Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If 'commoners' can marry into the royal family - why have a 'royal' family -

419 replies

HacketteofHacks · 21/03/2022 12:03

I totally respect the Queen and think she's been largely a force for good...
But at work we were talking about the tour that's on now.. my boss pointed out the the definition of a royal family was that its lineage is 'predetermined by God'.
Well that is archaic in itself - my boss (who is no royalist) the. pointed out that once members of a royal family marry commoners they lose this 'untouchable special-Ness'.
I think he had a good point...
He's from Jamaica so hence we were all having the conversation .

OP posts:
DGRossetti · 25/03/2022 16:02

I think ...
I've just been ...
"Zilla"'d

Grin

Chapeau !!

DGRossetti · 25/03/2022 15:59

Don't forget they are the RF for many countries with diverse majority ethnicities which is almost like the RF having multiple ethnicities themselves.

Possibly contender for "bollocks of the day" award. And given how batshit Putin is, that's some achievement.

Zilla1 · 25/03/2022 15:58

Schrodinger's Queen. Simultaneously above politics but having just enough power when it is essential for the nation's good. A quantum queen. How many PPs are macro-quantum entities and simultaneously able to do two contradictory things. And no, I'm not talking about the power to look at Legislation before it is published and having a quiet word.

Zilla1 · 25/03/2022 15:56

Don't forget they are the RF for many countries with diverse majority ethnicities which is almost like the RF having multiple ethnicities themselves. And I vaguely recall one defence to an employment tribunal was that there was a Black Press Secretary.

Blossomtoes · 25/03/2022 15:54

Thanks @Roussette. I don’t agree with you but I do appreciate you at least having a go at answering my question.

crepesncream · 25/03/2022 15:51

@Zilla1

We need to think about what to call Britain if the worst happens and Britain is no longer British. Britannia might be a bit too close and just remind everyone about what they lost. Albion has history but the inherent etymological white-ness might not represent everyone and might just remind everyone how we lost the multi-ethnic inclusivity the RF brought. It's inconceivable, as Vizzini might say.
www.irishtimes.com/life-and-style/people/racist-royals-buckingham-palace-banned-ethnic-minorities-from-office-roles-

Are we talking about the same royal family here? Confused

Roussette · 25/03/2022 15:48

Because the Queen is pretty powerless and does nothing to hold a PM to account (proroguing parliament unlawfully for instance) and European presidents protect constitutions and can rein in politicians breaking laws. Proroguing of parliament would not have happened for instance with a President, checks and balances etc.
The Queen does what the PM tells her to do. Hardly healthy is it.

crepesncream · 25/03/2022 15:45

They are also representative of Britains' Global identity and our history.
It's what makes Britain British

Absolutely not. How shameful if it was.

Zilla1 · 25/03/2022 15:41

We need to think about what to call Britain if the worst happens and Britain is no longer British. Britannia might be a bit too close and just remind everyone about what they lost. Albion has history but the inherent etymological white-ness might not represent everyone and might just remind everyone how we lost the multi-ethnic inclusivity the RF brought. It's inconceivable, as Vizzini might say.

crepesncream · 25/03/2022 15:37

Ireland's presidency two and a half times cheaper. If the president's no good you can vote them out. It's how democracy works.

Blossomtoes · 25/03/2022 15:28

[quote RogueBorg]@Hrpuffnstuff1 the royals are definitely not what makes Britain British Grin. And if it is - then that’s even more reason to get rid of them not less![/quote]
That’s some bizarre logic.

I’m still patiently waiting for someone to explain how and why it would be better for the UK to be a republic - apart from saving a relatively small amount of money, bearing in mind the a presidential system wouldn’t be free.

RogueBorg · 25/03/2022 14:41

@Hrpuffnstuff1 the royals are definitely not what makes Britain British Grin. And if it is - then that’s even more reason to get rid of them not less!

TheKeatingFive · 25/03/2022 14:31

The argument has been presented that RF is wealthy, entitled, privileged, etc, yet they bring in revenue.

What revenue?

Quincunx · 25/03/2022 14:07

crepesncream reddit has a bot that flags up crap and urban myths reposted zillions of times, on here people spend most of their time trying to keep on track 🤷

crepesncream · 25/03/2022 13:25

What revenue do they bring in? They cost us money.Confused

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 25/03/2022 13:13

@TheKeatingFive

In the fiscal year ending March 31, 2020, the Crown Estate pulled in more than $700 million, with more than $475 million in profits.

It's national suicide, even from a financial point of view.

You seem to be misunderstanding the legal status of the Crown Estates. The monarch has no claim or ownership of them at a personal level.

Lol, I know, hence my points.

Hail mary mother of goodness. Do people, deliberately misconstrue a point. Send you to the Westminister hall to be tried before THE KING for being facetious. Grin
The argument has been presented that RF is wealthy, entitled, privileged, etc, yet they bring in revenue. They are also representative of Britains' Global identity and our history.
It's what makes Britain British.

Quincunx · 25/03/2022 11:54

the Queen still traces her descent from Wotan via Cerdic and Alfred the Great.

So was it the gods, or actual God that bestowed the divine right
to murder and scam people rule? Mind boggles.

And when did her family decide it was ok to randomly change theistic approach? Must have been a bit confusing for the peasants. Still is I guess, for us serfs that plug our brains in from time to time.

BattledoreAndShuttlecock · 25/03/2022 11:31

@Briony123

The "descended from God" aspect ended with William & Mary several hundred years ago!
No it didn't, the Queen still traces her descent from Wotan via Cerdic and Alfred the Great. To be fair, so do most of the UK given the numbers of generations involved. That makes me all a tiny bit Valkyrie I reckon.
crepesncream · 25/03/2022 11:01

@Hrpuffnstuff1

I'm not seeing the link between what the Royal family has and what some people don't have.

I think if the idea to rid the country of the monarch was presented as a business plan, you wouldn't find a positive reception. In the fiscal year ending March 31, 2020, the Crown Estate pulled in more than $700 million, with more than $475 million in profits.
It's national suicide, even from a financial point of view.

The Queen's assets are less than 6% of GDP, on the open market without the 'Crown', they'd immediately be devalued.

It's a fantasy argument from all angles, points of view.

The crown estates don't belong to them though. That's why we allow them 15% of the profits. If the royals went the whole lot would revert to us.
Zilla1 · 25/03/2022 10:50

National suicide. We can't risk that just for a few hundred million. We need to act now. Do we think doubling the grant would be enough or should we provide a large enough endowment, the return on which might provide a cushion so we don't ever risk national suicide if adverse events happen in the future. I wonder if the Royal Household or UK plc have the Samaritans number to hand?

CathyorClaire · 25/03/2022 10:43

I think if the idea to rid the country of the monarch was presented as a business plan, you wouldn't find a positive reception

How do you feel about the value of the Sovereign Grant being protected from the Covid hit the Crown Estate took unlike so many other businesses who were left to suck it up? and the fact it's guaranteed never to reduce in value whatever the circumstances?

I reckon most businesses would snatch your hand off for either of those terms let alone both.

CathyorClaire · 25/03/2022 10:35

The Queen's assets

Can you clarify what you're including as 'assets'?

TheKeatingFive · 25/03/2022 09:41

In the fiscal year ending March 31, 2020, the Crown Estate pulled in more than $700 million, with more than $475 million in profits.

It's national suicide, even from a financial point of view.

You seem to be misunderstanding the legal status of the Crown Estates. The monarch has no claim or ownership of them at a personal level.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 25/03/2022 09:17

I'm not seeing the link between what the Royal family has and what some people don't have.

I think if the idea to rid the country of the monarch was presented as a business plan, you wouldn't find a positive reception. In the fiscal year ending March 31, 2020, the Crown Estate pulled in more than $700 million, with more than $475 million in profits.
It's national suicide, even from a financial point of view.

The Queen's assets are less than 6% of GDP, on the open market without the 'Crown', they'd immediately be devalued.

It's a fantasy argument from all angles, points of view.

Swipe left for the next trending thread