Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Reservations over Dads new will?

184 replies

MsMiaWallace · 20/03/2022 21:13

After a conversation with my dad this morning he informed me he was renewing his will following a health scare.

My Dad is currently retired, is very comfortable. Mortgage free 3 bed semi, owns a narrowboat & has around £70k if not more in his account.
He has a partner who lives with him.
She basically lives off him, barely works or contributes. This is how it has been since she met him.

I never challenge this as he's happy with the situation & it's his choice.
They've been together around 4 years. Since meeting her he has distanced from us & we were close.

This morning he told me that he is changing his will so although his house would be mine she has to stay at the property until she chooses to leave.
Again his choice however I am concerned that it is a large house. She's in her 60s & will be too big for her to maintain alone therefore I will have to upkeep the property whilst she continues to live there rent free?
I also have my own mortgage to pay, family to look after etc whilst doing this.
He told me I would be the landlord but without the rent.
She also has a son that will likely move in with her who also does not contribute.

I absolutely respect that it's his choice but
AIBU here to have reservations about this situation?

OP posts:
moose62 · 21/03/2022 09:48

I think it puts you in a very difficult position! Depending on whether it says she must have sole occupancy after his death, I would move in with my children and rest my own house out. Obviously she is welcome to live there as long as she wants to but you will be living there as well.

MsMiaWallace · 21/03/2022 09:46

I don't even know if he is doing a life interest trust.
As he said it will be hers to live in until she chooses to leave.

OP posts:
lunar1 · 21/03/2022 09:43

You would have to take out buildings insurance on the house. I have an apartment that I rent out and there is a lot involved. I don't know how it would work legally if it's been forced on you. Things like landlords insurance, all the various safety checks. If it's furnished are you responsible for repairs and maintenance?

As my apartment is fully furnished I have to allow for repairing/replacing all the appliances, replacing carpets and furniture when needed.

How does all this work if there is no income, I think you need legal advice of your own. Can you imagine having to replace the boiler on the place!

Gonnagetgoing · 21/03/2022 09:40

In OP's case - the partner has been there 4 years which isn't long really, and if she's planning on moving her son in then she does seem to be a bit of a user.

However, her DF can do what he likes with the house.

HELLITHURT · 21/03/2022 09:40

@AllOfUsAreDead

Jesus can't believe some people on here. 'she's been a big part of his life for 4 years?'. Yes I'm sure it was very difficult for her, not working not contributing and spending someone else's money. Hmm

Op is his daughter?! She's been a bigger part of his life from a lot longer, maybe like 4 DECADES. And this is how he treats his daughter for some moronic woman who can't provide for herself so leeches off other people? I suppose the ones saying you are being grabby op do the same thing. I'd ignore them.

I'd tell my dad he can do that if he wishes but I won't be paying any bills for her, or maintenance. If she wants to live there, she can pretend it's hers until she dies, then I turf the idiot son out and sell it.

I can't believe some parents. Willing to do this to their children for some twit that refuses to work and leeches off people. I bet when he becomes frail she'll say its too hard for her and either get op to care for him or send him to a home. Then she'll bring in her next arm candy to leech off.

She doesn't need to pretend it's hers until she dies, it is hers until she dies if she chooses to live there.

She is the life tenant, the OP has no need to pay for maintenance etc, until the other woman dies she is responsible.

Her father is of sound mind, so he can make this decision with his estate. It is very common for this to be the case when second partners are in the picture.

It is irrelevant who has know the DF longer, it's not about that.

And no, I am not living with a man as a second partner, I am married to my first husband and completely self sufficient and would be if he passed away. So stop with those ridiculous comments, it just shows your ignorance. OP can ignore everyone if she wants, but the facts remain that her father has made a decision to arrange a life interest trust, his money, his house, his choice.

The reason a life interest trust exists, is because of these exact situation.

You have a very low opinion of this woman maybe she will nurse him during the last years of his life, maybe she will have years of him being disabled and her needing to nurse her.

Is OPs DF happy, if he is then that's all that matters really, not who pays for what.

Gonnagetgoing · 21/03/2022 09:39

It's interesting re this - DM owns her house (paid mortgage off by herself) with stepdad, he's been with her 40 years or more but not married.

But stepdad is 10 years younger than DM and also has a property that was jointly owned with DM but when it was sold he got profits and are in savings. They also have a holiday home in SW France, jointly owned.

When DM dies (in her will) the house is to be sold and profits split 3 ways, between me, DB and stepdad. OK it's stepdad's home but she wants us both to have benefits of the profits. If he wanted to buy us out he could but it's a big house for 1 person.

lljkk · 21/03/2022 09:38

What if you asked to inherit the narrow boat instead & his gf can inherit the house? If she has to sell it to buy somewhere smaller (free up cash for home maintenance) then so be it. She'd have a lot of security and you're not tied to her decisions going forward.

My grandmother's home was put in a similar situation where my aunt can live there as long as aunt wants. I'm not sure about income for maintenance, but something has been arranged between aunt's & her 5 siblings, as they all will benefit when property is eventually sold. This decision still caused a lot of friction within a very close set of siblings, even though aunt is probably the most popular & poorest sibling in the group.

MsMiaWallace · 21/03/2022 09:37

No clearly I don't think he should kick her out

OP posts:
maddy68 · 21/03/2022 09:35

What do you think he should do?kick her out of her home when he dies?

I do think it needs to be worded better. Eg. She has the right to live there until death but pay you rent (so you can cover maintaince etc )

AllOfUsAreDead · 21/03/2022 09:28

Jesus can't believe some people on here. 'she's been a big part of his life for 4 years?'. Yes I'm sure it was very difficult for her, not working not contributing and spending someone else's money. Hmm

Op is his daughter?! She's been a bigger part of his life from a lot longer, maybe like 4 DECADES. And this is how he treats his daughter for some moronic woman who can't provide for herself so leeches off other people? I suppose the ones saying you are being grabby op do the same thing. I'd ignore them.

I'd tell my dad he can do that if he wishes but I won't be paying any bills for her, or maintenance. If she wants to live there, she can pretend it's hers until she dies, then I turf the idiot son out and sell it.

I can't believe some parents. Willing to do this to their children for some twit that refuses to work and leeches off people. I bet when he becomes frail she'll say its too hard for her and either get op to care for him or send him to a home. Then she'll bring in her next arm candy to leech off.

Neighbours87 · 21/03/2022 09:26

Op you need to get legal advise. The same happened my friend and the ended up being liable for tax, insurance etc. Whilst also having difficulty securing finance. In their case they would have been better being left with nothing. A right of residency is watertight. The house will be worse than worthless to you.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 21/03/2022 09:22

@PermanentTemporary

Perhaps just check if you would be liable for inheritance tax on the house, and whether paying it could be delayed until it is sold, possibly decades ahead?

Mn isn't the only place where people assume that planning for the future is grabby and unpleasant. If you're going to get landed with bills for tens of thousands and no means to pay it, it's perfectly reasonable to ask a few questions.

A landlord has no such right
WorriedMutha · 21/03/2022 09:21

I think you need to explain to your father that you don't want a life long relationship with this woman. There's huge potential for conflict. Surely it would be better if the will provides that the house is sold and some of the sale proceeds are applied to house her. That way a designated sum is hers and she can make some provision for her son. Your father's proposal potentially leaves nothing to him and therefore his partner may see more merit in a straight forward sale and division.

Quartz2208 · 21/03/2022 09:18

Neither do I get the whole unwllingness to sort all of these things out - proper planning for these things is vital and everyone should have a will and have discussions with relatives about these things

Sugarplumfairy65 · 21/03/2022 09:18

@Bogeyes

Who will pay the council tax?
The occupant pays the council tax
HELLITHURT · 21/03/2022 09:17

@brainhurts

I would make sure she is responsible for all repairs and upkeep, and you as landlord have the right to inspect the hours at any time
She is not a landlord! She has a remainder interest.

She had no rights to barge in whenever she wants!

Quartz2208 · 21/03/2022 09:16

[quote MsMiaWallace]@Quartz2208 thank you!

Of course I am fine with his choice. It's his to choose.
I'm not ok with potentially being financially responsible for the upkeep. It was the landlord without the rent part that threw me. He told me it would be in my interest to look after it as it's my asset.

I too have a mortgage to pay, kids & my husband has a life limiting illness that I may be required to care for him in time. [/quote]
I think the issue is you cannot talk to him. He should be making provisions for this as well alongside the house in order to keep that all ticking along - plus how on earth is she going to pay for bills.

I dont think it is being grabby that you sit down with him (possibly having done some research on life interest tenancy there is plenty about) and talk him through those kind of aspects including what you can and cant do as a trustee (which I assume you will be).

Maybe even ask to be with his solicitor as the will is drawn up so you are aware of the responsibilities.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 21/03/2022 09:13

@StrawberryPot

It's his money, not yours.

Wrong. Op is worried about the cost implication to her of the proposed arrangement.

Then she can refuse the inheritance
Sugarplumfairy65 · 21/03/2022 09:11

@SquirrelG

Having heard recently of a woman in her early 80s who is about to be forced out of her home upon the death of her husband I think your father is doing the honourable thing. Normally in these situations the person living in the house is responsible for the upkeep while they live there.

You sound rather bitter. Your father has a companion and is presumably happy with her, and he is not actuallly leaving the house to her, it will come to you eventually. He can actually leave his possessions to whoever he likes - I find all this angst about what people might/might not get from someone once they die distasteful.

So do I. The poor man isn't dead yet and the op is circling and complaining about what he wants to do with his property
beachcitygirl · 21/03/2022 09:10

[quote StrawberryPot]@beachcitygirl - try reading the thread properly before you start slinging spiteful and vindictive insults about? Hmm[/quote]
I have read the full thread.

I'm far from the only person calling op grabby, which imho she is.

I also wouldn't want this type of liability hanging over my head so were I in op shoes.
I would simply say dad. I'm a grown woman, leave your house to the woman you love. If you want to remember me in your will in another way, fabulous, but it's your money. You've earned it, spend every dime enjoying your life, travel, spend, have a world cruise - whatever. It's yours.

As far as I'm concerned the joy of a father is having one, not what I'll potentially get when he goes. Or making him worry that the woman he loves will be out on the street.

ThatsGoingToHurt · 21/03/2022 09:09

I would see a solicitor and see what you be liable for and if the costs are excessive I would be tempted to tell your dad you don’t want to inherit the house due to the additional costs.

If you already own a house and want to buy a new one you may have to pay additional rate stamp duty

I presume inheritance tax may be payable when the house is sold which you will need to pay

If he doesn’t set the trust up properly you may have to pay to maintain the house. Im assuming if you are the landlord you will also have to pay for landlords insurance and gas safety certificates

You DFs partner could move her son and a new partner in. The son could then move his partner and kids in.

What happens if she become frail and needs the house adapted. Do you have to pay for that?

If the house falls into disrepair and she won’t maintain it?

He could give her the 70k plus narrowboat which she could sell

ChoiceMummy · 21/03/2022 09:09

@MsMiaWallace

I believe upon speaking to a solicitor he will go with the life interest trust. Would I still have to pay maintenance at the property?
No, while the Life Tenant is in occupation of the Property they are liable for its upkeep and all costs relating to the Property, such as Insurance. But you will struggle to make her do this.
MsMiaWallace · 21/03/2022 09:06

@Quartz2208 thank you!

Of course I am fine with his choice. It's his to choose.
I'm not ok with potentially being financially responsible for the upkeep. It was the landlord without the rent part that threw me. He told me it would be in my interest to look after it as it's my asset.

I too have a mortgage to pay, kids & my husband has a life limiting illness that I may be required to care for him in time.

OP posts:
Quartz2208 · 21/03/2022 09:02

I dont think the OP is being grabby - I get the impression she is fine with it but doesnt want to have to pay out for maintenance etc and wants everything to be sorted.

Maintenance/Council tax etc should be their responsiblity. It isnt the same as being a landlord as the property is held in trust and the OP Dads partner should be responsible for everything

That said @MsMiaWallace I am concerned that your Dad has phrased it that way that you are the landlord - you should have some powers as trustee. Indeed is he making you a trustee. BEcause he should be leaving enough money as well or some means of her to be able to maintain it as well. It should not be down to you.

StrawberryPot · 21/03/2022 09:02

@beachcitygirl - try reading the thread properly before you start slinging spiteful and vindictive insults about? Hmm

Swipe left for the next trending thread