Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have refused to take DD to A & E

269 replies

Polarbearstar · 21/03/2022 12:16

‘Refused’ sounds more aggressive than it actually was, but DD has not really been quite right for a while now with a perforated ear drum, high temperatures, cold, streaming nose.

Doctor keeps saying to take to A and E and I am unclear what A and E can do that they can’t?

OP posts:
scootalucy · 21/03/2022 15:27

Hmm, although obviously ear infections can travel to the brain. I just don't think I'd make a fuss about who should be providing what care. I'd just go to the hospital and get it sorted.

LadyMacduff · 21/03/2022 15:24

I think i get your point, @Polarbearstar

Accident and Emergency implies that something serious has just happened, not a lingering issue that isn't resolving itself and requires further investigation.

Why then wouldn't OP be referred by the GP for an appointment with a hospital paediatrician or otherwise relevant specialist?

Why on one day is the GP seemingly happy to monitor and see how it goes, but the next time it happens, sending OP to seek urgent medical attention?

It's as though she is being told that the only route to a more specialist level of healthcare is via an Accident and Emergency department, taking up space for people who have been injured or need dealing with right away.

weathervane1 · 21/03/2022 15:23

I was in a similar situation fifteen years ago and so glad we went to A&E despite the GP being a bit vague about why and when. I understand your wish not to sit around for a few hours but it's been over three hours since you initially posted and that time could have been better spend, and would have reduced any potential risk to your child. I have always taken the stance of "just do it" when it comes to children's health. Fingers crossed it is nothing serious but if it is, the hospital can access tests and speedy results that your GP cannot.

implantreplace · 21/03/2022 15:22

You haven’t left this thread for 3 solid hours
You would have likely been seen by now, given age of your child

LottyD32 · 21/03/2022 15:17

@Polarbearstar

No, it’s not a wind up, I’m hoping someone can help me understand.

To be clear, she hasn’t looked at her and said ‘she must go to a and e now’, she has said that in future when her temp goes up or her ear leaks to go to a and e, but a and e say the same as the GP.

If there are safeguarding follow ups (there won’t be) I’m happy to justify my point but what I’m really about here is trying to understand why we are being sent to A and E.

Does it matter? Just take your kid, Jesus christ. Ask the questions later. Ask A&E why the gp sent you.
Carrotten · 21/03/2022 15:14

GPS make a lot of inappropriate referrals onto ED.

There'd a number of reasons for this. They want to skip waiting lists. They don't want to have to make an appropriate referral, they want to transfer the responsibility to ED. They can't be bothered to treat the patient appropriately

To me it sounds like the GP is washing their hands of you. They haven't given you any appropriate instructions for when would be appropriate for Ed, when you should worry. They were not happy to prescribe antibiotics today

If the GP thinks you need ent care through Ed they should call the ent on call. If the GP thinks you need ED They should tell you why for example - you may need IV antibiotics, you need a blood test, you need specialist treatment. They should also give you an indication of when would be appropriate e.g. if their temperature is spiking above 38 and can't be bought down with paracetamol

Just go to A&E if it happens again is not appropriate management

Catsrus · 21/03/2022 15:12

@Polarbearstar

I will take her to A and E when there is an accident or an emergency, of course.

I think people are completely and deliberately misunderstanding.

The doctor did not look at her, gasp and say ‘A and E! Now!’

The doctor looked at her, said what the condition was and diagnosed some antibiotics but said that in future to go to A and E with her, ie for routine childhood illnesses, not life threatening emergencies or things that clearly can’t be dealt with at the GP (ie broken bone.)

It would seem no one else has any idea either.

I understand what you are trying to say. No one will take the time to do a proper assessment.

My adult DD was in serious pain - was on a cocktail of ABs and Pain killers. When she went back to the GP as the pain was getting worse without seeing her, telephone consult, he said "If it continues to get worse, go to A&E". Of course, it was on a Sunday that it got really bad, she was vomiting - had to get a taxi to hospital as unable to drive. A&E said "go to your GP tomorrow" - no tests or scans done, no advice given.

The next day, Monday, I paid for her to see a consultant privately, she had a consult that same evening, then diagnosis, and appropriate treatment, within two weeks. Luckily for her she had a mother who had the resources to do that.

The buck is being passed. continually.
The NHS is broken. They broke it.

Polarbearstar · 21/03/2022 15:11

I think the thread is best left, tbh, but I will say one last time that the GP did not want or expect me to take DD to a and e now.

I was told with no misunderstandings or misinterpretations that if she is unwell again, to take her to A and E.

Not ‘if I can’t get a GP appointment.’

Not ‘if her condition worsens’

Not ‘if it’s out of hours.’

And other medics have confirmed this is a thing.

OP posts:
SVRT19674 · 21/03/2022 15:07

My 7 month daughter had what I thought was an ear infection, she was t GPs twice and that same night I took her to A&E at 1.30 am she was crying in a tone that really worried me. She had a blood test and when they came back 45 mins later, her white cells were sky high, she was in hospital for a week with antibiotics in vein. You do not play God with this subject.

ChloeHel · 21/03/2022 15:06

@Polarbearstar

tried to explain what the GP meant

@ChloeHel do you not think it is the height of arrogance to decide that I am too stupid to understand what someone says?

And when medics on the thread have confirmed this can and does happen?

I am not seeking advice on whether or not I should take DD to A and E. as it turns out the thread has been extremely helpful as I have a decisive course of action.

I have been really patient but I am getting a bit annoyed now.

Nothing to with stupidity but interpretation.

Again, not once did I mention advice on whether you should take DD to A&E. You asked what A&E could do that a GP could not and you have had numerous answers to that question. Which was the point to the OP.

Polarbearstar · 21/03/2022 15:02

tried to explain what the GP meant

@ChloeHel do you not think it is the height of arrogance to decide that I am too stupid to understand what someone says?

And when medics on the thread have confirmed this can and does happen?

I am not seeking advice on whether or not I should take DD to A and E. as it turns out the thread has been extremely helpful as I have a decisive course of action.

I have been really patient but I am getting a bit annoyed now.

OP posts:
UniversalAunt · 21/03/2022 15:00

Because national guidelines & treatments protocols are that small children are taken in to A&E as their conditions can change very quickly.

I have to ask why you ‘need to know’ before you follow important advice, is this consistent with other situations in your life?

‘If there are safeguarding follow ups (there won’t be) I’m happy to justify my point but what I’m really about here is trying to understand why we are being sent to A and E.’ - this is quite disconcerting, that you are equivocating about advice given to you by the GP.

OP, many posters see the point of taking a child to A&E & they are being gentle with you.

YABU if this were your own health & even more so as your child is just 16mo.

ChloeHel · 21/03/2022 14:58

@GreenFingersWouldBeHandy

OP, you sound like one of these people who is 'always right' so I"m not sure what the point of your post is.

You're ignoring professional healthcare advice, but then agree with random strangers on the Internet that there is no need to take your DD to A&E because that is what is most convenient for you.

I hope your daughter is OK. A perforated eardrum is no joke and may cause permanent hearing damage.

Completely agree, OP asked what A&E could do a GP couldn’t. Many of us have answered her question and tried to explain what GP could have meant. But OP isn’t taking on any information or advice and is stand offish. So yes, not sure what the point of the post is.
scootalucy · 21/03/2022 14:56

Oh and to be clear going to A and E was the best way to get emergency ENT doctor to see me. Perfectly sensible approach as far as I could see.

Tdcp · 21/03/2022 14:55

I'm going to go out on a limb and suggest that the GP meant that if she has a fever, a leaky ear and is in pain again and it's out of hours, go to a&e instead of waiting for a GP appointment the next day.. either that or she's trying to bypass referrals if it's a recurring issue.

I hope your dd starts to feel better soon!

scootalucy · 21/03/2022 14:53

I ended up in a and e with a perforated ear drum last year. The pain was horrific. I am pretty horrified that you are not following your GP advice to be honest.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 21/03/2022 14:53

OP, you sound like one of these people who is 'always right' so I"m not sure what the point of your post is.

You're ignoring professional healthcare advice, but then agree with random strangers on the Internet that there is no need to take your DD to A&E because that is what is most convenient for you.

I hope your daughter is OK. A perforated eardrum is no joke and may cause permanent hearing damage.

Ozanj · 21/03/2022 14:51

@Polarbearstar

I will take her to A and E when there is an accident or an emergency, of course.

I think people are completely and deliberately misunderstanding.

The doctor did not look at her, gasp and say ‘A and E! Now!’

The doctor looked at her, said what the condition was and diagnosed some antibiotics but said that in future to go to A and E with her, ie for routine childhood illnesses, not life threatening emergencies or things that clearly can’t be dealt with at the GP (ie broken bone.)

It would seem no one else has any idea either.

Infections can cause sepsis. In kids sepsis doesn’t always present in high temps (as low as 37 sometimes) & so they often don’t get diagnosed until it’s far too late. That’s why GPs advise parents to go to A&E if infection doesn’t seem to be responding to antibiotics.
jnh22 · 21/03/2022 14:51

By telling you to go to A&E if further concerns, the GP has successfully “safety-netted”. Therefore, if something happens and you wish to complain, GP has medico-legally protected themselves.

Polarbearstar · 21/03/2022 14:51

No, I think I have thoroughly clarified what the GP meant.

OP posts:
iolaus · 21/03/2022 14:48

I suspect from what you say about her having a high temperature last night so you took her this morning, what he's meaning is 'if she is that unwell at the weekend don't wait until the GP opens, seek help there and then, even if that means going to A&E'

Inastatus · 21/03/2022 14:47

Ask your GP to refer you to an ENT consultant. My DS had repeated infections which GP always prescribed amoxicillin for. They would clear it for a couple of weeks and then he would get another one. It was heartbreaking seeing him in so much pain. We ended up going private as we had medical insurance back then. The first thing the consultant did was swab his ear to find out what bug was causing the infection. Turns out amoxicillin was completely useless against it which is why it kept coming back. Got the right meds, then later had grommets inserted to clear his glue ear. He had to have a bit of speech therapy because his hearing had been affected. Please push for a referral.

londonrach · 21/03/2022 14:42

Yabu. If gp says your child needs to go to a and e you go to a and e

titchy · 21/03/2022 14:42

c) they are out of their depth, and want to kick it higher up the chain, so nobody can accuse them of negligence.

If the GP is out of their depth or cannot treat any further, the correct route would be a referral to a specialist. Not 'Go to A&E'.

catlady3 · 21/03/2022 14:40

I get where you're coming from, OP. I'm not English, maybe that has something to do with it, but I found the NHS just an absolutely baffling institution. And a mirage at times. Anyway.

Two thoughts, a) can you ring the GP and ask for clarification. Say you want to make sure you can tell A & E what exactly it is that you're there for. Have the GP tell you exactly why they are sending you, what you're supposed to tell A & E to do, and what the expected outcome is. Write this down and take it to A & E. b) Consider ringing 111 as an intermediate step? Top tip, don't ring them when your baby is asleep as they'll make you wake them. (I've been hung up on by 111 in an urgent but not life threatening situation because I refused to wake up my baby who had finally managed to calm down sufficiently to fall asleep, which was what enabled me to place a call, which btw uses speech recognition to navigate the menu, and I challenge anyone to get that accomplished with a screaming baby in their arms.)