Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

7rd old fucking football

210 replies

footballfckers · 21/03/2022 11:50

I just wrote out a whole post and then accidentally deleted it.

Really pissed off about football for seven-year-olds and really upset. I am not a person who cries but today I cried. I had a cal from a private sports club who run football training once a week. My son who is 7 was having a 3 week taster and they called today to say he isn't good enough abs can't come back. I am so upset for him. He is such a sensitive little boy who just wants to play and learn.

He plays in a small after school club once a week but can't get him into the village football club either. To get in the village club it seems to be either who you know or sending a WhatsApp at the right moment. My husband has offered to do the Coaching qualifications and now I am thinking maybe we need to make a 'donation'.

He was offered a space in November but was having eye surgery so I asked if he could come in Jan. Tbey said yes and then ghosted me in January.

I don't want to be 'that' parent but my 7yr old needs someone to speak for him and sort these things out. He just wants to play football with his friends.

It's fucking ridiculous.

OP posts:
gizmo · 21/03/2022 17:36

Interesting thread. Very sorry for your boy @footballfckers, no sport should be about making a 7 year old feel bad about themselves.

But football is such a massive cultural thing for small boys. My DS is a big rugby player and loves it, but at primary school would still participate in a football kick about with his mates at school as a social thing.

So I guess the question is what your DS wants from football? Does he want to be respected by his peer group, to play a sport he's mad about, or to win games? Or is it something else?

Someone asked how rugby is able to accommodate a wider range of competence and I think the answer is partly a) bigger teams b) it needs a greater variety of skills, especially as you get older. So there are a lot of opportunities for kids to develop quite niche but valued skills, and feel they contribute in that way.

LookMoreCloselier · 21/03/2022 17:35

We took ds1 out of the village football club as it was too competitive and a drag driving him around to festivals all over the place every weekend when he just wanted a kick about. Instead we put him into training for kids at Goals, do you have one nearby as they might have similar, we only knew it was on because dh plays there too.

MasterBeth · 21/03/2022 17:20

Our boys played football and rugby. Both were coached by "competitive dads" and, even when they thought they weren't, couldn't really get out of the mindset that winning matches was what they were there for. That naturally lead to playing the best players for longer and recruiting for better players over time.

For me, subjecting under 11s to that mentality is mercilessly cruel, and over 11s still pretty mean, although by secondary school age they are at least a bit more aware of their own abilities and frailties at sports.

One problem is, football is culturally enormous - and a brilliant sport. Playing lacrosse or hockey or orienteering might seem like a more pleasant alternative, but it's not football. Kids want to play football.

Another problem is that no-one wants to play in a team where everyone is even more shit than them. Our boys wanted to compete with players of their standard, not a poorer standard.

IKnowYouDontTurnTheLightOn · 21/03/2022 17:17

@MrsAvocet you have put it far more eloquently than me. But you're right - this is what I was trying to say. Football doesn't teach that ethos at all - and you see it in the school playground and on the pitch from a very young age. It comes from the parents, the kids and the coaches.

And then it comes through to the professional game too.

It's very sad. Change will start from the grass roots too. But it would appear that those in the 'less-than-beautiful' game don't appear to see it as a problem which is, itself, the problem.

It's odd how sports such as rugby and hockey can play in mixed ability teams and yet footballers can't?

MrsAvocet · 21/03/2022 17:13

There is no value to anyone in players of different abilities being on the same team. Even at 7, they know. The less able kids don't get passed to, the more able kids get frustrated and hog the ball. It benefits no one.
Well that, I would say, depends on how they have been coached. When my DS was playing junior hockey their team varied from kids who were in the regional and county squads, to brand new starters and a couple with learning disabilities. They all got a great deal of value from it, as players, and more importantly, people.
And had any of the higher level players ever behaved how you describe they would have had plenty of time to reflect on their behaviour from the bench. But they didn't, because that was not the ethos of the club and they knew it.
They regularly didn't win of course, but whether you view that as important or not depends on what you think the purpose of grassroots sport is I suppose.
Interestingly, not only has that particular club been over represented for years in the county squad and above, it's produced more than it's fair share of county captains and "players' players" etc. Surprising, for coaches who adopt a strategy that is of no value to anyone. Or then again, maybe it's not surprising at all.

tttigress · 21/03/2022 16:55

Can't believe the company said he couldn't continue.

I thought these companies made money by coaching kids, surely if they have one less kid, it is less money?

BogRollBOGOF · 21/03/2022 16:48

@arethereanyleftatall

There is no value to anyone in players of different abilities being on the same team. Even at 7, they know. The less able kids don't get passed to, the more able kids get frustrated and hog the ball. It benefits no one. For sure, there should be a team for all types, but they're generally volunteer led, so unless you're doing the volunteering, you can't really complain. I think on this thread you can really tell which people don't volunteer for anything and have no real understanding of it at all.
I commented upthread about DS's experience. I'm already tied up with Scouting, Guiding and organising junior parkruns. You tend to find with volunteers that they'll often do multiple things, but there's a limit to what they can take on. I'm full. I also know that football has up to 11 players including a goal keeper, you kick the ball towards your goal and swap ends at half time, and that's about it. Girls weren't taught boys' sports at my school, not that I had any aptitude for team/ ball sports. DH grew up in a country where soccer was not the priority sport so he'd also be pretty useless at volunteering, so we can't solve DS's issues that way. I've already bailed out his Beavers then Cubs in the face of leader shortages while maintaining my Guiding unit.

Just volunteer yourself isn't that simple. You need appropriate skills and the time to commit. More could do it, but it's not a viable solution to everyone.

footballfckers · 21/03/2022 16:48

@nodogz we tried going to a for profit organisation and they kicked him out as they didn't think he was good enough. This was after 2 sessions abs I had explained he had played very little before.

OP posts:
mumda · 21/03/2022 16:48

Start your own team!

nodogz · 21/03/2022 16:41

If your ds is a standard player interested in fun/teamwork and not a technically skilled player your options are; setting up a team to coach yourself (our club would be very open to this) or to join a football skills weekly session that someone puts on for profit.

Kids football is brutal. They get organised in to leagues at a very young age and some teams can be very competitive. They rely heavily on parents coaching and this does mean they are not always fair on entry. Also, the kids playing together do need to be a similar standard from about age 8 as they just don't pass to less skilled kids on the pitch after this. Like I said it's brutal!

I do think there's a big gap for kids who want to train and play for fun.

My ds is 9, has been in his team since he was 4, is a skilled player (gets offers from other teams regularly), plays non-stop at school and at home, and his dad is on the football team board. We book our holidays around football and we are considered quite hands off as kids football families go!

There are times when the kids go from five a side to seven a side and so on which means there's more space in teams so you might get a place then.

There seems a bit more flex in tennis, rugby and cricket for the balance of skills and fun so possibly they might be the way to go for interest and skills?

IKnowYouDontTurnTheLightOn · 21/03/2022 16:38

@footballfckers I really would encourage your DS to give rugby a go and see if he likes it Smile.

IKnowYouDontTurnTheLightOn · 21/03/2022 16:37

Haha! Nope - you couldn't be more wrong. I've volunteered to help at every activity my children belong to, because it's only fair that I help out. I've taught kids sport for decades, including coaching hockey, so I do know a little bit about it. Football seems to be the exception in ensuring they make kids feel shit about their abilities from a very young age. It really doesn't need to be that way but it's not going to change which is why I was never prepared to get involved with football. I've never had one word of abuse from parents in the other teams I've helped out in, but the horror stories I've heard and witnessed from football parents was enough to put me off for life.

footballfckers · 21/03/2022 16:36

Thanks for all the suggestions. They have two teams already abs my husband has offered to lead a third and apparently there are enough children . I am just frustrated at tbe lack of transparency in the process and the wishybwashy response from the current coaches on whether we can even come to training.

OP posts:
arethereanyleftatall · 21/03/2022 16:33

There is no value to anyone in players of different abilities being on the same team. Even at 7, they know. The less able kids don't get passed to, the more able kids get frustrated and hog the ball. It benefits no one. For sure, there should be a team for all types, but they're generally volunteer led, so unless you're doing the volunteering, you can't really complain.
I think on this thread you can really tell which people don't volunteer for anything and have no real understanding of it at all.

BeautifulDragon · 21/03/2022 16:27

[quote IKnowYouDontTurnTheLightOn]@BeautifulDragon how does rugby get around the different abilities then? My eldest son is an exceptional rugby player, my youngest not so much. They still both are accepted and encouraged on the rugby field equally. I think it teaches so much about tolerance and acceptance if they play with different ability kids. I'm afraid as a teacher I can usually spot the kids who play on an outside football team a mile off, and it's rarely for their sportsmanship Sad.[/quote]
I have no idea about rugby, so I can't answer.

But you can't really have an open door 'everyone come and play' policy, when it's a 5-a-side game. They can't all play, because there isn't enough space.

I guess what I'm trying to say is, if you want more teams then more parents need to volunteer to run them.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 21/03/2022 16:18

I am having problems with football for 7 year old DS too. He plays in what was meant to be a friendly, casual team, but as the boys improve it is becoming more competitive. The coach is great and everyone gets to play but even at the age of 7 it is perfectly clear DS is not great, and a hierarchy is emerging between the boys who are good and the ones who are not. Since I don't give a shit about football I would prefer him to give it a miss and focus on athletics, which he is good at, but he wants to stick with football.

I understand the competitive nature is what makes it exciting, but it bothers me how young the line is drawn and less able players squeezed out.

IKnowYouDontTurnTheLightOn · 21/03/2022 16:17

@BeautifulDragon how does rugby get around the different abilities then? My eldest son is an exceptional rugby player, my youngest not so much. They still both are accepted and encouraged on the rugby field equally. I think it teaches so much about tolerance and acceptance if they play with different ability kids. I'm afraid as a teacher I can usually spot the kids who play on an outside football team a mile off, and it's rarely for their sportsmanship Sad.

BeautifulDragon · 21/03/2022 16:14

My DH coaches my son's u7 team.

When it started all the kids were just playing together in one big group, then they asked some parents to volunteer and they split them into 4 team according to ability. Some didn't want to be in teams and left. The league goes from A-G, with G being the lowest ability, so room for everyone!

It's difficult because you need the children to be of a similar ability or it just doesn't work. If one child isn't as good as the rest of the team it's very noticeable and frustrating all round.

There's only 8 children on my DS's team, so the spaces are very limited. If you're not there at the beginning, or a really good player, then the chances are you will struggle to find a team.

But ultimately if you want your child on a football team and the club doesn't have any spaces available, then offering to start and manage a new team is the way to go.

My DS loves his team, they are the best of friends and it's been a fantastic experience for him, but the team wouldn't exist if DH didn't offer to run it.

balalake · 21/03/2022 16:04

There is only a few weeks left of the season, hope you can find somewhere before September.

inmyslippers · 21/03/2022 15:55

That's soo sad, sport should be for everyone. Hope you find another club

IKnowYouDontTurnTheLightOn · 21/03/2022 15:55

@Labracadabradoodle isn't this part of the problem though Sad? Why do football teams for 7 year olds care so much about 'off seasons and leagues? If any child approaches my boys' rugby team at any time, they can join. They don't get all stressed about teams and leagues and who's good and who's not - they just play. I think kids' football has lost it's way and it's such a shame. At that age they should just be playing for fun and not having dads on the touchline screaming abuse at their own and other people's kids because they're 'not good enough'. Sad

Labracadabradoodle · 21/03/2022 15:51

You could also looking for kids kickabout/skills sessions run by any of the bigger league clubs near you. Normally advertised on their websites.

Ozanj · 21/03/2022 15:48

In some areas social football is in schools. Out of school is when the local football teams start scouting and so players need to be good or they’ll stop scouting. You need to stick with the team, attend all the training / warm up sessions, and work your way up. You don’t need to have a place on the team to get the social benefits if you just stick with it.

salemcat · 21/03/2022 15:42

Don't get this shit at rugby here🏉🏉. Loath sports that do that to kids!

Labracadabradoodle · 21/03/2022 15:30

This may also help
www.thefa.com/play-football