Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If 'commoners' can marry into the royal family - why have a 'royal' family -

419 replies

HacketteofHacks · 21/03/2022 12:03

I totally respect the Queen and think she's been largely a force for good...
But at work we were talking about the tour that's on now.. my boss pointed out the the definition of a royal family was that its lineage is 'predetermined by God'.
Well that is archaic in itself - my boss (who is no royalist) the. pointed out that once members of a royal family marry commoners they lose this 'untouchable special-Ness'.
I think he had a good point...
He's from Jamaica so hence we were all having the conversation .

OP posts:
IKnowYouDontTurnTheLightOn · 22/03/2022 21:26

And why is using royal estates to house refugees ridiculous? If they’re no longer needed they’ll be empty - why not put them to good use? I’m obviously being slightly facetious but it just highlights the obscenity of the situation.

IKnowYouDontTurnTheLightOn · 22/03/2022 21:25

@Hrpuffnstuff1 odd that you ignore all the very valid examples of thriving and successful presidential systems.

What does a nation state with a sovereign head represent then? Do enlighten us with your wisdom.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 22/03/2022 21:12

@AnIconOfImperfections

This thread is so refreshing, the overwhelming majority of posts are full of critical thinking and intelligent analysis, with only the odd forelock tugger post thrown in here and there for good measure (and always entertaining to see these silly posters destroyed by the clever MN republicans).

It has to be abundantly clear to even the most staunch monarchist that the tide has turned and the RF’s days are numbered.

👏🏼 👏🏼 👏🏼

🤣🤣🤣🤣 Critical thinking, using Russia and The US as an example. The country that had Trump as a president whilst also shooting one in the head whilst on a presidential parade.

And the suggestion to use Royal estates to house refugee's is ridiculous.
Carry on.

One of main issues if the lack of understanding of what a nation state with a sovereign head represents.

Brefugee · 22/03/2022 21:02

I see the Dutch royal family are putting up 30 Ukranians (or families) in one of their spare palaces.
I won't hold my breath Grin

Blossomtoes · 22/03/2022 21:00

It has to be abundantly clear to even the most staunch monarchist that the tide has turned and the RF’s days are numbered

Statistics don’t support that view. And wait for the outpouring of grief when the Queen dies, that will see an upturn in support for the monarchy. Despite the vociferous republicanism on MN, it’s definitely not representative of the UK population.

www.statista.com/statistics/863893/support-for-the-monarchy-in-britain-by-age/

DGRossetti · 22/03/2022 20:54

I don't think he'll remotely get the same respect as HMQ does, but I don't think his reign will be long enough to destabilise the monarchy enough to end it.

I think the reverse ... another coronation so soon after his (10 years ?) would just revive this discussion + time....

JustLyra · 22/03/2022 20:25

*15 or 20 years

JustLyra · 22/03/2022 20:23

[quote IKnowYouDontTurnTheLightOn]@JustLyra interesting point - he’ll be lucky to make two decades i guess 🤷‍♀️.[/quote]
Even if he was to make a full two decades he won't be the full public face for the whole time - like the Queen he'd have to start slowing down before that. So, maybe ten/fifteen 'good' years at most I'd say. I don't think that's long enough to finish off the monarchy.

The average age of dying in his parents and grandparents (obviously so far given HMQ could last another week or decade!) is 83, 88 if you remove George VI due to him being a heavy smoker.

No medical training or psychic powers at all, but I just don't get the feeling he's going to match his parents in longevity. He just doesn't look as healthy as they did at his age. I think he's indulged in the good food and good life far more than they did and that will have a toll.

If William takes over in 15 or years he'll only be 55/60 - that's going to give much more time to cock things up than his father will get.

AnIconOfImperfections · 22/03/2022 20:11

This thread is so refreshing, the overwhelming majority of posts are full of critical thinking and intelligent analysis, with only the odd forelock tugger post thrown in here and there for good measure (and always entertaining to see these silly posters destroyed by the clever MN republicans).

It has to be abundantly clear to even the most staunch monarchist that the tide has turned and the RF’s days are numbered.

👏🏼 👏🏼 👏🏼

Myee · 22/03/2022 19:49

Re respect for HMQ, I think she is seen as the elder lemon, of the old school, who keeps her mouth shut and doesn't put her foot in it. She has been there forever so people know no different. She hasn't changed one bit, and has carefully crafted the gift of saying nothing at all. No one knows much about her as a person. That is deliberate, in order to enshroud her in an air of mystery and monarchy.

Also those who are monarchists are (in general) of her generation. The next generation is not so good at tugging the forelock, but for now will keep their counsel out of maybe kindness to HM. I agree she has done nothing to really earn respect, and is a wily old bird who hides behind her throne.

But I don't think people will stay quiet regarding Charles. If the media turn on him it's all over. And as for William well he is no example of a hard working, intelligent, vibrant future King is he. I think the monarchy is nearing its natural end, and whilst I know that is not going to happen constitutionally for a long long time, it will happen by osmosis via the people who won't give a damn about them anymore.

IKnowYouDontTurnTheLightOn · 22/03/2022 19:30

@pigsDOfly I’ve asked that a few times and no one has answered! Although tbf the vast majority of people on this thread are Republicans so not many are going to say anything positive about Liz!

pigsDOfly · 22/03/2022 19:24

will Charles command the same respect as HMQ, and will his reign be the begging of the end for the RF, well maybe for the interest in and respect towards it that exists purely for the sake of HMQ at the moment.

Whenever there's a discussion on here about the RF there's always a number of posters who say that they have respect for the Queen but never explain why?

What has she actually done to earn their respect?

She's lived and enjoyed a long privileged live in which she been given the best of everything.

She's indulged her very expensive hobbies and lived in fabulous palaces.

Is this something to respect her for?

She's travelled to various places here and abroad waving to the masses and asking a few questions of a few specially selected people.

She has a weekly meeting with the prime minister and attends several ceremonious occasions throughout the year.

It's hardly a life of unrelenting hard work.

What is it about her and what she does that some people find so respect worthy?

IKnowYouDontTurnTheLightOn · 22/03/2022 19:22

@JustLyra interesting point - he’ll be lucky to make two decades i guess 🤷‍♀️.

IKnowYouDontTurnTheLightOn · 22/03/2022 19:20

@Myee I agree. I definitely don’t think he’s held in much regard at all. I think he’s in for a very rocky time. His brother and son are both embroiled in controversy, his wife isn’t much liked, he’s dull as fuck, other countries are already starting to break away from the royals. Jamaica looks like it’ll be next - it’ll be interesting how long it takes for Oz to follow.

JustLyra · 22/03/2022 19:14

@Myee

Re Prince Charles becoming king.... I doubt somehow that the respect given to HMQ whether you like her or not, will transfer to her son on his accession to the throne.

There is anger and indifference amongst many re the RF, but while HMQ is alive it is kept buttoned I think.

What do others think?, will Charles command the same respect as HMQ, and will his reign be the beginning of the end for the RF, well maybe for the interest in and respect towards it that exists purely for the sake of HMQ at the moment.

I don't think he'll remotely get the same respect as HMQ does, but I don't think his reign will be long enough to destabilise the monarchy enough to end it.

I don't think he'll antagonise enough people to bring about the political/system reform that would be needed to end the monarchy.

Myee · 22/03/2022 18:48

Re Prince Charles becoming king.... I doubt somehow that the respect given to HMQ whether you like her or not, will transfer to her son on his accession to the throne.

There is anger and indifference amongst many re the RF, but while HMQ is alive it is kept buttoned I think.

What do others think?, will Charles command the same respect as HMQ, and will his reign be the beginning of the end for the RF, well maybe for the interest in and respect towards it that exists purely for the sake of HMQ at the moment.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 22/03/2022 17:35

Ah, I see what you mean Keating, though with the Queen apparently against formal retirement it seems he'll be waiting still longer

Which for monarchists may be no bad thing ...

TheKeatingFive · 22/03/2022 17:28

Considering the time he's been waiting I'm not sure how much longer the "lead in" could have been?

I mean actually doing the job. 70 something is awfully late to start the thing your life's been leading up to. I think it would have benefitted him to have been king with the retired Queen in the background to give advice.

Of course it may have made no difference

Puzzledandpissedoff · 22/03/2022 17:25

I can see Charles' reign being pretty rocky. He doesn't have anything like the Queens personal skills and experience and that will be very obvious very quickly. A longer lead in would have helped

Considering the time he's been waiting I'm not sure how much longer the "lead in" could have been?

For me at least the problem seems to be not the timescale, but what he's done in it and how little he's learned from his mother's example around constitutional matters and just plain shutting up

IKnowYouDontTurnTheLightOn · 22/03/2022 16:50

@Hrpuffnstuff1 why do you think they’re going nowhere? Why are you so wedded to such a ludicrous system? Did you read the book review?

There’s also the travesty that is the Duchy of Cornwall @crepesncream - scandalous theft of property and money and the way he treats his tenants Angry.

JustLyra · 22/03/2022 16:48

There are loads of shocking cases in here one dating back in 1962 involved Princess Alexandra (who I admit to having never even heard of) forcing a chartered aircraft she was using for royal duties to divert to Vancouver in order to visit some friends, and then demanded that the tax payer meet all costs, including the clothes she bought herself. The cost of the detour in today’s money was around £200,000 and the outfits around £100,000. The government paid up.

Princess Alexandra is the Queen’s cousin.

However, she didn’t tour Canada in 62. The Queen Mother and the Princess Royal (Princess Mary) did. I’d put a far bigger bet on it being one of them if that story is anything like accurate.

Zilla1 · 22/03/2022 16:31

And I know that's a trivial comment against the substance of what you posted. It just stuck out a little.

Zilla1 · 22/03/2022 16:30

'and the fact that Princess Michael of Kent’s father was a Nazi and fought in WWI against the Allies too' it seems unsatisfactory to visit the sins of the father on the children to be fair the Princess Michael and I'm surprised at my saying this. Jeremiah says different to Exodus and Numbers?

For fighting against the Allies, didn't Wittgenstein got a medal and that didn't negate his later lectures nor his contribution to philosophy.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 22/03/2022 16:30

@DGRossetti

Generally the less people know about history, the more they think they are monarchists.

They forget that the Saxons used to elect their kings.

Still followed bloodlines mainly primogeniture or firstborn. It's an interesting subject however, the monarch and our fundamental style of governance are going know where.
crepesncream · 22/03/2022 16:18

This review of the book."What do you do" puts it far better than I could.

“In total, the taxpayer pays for a hundred buildings, six thousand rooms and twenty acres of roofs. And of course the Queen owns plenty of private property too, notably Balmoral and Sandringham, both bought with public funds, which also qualify for taxpayer support when they are used for official business.”

Ridiculous, bloated, antiquated, greedy, deluded, shameless parasites, are just seven of the less offensive words I‘d use to sum up the royals. Baker clearly feels along the same lines too. From the perfect quotes used in the epigraphs this book hits the right mood and tone from the very first turn of the page.

Baker has a lot to work with here, from the blatant examples of pro-Nazism from Edward VIII and his American wife (the couple received a gold inscribed wedding gift from Hitler) and the fact that Princess Michael of Kent’s father was a Nazi and fought in WWI against the Allies too, it is almost like shooting fish in a barrel. There is the bizarre and antiquated thing known as the honours system, a number of paedophiles, war criminals and dictators have been given various honours over the years, the likes of Kaiser Wilhelm II, Ceaucescu, Mugabe to the likes of Jimmy Savile and Bishop Peter Ball to name only a few.

“For 2001-11, the civil list was set at £7.9 million for each year. This became £13.7 million in 2011. The first year of Sovereign Grant saw support rise to £31 million in 2012.”
But then it continued to rise 2013/14: £36.1 million (up 16.5%), 2014/15: £37.9 million (up 5%) 2015/16: £40.1 million (up 5.5%) 2016/17: £42.8 million (up 7%) 2017/18: £76.1 million (77.8 %), 2018/19: £82.8 million (up 8%).

When factoring in the vast security costs, often for obscure or minor royals “the true cost to the public purse stretches well beyond £300 million a year.”

We see that old Prince Charles alone has 31 medals (for what?) and we learn of his immense hypocrisy in terms of his approach to the environment. His environmental impact from his tax payer subsidised travel alone including his vast entourage and security, puts a clown’s nose on his so called environmental concern.

“It is worth noting that the practice of paying sums to the monarch’s relatives, other than the King’s wife, only started when the present Queen came to the throne in 1952.”

Of course let us not forget the Royal Collection, a public asset, which the palace continues to pocket money from charging the public to see, and only 0.1% of it is ever on a display. Due to the secret and opaque nature it is hard to get an accurate value of its worth, but some estimates say it may be as high as £20 billion.

Then we get the dossier on hapless old Air Miles Andy who is beyond belief and beneath contempt, a repulsive and repugnant parasite with connections and/or business dealings with various dictators, Middle Eastern theocracies, Gaddafi, the Bin ladens and of course old Jeffrey Epstein (In Epstein’s incriminating black book, there was no less than 16 different contact numbers for the royal and 18 for his ex-wife). Among the many sinister and sickening facts around him is that in the ten years to 2011 he cost the taxpayer £4 million, with another £10 million for his police protection. We do know that his mummy gives him £249,000 tax free each year and that he gets £20,000 from a pension, but we don’t know how he and Sarah Ferguson managed to pay for their £13 million ski chalet in Switzerland?...

There are loads of shocking cases in here one dating back in 1962 involved Princess Alexandra (who I admit to having never even heard of) forcing a chartered aircraft she was using for royal duties to divert to Vancouver in order to visit some friends, and then demanded that the tax payer meet all costs, including the clothes she bought herself. The cost of the detour in today’s money was around £200,000 and the outfits around £100,000. The government paid up.

Then there’s the Offshore tax havens, Cash for Access scams, the ever growing unaccountability, Hereditary peerages, immunity from countless laws (not just seat belt wearing and hate speech), exemption from the Freedom of Information Act, the hunting (whilst claiming to be animal welfare advocates), the sneaky lobbying and political interference, the endless freebies, the lecturing people on climate change whilst travelling on private jets with extensive entourages, and using £369 million in order to revamp Buckingham Palace. The list goes on and on.

“The sovereign is not legally liable to pay income tax, capital gains tax or inheritance tax.”

So what all of this is really saying is that the British royal family are above the law. They have been granted impunity. Their very existence puts a giant dildo on the face of Britain’s idea of democracy, fairness and equality. If we were to see a mob of scroungers who ripped off their country to such a degree anywhere else in the world, we would laugh in pity and condescension. They are a sham that no one is ever supposed to speak out on or challenge. We routinely see that even so called sacred institutions like the BBC and every single British government since she came to the throne are all guilty of sickening levels of sycophancy and brown nosing.

It is beyond absurd that the royal family are allowed to get away with what they still get away in the year 2020. There are so many awful things related to them, that it is hard to know where to start. In spite of worsening global warming, a global financial crises they remain immune and are continue to be subsidised and enriched, granting themselves impunity in almost any situation that pleases them, when it pleases them.

Baker makes another wonderful point when he compares the royal set up to the MPs stealing from the tax payer, “For the royals to use civil list money to buy and help amass a private property portfolio is no different: it is fiddling their expenses.”

I am not sure I have shaken my head in disbelief so much during a book as I did reading this. It is way beyond belief what the British royals get away with. There should be no place for this blatant anomaly, which takes far more away from many than it occasionally gives back to the few. The royal family is a bloated farce of a thing, an absurd, extortionate pantomime stuck somewhere between a tedious BBC costume drama and a crap Monty Python sketch complete with the plummy, self-important English accents.

Swipe left for the next trending thread