that way. I have encountered you many times 'helpfully' posting legal information. Believe me, teachers already feel shit enough about being unable to meet your child's needs without you sticking the knife in.

betwixtlives · 21/03/2022 17:14

What do you think the solution from college should have been OP?

Imitatingdory · 21/03/2022 17:03

Hercisback None of that actually helps today though.

Yes, it does. If OP knew her DS’s rights, advocated for him and forced the college to follow the law and their own exclusion policy she may find they either changed their mind or formally exclude, which would provide her with evidence for when she applies for an EHCNA. I am not saying DC with additional needs should never be excluded, I am saying if schools or colleges are going to exclude they should follow due process and do it correctly. Illegal exclusion don’t help anyone.



You bat everything back to the LA, who, again, can ultimately do very little because they have no funding either.

Yet LAs have the money to spend £££ on defending indefensible cases against unrepresented parents. If only the public knew how much was wasted on this unnecessary expense. A lack of funding does not explain, nor excuse, LAs and schools acting unlawfully.



But a lot of your posts come across as unnecessarily confrontational. They also leave hardworking staff that are trying their best feeling like shit (again).

If you knew me in real life you wouldn’t consider me confrontational, it’s not something I have ever been called in real life even by the LA when dealing with 2 EHCPs. Wanting LAs and school to follow the law is not confrontational. Stating regulations is not confrontational, it’s factual. A lot of posts by posters who excuse LAs and schools acting unlawfully leave parents already at the end of their tether feeling shit, too, they also give the impression there’s no help for them, which, even if it isn’t easy, isn’t the case. Also, perhaps you should consider that parents of DC with ASD are also statistically more likely to have ASD themselves which can sometimes be perceived by others as being blunt, that doesn’t mean they are being confrontational.

DearMallorie · 21/03/2022 17:01

@BoredZelda

What do you expect schools to do when they don't physically have the staff to keep OP's son safe?

Why is OP’s son’s education less important than that of the non disabled students?

That didn't answer the question.

EatToTheBeet · 21/03/2022 17:00

If the main college tutor goes off, they find a replacement.

My dd is doing three A levels so three teachers. This week she only has lessons for one as they other two teachers are off and they can't get any supply.

gogohm · 21/03/2022 16:47

Op I really do understand, I lost 2 jobs due having to fetch dd, similar diagnosis. The only reason I kept my last one was because it was 5 mins from her college and they didn't mind me having her with me (and she could play the piano downstairs which calmed her down (unusual in a job). Ultimately job isn't care so they can only do so much, do get the papers and reports etc in order because once they turn 18 it's hard if they haven't got paperwork.

My dd is a bit older having worked and studied locally, now is away at university and so far coping, she wasn't ready until mid 20's though

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 21/03/2022 16:45

@BoredZelda

It’s not, but if a kid says they may harm themselves or others they can’t be at school/college.
OP needs to get an EHCP for her son, I’m surprised they are even giving a 1-1 without one, where’s that finding coming from?

Hercisback · 21/03/2022 16:41

If the main college tutor goes off, they find a replacement.

Not always they don't.

Getting supply staff is very tricky right now.

BoredZelda · 21/03/2022 16:41

What do you expect schools to do when they don't physically have the staff to keep OP's son safe?

Why is OP’s son’s education less important than that of the non disabled students?

WomblingWilma · 21/03/2022 16:40

Not sure an EHCP would make any difference although you really should have applied for one a long time ago OP, when he was at home for years before? Were you never advised to? They go up to age 25.

My DS’s has a similar diagnosis to with a learning disability as well (and had a 1:1) and his mainstream college did exactly the same thing despite him having an EHCP. He used to scratch his hands (superficial) and if he so much as looked at a stapler or pencil sharpener, I’d be called to pick him up. They then said they couldn’t meet his needs and he has been without a placement since last June and at home all that time. The LA know they’re breaking the law but don’t care.

Nowhere else will take him now due to the self harming being on his record!

Your DS’s 1:1 is not a legal requirement without an EHCP so there’s not much you can do about it I don’t think.

BoredZelda · 21/03/2022 16:39

If he doesn't have an EHCP in place, the college have already gone above and beyond to provide him a 1-1.

No they haven’t, they made provision for a disabled person.

BoredZelda · 21/03/2022 16:38

It's a college, not a 1:1 child care service.
How many students do you expect to miss out on being educated in order that your son has 1:1 care? HIs 1:1 tutor was not there - it's not as if they chose to divert 1:1 tutors time to work on something else.

If the main college tutor goes off, they find a replacement. As they should with a 1:1. They have a legal obligation to provide the service to disabled people. Or do you agree disabled people should just be treated like second class citizens?

Hercisback · 21/03/2022 16:35

Oh I don’t know, follow the law and their exclusion policy and have applied for an EHCNA well before now.

None of that actually helps today though.

You bat everything back to the LA, who, again, can ultimately do very little because they have no funding either.

I understand the point you are trying to make on a wider level and appreciate that by kicking back, the hope is eventually something will be done. But a lot of your posts come across as unnecessarily confrontational. They also leave hardworking staff that are trying their best feeling like shit (again).