Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Reservations over Dads new will?

184 replies

MsMiaWallace · 20/03/2022 21:13

After a conversation with my dad this morning he informed me he was renewing his will following a health scare.

My Dad is currently retired, is very comfortable. Mortgage free 3 bed semi, owns a narrowboat & has around £70k if not more in his account.
He has a partner who lives with him.
She basically lives off him, barely works or contributes. This is how it has been since she met him.

I never challenge this as he's happy with the situation & it's his choice.
They've been together around 4 years. Since meeting her he has distanced from us & we were close.

This morning he told me that he is changing his will so although his house would be mine she has to stay at the property until she chooses to leave.
Again his choice however I am concerned that it is a large house. She's in her 60s & will be too big for her to maintain alone therefore I will have to upkeep the property whilst she continues to live there rent free?
I also have my own mortgage to pay, family to look after etc whilst doing this.
He told me I would be the landlord but without the rent.
She also has a son that will likely move in with her who also does not contribute.

I absolutely respect that it's his choice but
AIBU here to have reservations about this situation?

OP posts:
Quartz2208 · 22/03/2022 18:25

But the flipside of that is that a woman built up savings and a life with a man that she envisioned would go to her children when she dies. After she does die suddenly along comes another woman who has very little money and 3 children and decides to marry a man and have money split 5 ways between her children

The OP has a right to be upset for her mum and that it goes to others - it is a fairly normal emotion to have in this situation

HELLITHURT · 22/03/2022 18:21

@Missdotty

I like your idea about you move in with her. Win win for you since you save money on housing, and you can ensure she pays half the bills etc. Plus, since she will have lots of money and the boat from your dad, might just decide to f it and move out and find her own place.
Yeah, what could possibly go wrong with that? Why half the bills? Is OP single?
ConkerBonkers · 22/03/2022 18:18

I like your idea about you move in with her. Win win for you since you save money on housing, and you can ensure she pays half the bills etc. Plus, since she will have lots of money and the boat from your dad, might just decide to f it and move out and find her own place.

MrsDThomas · 22/03/2022 18:10

Of course its up to him. But when she had nothing when she met him its clear what she saw.

Mariposa67 · 22/03/2022 17:56

MrsDThomas I'm sorry but you are grabby. Why shouldn't people in their 70s get married? That's an outrageous thing to say.

No-one is entitled to anything. It's up to individuals how they spend their money.

beachcitygirl · 22/03/2022 17:50

@MrsDThomas

Its very difficult to speak about things like this.

My mum passed away many years ago snd last year dad remarried. Being in his 70’s i don’t understand why, they could have lived together.
She sold her house, lives with dad, now she has no mortgage and not much was left after the sell. What was left she pooled with dad and this is wha im not happy about. I know what dad has in the bank. (His and mums money)

His will stated the house us mine and my brother’s. And his wife lives there till she dies-fair enough.

But the money is being split 5 ways. Her 3 kids and me and my brother when both die.

But its my dad and my mum’s money, she pooled about 20% of what its worth. How do i tackle it? I can’t because it will make me seem grabby.

And i don’t think you can tackle this easily either.

It doesn't make you "seem" grabby.

You are grabby.

What the hell makes anyone think they are entitled to anything ?

I told my parents to live the life of Reilly. Spend every last dime, cruise the world, buy the dresses, eat the cake.

It's NOT your house or money .

Your parents brought you up. You're owed zilch. Nada, nothing.
No one is.

MrsDThomas · 22/03/2022 17:34

Its very difficult to speak about things like this.

My mum passed away many years ago snd last year dad remarried. Being in his 70’s i don’t understand why, they could have lived together.
She sold her house, lives with dad, now she has no mortgage and not much was left after the sell. What was left she pooled with dad and this is wha im not happy about. I know what dad has in the bank. (His and mums money)

His will stated the house us mine and my brother’s. And his wife lives there till she dies-fair enough.

But the money is being split 5 ways. Her 3 kids and me and my brother when both die.

But its my dad and my mum’s money, she pooled about 20% of what its worth. How do i tackle it? I can’t because it will make me seem grabby.

And i don’t think you can tackle this easily either.

BruceAndNosh · 22/03/2022 17:19

I would point out to your dad (in writing so he can't strop) that you have understand he wants to ensure his partners security. You also have never had any problem with his choice to totally support her by covering all her living costs.
But by leaving the house to you, he is expecting YOU to support her. If she doesn't work, who is going to pay the utility bills?

Mintine · 22/03/2022 13:01

That happened with my neighbour. The lady is now in a nursing home at a 102! But she has outlived both her partner whose house it was, and his daughter and it will now go to the step grandchildren.

crosstalk · 22/03/2022 12:49

It's up to OP's father to do what he wants.

However, his lady may remarry and then leave the rights to her deceased husband's home to both her son and the children of her new husband.
At the moment it looks as if OP's dad has circumvented that by leaving the house to OP as owner and landlord after death but with a burden of upkeep which -should she live to 90 - is a lot of hassle, especially with the son there who could argue that he cannot be ejected by a landlord.

OP, I would take his will to your own solicitor.

70kid · 22/03/2022 12:48

My parents will had a life interest possession ( think that’s what it was )
When my mum passed away her half was left in trust for my sister and son
My dad still had to maintain the property

I don’t think there was a clause about anyone else not living in the property with my dad

It still cost money to get a solicitor to update the jabs registry

I know you can do this yourself but i wanted it done properly as I was the executor of my mums will

As you may have to go on the deeds when your dad pass away this can possibly cause problems if you are a first time buyer or already have a home

bracebrace · 22/03/2022 12:43

Don't be too mean about the whole thing op or he might just leave it to her!

AllOfUsAreDead · 22/03/2022 12:29

@MsTSwift

No I wouldn’t worry because you are being ridiculous the op cannot be under a legal obligation to pay for the bills and up keep for a house out of her own money. This is a complex will only a professional would attempt to draft it. But crack on it’s much more fun being aggrieved and morally outraged on the ops behalf!
So why have other posters said that there has been situations where maintenance and/or bills end up getting paid by the person who inherited, not the person allowed to stay in the house?

The best situation is that op doesn't have any worries, nothing extra to pay and her dad's partner is liable for everything. But she isn't convinced of that. Rather than just saying we are all being ridiculous, maybe provide some proof that op definitely won't be liable? That would alleviate her fears then and solve the issue without her having to get solicitors involved.

Starlitexpress · 22/03/2022 12:18

Hi,
I agree, this all needs to get sorted for both your sakes.

I knew someone who's mother left her the house but partner had life tenancy. Everyone was happy with this as it was assumed he would stay a few years before finding somewhere more suitable. He didn't.

She had this huge asset but couldn't get a mortgage for herself , he wasn't maintaining it beyond the bare minimum and it would upset her going past looking at her mother's garden covered in rubbish and weeds.

I would certainly go with a time limit she can stay there, or it is sold and she gets a small lump sum to set her up on her own

MsTSwift · 22/03/2022 12:02

No I wouldn’t worry because you are being ridiculous the op cannot be under a legal obligation to pay for the bills and up keep for a house out of her own money. This is a complex will only a professional would attempt to draft it. But crack on it’s much more fun being aggrieved and morally outraged on the ops behalf!

beachcitygirl · 22/03/2022 12:00

@AllOfUsAreDead
That's the thing tho, she doesn't Have to do anything.

She can say no thank you.
But she wants her dads money.
Therein lies the dichotomy.

Grabby is as grabby does.

AllOfUsAreDead · 22/03/2022 11:42

@MsTSwift

Some posters need to calm down! A properly drafted will ensures that the partner pays the maintenance and bills herself or alternatively the residue of the estate does - not the op.

Other option is he gives her a right of occupation which terminates on a specific specified date say 2 or 5 years after death and she is given some money from the sale to rehouse herself.

A life interest trust is better if they married for the tax benefit - a right of occupation better for unmarried but it’s up to him of course. He can give her the right to sell and buy somewhere else which the trust would own if he wants.

Also if he cut the partner out completely she would have a claim anyway as they living together she could argue he was supporting her and hadn’t made proper provision for her.

But that's the problem isnt it? Op doesn't know if it's been properly done, she hasn't seen the will and her dad is refusing to talk about it. Would you be happy to just leave it and wait and see if you had to pay bills on a house you couldn't live in for 20+ years potentially?
Quartz2208 · 21/03/2022 19:18

Well yes exactly a properly drafted will is exactly what is needed. And what the OP has a right to ask her father if he is doing it properly.

The risk is that the father is going ahead with something without doing it properly and from some of the things that the OP says either she isnt getting how he is doing it properly or he isnt doing it properly

HELLITHURT · 21/03/2022 19:00

@MsTSwift

Some posters need to calm down! A properly drafted will ensures that the partner pays the maintenance and bills herself or alternatively the residue of the estate does - not the op.

Other option is he gives her a right of occupation which terminates on a specific specified date say 2 or 5 years after death and she is given some money from the sale to rehouse herself.

A life interest trust is better if they married for the tax benefit - a right of occupation better for unmarried but it’s up to him of course. He can give her the right to sell and buy somewhere else which the trust would own if he wants.

Also if he cut the partner out completely she would have a claim anyway as they living together she could argue he was supporting her and hadn’t made proper provision for her.

The voice of reason!
MsTSwift · 21/03/2022 18:49

Some posters need to calm down! A properly drafted will ensures that the partner pays the maintenance and bills herself or alternatively the residue of the estate does - not the op.

Other option is he gives her a right of occupation which terminates on a specific specified date say 2 or 5 years after death and she is given some money from the sale to rehouse herself.

A life interest trust is better if they married for the tax benefit - a right of occupation better for unmarried but it’s up to him of course. He can give her the right to sell and buy somewhere else which the trust would own if he wants.

Also if he cut the partner out completely she would have a claim anyway as they living together she could argue he was supporting her and hadn’t made proper provision for her.

MayMorris · 21/03/2022 18:40

[quote godmum56]@MayMorris
"he must not be allowed"

who is going to stop him?[/quote]
She can refuse. Ultimately she can refuse to inherit or act as executor. I’m not sure she is in that situation though- it just sounds like a half cock idea by someone who really hasn’t thought it through.
She does not have to accept being burdened with it

brainhurts · 21/03/2022 18:02

I think the solicitor will make sure it's left in trust , his partner can stay for as long as she wants but must pay for the upkeep of the house .
Say for example your dad died then not long after you did , the house would then be passed to your beneficiary, they like you should not be a obligated to pay expenses on the house .

godmum56 · 21/03/2022 17:10

@MayMorris
"he must not be allowed"

who is going to stop him?

balalake · 21/03/2022 16:07

YANBU to have reservations, and in your shoes I would definitely prefer the house to be sold with split proceeds. The son might move in for the best of reasons such as helping his mother if she cannot manage by herself, but then once his mother dies, where does he go?

Changechangychange · 21/03/2022 15:48

@Cheeserton

This would never actually stand up. You can't impose huge obligations and expenses on people involuntarily with a will. I strongly suspect you could find your way out later if necessary.
The problem is that the way out is to give up your right to the house, ie hand it over to the partner. And if the house is worth a reasonable amount (or if there is bad blood with the stepmother), people don’t generally want to do that.