Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have refused to take DD to A & E

269 replies

Polarbearstar · 21/03/2022 12:16

‘Refused’ sounds more aggressive than it actually was, but DD has not really been quite right for a while now with a perforated ear drum, high temperatures, cold, streaming nose.

Doctor keeps saying to take to A and E and I am unclear what A and E can do that they can’t?

OP posts:
Whywonttheyhelpme · 21/03/2022 13:54

FFS. YANBU @Polarbearstar

If either I or my child had a reoccurring infection I would expect the GP to prescribe antibiotics. If this didn’t work I would expect them to swab and find out why it wasn’t healing. If they still couldn’t figure out the issue I would expect a referral to a specialist, not to be fobbed off to A&E.

Accident and emergency is for that alone. Your DC has had a diagnosis but isn’t responding to treatment. She needs a referral to ENT.

theveryhungrycatapillar · 21/03/2022 13:53

A lot of people aren't reading this thread correctly.

The doctor didn't say go to a&e right away shes said next time take her straight to A&E.

I see your point OP and my gp has also advised me to take DC to a&e for things such as viral cold, water infection etc and it really feels like they are trying to palm you off when you know a&e just means a long wait to receive the same treatment as gp would prescribe.

Obviously If your child is very poorly and your worried you would take her to a&e but in this case how can doctor recommend it for the future without seeing your child

MrsMingech · 21/03/2022 13:51

So anyway.... you'll call the GP again and get the swab...?

Calennig · 21/03/2022 13:51

I'd probably try 111 or out of hours services if they exist in your area before A&E as waits can be extreme.

I've had similar - well before covid - woke up with red swollen itchy eye - washed it out it was getting steadily worse itched like hell took anti histomes - didn't think chemist would be able to offer more than we had in so rang GP in morning - explained got an appointment with health care practitioner - she was vile gave me perscription drops told me off for not going at eye A&E in next city - that I didn't know even existed and said next time I shouldn't waste their time.

We were fairly new to area and they werent' enough GPs but it was an early sign they were worst GP we'd ever had. Had to learn to be very peristant and frequently print off and go in with NICE guidelines.

Polarbearstar · 21/03/2022 13:50

Well, it’s definitely not something we can arse about with, that much is clear.

OP posts:
Whatdramain2022 · 21/03/2022 13:49

@LittleSnakes

• Antibiotics make little difference to the number of children whose symptoms improve • Antibiotics make little difference to the number of children with recurrent infections, short-term hearing loss or perforated eardrum

From NICE guidelines. Every time I’ve been to GP for something similar, they say ‘come back and see me if it doesn’t go away’. Not ‘go to A&E if it doe my go away’ Unless there’s concerns about sepsis obvs.

So my father, in the days before antibiotics, had to have all his inner ear removed as a small child because of an ear infection. If he had antibiotics he would have been able to hear in both ears, not just one. The NICE guidelines are very risky.
Newmama29 · 21/03/2022 13:48

As an A&E nurse you aren’t being unreasonable. The GP is getting out of seeing a patient & by telling you to go to A&E is ultimately passing you on the the hospital system instead of being treated in the community. A&E stands for ACCIDENT & EMERGENCY, can your baby breathe? Is she otherwise fairly well? Eating & drinking? Peeing & pooing? If yes to the above then this is neither an accident or an emergency & the GP should be providing you with care. This is the reason that hospitals are overwhelmed & ambulances are stuck at A&E departments & unable to attend calls, GPs must go back to seeing patients in the community

Polarbearstar · 21/03/2022 13:48

A few people have confirmed that GPs do do this, so I really don’t think I misunderstood her, in fact I know I didn’t.

@SleepWhenAmDead thanks - it is a bit of a headache. I’ve asked for a referral so we can go through BUPA but even privately it’s looking like it’s difficult.

OP posts:
welshweasel · 21/03/2022 13:48

I agree, it doesn’t sounds like A&E is the most appropriate route. I would be asking the GP to discuss with paeds and seeing if you can be seen on the assessment unit or in hot clinic. Sitting for hours in A&E benefits no one

Cheeserton · 21/03/2022 13:47

One good way to understand better would be to... Take her to a and e like the Dr said.

Mindymomo · 21/03/2022 13:47

For a perforated ear drum if antibiotics don’t dry it up, will need to be swabbed to determine what type of infection it is, either bacterial or fungal, then different medication can be given. My DH has a perforated ear drum, which perforated about 15 years ago. The operation to close the perforation, he was only given a 50% success rate then, although now, the success rate is way higher and you should consider this going forward, if you want her be able to go swimming.

MissMarplesGoddaughter · 21/03/2022 13:47

@IDidntKnowItWasAParty

Wtf is wrong with you OP - your baby is ill, Gp tells you to take them to A&E, yet instead you come on here?! Jesus wept, your poor child. Go to A&E.
^ x 1,000,000 times

Your poor child, why do you think you know better than your GP?

Porcupineintherough · 21/03/2022 13:46

@Whinge

Another one saying YABU. Doctors / GPs don't say go to A+E for no reason. If they're suggesting it (and it seems like they've suggested it more than once) then you should listen.
Actually I disagree, it doesn't sound like the GP is concerned, it sounds like they are washing their hands of her. If they are concerned they should be referring her to audiology, or ent or whatever the right consultant is.
wonderwoman26 · 21/03/2022 13:43

Many GP's say this as a way of bypassing the referraly system.

If your DD was referred by tge GP, they would enter the ENT waiting list and could be waiting months for an intial appointment especially in the current NHS climate.
By going through A&E - they will do an intial assessment there and then and in general will be transferred to a specialist quicker.

If im honest (hospital worker) its an absolute nightmare that they do this and it one of the reasons hospitals are struggling with A&E waits - A&E is life or death, not a quick route for a referral but the GP's are happy to give this advice as they are under so much pressure it easens their burden.

Its a bit of a loophole, you technically can do it - but knowing the system makes it a bit morally wrong for me. Obviosuly you know your DD better than anyone and can best assess their need for A&E or to return to GP and ask for a proper referal to a ENT specialist

fairgame84 · 21/03/2022 13:42

They would recommend A&E in my area because A&E can refer you on to the ENT Emergencies clinic. GP's can't do that round here.

AnnesBrokenSlate · 21/03/2022 13:41

OP is there a language difference between you and the GP or is there a reason why the communication was so poor? As I said in my earlier post, I think you misunderstood them.
It's important to have clear communication channels with dealing with medical staff. If the problem is with the GP, then perhaps you need to change GPs. If you need extra support then ask the surgery what is available. Or try to ensure someone else comes with you if possible or ask the GP to write their advice down. It can be easy to miss nuance if you're worried about your DC Flowers

SleepWhenAmDead · 21/03/2022 13:41

OP - you've got your work cut out either way with ENT for children. My DD's audiologist said that she needed to see ENT. The waiting list for NHS ENT is really long. The COVID really impacted on ENT.

I then also tried to get a private ENT appt and in my COUNTY they will only see adults and had no suggestions for me.

In the end my DD showed symptoms of mastoiditis and I took her to the GP who said to go to A&E where we did get to see an ENT Consultant. (mastoidisits is not recommended though).

I think you need to be persistent and prepared to travel if you can xx

Whatwouldscullydo · 21/03/2022 13:41

This is what it's like now.

The whole point of the gp is surely to prevent things getting to the point it becomes an a&e job. But you cant get in.

Then you cant get seen at a&e fir hours and hours because its full of people who should be at the drs Hmm

Polarbearstar · 21/03/2022 13:41

Also, the GP did put her hands on and around the bad ear and DD didn’t wince or show any signs of discomfort so the GP does not think she is in pain. I’ll agree it’s unpleasant and that’s why I am spending money to sort it!

OP posts:
tkwal · 21/03/2022 13:39

Ruptured ear drum is horribly painful (personal experience) a&e can do things GPS can't, like xrays ct scans and intravenous drips of antibiotics, painkillers or just fluids if needed. Intravenous antibiotics are more effective than tablets or liquids. They have all the departments there to investigate possible causes too. Go early in the day and there's a good chance you will make more progress. Its still going to be quicker than waiting for a GP referral. I really can't believe you're neglecting her needs like this

Onlyforcake · 21/03/2022 13:39

Because as the OP says A&E isn't always the best interests of anyone. Sitting around for hours in a frentic environment Vs being at home, comfortable.

Polarbearstar · 21/03/2022 13:38

I can only go off what the GP said to me. If you ask and they answer twice and people still insist no, what they mean is … then that needs to be a lot, lot clearer. It really was not what was said, or meant.

@Blossom64265 that really is unfair. We had a GP appointment as soon as the ear clearly had an infection.

OP posts:
Onlyforcake · 21/03/2022 13:37

13:30Blossom6426
A LOT of children will have an ear infection that goes unnoticed until the eardrum perforates. As an adult I've had an ear infection that I hadn't acknowledged as anything other than a dull ache until the eardrum burst. Implying the OP was somehow negligent in "allowing" an ear infection is ludicrous

LaraDeSalle · 21/03/2022 13:37

Another mind boggling post as to why a mother wouldn’t put the best interests of her child first.

VanGoghsDog · 21/03/2022 13:37

When I had pneumonia the GP prescribed and sent me for a chest x-ray with the instruction to go to A&E if there wasn't significant improvement within 24 hours.

Seems pretty standard to me.