Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Female friendship - am I too jealous?

139 replies

amioverreacting6838 · 21/03/2022 13:52

In a new relationship with a guy, coming up 6 months. He has a close female friend and something about it makes me uncomfortable.

I was hoping to make plans with him at the weekend but he's already got plans with her. I asked what he was up to and he said she was coming round his, then they were going for a walk along the river and out for brunch and shopping.

Am I being really insecure to find this a bit much? I have plenty of man friends who I would go out to casual lunch with but I'd never have them around my place one on one and go out to brunch at some fancy hotel.

Apparently she has a partner, not that I'm sure if it makes a difference, but he does have a very high sex drive and something about her coming around his flat doesn't sit right with me.

Am I being massively jealous and overreacting or am I justified in feeling this way? AIBU?

OP posts:
Mummytobe93 · 21/03/2022 16:32

It’s not really a night out/dinner though, they’re planning on spending the whole day together …

Myoldtable · 21/03/2022 16:24

I think it’s interesting that you know that he finds lots of women attractive. Why did he feel the need to tell you that?

Meltedwellie · 21/03/2022 16:24

YABU there's nothing wrong with him seeing a friend like this. Work on your own self esteem and don't bring past people's behaviour into a good current relationship.

gannett · 21/03/2022 16:12

@Samarie123

I’d arrange a day out with a male since you have them. See how he reacts. Seems a bit weird if you ask me, lunch and a walk by the river? Different if it was watching a game of footie in the pub and both supported the same team, that would be more understandable…
What is weird about lunch and a walk? Genuinely can't imagine.

If either DP or I wanted to watch a game of football now that would be weird given that neither of us can stand it.

WeDontShutUpAboutBruno · 21/03/2022 16:06

[quote dumdumduuuummmmm]**@WeDontShutUpAboutBruno* You would drop pre existing plans with a friend if your partner of 6 months decided they wanted to do something at that particular time?*

No, I wouldn't make plans for the weekend without checking in with my partner first. After 6 months I would assume my partner and I would be seeing each other in the weekend. But hey, that's just me. On MN, it seems that 6 months is barely a relationship.[/quote]
So your friend says "fancy some lunch on saturday" and you say "I'm not sure I'll have to ask the person I've been dating for 6 months to see if they come up with a better offer, if not then I'll have lunch with you" Confused

They aren't living together, they have been dating for a short period of time, why should he check with op every single offer of a lunch/dinner/night out before he accepts.

What a really weird attitude.

Echobelly · 21/03/2022 16:06

Have you met her? I think that without seeing them interact, it might be hard to say whether you have anything to be worried about. If he seems to be deliberately keeping you apart, obviously that's suss, but I think one would get a picture seeing them together.

1forAll74 · 21/03/2022 16:06

I wouldn't mind this situation with a man friend, going out for six months with someone, doesn't mean you are stuck together permanently, and each of you can socialise with others outside of your relationship if you wish.

user375242 · 21/03/2022 16:06

I have an opposite sex best friend, and generally choose to invite them round when DH is not home, and they often sleep over too, which might sound dodgy, but it is actually because I prioritize time with DH, and I need time to socialise without him sometimes. When I first met DH, I introduced them quickly, and made sure we all spent time together often, particularly at first. I wouldn't have ditched DH for a full 'date like' day when we were only 6 months dating.

Consequently my friendship did suffer for a few years, and I almost lost contact with my friend, so finding the balance is tricky. It's not right to ditch a close friend for a new relationship, but I do think special considerations need to be made when friends are opposite sex. He should go for a walk/brunch/couple of drinks with friend but then go and see you, or see you for the day and then spend the evening with the friend. Or invite you along for at least half of the plans!

Of course I really do believe friendships like this can be platonic, but honestly we all know it's probably more common in close opposite sex friendships that one of the two is hoping for something more. A lot of my friendships have been with the opposite sex, and I have swore blind each time they were platonic, and all but one has eventually wanted more (ruining the friendship).

dumdumduuuummmmm · 21/03/2022 16:02

@WeDontShutUpAboutBruno You would drop pre existing plans with a friend if your partner of 6 months decided they wanted to do something at that particular time?

No, I wouldn't make plans for the weekend without checking in with my partner first. After 6 months I would assume my partner and I would be seeing each other in the weekend. But hey, that's just me. On MN, it seems that 6 months is barely a relationship.

Ionlydomassiveones · 21/03/2022 16:01

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

sayanythingelse · 21/03/2022 15:59

Women like many on this thread are the reason I've lost a lot of my long term friends.
I've always got on better with men and a few have dropped out my life because girlfriends didn't like them having a close female friend. I've been deleted off all my old housemates socials by his wife and had my number blocked from a long term friends phone for no reason other than having a vagina. Despite the fact I've been happily married for 8 years.

My DH has a female best friend. He's known her since primary school and I've never even considered that I should worry about their friendship.

Verv · 21/03/2022 15:59

I wouldn't and dont have a problem with partner seeing friends.
If their plans were fixed before yours then why wouldn't he be able to spend a day with his friend?

Sorry, but its usually friends that are there for you when relationships fall by the wayside so I think its fine to prioritise them some of the time.

5128gap · 21/03/2022 15:58

@ThatsNotItAtAll

It would bother me. If it wouldn't bother other people that's their look out, but friends who had relationships in which they tried to be cool about their boyfriends having uncomfortably close female friends always ended up having their comfort zones pushed and pushed and being gaslit into being cool with more and more uncomfortable situations... Its not a type of relationship I've ever been remotely interested in, and there are plenty of men out there who will have similar boundaries to you.

You're only 6 months in. If you're uncomfortable cut your losses. It doesn't matter whether it's "reasonable".

Completely agree. All these accusations of insecurity and jealousy, that have women believing they're unreasonable if they should question anything a man chooses to do, are an absolute gift to men looking to take advantage.
Samarie123 · 21/03/2022 15:56

I’d arrange a day out with a male since you have them. See how he reacts.
Seems a bit weird if you ask me, lunch and a walk by the river? Different if it was watching a game of footie in the pub and both supported the same team, that would be more understandable…

Charette · 21/03/2022 15:54

@amioverreacting6838

I'm not telling him to do something with me instead, and I haven't told him to stop. So no need for the comments here telling him to dump me thanks, they're irrelevant.

I was just coming here to ask if their day out and the fact she's coming over to his house would bother anyone else. It feels like more of a date to me. I don't need a lecture that men and women can be friends as I have plenty of my own, but wouldn't really plan that type of day out with them. Can't imagine their girlfriends and wives would be best pleased if I did.

I do this all the time with a good male friend. I actually drove to the beach with him and had dinner there afterwards on a Saturday because DS was at a sleepover. DH has spent the weekend in another city visiting a female friend. Our sex drives are irrelevant to this.
Herewegoagain84 · 21/03/2022 15:51

Have you met her? Is he happy for you two to spend time together at all? That’s how I would gauge their relationship. If he’s interested in you, he’d want you to know his friends. If he wants to keep you apart from her, I’d be more suspicious.

black2black · 21/03/2022 15:47

@SoloSunrise

Honestly, it wouldn't be for me. Judging by this thread it would be fine with a lot of women, but I would probably end a fairly new relationship over something like this.
Same here. I would never feel comfortable with this.
SoloSunrise · 21/03/2022 15:47

@5128gap

It may be platonic or it may be an affair hiding in plain sight. No way of knowing. And imo life is too short, and there's too many other men out there who don't have these situations to waste my time on one that would have me wondering.
Yes this is what I was thinking. I think in the long run it might end up being an emotional affair, if nothing else.
AngelinaFibres · 21/03/2022 15:47

@amioverreacting6838

I'm not telling him to do something with me instead, and I haven't told him to stop. So no need for the comments here telling him to dump me thanks, they're irrelevant.

I was just coming here to ask if their day out and the fact she's coming over to his house would bother anyone else. It feels like more of a date to me. I don't need a lecture that men and women can be friends as I have plenty of my own, but wouldn't really plan that type of day out with them. Can't imagine their girlfriends and wives would be best pleased if I did.

If I was in a new relationship I would imagine that, after working all week, I would be very keen to see that person, and to do the things with him that he is doing with this other woman. I would expect the person I had been seeing for 6 months to be very excited to see me too. I would certainly find it odd if he wanted to spend hours on end with someone else.
5128gap · 21/03/2022 15:45

It may be platonic or it may be an affair hiding in plain sight. No way of knowing. And imo life is too short, and there's too many other men out there who don't have these situations to waste my time on one that would have me wondering.

Mummytobe93 · 21/03/2022 15:43

@gannett I didn’t vanish from my social circle - we simply attended events/ nights out together 😁 (unless it was a ladies only event).

Lwren · 21/03/2022 15:37

I'd personally be fine with DP doing this with a friend, he'd feel the same.
We've both had partners of friends be hostile or downright vile towards us and try poking holes in our relationship because we're happy to have friends who are opposite sex to us. That's their insecurity, not ours.
I wouldn't sweat this OP, if it was anything to be worried about it would be a shady excuse, he's being honest.
And having plans with friends isn't not prioritising you as been said, he's just made other plans.
Don't put yourself down either, be as nice to yourself as you would about your friend.

Pinkbonbon · 21/03/2022 15:35

I would expect to meet her tbh, I message him 'I think its time I meet this friend of yours seen as you guys are this close. Ask her of she wants to do dinner with us some night next week'

Tbh it doesn't bode well that he hasn't suggested it though. Also, if my best male mate had a gf I would think it respectful to meet her as soon as possible so she could see me n him were just mates.

gannett · 21/03/2022 15:32

Surely it's weirder to ask to meet her to suss them out together though! I agree having never seen them together it's just in my mind.. but I don't want to go all bunny boiler over it.

I'd want to meet my DP's friends but not to suss them out. I just like to meet new people and if he likes them there's a chance that I'll like them and might even become friends with them myself.

Overall I'm definitely on the side of "a walk and brunch is a perfectly normal thing to do with any friend, male or female, either one on one or in a group". But in terms of helping your insecurity when it comes to all these beautiful women he's friends with - well, if he wanted to be with them then he would be already. He's chosen to be with you.

I was once talking to a male friend about a mutual female friend of ours, asked him why they never got together because they're pretty similar and she's gorgeous. He said, of course she's beautiful, anyone with eyes can see that, and she's great company, but if we lived with each other it just wouldn't work because we want completely different things out of a relationship.

In most platonic friendships, both parties know they'd be incompatible as relationships.

gannett · 21/03/2022 15:25

@Mummytobe93

I don’t think it’s a about trust as such but about the idea of spending free time with a friend when you’ve got a girlfriend of few months.

I know some people are cool with this but I wouldn’t like to be turned down by my boyfriend cause he prefers to hang out with a friend (male or female).

I’m not possessive but early on in a relationship we spent any free time we had together.

I was the opposite. When I first got together with DP, I made sure I didn't let my existing friendships fall by the wayside. I didn't want to be one of those people who vanish from the social circle when they get loved up. I didn't want to deprioritise my friends, who I'd known for years, over a new man I'd known for a few months.

DP was much the same and 10 years down the line it's paid off because we still have excellent friends.

Swipe left for the next trending thread