Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that being honest about telling the truth about having a baby means you're judged as having mental health issues?

58 replies

BabyFeb22 · 21/03/2022 11:24

Just that really! I had my beautiful first DD 5 weeks ago. Last week I posted on social media the truth... basically saying that social media makes all new babies/parenting look perfect and like a breeze when actually let's be honest it's bloody hard work!! This resulting in me getting at least 6 private messages asking if I was coping and saying I should speak to the doctors if not. Has social media really got to a point where we can no longer be truthful? AIBU in this was just caring messages or is it that no one likes the truth anymore and if you don't have a 'prefect' life then something must be wrong.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Latecomer131 · 22/03/2022 10:16

@Donra , I agree. I am late 30s with a 4 month old, and this is why DH and I decided in advance that we'd be sticking at just one. (We both work full time and have no extended family help nearby.)

In my social circle, most of the hetro couples where the woman has kept her career and hobbies post kids have stopped at just one kid. The only exceptions are : 1) one couple I know where the male partner has an extremely flexible WFH remote job and the woman works part time. 2) Another couple who are living abroad, where it's extremely cheap (compared to the UK) to hire a full time nanny.

Asthenia · 21/03/2022 21:53

Agree with @groeggmeg …tbh I feel like all I read about is how hard motherhood/having a baby is so I feel like I was pretty well prepared. I have an 11 week old baby and I found the first 4 weeks pretty hard going as I was knackered from birth and we were getting into our groove with sleeping. However I can genuinely say I started to enjoy it from about 5 weeks onwards and so far we have been lucky enough to have a very contented and fairly chill baby. I haven’t found things particularly difficult so far - it didn’t come as a surprise to me that I wouldn’t be able to get stuff done as quickly or efficiently as I used to. However I appreciate that it’s totally luck of the draw and a lot of people have it much harder.
I still feel like I hardly ever read anything positive about having a baby though.

groeggmeg · 21/03/2022 20:51

I don’t really understand why anything needs to be announced on social media. I just accept social media is a highlight reel and I actually find the ‘raw’ and ‘honest’ posts equally disingenuous. Equally we are all different, I didn’t find a new born phase that hard so the post would resonate as ‘oh I hope she’s not struggling’ to me and if I t was a good friend of message to check in. The toddler years however was a totally different story..

LemonDrizzles · 21/03/2022 20:39

If you were my friend on social media and I saw that post and knew the baby was 5 weeks I would not have responded because that is a known hard part, the week before baby smiling typically begins...

EmmaH2022 · 21/03/2022 20:36

I find that ridiculous

You didn't even say anything controversial. Certainly your post is not what I expected from the title. The observation that parenting is hard really shouldn't warrant that response.

myyellowcar · 21/03/2022 20:29

@BulletTrain

For me, it wasn't about people caring, it was about being told to I should go to the Dr for depression if I was having a bad day/week because that wasn't "normal".
Totally agree. I remember telling my sister that I was finding it hard, and rather than listening to what I was actually saying about the reality of life at that time, she went all head tilty and I know she was thinking about PND.

I didn’t have PND by the way, I just found the relentlessness tedious and missed my old life. People are very quite to say there is something ‘wrong’ when it really is a bomb going off in the middle of your life and you finding your feet as the dust settles.

Calandor · 21/03/2022 20:28

I think they're just trying to look out for you. PND is very common and they want you to feel supported if you're finding it hard for whatever reason.

SophieG121 · 21/03/2022 20:26

I agree with what you're saying OP. I don't use social media but when I have talked about my much harder experience with my second baby (currently 5 months) compared to my easier first baby, people seem to think I'm not coping when actually I just want to rant about not being able to eat/drink/shower etc.

inheritancetrack · 21/03/2022 20:16

Tell the truth to friends in a small face to face group and they will all say the same. Say it on social media and you get the reaction you did.

SM is not real life just an unrealistic facsimile

Hugasauras · 21/03/2022 19:51

I think it just depends tbh. In my antenatal group, three of us are having/have had a second (out of four; it was a small group) and all of us will be going back to work after maternity leave or have already gone back. We are all mid-late 30s. And two of us have no family within three hours drive.

Experiences are just so varied and individual tbh.

BingBangB0ng · 21/03/2022 19:17

@LittleGwyneth

Honestly all I've heard is the opposite. I hear how hard it is, miserable, lonely, exhausting. No-one has told me how fun or exciting it's going to be. It would be nice to get a bit more balance.
If you don’t normally post on social media about finding life hard, your friends probably assumed you did so because you hoped to find some support. It doesn’t mean they’re judging you, it just looked like you were reaching out.

I think it’s fine to moan on social media, god knows I’ve been known to do it, but I don’t understand the hate from some posters towards people posting highlights. It’s natural to want to share nice moments.

BulletTrain · 21/03/2022 19:05

@Donra

Yes pretty much. The couples who both have full time jobs and no parental support have had their first child and gone “fuck this is hard and between parenting and working I have no life”. So they’re not keen to make it worse by having a second child. The only people who can cope with more than one kid are those who either don’t work or can fob their kids off on family so they can still have a life.
My NCT group are all over 30 (first baby is 4). 5 out of 8 have had a second baby (twins in one case) and 4 out of those 5 are SAHMs.

Even here where childcare is cheap, 3 days a week at nursery for 2 under 2s is £1200 a month. It's not hard to see why this pattern happens.

Donra · 21/03/2022 18:59

Yes pretty much. The couples who both have full time jobs and no parental support have had their first child and gone “fuck this is hard and between parenting and working I have no life”. So they’re not keen to make it worse by having a second child. The only people who can cope with more than one kid are those who either don’t work or can fob their kids off on family so they can still have a life.

TheOrigRights · 21/03/2022 18:55

@Donra

Virtually everyone I know who is 30s-40s has had one kid and said no more because it’s too hard. Those who have had a second child either don’t work for a living or have incredibly supportive parents.

The older generation who like to say how great it is to have kids are invariably people who were a married couple with a SAHM who never worked and a father in a stable job, with a nice suburban house and a local community of other SAHMs and kids. None of them ever had to juggle childcare and work. Otherwise they’d be saying the same as our generation is: it’s too hard.

Gosh, you must move in very, very different circles to me.

The only people you know with more than one child are SAHM or have supportive parents?

Donra · 21/03/2022 18:32

Virtually everyone I know who is 30s-40s has had one kid and said no more because it’s too hard. Those who have had a second child either don’t work for a living or have incredibly supportive parents.

The older generation who like to say how great it is to have kids are invariably people who were a married couple with a SAHM who never worked and a father in a stable job, with a nice suburban house and a local community of other SAHMs and kids. None of them ever had to juggle childcare and work. Otherwise they’d be saying the same as our generation is: it’s too hard.

Sceptre86 · 21/03/2022 18:28

It's nice that they were caring though. Pnd presents in different ways, not all mothers who have it are apathetic to their baby, I know from my own experience I had horrendous feelings of guilt that I failed to keep her safe inside me, that I didn't have a natural birth, that breastfeeding was a struggle. At the time I thought that things were challenging but that with a tiny baby most mums would feel like I did so I glossed over it, looking back now I recognise the pnd for what it was and was more alert to those feelings in my subsequent pregnancies. Thankfully I didn't experience it again with pregnancy two and three but I did know where I could reach out to for help.

As for saying its rough with a new baby, it can be. It was for me with my first but despite a small age gap my son was great and I adjusted to 2 under 2 really well. My 3rd had been a breeze and she's just easy, there have been a few challenges as she has had reflux and initial slow weight gain but she is thriving and most importantly sleeps. Not all parents find it difficult struggle in the early days.

Notdoingthis · 21/03/2022 17:23

I would check my friendnwas ok of she posted that. You are assuming your experience is the same for everyone. When I had my first I was amazed at how easy and joyful it all was. I didn't understand what all the fuss was about.

Strawmite · 21/03/2022 15:16

It’s hard I have had friends say ‘why does no one tell you how hard it is’ and others who get upset as parents have been ‘scaring’ them with the realities of parenting. What’s the perfect way to pitch it? I try to just be supportive of new parents and acknowledge the difficulties rather than force them to ‘enjoy every second!!!!’ and listen to them when they need it.

RantyAunty · 21/03/2022 15:13

No social media when mine were born but yes, parts were terrible and difficult. I was also pretty excited about it too.

I'm happy there wasn't social media. Did have to worry about taking perfect pictures and having silly made up things to post about.

contrary13 · 21/03/2022 14:53

SM is a fallacy; an illusion at the best of times and out-right lies at the worst. And I'm willing to hedge bets that these "are you alright, hun?" messages were from either non-parents or those mothers who portray the perfect life with their newborns/toddlers...?

I had my youngest before most of my friends started to have their babies, and there's a large age-gap between my duo. When first-time parent friends asked me what to expect, I was brutally honest with them. Lack of bodily autonomy, the torture of sleep deprivation, the whole horrific healing process of a mother's body for weeks afterwards, the crushing sense of loneliness when you're trapped alone in the middle of the night cluster feeding a restless baby, having to make the decision between your little finger and a dummy even though you've always been so outspoken against them (... unfortunately for my youngest; I needed my little finger!), the risk of bacteria preventing you from having the birth you want because you need to put your baby's life first (group B strep)...

... and yep; I got the "are you coping, hun?" head-tilty questions. Even though my youngest was 2/3 years old plus at the time. Now their children are pre-teens up, they're all quizzing me about the teenage wilderness (mine are 26 and 17), and I'm very much "do as I did and work it out for yourselves!" about a lot of it.

Yet all of their SM "lives"? Perfect. No problems. There's no sign on Friend A's IG that her child tried to kill their neighbours guinea pigs with a golf club, for example, or how Friend B's son is doing drugs with my much older son's former group pf friends, or of how Friend C's teenager has decided they're non-binary, self-harming and having sex with a much older teen (of the opposing birth sex). Nope. All of their SM "lives" are rosy as fuck.

Mine on the other hand? This morning, on FB I was complaining about my 17 year old not being able to get out of bed on time and then leave enough hot water in the tank for his older sibling - not to mention my ire at the amount of wet towels I'm expected to pick up after the pair of them. Yesterday, it was them both telling me they were home for dinner last week, so I budget around a full Sunday Roast... and then they get better offers and fuck off elsewhere. I'm very honest on my SM, but also very aware that 99% users of it... are not.

@BabyFeb22, from one long-time Mum to a new-time Mum... keep on being honest about what your experience of parenthood is. Why? Because this is YOUR story. Your journey with your little one, which one day, they'll be able to access/look back on and feel grateful for your honesty, rather than their peers thinking a newborn shits roses and rainbows.

Flowers
Onlyforcake · 21/03/2022 14:42

"social" media is not an arena where sharing your personal thoughts and genuine feelings will get you any support etc, in general. Kind of ironic. But i think of social media is for edited highlights only. Noone has time for people's actual lives on there. I don't consider anyone on social media a friend unless they are someone who is likely to use a more private means of communicating regularly.

LimeSupper · 21/03/2022 14:37

There’s no one universal experience of having a newborn. It’s not the truth, it’s your truth. You can express how hard you’ve found things and it sounds as though there are some people who’ve tried to show care?! Some people will struggle in silence of course but others will genuinely be full of joy. It’s different for everyone. I’ve had two babies and to be honest found the newborn months delightful as they were so precious, really easy babies and very sleepy! There were tough days of course but I wouldn’t have been lying to say I loved those early days. If you want to voice your own experience then of course do so but I wouldn’t see it as exposing a hidden truth.

Ducksurprise · 21/03/2022 14:30

I agree with rethinking it, you have lovely friends.

Also worth bearing in mind we forget what it is like to have a small baby. Looking back it is all sunshine and roses, the bone crippling tiredness and relentless slog is all forgotten. Hence why people have more.

ForeverSingle881 · 21/03/2022 14:28

YABU. All I hear from everyone of my generation (30-40s) is how hard and awful it is having kids. I literally do not know a single person who says it's wonderful, only my parents and older people say that. It's like a competition of who hates parenthood more, like you're some saint managing to give birth and care for a baby, it's exhausting. I get that it's hard but your picture of things is the complete opposite of what I'm seeing.

You posted you were struggling, most people would interpret that as a cry for help and, being caring people, they reached out to you. If you're not struggling, then it sounds like you were just attention seeking.

WarmWinterSun · 21/03/2022 14:03

OP I probably would have done the same as your friends. I find social media an odd place anyway, but I would worry about a friend sharing publicly that things are hard because to me it could appear a cry for help. But I am pretty careful about what I post publicly and so may not relate to many people who use it to share all kinds of things.