Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If 'commoners' can marry into the royal family - why have a 'royal' family -

419 replies

HacketteofHacks · 21/03/2022 12:03

I totally respect the Queen and think she's been largely a force for good...
But at work we were talking about the tour that's on now.. my boss pointed out the the definition of a royal family was that its lineage is 'predetermined by God'.
Well that is archaic in itself - my boss (who is no royalist) the. pointed out that once members of a royal family marry commoners they lose this 'untouchable special-Ness'.
I think he had a good point...
He's from Jamaica so hence we were all having the conversation .

OP posts:
RogueBorg · 24/03/2022 17:26

@Blossomtoes a republic would only be one small part of a very long journey to a more fair society. Ending poverty is a massive task and would involve an awful lot more than an end to hereditary privilege - but it would be a start.

Blossomtoes · 24/03/2022 17:23

Scandinavian countries somehow manage to combine a far more equal society than ours with retaining their monarchies. I’d be far more persuaded by the republican argument if I thought we’d see an end to poverty and top class public services if we didn’t have a monarchy. I’m far too cynical to believe for a moment that would happen.

TheKeatingFive · 24/03/2022 17:06

I think the Brits are somewhat deluded about how 'big' they are on the world stage, in fairness.

It's not 1890 any more

DGRossetti · 24/03/2022 17:04

Yes, the Scandinavian countries are big players on the world stage.

I'd much rather our hungry were fed, our homeless housed, and our children out of poverty before I shot my load all over the idea of being a "big payer" on the world stage. If the argument is that it's better some children go cold in our own country so we can keep a royal family, then I'd like to know who is making it;

RogueBorg · 24/03/2022 16:56

@Hrpuffnstuff1 who gives a shit if we’re “big players on the world stage”?! Arguably since Brexit we’re not anyway. Need to get our own house in order.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 24/03/2022 16:39

@EdithWeston

I don't think most of Scandinavia or the Netherlands would like to be described as not fully functional. Nor would I think it a good description of countries whose measures of equality are so very good
Yes, the Scandinavian countries are big players on the world stage.

Not.

EdithWeston · 24/03/2022 16:31

I don't think most of Scandinavia or the Netherlands would like to be described as not fully functional. Nor would I think it a good description of countries whose measures of equality are so very good

Myee · 24/03/2022 16:21

These tours are well choreographed. I don't think for a minute that William would have the cop on to mention anything from his own heart. Maybe he is not allowed to I dunno.

He has been prepped and primed and prepared for anything he says, and his speeches written out in full for him. Topic depends on the country being visited and is decided more than likely by the Firm. Designed to calm the natives that they have nothing to fear from the RF, hmmmph.

RogueBorg · 24/03/2022 15:48

Voting not voter

RogueBorg · 24/03/2022 15:48

Progress to democracy - surely even you would agree that a fully functioning democracy (a fairer voter system, no hereditary principle) is progress compared to what we have now? Surely no one could actually justify a system where one family rules and everyone else is excluded? Smile

Blossomtoes · 24/03/2022 15:27

You could argue that our entire society is built on slavery and we all benefit from it. I really can’t see the point of apologising for it now. The people owed an apology are long dead.

Every member of the royal family from the Queen onwards should be apologising for the treatment of miners in the Bowes-Lyons’ pits. Several of my dad’s family died in them. Whatever they said now wouldn’t turn the clock back.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 24/03/2022 15:18

[quote RogueBorg]@Hrpuffnstuff1 the clearest end of ever?! Grin

Except it isn’t. It proves nothing. We can change, we can progress, your argument is utter nonsense 🤷‍♀️.

End of. (We can all use meaningless statements to “prove” our point).[/quote]
Progress.
To what?

RogueBorg · 24/03/2022 15:00

I think once Jamaica goes it will have a dominoes effect. It won’t instantly change anything here but the narrative will change and those defending the indefensible will find it infinitely harder.

TheKeatingFive · 24/03/2022 14:59

But those nations will realise the unviability of a republic

Why would a republic be unviable?

RogueBorg · 24/03/2022 14:59

@Hrpuffnstuff1 the clearest end of ever?! Grin

Except it isn’t. It proves nothing. We can change, we can progress, your argument is utter nonsense 🤷‍♀️.

End of. (We can all use meaningless statements to “prove” our point).

Zilla1 · 24/03/2022 14:33

But those nations will realise the unviability of a republic compared with the benefits of a constitutional monarchy and the foolhardiness of such a decision.

DGRossetti · 24/03/2022 14:25

@Porcupineintherough

Does saying slavery was abhorrent and should never have happened count as grovelling?
I think it depends who is doing the saying really. It's hard to take it seriously from people who have benefitted from it every single generation from then to now with fuck all action to back it up.

I'm sure Wills and Co are sincere. Because that's cheap. I'm sincere about shed loads of stuff I have fuck all intention of doing anything about.

Quincunx · 24/03/2022 14:03

@Porcupineintherough

Does saying slavery was abhorrent and should never have happened count as grovelling?
grovelling: acting obsequiously in order to obtain forgiveness or favour.

Yes, pretty much. Desperately trying to win affections to legitimise the indefensible. Barbados, Jamaica, who's next?

Will Ladbrokes be taking bets do you think?

Antigua and Barbuda, Australia, Belize, Barbados, Canada, Grenada, Jamaica, New Zealand, Papua New Guinea, St Kitts and Nevis, St Lucia, St Vincent and the Grenadines, ...

Porcupineintherough · 24/03/2022 10:55

Does saying slavery was abhorrent and should never have happened count as grovelling?

Blossomtoes · 24/03/2022 10:46

cringing at Wills grovelling in Jamaica in a desperate bid to preserve his ill-gotten fortune

What jurisdiction does Jamaica have over his fortune? .

Quincunx · 24/03/2022 09:09

@Hrpuffnstuff1

99% of republicans are?? 😂😂
...cringing at Wills grovelling in Jamaica in a desperate bid to preserve his ill-gotten fortune.
Puzzledandpissedoff · 23/03/2022 22:13

Are there other HRH's with 4/8/12 children?

Well, Crown Prince Pavlos of Greece and his wife Marie-Chantal have five, but since the throne no longer exists I don't know if they called themselves HRH any more

Zilla1 · 23/03/2022 22:04

I think I'm uncharitable and angrier than normal after considering the effects of the absence of help in the Chancellor's statement today on patients whom I know were already desperate. If I were sensible, I'd have realised it might be an idea to step back from the advice and the occasional whimsy and distractions I post on MN.

Zilla1 · 23/03/2022 21:59

FWIW and to avoid derailing the minor diversion, I meath HM and had forgot she became HM though I'm grateful for the suggestion of HRH Prince Philip as a fallback. Perhaps let's not discuss if that makes the stats 33.3% or 0%....

The mathematician in me would suggest that it would mean HM as it would need a HRH with 4 or 8 or 12 children to give a possibility of a 25% as an option. Are there other HRH's with 4/8/12 children?

RoseAndRose · 23/03/2022 21:45

The Queen hasn't been HRH since Feb 1952

She's HM

Swipe left for the next trending thread