Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to be a parental carer in future?

190 replies

janeseymour78 · 20/03/2022 20:57

My mother has been a carer for the last ten years to her parents. She partially did this so that my grandparent could stay at home. At the beginning it was very hard and time consuming and she said 'if I get I'll like that in future please just put me in a home'. I would argue she has done barely anything with her life aside from this in that time.

The other day she said that homes are terrible places because anyone that goes there dies within months of arrival. She also commented on how much costs had been saved by keeping grandparent at home. So this change of tune makes me think she now expects me to give up my life in a similar way if need be.

I have always had a complicated relationship with my mother - she wasn't a great parent due to her own issues and acknowledges this.

Recently I have started thinking she is getting older and I should consider talking to her about if/when she gets ill in future. About how we would handle it. AIBU?

OP posts:
HelpMeHiveMind · 21/03/2022 17:23

This is a real worry for me too. My mother also said she wouldn't expect care and, like you, I have a very ropey history with her. BUT in recent years she's moved herself very close to me (her choice) and is going out of her way to help with the kids etc unasked. My mum does not do anything for anyone without expecting payback so I'm pretty certain she now sees me as her care option. I could cope with doing shopping, arranging a cleaner. But I have huge body issues even for myself never mind anyone else and the idea of having to help her toilet or bath makes me feel physically sick. Just don't know what we'll do as she also has a lot of savings but is adamant "the state aren't getting their hands on them" and would never give me power of attorney so I can hardly force her to use them can I.

hellcatspangle · 21/03/2022 17:20

As they got older and needed a bit of help, I found it exceedingly simple to spend a bit of time pitching in to help them.

It's all well and good when it's just "a bit of help". The problem is when it takes over your entire life and you end up being a full time carer with no life of your own. Unfortunately that can creep up on people without them realising.

Clarabe1 · 21/03/2022 17:20

Having once worked as a carer I think some people have a romanticized view of what caring actually is. It’s not even IF you want to do it it’s that you might not be physically capable. Lifting people around is not easy. Most homes are not set up for hoists and lifts and all the paraphernalia you need if someone is immobile. Dementia can change a person from a loving and caring to nasty and aggressive. Sometimes people have no choice but to seek professional help. The mental and physical burden caring brings should not be underestimated.

Badyboo · 21/03/2022 17:17

For all those people adamant they'll be caring for their parents... My mum was a carer her entire working life, absolutely loved that job and the people she looked after.

Then she did it for her own parents. It damn near destroyed her. She missed out on her own family life because she felt like she could never leave them. In the end she had a nervous breakdown because she couldn't cope any longer. Until you've lived it, don't criticise others (and don't call them selfish!)

My mum and dad have got their LPA's in place. No homes unless absolutely necessary, paid for carers and no personal care from children. That's what they want, and that's what we will do our bests to provide.

geekchicz · 21/03/2022 17:14

I’ll offer my perspective which is elder care does not happen the way you think it does . Alyears ago I was expecting my second baby at 39 . I had a 3 years My elderly mother died last year at 86 with vascular dementia

tedgran · 21/03/2022 17:13

A friends mother said" you won't put me in a home will you?', her response was that she couldn't promise that, DH is nearly 10 years older than me, and has said the same, my response was the same as my friends. I'm 74 and don't want my children to have to look after me, and certainly don't want them doing personal care, upsetting for every one.

MargosKaftan · 21/03/2022 17:11

Could you try "mum, not all homes are terrible, many people live in them for years - they end up living long enough to spend all their house sale money, keeps being on the news so there must be enough living long enough for that to be an issue. If gran gets so she needs nursing care beyond what you can manage, there would be nothing wrong with finding a good home for her. Just when it's beyond what family can do." Give her the "way out" of her position if she's struggling.

CPL593H · 21/03/2022 17:10

I think some people who confidently say "I will look after my parents and they will never go into a care home" ignore the fact that by the time the parents need substantial care, the adult child may well be 60s or 70s themselves, with less energy, physical strength and quite possibly their own health issues.

It is possible for people without severe dementia to remain at home safely for a very long time, often for ever. We need a properly organised and resourced system that values paid carers, not to guilt trip people who for whatever reason are unable or unwilling to act as unpaid ones.

OP, some good advice upthread about having conversations with her now that are clear about the need for forward thinking.

DejaBat · 21/03/2022 17:07

*most not Misty!

DejaBat · 21/03/2022 17:06

@DreamTheMoors

My parents fed me, bathed me, sheltered me for the first 18 years of my life, and then put me through 4 years of university. They did the same for my siblings. As they got older and needed a bit of help, I found it exceedingly simple to spend a bit of time pitching in to help them. We had many good times and laughs and it was never a burden for me. I’d do it again in a heartbeat. I miss them both terribly.
They chose to bring you into this world, you didn’t ask to be born. It was their responsibility to keep you alive. Feeding, bathing, sheltering is the Misty basic and necessary of parenting. You’re making it seem like they went way above and beyond Confused
janeseymour78 · 21/03/2022 17:02

@MargosKaftan I hadn't thought about it like that but I think you might be right.

She goes on about how she has sacrificed much of her life to be a carer. I keep quiet about the fact she didn't have to do this and chooses to do this. I think it borders on superiority - 'look what I gave up' - of course she has been through a lot and argues she has helped to keep my grandparent alive longer. She might be right. Is that a good thing? I'm not sure it is. Her quality of life is about nil.

I hope this doesn't sound heartless. We all should make decisions as we see fit and obviously I'm personally close to this.

OP posts:
janeseymour78 · 21/03/2022 16:58

@DixonD

The prospect of getting old in this country can be quite terrifying, so I would do all I could to keep my mum at home for as long as possible, provided she was safe and comfortable there. However, any type of dementia would, in my mind, need professional care at some stage. It’s a very, very hard disease to endure, and not just for the sufferer.
I agree. Feels like we're going backwards.

I'm not suggesting I'm going to abandon my parents. I will be there for them and help out where possible. But I have been feeling down lately about the fact I'm an only child and definitely won't have that sibling help and also both my parents are already quite reliant on me emotionally if not on a day to day basis. I see it seeping into over reliance quite easily as they age.

Some PPs have suggested im jumping the gun. I might be but my mother has not always looked after herself over the years and she does next to no exercise to stay healthy. I'm more confident my dad will be fine - I guess it is true you never know though.

OP posts:
MargosKaftan · 21/03/2022 16:53

Could she be bad mouthing homes now because she needs you to say they are great and put gran in one? Could it be shes got to try to justify her decision to give up a decade and has had to convince herself it was worth it?

The reason many older people die in a short period after going into a home is that for many families, they only reach the crunch point of not being able to offer care at home just before the end. Often the older person has had to put up with inadequate care for a while, so they decline faster than they would have done in a home earlier.

Many people last a long time in a home, this is evident from whole value of houses going. My grandmother lasted 7 years in a home, after living with my parents for years before. She had dementia but also mobility issues so it was when my parents couldn't lift her she had to go in a home, but beyond that her health was pretty good. After 5 years the value of her house had been spent. Last 2 were state funded. There was a suggestion they might move her to a different home that stressed my mum, but luckily that didn't happen.

knittingaddict · 21/03/2022 16:52

@NeedleNoodle3

knittingaddict that sounds so difficult for you.
It will get sorted eventually, but this week in particular is going to be very tough. It's a bit raw right now, which is why the thread drew me in. I don't want to take away from the op's potential issues though as it's hard for lots of us.
DixonD · 21/03/2022 16:51

The prospect of getting old in this country can be quite terrifying, so I would do all I could to keep my mum at home for as long as possible, provided she was safe and comfortable there. However, any type of dementia would, in my mind, need professional care at some stage. It’s a very, very hard disease to endure, and not just for the sufferer.

NeedleNoodle3 · 21/03/2022 16:47

knittingaddict that sounds so difficult for you.

toconclude · 21/03/2022 16:46

@PinkFluffyUnicornSlippers

Personally I think you’re being selfish but then again I love my mum 🤷‍♀️ I just want her to be safe in her old age.
Personally I think you don't know what you're talking about. As a former op social worker I saw far more unsafe practice from family carers than in care homes.
Cameleongirl · 21/03/2022 16:46

@DreamTheMoors

My parents fed me, bathed me, sheltered me for the first 18 years of my life, and then put me through 4 years of university. They did the same for my siblings. As they got older and needed a bit of help, I found it exceedingly simple to spend a bit of time pitching in to help them. We had many good times and laughs and it was never a burden for me. I’d do it again in a heartbeat. I miss them both terribly.
It’s lovely that you had such a great relationship with your parents. Please be kind and non-judgmental towards those who don’t have similar experiences, though.

My remaining parent has long-standing serious MH issues and made my Mum’s life very difficult when I was growing up and then mine ever since she died. I love him, but he would destroy my life if I became a carer for him as he doesn’t really see other people as human beings with their own needs, everything has always revolves around him.

Sone children need to keep some distance from their parents to retain their sanity and inevitably, people who have nice, supportive parents can’t really understand that.

Ducksareruiningmypatio · 21/03/2022 16:46

Absolutely no way am I becoming a carer for my parents.
I was horribly let down during my teens and feel I don't owe them anything

knittingaddict · 21/03/2022 16:44

@NeedleNoodle3

I think a big problem is the period of time before a care home is needed but after your parents being able to manage at home independently. This bit can go on for years. So many old people I know won’t accept any care ‘because they can manage’ but are fine having their DC come over and do the care.
Exactly. We have arranged carers to come into my mum's home because she isn't safe alone and won't eat. She won't let them do anything. Not a thing, so they are being paid a furtune to basically make sure that mum doesn't blow herself up or starve to death. Every day someone is with her for a few hours, either carers or family. She doesn't remember any of it and if you asked her she would say that she hadn't seen anyone all week. It's exhausting and frustrating.
incognitoforthisone · 21/03/2022 16:38

@knittingaddict

Some of the posts on here are making me Angry. Have a bit of empathy for those with less than lovely parents FFS.
Yes, exactly. And also for those whose parents were lovely once but became a lot less lovely due to the ravages of dementia. Even a lovely parent can be aggressive, hurtful and even violent if they've got certain conditions. My friend's dad, with whom she always had a wonderful relationship, is now at a stage of dementia where he has huge temper outbursts, throws things and is physically violent, and he also makes sexually inappropriate comments to every woman he sees, including her. She couldn't possibly care for him at home, especially with her kids in the house too.
Clarabe1 · 21/03/2022 16:35

Just because your Mum has chosen this path doesn’t mean it has to be yours. Obviously you help your parents out as they get older but that is very different to being a carer. I think you are jumping the gun as well, who says she will need a carer? Lots of old people don’t. I know a few very elderly people who are quite independent.

toconclude · 21/03/2022 16:34

@godmum56

You don't say how old or fit your mother is but if you don't want to address the thing head on and potentially risk becoming estranged from your mother, I'd soft pedal it a bit. if she asks for promises or assurance then you might want to be more direct but unles there is a drip feed, you are worrying about something that may never happen. I just checked the stats and only 4% of all over 65's ever go into residential care. Its interesting because although the actual number of people over 65 is rising, the percentage of those needing res care seems to have remained the same for quite some time....maybe around 40 years which is when i first heard that statistic.
It does rise to about 15 pc of over 85s but still very much the minority. What used to be 'needs a care home ' can often nowadays be provided in one's own home
incognitoforthisone · 21/03/2022 16:33

@DreamTheMoors

My parents fed me, bathed me, sheltered me for the first 18 years of my life, and then put me through 4 years of university. They did the same for my siblings. As they got older and needed a bit of help, I found it exceedingly simple to spend a bit of time pitching in to help them. We had many good times and laughs and it was never a burden for me. I’d do it again in a heartbeat. I miss them both terribly.
I'm really glad you found it 'exceedingly simple' and 'had many good times and laughs.'

Unfortunately, caring for people isn't always like that. It can be incredibly gruelling and distressing and for some people it can ruin their relationship with their parents. Also, there's a big difference between 'spending a bit of time pitching in' and being the full time carer for someone who might have extremely challenging mental and physical problems to manage.

I'm genuinely really pleased for you that your situation worked out happily. But there are many, many different caring situations and many different familial relationships and set-ups. Not wanting to be a full time carer to an elderly parent doesn't mean you love them any less. I adore my dad but I couldn't possibly care for him safely at home. I can't afford not to work and he needs 24-hour specialist care; plus he would be mortified at the idea of his daughter having to bathe him and change his incontinence pads.

TimBoothseyes · 21/03/2022 16:32

I've already told my adult DD that, under no circumstances was she to be my carer when I get to that stage. She's worked hard for the life she has and I don't want her giving it up out of a sense of duty to me.