Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have refused to take DD to A & E

269 replies

Polarbearstar · 21/03/2022 12:16

‘Refused’ sounds more aggressive than it actually was, but DD has not really been quite right for a while now with a perforated ear drum, high temperatures, cold, streaming nose.

Doctor keeps saying to take to A and E and I am unclear what A and E can do that they can’t?

OP posts:
BananaPlants · 21/03/2022 13:17

@Polarbearstar - I am wondering how recently some of those posters have actually attended A & E, with the talk of accessing tests and correct departments and referrals…

WhyIsEverythingSoHard · 21/03/2022 13:16

Therefore, if you went to A&E, DD would be seen by the relevant department and after testing and proper diagnosis may be referred quicker to ENT than if the GP referred them.

Except the OP is very clear that she has done that before and it didnt work.
And tbh, where I live, I havent seen A&E ever referring patienst to department (unless the specilist is needed there and then or they patient is kept in hopsital). We are told to go back to see a GP to be referred to the specialsist. A very similar experience than the OP's.

AlandAnna · 21/03/2022 13:15

Seems odd to go to A&E I agree.
Your GP should refer to paediatrics if s/he is concerned.

Polarbearstar · 21/03/2022 13:14

Thanks @fixyourfences am on hold now.

OP posts:
Polarbearstar · 21/03/2022 13:13

No definitely none of the meningitis symptoms.

OP posts:
StaplesCorner · 21/03/2022 13:13

OP I completely understand what you are saying and clearly some posters are either genuinely misunderstanding or being deliberately obtuse for the sake of a row. I've seen so many threads go like this across all topics recently. @WinterIsHere96 has said what I would - insist on an ENT referral.

My DD is a lot older than yours (20!) but she was told to go to A&E by our GP after a 30 second tele-consult and at A&E and she was humiliated by the on call doctor shouting at her saying how dare she take up NHS time by coming into A&E instead of seeing the GP (course she was also young and shy and on her own so great candidate for being shouted at but that's another thread entirely).

Its very hard to see where GPs are coming from and understand what is happening, particularly as its not all GPs. My family have two different GP surgeries between us and we are having polar opposite experiences. One blames everything on COVID and nothing can be done etc., the other is operating fairly normally. I don't know what the answer is but you are right to ask the WTAF question.

Polarbearstar · 21/03/2022 13:13

It would be madness and poor parenting if that happened, yes. But it didn’t.

So people clearly think that you go to A and E and you are seen, if not promptly, within a reasonable time frame, you are referred to the appropriate person and your condition is treated. I have been to A and E with DD before and none of those things have happened. I’m not claiming they never do, but they haven’t.

What is poor parenting is taking her somewhere they won’t treat her, I think.

OP posts:
fixyourfences · 21/03/2022 13:13

I think in your position OP, I would book a private online consultation with a mainstream private GP service e.g. Lloyds or Superdrug. Think they are £20-30? They can prescribe antibiotics. If I was sure my DC was not floppy or didn't have a rash or sensitivity to light - those would be straight-to-ED in my own transport situations.

BananaPlants · 21/03/2022 13:13

Is anyone actually reading the OP?

She isn’t being told to take child to A and E now. She has been told that if her child is unwell with an ear infection, in future, and has a temperature or pain, then to take her to A and E.

This clearly doesn’t make sense and isn’t what A and E is for. My local hospital has 20 ambulances waiting outside at times, with patients waiting to be seen. They are not there for ear infections or to “ arrange hearing tests” and OP is perfectly reasonable to question this “advice”.

OP, can you ask to change to a different GP at your surgery?

Electriq · 21/03/2022 13:13

If this is a long term issue you have had with your child and the gp is unable to treat it, constant antibiotics will not do your little child much good.

However attending a&e (which isn't just for broken bones fyi!!) could get your daughter the correct treatment by being transferred to or referred to the correct person, not to mention they have the facilities and specialists to carry out far more tests than your gp can do, your child is also so young, she needs to be seen by a paediatric doctor.

I do not like the attitude with regards to sitting in a hospital for hours, this is what we have to do for our children, its not meant to be enjoyable, its to get treatment for your poorly child, you child could face permanent damage if this is not treated!

But posting on mumsnet was more important than seeking the medical attention your child needs!

ChloeHel · 21/03/2022 13:12

[quote Polarbearstar]@ChloeHel that would make sense but no. She isn’t being referred to an ENT or paediatrics.

Also, while the infection seems to have lasted a lifetime, it’s actually only been a couple of weeks. We had an initial telephone appointment and then a face to face,however the condition worsened and high temp last night. So took to the GP today.[/quote]
As a PP mentioned ENT referrals are long winded and there is a waiting list. Sadly our NHS is overwhelmed.

Therefore, if you went to A&E, DD would be seen by the relevant department and after testing and proper diagnosis may be referred quicker to ENT than if the GP referred them. There is only so much a GP can do, especially in child illnesses. As I said, it’s pointless them constantly prescribing x,y,z - so I do understand the GP’s advice. It just maybe didn’t come across as clear and could have been worded differently.

Polarbearstar · 21/03/2022 13:11

@Calmdown14 no, it isn’t. It’s completely the opposite, it is one ear infection.

OP posts:
MrPickles73 · 21/03/2022 13:11

Polarbearstar I'm with you, GP service is currently shocking..

yomommasmomma · 21/03/2022 13:11

So to confirm a doctor has advised that if your 16 month old's symptoms continue they need to be taken to A and E, the symptoms have continued and because it is inconvenient for you, you are not taking the child......madness and poor parenting

Louisethemum · 21/03/2022 13:10

Hi OP. I've read through and agree that the original post perhaps didn't convey the issue very well. When a post has lots of replies, people don't always read through them all, which is perhaps why you've had so many replies with concerns for your child.

I agree that at the moment, it's hard to know which way to turn. The hospitals are too busy, they release Facebook videos with consultants begging you to use first line services first, like your GP. Then the post directly under that, is the video of your local GP begging you to see the pharmacist or use 111 as they are struggling under the pressure. So you go along to your pharmacist or possibly 111, who both immediately tell you to see your GP. But your GP hasn't got time, and the vicious cycle continues.
This isn't a criticism of any of the services I've mentioned, but there is a sort of helplessness at the moment when in a crisis.
Personally, I think it's clear to most parents when a child needs to go to A&E. and if it's not, I think the NHS website is very helpful and clear. However, at the moment, I agree, it's hard to know.
I'm not sure what your GP was meaning OP, but I would continue to seek medical care in the places you normally would x

toomanydogsandcats · 21/03/2022 13:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

fixyourfences · 21/03/2022 13:07

People are dying of heart attacks at totally scandalous rates because Emergency Departments are busy with people who should be getting seen by a GP (ambulances waiting to unload people into the ED can't do so, so ambulance has to wait for hours outside ED, meanwhile people are dying at home because no ambulances are available to go and retrieve/collect them).

Having been in your position OP many years ago, the GP saw the child, did examination, prescribed antibiotics within 1 hour space of time. GP has also previously referred said child to ENT multiple times. Never did the child go to the Emergency Department.

Calmdown14 · 21/03/2022 13:07

If it's not one episode that is escalating and is more of an issue with recurrent ear infections then a and e doesn't seem the place.

How many ear infections has she had?

My son suffered. Has her hearing been tested? And ENT referral would seem to be sensible if this issue keeps coming back

Polarbearstar · 21/03/2022 13:07

Absolutely @LBFseBrom but the problem is that they don’t - they advise Calpol and tell you to see your GP. At which point I realise why the furniture is all screwed down!

OP posts:
ravenmum · 21/03/2022 13:07

Sounds like a severe case of crossed wires.

CSIblonde · 21/03/2022 13:07

The GP is saying that because if you go to A&E again with a v young child who is persistently unwell & isn't responding to their treatment ( and you convey that history to them ) then they can do blood tests to see if it's something else causing or underlying those symptoms & you can get her seen by a specialist paediatric Consultant asap. This is way quicker than the GP doing a written referral to get her seen by a specialist. That could take months & months if the GP went the 'formal' referal route . You need to be very clear she's not getting better & you want a paediatric specialist to see her. The GP is obviously trying to help you get a quicker route to a Specialist. Please, please take your child, the GP won't refer you to A&E for no good reason!

WinterIsHere96 · 21/03/2022 13:07

My DP works as an A&E locum doctor. He's seeing lots of patients (adults and children) with minor ailments and illnesses who are saying they were told to attend A&E for what in his opinion are GP matters and not much he can do in an A&E department. He's having to refer on to ENT or wherever but mostly just tells them they need to see their GP. So I can completely believe OP was told to go to A&E for recurring ear infections.
I'm still moaning to any and all that my GP is still insisting on phone appointments and not seeing me in person. I've on going autoimmune problems, and need regular checkups and changes to my meds.
If antibiotics aren't work I'd be calling the GP and insisting on ENT referral.

Polarbearstar · 21/03/2022 13:07

@SleepWhenAmDead - thank you. That does make sense. It hasn’t been a repeated case but it doesn’t seem to have cleared up at all, which is the worry. I definitely agree urgent medical attention is sometimes appropriate but the problem is when you end up on the carousel of the GP telling you to go to A and E and A and E telling you to go to the GP it’s very frustrating and you get nowhere.

@ColgateGirl I did ask for clarification and she did say to go to A and E whenever she is unwell. I agree it sounds bizarre which is why I posted on here - I am lost myself - but you can’t keep saying ‘is this what you mean’ and being told ‘yes.’

@HistoricGreenBox yes, you have misunderstood I think. Of course it’s nonsensical to keep trying treatment that doesn’t work. However, I would expect the GP to be making appropriate referrals to ENT or to the paediatric unit. Waiting for her to be unwell then going to A and E is surely not the right way of going about it.

At any rate I am calling BUPA now so hopefully we can get something sorted.

OP posts:
LBFseBrom · 21/03/2022 13:06

A&E can do all the baseline tests that your GP cannot do; your daughter will see a specialist and treatment will be expedited. As GP advised it, do please take her to A&E. Ears are important and not just for hearing.

implantreplace · 21/03/2022 13:06

@Polarbearstar

That’s certainly not what was said, *@ravenmum*. And I did ask for clarification. We do not go to A and E if the infection worsens, we go to A and E when she is ill.

No one is saying that going to A and E is a waste of time, it is best to be sure, but I do think some common sense and some judgement can be used as well. Going straight to A and E for absolutely everything is neither sensible or conducive, surely?

She obviously didn’t mean that OP I think you need to apply a “some common sense”