Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If 'commoners' can marry into the royal family - why have a 'royal' family -

419 replies

HacketteofHacks · 21/03/2022 12:03

I totally respect the Queen and think she's been largely a force for good...
But at work we were talking about the tour that's on now.. my boss pointed out the the definition of a royal family was that its lineage is 'predetermined by God'.
Well that is archaic in itself - my boss (who is no royalist) the. pointed out that once members of a royal family marry commoners they lose this 'untouchable special-Ness'.
I think he had a good point...
He's from Jamaica so hence we were all having the conversation .

OP posts:
RogueBorg · 25/03/2022 09:03

@Blossomtoes loads of links to further reading in the thread Smile.

DGRossetti · 25/03/2022 07:47

Hopefully other republicans who are willing to have a rational discussion about this will be along at some point.

Why ? Many people justify support for the monarchy in irrational terms. The UK doesn't do evidence based anything. So why do republicans have to be the ones who are put to the test for rational discussions ?

Briony123 · 25/03/2022 00:51

The "descended from God" aspect ended with William & Mary several hundred years ago!

Myee · 24/03/2022 23:53

@Boxowine

Sure, everything is so much better when the people select leaders like Trump and Johnson.
Both countries that have oh so democratic FPTP systems too. So rare nowadays and very few "normal"countries have it.
Boxowine · 24/03/2022 22:45

Sure, everything is so much better when the people select leaders like Trump and Johnson.

Quincunx · 24/03/2022 22:28

Yes you are absolutely right about absolutely everything, bt.

It's just outrageous how the rogue republicans like me refuse to summarise books that you cba to read and that have already been summarised 15 times by 15 other posters. Just shocking.

I shall self-flagellate with a rolled up Daily Mail and atone for my sins while chanting a few Hail Catherines and wondering which pedo relative they'll be naming sprog number 4 after.

Blossomtoes · 24/03/2022 21:53

@Quincunx

I cannot read Norman Baker's book (quoted about 165 times on here), for you. You will have to do it yourself (but you will not). All the evidence is summarised perfectly in that book. No scrolling, no logging in, no annoying republican mumsnetters, just page turning and digesting the info.
You’re absolutely right, I won’t. You could summarise the highlights for me but you won’t.

I asked a very simple question: What’s lacking in Scandinavia, Belgium and The Netherlands that we’d miraculously have here if we became a republic?

You responded with a lot of abstract stuff about truth and transparency, tentacles into all sorts of areas which you can’t/won’t specify and “vast assets” that doesn’t bear the daylight of scrutiny.

In other words, no answers. Hopefully other republicans who are willing to have a rational discussion about this will be along at some point.

Quincunx · 24/03/2022 21:42

I cannot read Norman Baker's book (quoted about 165 times on here), for you. You will have to do it yourself (but you will not). All the evidence is summarised perfectly in that book. No scrolling, no logging in, no annoying republican mumsnetters, just page turning and digesting the info.

Blossomtoes · 24/03/2022 21:31

Why do you want other people to do your research for you?

I don’t. I want republicans to justify their belief that the UK would be a better place without the monarchy. And you have so little evidence for your prejudice that you won’t even try. 🤷‍♀️

Quincunx · 24/03/2022 21:28

@Blossomtoes

So, basically, still no answers. If we got rid of the monarchy in what way would we be better off? We still wouldn’t be able to stay in the palaces or wear the jewellery. The government would have a bit more money to waste.

I’m just waiting for someone to tell me.quite simply, how the country would be better off as a republic. And I’m told to scour God knows how many MN threads. Not looking good, guys.

Well if you'd read them at the time you were on those threads assiduously scrolling past all the detailed and comprehensive answers to your repetitive rhetorical questions, it'd be less of an arduous task to get the answers now, wouldn't it?

Plus the rest of the internet's free to anyone with a wifi connection, which you clearly have. Why do you want other people to do your research for you? Because it's just easier to keep typing god save the queen into the search bar?

TheKeatingFive · 24/03/2022 21:13

The government would have a bit more money to waste.

Well if you're going to look at it like that, that's your lookout. Personally, I believe almost anything is better than letting one already obscenely wealthy family have exclusive access to it. Why would anyone advocate that?

The palaces can be turned into anything the country wants them to be. A significant proportion of the jewellery collection could be sold, the rest on permanent display. Better than sitting in darkened vaults, getting an outing once a decade when a grandchild deigns to marry or whatever.

Blossomtoes · 24/03/2022 21:01

So, basically, still no answers. If we got rid of the monarchy in what way would we be better off? We still wouldn’t be able to stay in the palaces or wear the jewellery. The government would have a bit more money to waste.

I’m just waiting for someone to tell me.quite simply, how the country would be better off as a republic. And I’m told to scour God knows how many MN threads. Not looking good, guys.

TimandGinger · 24/03/2022 20:18

The monarchy will pretty much go with the Queen. I’ve been at events that the Queen has been at and people were transfixed. Can’t see Wills having that effect!
Having said all that some of her privileges are as head of State. The French president for example lives like a king.

Myee · 24/03/2022 20:16

Imagine if a group of us vipers rocked up to one of the palaces that we "own" and demanded to stay for a week full board and lodgings. Oh and while we are at it we could ask to wear the jewellery and view all the paintings and "ornaments" that we own also. Then bring all our families to the big house for a BBQ and use the contents of the cellar and the kitchens to entertain them.

Well we own it don't we?

Quincunx · 24/03/2022 20:13

we allow them to live in the palaces.

Boris and the arsekissers do. The taxpayers are hostages to these cowardly political decisions.

Quincunx · 24/03/2022 20:08

@Blossomtoes

Precisely the point I was making *@TheKeatingFive*. I want to know what “vast assets” we’d remove from the royal family if we abolished the monarchy. Because I honestly can’t think of any.
Look back on the RF threads over the past 6 months and you'll find countless examples of royal financial skulduggery and literally dozens of convincing reasons to become a republic. It's not up to us to repost them and keep on with the same old links. It's up to you to read them. But you absolutely won't do that as it's easier to reside in monarchist fantasyland.

RF = Titanic in slow motion. Going down whether you believe it or not.

TheKeatingFive · 24/03/2022 18:59

We already own all those things. The sovereign grant is 15% of the income from the Crown Estate, they get the income from the duchies and we allow them to live in the palaces. We can’t take away what we already own

We don't own it in any meaningful sense. They spend the duchies and the sovereign grant. We don't have access to the palaces or what's in them.

Ooh and let's claim back the 7 billion jewellery collection that the Queen may not technically 'own' but has full run of when no one else does.

Blossomtoes · 24/03/2022 18:56

We already own all those things. The sovereign grant is 15% of the income from the Crown Estate, they get the income from the duchies and we allow them to live in the palaces. We can’t take away what we already own.

TheKeatingFive · 24/03/2022 18:52

I want to know what “vast assets” we’d remove from the royal family if we abolished the monarchy. Because I honestly can’t think of any.

The sovereign grant, duchies, and all of the royal palaces (dont know how many there are off the top of my head, but they're quite numerous)

Not bad really

Blossomtoes · 24/03/2022 18:48

Precisely the point I was making @TheKeatingFive. I want to know what “vast assets” we’d remove from the royal family if we abolished the monarchy. Because I honestly can’t think of any.

TheKeatingFive · 24/03/2022 18:44

The Crown Estate already essentially belongs to the tax payer as we keep 85% of its revenues. So are we going to confiscate their personal assets?

The crown estates don't belong to them personally, this isn't an issue. They would of course keep their personally owned estates, Sandringham and Balmoral

Blossomtoes · 24/03/2022 18:26

A greater degree of truth, clarity, transparency, integrity, fairness and social justice, with a redistribution of vast assets currently held by one oversized family who've got their tentacles into places and industries they have no right to have them, thanks to a series of corrupt governments enabling them

Sounds great. truth, clarity, transparency, integrity, fairness and social justice is like motherhood and apple pie but what does it actually mean in a tangible sense? And are other monarchies also lacking in those qualities?

Where does the royal family have its tentacles? Some examples would bd very helpful for me to understand.

Then there’s the vast assets. The Crown Estate already essentially belongs to the tax payer as we keep 85% of its revenues. So are we going to confiscate their personal assets? If we do that it sets a very dangerous precedent - if we take away their privately owned properties where does it stop? It probably means that if the state takes a fancy to my house it could take it away.

As I said, if anyone can present a convincing argument that the UK would be better off as a republic I’d give it consideration. We’re not even close yet.

Morfil · 24/03/2022 18:18

What’s staggering to me is that the Royals continue to be more popular among older demographics - surely people should have grown out fairytale bullshit by that age?

Quincunx · 24/03/2022 18:05

@Blossomtoes

So exactly what would getting rid of the monarchy achieve that can’t be managed with it still in place? What’s lacking in Scandinavia, Belgium and The Netherlands that we’d miraculously have here if we became a republic?
A greater degree of truth, clarity, transparency, integrity, fairness and social justice, with a redistribution of vast assets currently held by one oversized family who've got their tentacles into places and industries they have no right to have them, thanks to a series of corrupt governments enabling them.

If the current trend of neverending sovereign grant increases and unchecked royal involvement in absolutely everything that makes money is not slowed or preferably reversed immediately, the RF will keep on taking taking taking.

And a slimmed down monarchy's no good either: it's like realising all those tacky china ornaments on the shelf are completely useless and gathering dust but deciding to keep 4 of them anyway and paying 87m a year to have them cleaned and polished.

Blossomtoes · 24/03/2022 17:29

So exactly what would getting rid of the monarchy achieve that can’t be managed with it still in place? What’s lacking in Scandinavia, Belgium and The Netherlands that we’d miraculously have here if we became a republic?

Swipe left for the next trending thread