Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Reservations over Dads new will?

184 replies

MsMiaWallace · 20/03/2022 21:13

After a conversation with my dad this morning he informed me he was renewing his will following a health scare.

My Dad is currently retired, is very comfortable. Mortgage free 3 bed semi, owns a narrowboat & has around £70k if not more in his account.
He has a partner who lives with him.
She basically lives off him, barely works or contributes. This is how it has been since she met him.

I never challenge this as he's happy with the situation & it's his choice.
They've been together around 4 years. Since meeting her he has distanced from us & we were close.

This morning he told me that he is changing his will so although his house would be mine she has to stay at the property until she chooses to leave.
Again his choice however I am concerned that it is a large house. She's in her 60s & will be too big for her to maintain alone therefore I will have to upkeep the property whilst she continues to live there rent free?
I also have my own mortgage to pay, family to look after etc whilst doing this.
He told me I would be the landlord but without the rent.
She also has a son that will likely move in with her who also does not contribute.

I absolutely respect that it's his choice but
AIBU here to have reservations about this situation?

OP posts:
Cheeserton · 21/03/2022 14:12

This would never actually stand up. You can't impose huge obligations and expenses on people involuntarily with a will. I strongly suspect you could find your way out later if necessary.

AdaColeman · 21/03/2022 13:55

@MsMiaWallace

Not sure where I would stand if she did move a new partner in?
The will should be drawn up in such a way as to prohibit this. Many divorces include a clause stating that cohabiting or marriage with a new partner terminates the right to remain in the property. It's a standard thing obviously.

It would be far better for you if your Father left you the narrow boat, and his partner the house. While the boat would be worth less than the house, you could sell it immediately, with no possible financial commitment for years ahead.

MsMiaWallace · 21/03/2022 13:23

Not sure where I would stand if she did move a new partner in?

OP posts:
AllOfUsAreDead · 21/03/2022 13:15

@Quartz2208

Its not totally about his partner, but she could be the influence here for this. But yes it's her dad's reluctance to discuss it and to sort this out to protect his daughter that is the problem. He's not going to do that from the sounds of it, he could be leaving his daughter with a major hassle, debt and many problems, all for a woman he has known for a tiny portion of his life.

MayMorris · 21/03/2022 13:04

@MsMiaWallace

I don't even know if he is doing a life interest trust. As he said it will be hers to live in until she chooses to leave.
This is the issue. He must not be allowed to do this without that trust, so that you aren’t hit with maintenance and repair bills that you don’t have money for. You must explain this to him. You must get a solicitor to draw the terms up correctly. It is also in this womens interest to see the solicitor and do it properly. There is another poster here who points out the other common problem . The lifetime trust doesn’t allow someone to move to alternative accommodation even if they are struggling to stay in house. Good contracts should allow for this (unless the house has sentimental value), with your input and approval. E.g. allowing her to downsize into a Sheltered house in later life, releasing some equity to you at the time. But you need a veto if the place she wants to move into would be hard to sell on as they often are in pensioner villages. These types of arrangements are so liable to too many issues and problems that tie people up and cause a lot of heartache and financial problems later. Not,least of which he is giving you both a lifetime obligation to each other , she was not your step mum, or relative and tell completely out of order for him to impose this on you. Much better for him to rethink and go for a clean break so you don’t need to be involved with this women for next xxx years. He is tying both
MayMorris · 21/03/2022 12:54

@NeedleNoodle3

Try not to think about it, there’s nothing you can do. I assume your dad’s partner will care for your dad if he needs it when he’s older if they are still together.
Whoa😱🤦‍♀️ Very bad advice Her father is potentially landing her with massive bills for maintenance, decor etc and giving her all the responsibilities for being a landlord, but without any rental income to pay for it. For an indefinite period of time. This is not Ok. It could cost her thousands in liabilities for the mother and son to trust the house badly and expect her to repair it. Absolutely not a good idea to ignore. She must get the father to understand he is dumping a burden on her for the lifetime of this women. He seems to have completely ignored this. There needs to be a trust to state that the women and son are mutually and individually liable for all repair and maintenance whilst they are staying there and ensure that the house is in good condition when they leave ….not leaving damp ingress, poor roofing etc. she also must consider what will happen to capital gains tax if the house is hers but she can’t sell. If she inherited immediately she can sell and dispose of as part of estate and pay inheritance tax if required. As long as she sells quickly there is unlikely to be much capital gain over the annual allowance. If however she is forced to keep the house, in her name, for 20 years and then tries to sell, she will in theory be liable for capital gains on any capital increase on house form point it was valued at father deaths (as at of probate) to what is worth by then. She must find out how this works or could be left with a massive capital gains tax that if she sold the house at his death and invested it in tax efficient savings she would not be hit with this (e.g. ISA, pension, Premium bonds). There are massive implications to hit her hard financially at time when she will not receive any benefit form this “inheritance” . Burying her head in the sand is extremely bad advice.
Nancydrawn · 21/03/2022 12:54

I like the suggestion of a previous poster. What if you sat down and told your father that rather than doing this, you'd prefer that the house be sold immediately and the proceeds split?

I assume he'd be concerned that she wouldn't have a place to live and that the sum wouldn't be enough for her to live on...but then again, how is he expecting her to pay for the upkeep, maintenance, council tax, etc.?

Is it possible to have a generous, non-emotive conversation with your father--or is this something he'll be put off by?

Quartz2208 · 21/03/2022 12:35

[quote HELLITHURT]@Quartz2208 who said she was a trustee? It is not her place to sit down with a solicitor and her father, it is his money and he can do whatever he sees fit.[/quote]
Yes and he is - but she has to know exactly what she is taking on which is the whole point of this thread.

It is entirely up to him what he does but the OP needs to know the legal implications of it and exactly what he is expecting in order to avoid potential cost and tax issues

Donra · 21/03/2022 12:25

My Aunty is the partner in this situation. She lived with a man for 25 years, cooked and cleaned for him, and looked after him when he was dying of cancer. He left the house to his sons with a life interest for my Aunty. The sons are annoyed about the hassle, they want her out so they can sell the house, get the money and be relieved of the responsibility. My Aunty has to maintain and insure the house.

She’s very unhappy. She doesn’t want to live there but has no money to move anywhere else. If she moves out she gets nothing. She would like to move back to our home town to be near our family but she can’t. She struggles with the stairs now and would prefer to move to a bungalow but can’t, so she sleeps in the living room. She’s pointed out to his sons that if it wasn’t for her there would be no house at all, because their father would have had to go into care and they would have taken the house to pay his fees. They’re still being mean, they just want rid of her. It’s a bad situation for everyone involved.

HELLITHURT · 21/03/2022 12:05

@Quartz2208 who said she was a trustee? It is not her place to sit down with a solicitor and her father, it is his money and he can do whatever he sees fit.

Changechangychange · 21/03/2022 12:05

I would be extremely cautious, and insist on being included in the setting up of the trust. It can go badly wrong.

One of my mother’s work colleague was married to a much older man (he died in his 80s, when she was in her early 50s). He left her a life interest in the house, with his sons responsible for all utility bills and maintenance. They took her to court to try to get her to pay a share of the maintenance costs, lost, and from then on she was very vindictive, turning the heat on in summer and opening all the windows etc to drive up the bills, getting a new boiler, new kitchen, new bathroom etc, to try to cost them as much as possible. I don’t know how it ended as my mum retired, but it has convinced me that these arrangements can be horribly abused if the person with the life interest chooses.

I’m not sure what options you will have if your father insists on going ahead without putting in place proper plans for meeting the costs - in the case I’m talking about, the husband obviously cherished his wife and wanted her fully taken care of as he would have done, and that is not really a realistic expectation of how your grown up children are likely to feel about a stepmother they barely know.

But once the trust is set up, the option is either to spend a lot of money keeping your stepmother in the lap of luxury, or give up the house in the future and hand it to this woman’s son to inherit. Neither are great options really are they?

Quartz2208 · 21/03/2022 11:46

[quote AllOfUsAreDead]@HELLITHURT

How do you know op won't get lumbered with the costs? She thinks she will, she knows this woman better than us, what if the woman trashes the place? Ops dad is potentially leaving her with a ton of repair work to do or bills to pay to avoid getting into debt because someone else won't pay them. And it will be ops name on the house, not this woman's. With no rental agreement. Sounds like an absolute nightmare for the op.

You are self sufficient, this woman isn't. That's the difference, she has found a man with assets, got in there quick and now probably convinced him she needs security. Just like another thread a week ago from a man who said his girlfriend wanted to be left his house instead of him leaving it to his daughter. There are money/asset grabbing women out there, and op doesn't think much of her. Considering she knows her, I'll trust her opinion. He's distanced himself from his family since meeting this woman too, she couldn't have more red flags if she tried.[/quote]
It isnt about her Dads partner though.

All of this should be covered in the trust set up - including having the savings with which to do so. The OP should be talking to her Dad about how it going to work with her as trustee and the powers that she has.

She is right to have reservations based on what her father has told her so far. That said she should be able to sit down with him and solicitor and clearly create a trust that fits what her Dad wants and doesnt have her losing money - including having clauses to cover what happens in certain situations and what can trigger clauses to give her powers to sell etc and to cover the tax implications as well.

It is not hard for a decent solicitor to create a will that covers all of this and makes sure that the OP interests are protected and her Dads partner can stay there.

What is concerning is his unwillingness to discuss and I wouldnt want to take this on without proper communication and seeing the terms of the trust/will

AllOfUsAreDead · 21/03/2022 11:35

@HELLITHURT

How do you know op won't get lumbered with the costs? She thinks she will, she knows this woman better than us, what if the woman trashes the place? Ops dad is potentially leaving her with a ton of repair work to do or bills to pay to avoid getting into debt because someone else won't pay them. And it will be ops name on the house, not this woman's. With no rental agreement. Sounds like an absolute nightmare for the op.

You are self sufficient, this woman isn't. That's the difference, she has found a man with assets, got in there quick and now probably convinced him she needs security. Just like another thread a week ago from a man who said his girlfriend wanted to be left his house instead of him leaving it to his daughter. There are money/asset grabbing women out there, and op doesn't think much of her. Considering she knows her, I'll trust her opinion. He's distanced himself from his family since meeting this woman too, she couldn't have more red flags if she tried.

Polyanthus2 · 21/03/2022 10:24

From google
o you have to pay inheritance tax if you own a house?*
*
There’s no Inheritance Tax to pay if you do this. If you leave the home to another person in your will, it counts towards the value of the estate. If you own your home (or a share in it) your tax-free threshold can increase to £500,000 if: There’s normally no Inheritance Tax to pay if you move out and live for another 7 years.

I think that means OP could be liable depending on DFs estate

Polyanthus2 · 21/03/2022 10:17

If OP rejected the will I wonder what the gf would live on - houses require maintenance

Quartz2208 · 21/03/2022 10:14

If done properly and a life interest trust drawn up alongside a plan to have some income (presumably from his savings) available to the trustee (the OP) in order to maintain it is a perfectly viable legal solution to the problem

Care is another thing that needs to be sorted - what happens if she needs to go into care. Or indeed if he needs to go into care.

There is nothing to say that the OPs father isnt doing all of this - and if he is doing it via a solicitor than they should be.

What the OP needs to do is to say to her father that if she is going to be trustee she needs to know exactly how it works including funds being set aside to deal with insurance and maintenance.

TheSoapyFrog · 21/03/2022 10:14

I don't think YABU. I would want my DF to clarify exactly what is meant by "landlord without the rent". If he means that you'll own the house, they'll be no rent paid, but you will be financially responsible for upkeep and maintenance, I wouldn't be happy, and would most likely decline this. I can't imagine that he is expecting you to pay bills as well is he?

If he wants her to remain there for as long as she wants or until her death, and she's responsible for all bills and upkeep etc, and then the house goes to you, that's fine.

But you really need to get him to answer this. I wouldn't care about her living there, but I sure as hell wouldn't want to be connected to her in any way, shape or form after DF's passing.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 21/03/2022 10:05

@Juno22

Some of the responses on here are awful. OP should move into the woman's home with her family?

OP's father isn't disinheriting her or choosing to leave everything to the woman he lives with. He's proposing a solution that enables the woman he lives with and shares his life with to remain in her home in the event of his death. That sounds to me like the actions of a caring person who is thinking of all involved. He might be with her for another 10 or 20 years. He's not proposing to leave everything to her not his daughter.

The op can't do that legally. The trust won't pass it to her until his partner either moves out or dies. The op should perhaps have posted in legal matters rather than AIBU then she could have got proper legal advice rather than uneducated speculation. But then she wouldn't have got all the drama.
Curlygirl06 · 21/03/2022 10:03

My friend's dad did something similar but he was married to the step mum. When he died she could live there until she died but the maintenance and some insurances had to be paid by my friend and her sister.
Long story short, dreadful time, both the grown up children lived miles away and although originally they got on fine with the step mum, when her son got involved and started demanding this, that and the other things got very awkward.
I would advise your dad to ensure that funds are separate with a condition that a certain amount of money is put aside to maintain the house, insurance is paid by you from the fund (so you know it's paid) and a condition in the will that only she has the right to live there.
It took years for my friend and her sister to sort things out, even after the step mum went into long term care. If I remember rightly they had to rent the house out and use the funds to pay for her care home fees, as their dad hadn't put in his will that the house could be sold if she went into care, only if she died.

Juno22 · 21/03/2022 10:03

Perhaps as your father is retired he doesn't want his partner to work if he is able to support her as he wants her company in retirement? Life is short. It's not for us to judge how others live their lives and spend their own money.

Juno22 · 21/03/2022 10:01

Some of the responses on here are awful. OP should move into the woman's home with her family?

OP's father isn't disinheriting her or choosing to leave everything to the woman he lives with. He's proposing a solution that enables the woman he lives with and shares his life with to remain in her home in the event of his death. That sounds to me like the actions of a caring person who is thinking of all involved. He might be with her for another 10 or 20 years. He's not proposing to leave everything to her not his daughter.

MsMiaWallace · 21/03/2022 10:00

DF's partner rented a property & worked full time before.
Now she doesn't.

OP posts:
Boysnme · 21/03/2022 09:56

@MsMiaWallace

I feel for you in this situation and don’t think you are coming across as grabby at all. You just want to know that it’s all ironed out and everything that’s in place is there to protect you both.

We have the same issue with my dad, except he married her. She’s actually lovely but I can’t say the same for her family.

My dad won’t talk to us at all about his will so we have no idea what he has in it. I hope to god he either spends it before he dies or just leaves it all to her so we don’t have the hassle.

I’d never forgive him if he saddled me with a load of cost just so I could potentially inherit a worthless house. If this happed I’d be doing as others have said and rejecting the inheritance (which was not something I realised could be done before this thread!)

NorthSouthcatlady · 21/03/2022 09:56

This sounds like a nightmare to me. Personally l wouldn’t want to enter into this as it sounds stressful and fraught with issues. The boiler dies whilst OP is on holiday or sick, how is she supposed to sort it. Suppose she doesn’t have the money for a new boiler? Suppose OP wants one boiler but fathers girlfriend wants another one which happens to be 50% more expensive? That’s even before you get onto tax implications etc

How did this women fund her life before she met OP’s father?! All of her Christmas’s must have come at once!

Sugarplumfairy65 · 21/03/2022 09:53

@MsMiaWallace

No clearly I don't think he should kick her out
What is your solution then?