Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If 'commoners' can marry into the royal family - why have a 'royal' family -

419 replies

HacketteofHacks · 21/03/2022 12:03

I totally respect the Queen and think she's been largely a force for good...
But at work we were talking about the tour that's on now.. my boss pointed out the the definition of a royal family was that its lineage is 'predetermined by God'.
Well that is archaic in itself - my boss (who is no royalist) the. pointed out that once members of a royal family marry commoners they lose this 'untouchable special-Ness'.
I think he had a good point...
He's from Jamaica so hence we were all having the conversation .

OP posts:
IKnowYouDontTurnTheLightOn · 22/03/2022 15:40

Agreed. They, and many others, still think they’re our betters. Nonsense of course but a surprisingly widely held belief.

IKnowYouDontTurnTheLightOn · 22/03/2022 15:39

www.bitebackpublishing.com/books/and-what-do-you-do

DGRossetti · 22/03/2022 15:38

It used to be argued that the RF were our betters

Your use of the past tense renders your statement partially inaccurate ...

Sloth66 · 22/03/2022 15:34

It used to be argued that the RF were our betters.
Problem is now that we can see in many instances, how they are worse. Not just the likes of Prince Andrew, but the duplicity, self interest and sheer greed detailed in Norman Baker’s book , is pretty disgusting given their wealth.

Quincunx · 22/03/2022 15:00

Britain's influence and power emanate from this form of government

Good job my keyboard wasn't in coffee-spitting range, I mean do you honestly believe that, previous monarchist poster?

In a way it's true though, as Handy Andy negotiates with arms dealers and corrupt regimes so they buy lots of property in London, launder money and take over football clubs etc. Power, wealth and influence for 1 family = lifelong service to the nation?

Zilla1 · 22/03/2022 14:54

@crepesncream it is interesting how the detail of the right to be consulted on new Legislation has then led to lobbying for changes and used for the Crown's benefits when the narrative before was of a self-sacrificing role above the fray acting in everyone's best interests.

Brefugee · 22/03/2022 14:45

The Queen doesn't believe in the divine right of Kings. She won't abdicate because she made a vow to serve as Queen until her death.

because god gave her the job

I would argue the sovereign monarch is a concept from which strong ideologies follow. Sovereignty is a fundamental concept of human existence. Britain's influence and power emanate from this form of government.
Consequently, it would be nearly improbable if not impossible and even foolhardy to replace it with a republic. I would argue that the monarch is a complete necessity for political conditions to form a rational nation-state.
Dreams of republican administration will remain just that if the dreamers can offer no alternative to the fundamental concept of monarchial political power.

Charles, is that you? Monumental guff.

You do realise there are several VERY successful nations that don't have monarchies, right?

Crimesean · 22/03/2022 14:34

This is the sort of bumf that Prince Andrew genuinely believes - he was outraged that his DDs were going to have to work for a living and not be given permanent royal roles and security, as the only (and I quote) "princesses of the blood".

DGRossetti · 22/03/2022 14:22

Would be entirely bloodless

doesn't have to be ....

crepesncream · 22/03/2022 14:18

There's a book by Norman Baker (former minister of transport) called "What do you do""(what the royal family don't want you to know)".....a factual book that lifts the lid on what really goes on with the royals, the greed, the secrecy, the interference with government for their own benefit etc.

I think it might open the eyes of even the most staunch of royalists if they read it.

IKnowYouDontTurnTheLightOn · 22/03/2022 14:18

"I would argue that the monarch is a complete necessity for political conditions to form a rational nation-state."

Seriously???? How can this statement be taken seriously??? Dozens of incredibly well-functioning democracies across Europe don't have a monarch. The idea we need a hereditary head of state in this day in age is total nonsense. There's nothing rational about a HoS chosen on an accident of birth. There is everything rational about a democratically elected HoS, chosen by the people, removed by the people, replaced by the people.

Of course no one wants Putin as our HoS Hmm I think the idea was mentioned as they removed their royals to replace them with a republic - but it's an incredibly poor example obviously. There are many others that have managed it with no issues and have very progressive democracies.

It's totally doable. Would be entirely bloodless and would lead to progress and a less class-based society which can only be good for everyone in this country (except those tiny few that benefit from the status quo, which I'm assuming you're part of).

DGRossetti · 22/03/2022 14:11

Generally the less people know about history, the more they think they are monarchists.

They forget that the Saxons used to elect their kings.

crepesncream · 22/03/2022 14:05

Consequently, it would be nearly improbable if not impossible and even foolhardy to replace it with a republic

No it really wouldn't. Confused

Wishingthreestonesaway · 22/03/2022 14:05

The whole concept of a Royal Family is ridiculous. They don't live a family life that many of us know. Their lives are stifled by protocol and they take on advice from the 'men in grey suits'. The faux sympathy for the Queen when Philip died was crazy. They didn't live together. He lived in a vast 'cottage' in Norfolk while she lived elsewhere. I'm sure that even Kate, who was desperate to be a part of it, must struggle. Hence her extreme weight loss. She had a normal body pre RF. Meghan must havre been aghast at the lifestyle, which is stuck in the 1950s. A President could serve a maximum of four years, so if they were awful, they would soon be replaced. Bring on the Republic.

crepesncream · 22/03/2022 14:02

So many people are impressed by the he queen's vow to serve as queen untill death. I mean it wasn't like a great hardship. I'm sure if it was she'd have stood down by now.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 22/03/2022 14:01

Outdated.Grin

It's the most sophisticated form of human governance ever created.
Ignorance is bliss of course.

Can't believe Russia has been used as an example.
Really, do we want a Stalin or a Putin?

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 22/03/2022 13:58

David Starkey's Monarch gives a comprehensive history of our birth as a Nation-state.
This is what I meant by history.
www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLd8OQ6-KwPrZ5QX8C7NxJdtzxmVM0VVpW

Xpologog · 22/03/2022 13:41

@Brefugee

Where did he get that definition of “predetermined by God” from?

The queen believes that guff which is why she won't abdicate. Divine right of kings - they are chosen by god to be born from the right golden womb.

It is unbelievable in this day and age that this twaddle is still pandered to.

^ This. Won’t be sad to see them go. Outdated, too many hangers on. And how was Camilla predetermined by God?????
AffIt · 22/03/2022 13:39

It's all complete and utter nonsense and needs shelved asap.

The idea that somebody tugs their forelock to another human being, purely by dint of the families they were accidentally born into, is utterly ludicrous.

DGRossetti · 22/03/2022 13:35

Consequently, it would be nearly improbable if not impossible and even foolhardy to replace it with a republic

Oh, it's entirely possible. Ask the Americans. Or French. Or Russians.

DGRossetti · 22/03/2022 13:34

wow I've never heard that argument before about them being a defence against a malevolent government

I have, and it's utter bollocks.

TheKeatingFive · 22/03/2022 13:21

I understand why the Queen won't abdicate/step back, but I think this will be seen as a poor judgement call ultimately.

I can see Charles' reign being pretty rocky. He doesn't have anything like the Queens personal skills and experience and that will be very obvious very quickly. A longer lead in would have helped.

MumsMetHer · 22/03/2022 13:15

The queen believes that guff which is why she won't abdicate. Divine right of kings - they are chosen by god to be born from the right golden womb

The Queen doesn't believe in the divine right of Kings. She won't abdicate because she made a vow to serve as Queen until her death.

Zilla1 · 22/03/2022 13:12

Might be mis-interpreting terminology but I wonder how Barbados and the preceding nations who did the same will cope without this monarch after becoming a Republic? Perhaps it's possible without violent revolution or existential crisis or losing the essence of a 'rational nation state?'

Regarding influence, I suspect it is similar to the notion of tourism. Easy to assert its importance though the figures seem to show there are similar Western European nations that have greater tourism visitors and revenue without a monarch and while each example can be justified by 'It's France', 'It's sunny' and so on, but I think on some rankings, the UK is 6th behind Germany, Turkey, Italy, Spain and France. And all the buildings would remain.

Swipe left for the next trending thread