Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to be a parental carer in future?

190 replies

janeseymour78 · 20/03/2022 20:57

My mother has been a carer for the last ten years to her parents. She partially did this so that my grandparent could stay at home. At the beginning it was very hard and time consuming and she said 'if I get I'll like that in future please just put me in a home'. I would argue she has done barely anything with her life aside from this in that time.

The other day she said that homes are terrible places because anyone that goes there dies within months of arrival. She also commented on how much costs had been saved by keeping grandparent at home. So this change of tune makes me think she now expects me to give up my life in a similar way if need be.

I have always had a complicated relationship with my mother - she wasn't a great parent due to her own issues and acknowledges this.

Recently I have started thinking she is getting older and I should consider talking to her about if/when she gets ill in future. About how we would handle it. AIBU?

OP posts:
OverTheRubicon · 21/03/2022 23:18

@cansu

I think there would be little point in having this conversation. If your mum has capacity, you would not be able to force her into a home in any case. If she doesn't then you would not be having the conversation anyway.
This kind of thinking is storing up trouble for later. If someone knows that their children will not be taking over physical care and support, it's an incentive to for example look into a bungalow or flat Vs staying in a harder to manage terrace house. No good if mum sells her house and spends all her cash travelling around Europe in a camper van, only to find that actually her daughter doesn't want to put her up in the downstairs bedroom, and that as all her savings are gone, she's scraping by on her state pension, or being put into whatever home the council can find a space in.
BlackishTulips · 21/03/2022 22:39

What is a Mexican standoff?

knittingaddict · 21/03/2022 19:40

Mexican standoff. That's exactly what I expect to happen on Thursday. I'll come back to this thread and update if I have the mental energy.

NeedleNoodle3 · 21/03/2022 19:37

If the parents have under 23k in savings then they’d pay about £80 per week towards a care package.
That’s what I did with my DM, all good until she hit one of them.

iklboo · 21/03/2022 19:25

You employ carers.

Who don't come free of charge. They're not cheap and costs can escalate hugely depending on what you need them to do. Not an option for everyone.

cansu · 21/03/2022 19:20

I think there would be little point in having this conversation. If your mum has capacity, you would not be able to force her into a home in any case. If she doesn't then you would not be having the conversation anyway.

geekchicz · 21/03/2022 19:15

“But if mum changed and became aggressive or became a danger in the home I would not put my family through that and she would go to a home. “ which is exactly what I tried to do and it still was a long torturous process because my mother believed she was absolutely fine . She defied everyone gps health services consultants and the social workers . Because she was not physically aggressive there was nothing I could do . We even got as far as a Mexican stand off in the carehome garden one time . Capacity is quite decision specific in the law . It was horrendous because no one could help me ( although I realise my mums case was quite extreme )

Fizbosshoes · 21/03/2022 19:00

There are varying degrees of care which may or may not be possible for an adult child to provide to their parents either out of financial limitations or practical.
A lot of people needing the type of care that requires a care home need 24/7 care. Not everyone could afford to give up work to provide that, or offer it in a practical sense either if they have young children , or are unable to deal with practicalities of lifting, bathing, changing a grown adult.
My dad had carers to begin with but it soon became clear he needed more than 4 x a day visits. It wasn't possible for me and my siblings to manage ourselves and we thought it was safer for him to be in a care home with 24 hour support.

Countrydiary · 21/03/2022 18:33

I think a lot of posters have no idea of the intensity that is needed for some forms of care and as @OverTheRubicon said, the decision that a care home is needed is nothing about whether the person has ‘earned’ the care from children or not.
Care needs can be incredibly diverse and varied, and the other responsibilities of those doing the caring similarly varied.

My Dad is currently my Mum’s carer and it is eating him alive. I do what I can but I honestly dread what would happen if he was taken ill, say, I don’t know how I could manage her care needs and my working hours and the basics of caring for my five year old. That’s without a much loved Aunt in a care home 45 minutes away with complex needs that I’m also responsible for.

For the OP I would urge getting it talked through whilst it is more theoretical. Once (potentially, I very much hope you don’t get to this point) you are in the thick of it it will be much harder.

RidingMyBike · 21/03/2022 18:32

My Mum, after years of saying she wouldn't want us to have to care for her, would be responsible with downsizing and eventually go into a home, seems to have had a sudden change of mind in her mid-70s. There are now snide comments about me working full time and how much she sacrificed to look after elderly relatives. We've moved closer to her - we're now 2 hours away rather than 4-5 hours - but we don't see her that often. Only 3-4 times per year even before Covid. She's never been interested in seeing more of her grand-daughter or being more involved. We don't really get on and having her to stay at Christmas used to drive me mad!

I can't care for her, or even do shopping and laundry as we're too far away. I wouldn't spend every weekend travelling that distance to so it, although I'd organise an online shop etc. I've been trying to encourage her to look at bus routes etc for when she can't drive any longer. We're about to buy a house with an adapted downstairs for a disabled person and she's been dropping hints about it. We actually want it as WFH space!

IthinkIsawahairbrushbackthere · 21/03/2022 18:30

Nine years ago my dad died and I became the carer for my mum while having a home, a husband and five children. We had a lot of fun together, she was very generous and loving towards me and my family and she and my dad were wonderful parents. But as her physical and mental abilities deteriorated so did our relationship. Caring for her was not "a privilege". It was a chore, a dirty, miserable, thankless chore. Even with the support of two care visits a day provided by the local council which I had to pay for because as far as mum was concerned she had no need of them. I was selfish and lazy and put my own needs before hers.

Then last summer she collapsed in the bathroom. Although the paramedics who came to help her up didn't find anything wrong the carer was concerned and felt mum may have had a stroke. Thanks to her support and the local surgery she was admitted to hospital, then into rehab and from there to a local nursing home.

It was not an easy decision for me to make and it was a very difficult conversation for me to have with her but her needs are such that I can not meet them at home, even with support from carers etc. She is doubly incontinent, confused and agitated and needs to be hoisted from bed to chair to wheel chair etc.

I am so relieved that her day to day care is no longer my responsibility.

I am doing all I can to make sure that my adult children and my husband know that I do not want them to be in the position I was in. I tell them regularly with humour and seriously, that they are to live their lives independently and not sacrifice their happiness to keep me at home.

I still love my mum and week by week I can see that my feelings for her are changing. I am beginning to see her as my mum again instead of as a very difficult employer.

Ganymedemoon · 21/03/2022 18:26

[quote crosstalk]@Useranon1

and all the PPs who would and are caring.

All well and good. Hats off to you, truly.

But how do you cope with a (especially a weighty) person who needs turning or getting out of bed in the middle of the night? The washing if they cease to be continent? Getting them to the loo? Keeping them safe if they get demented and wander around at all times of day and night, forgetting to turn ovens off or escaping out of the house?

Especially if you have a job and children. And don't live nearby - and neither do your siblings (or they're not interested).

I had a relative who had dementia but whose family lived within 10-20 minutes of her (walking). All the 5 daughters and their children worked a rota to clean, feed and sort her out and give her company. Even then, in the last two years (they were all working and some on shifts) they employed a night nurse between them along with the very basic social care she got.

My DM didn't want us to do any of this and was lucky enough to afford carers. However we were mostly around despite jobs and children to do what she wanted - which was talk.[/quote]
Absolutely. Caring comes in many different ways and a huge factor is the persons needs. My mum does have dementia but she is not aggressive can still mobilise and knows who we are and where she is. She's had vascular dementia for 9 years and it's progress has been slow. I am also a nurse and so far happy with my choice to do this albeit with the help of carers. But if mum changed and became aggressive or became a danger in the home I would not put my family through that and she would go to a home. Everyone has a limit.

iklboo · 21/03/2022 18:22

As they got older and needed a bit of help, I found it exceedingly simple to spend a bit of time pitching in to help them.

It's good that you could do that. But I expect it wasn't things like scrubbing faeces out of the carpet at 4am, changing their clothes & strip washing them. Or changing dressings & cleaning infected wounds trying your best not to hurt them. Because social care were so swamped they couldn't send anyone out.

Useranon1 · 21/03/2022 18:07

You employ carers. I have also been there before and it's awful. I hated seeing them like that and the relentless of it is so wearing. But for me, not as wearing as knowing they were helpless somewhere unfamiliar.

crosstalk · 21/03/2022 18:02

@Useranon1

and all the PPs who would and are caring.

All well and good. Hats off to you, truly.

But how do you cope with a (especially a weighty) person who needs turning or getting out of bed in the middle of the night? The washing if they cease to be continent? Getting them to the loo? Keeping them safe if they get demented and wander around at all times of day and night, forgetting to turn ovens off or escaping out of the house?

Especially if you have a job and children. And don't live nearby - and neither do your siblings (or they're not interested).

I had a relative who had dementia but whose family lived within 10-20 minutes of her (walking). All the 5 daughters and their children worked a rota to clean, feed and sort her out and give her company. Even then, in the last two years (they were all working and some on shifts) they employed a night nurse between them along with the very basic social care she got.

My DM didn't want us to do any of this and was lucky enough to afford carers. However we were mostly around despite jobs and children to do what she wanted - which was talk.

geekchicz · 21/03/2022 18:00

That’s what happened to us FilbbertyGiblets. Also people don’t understand what dementia is - there’s a whole spectrum between grandma nodding gently in the corner reminiscing about the past and people needing to be sectioned at the later stages . People do “ manage “ with dementia in the early stages but it goes on for years . My mother regularly believed she was living a duplicate house right down to the carpets, pictures etc . She was angry and regular took her frustration out on me as her world shrunk and shifted like sand She could at that time just about make a cup of tea and knew who the prime minister was . Dementia is a devious disease. 1 in 4 of us will get it . My mother had a small stroke in her mid 70s and it all stemmed from there . I started off organising online shopping and right at them end I was doing intimate care with professional paid carers because of the Pingdemic and the awful situation we were in

Strawmite · 21/03/2022 17:54

I don’t want to be come my parents carer. I want them to live a long and healthy life and then die suddenly in their sleep at 93, having been at home with a cleaner and me popping in a couple of times a week prior to this.
That’s what I’d like, sadly I can’t choose so we will have to see what happens in the future and hope that it won’t be necessary. I’m a nurse and know how complex and full on caring for anyone let alone a relative can be. I also could never do it for my MIL- she is morbidly obese at 50 so there’s not a chance in hell I could even help lift her up the bed let alone mobilise around a room constantly.

Gwenhwyfar · 21/03/2022 17:54

"My two siblings have no children so I would think they should be in line before me! "

WTF? You chose to have children.

FlibbertyGiblets · 21/03/2022 17:45

The thing with caring for a parent with dementia is it starts small and ends up consuming the carer. No amount of pitching in will equal the real demands.

The other thing is the authorities do not make clear that Alzheimer's etc is a terminal disease. Lots of jolly stuff about living well with dementia in the same vein as, oh I dunno, living well with diabetes, or chronic pain. Lots of fluffing over and fudging the progressive stages.

Those of you who just wouldn't consider or entertain the notion of not caring for a parent themselves, I truly hope your loved ones don't get a lingering disease, it kills the carer too. You get hollowed out as well.

geekchicz · 21/03/2022 17:36

Sorry pressed too soon! 9 years ago I was expecting my second child at 39 when my df dropped dead suddenly of a heart attack . As an only child I had to pick up the pieces for my grief stricken mother and myself and my husband living two hours away spent 3 years first of all watching her crumble & neglect herself slowly realising something was very wrong . We spent 3 years trying to persuade her to move closer to us figuring it would be slightly easier to manage the constant emergencies , errand & admin . The next 6 years including the pandemic have been like lobsters boiling . An endless death by a thousand cuts as we tried to manage it all and bring up a family . The very paradox of my mothers dementia was she refused to believe anything was wrong . She refused to accept cleaners , gardeners and carers . We could only bring a new level of care when another step down ( usually a hospital admission ) meant it could be introduced by stealth . As a self funded SS were not interested and my mother refused to have assessments of needs done . The MHSOP who diagnosed her dementia were useless . The pandemic left us broken and very desperate . We were left alone . It nearly broke my marriage and I had no choice but to abandon my career in education whilst trying to do it all with primary aged children I found myself lost in a world of bureaucracy , admin and the law which is woefully not up to the job . I spent 6 years leaping out of bed at 3am racing round the corner to meet ambulances or talk my mother down that it was not 2 in the afternoon or there were people in the living room. The consultant would dole out another drug and we were left to struggle on . I joked I had a fast pass to the a&e . Nobody helped until mum reached a particular tipping point and finally after a best interests meeting my mother was given 24 hour care . During the pandemic my mother was admitted to an a&e dept the night the city lockdowned . They rang me and said they would make her comfortable aka she was dying . She rallied and then the nurses let her ring me where she screamed down the phone at me . I have never felt so awful and broken . I howled in my backgarden . When the time came for the carehome she did not last long but they made her comfortable and ensured I could be with her at the end . I was very grateful to them . I have made sure I’ve made my wishes clear in writing . I’m not managing past 75 . I will use assistive care . I miss my mum and I loved her but the situation broke me and I will never get over it . I did what I could - if you can afford use professional care . The care system in the UK is broken it was more than happy to let me struggle on in extreme situations caring for a confused person with dementia whilst trying to bring up small children . People have no idea or they heaps of help or cash or time .

HappyDays40 · 21/03/2022 17:36

People like to be all virtuous about keeping their elderly relatives at home but until you are there you can't possibly realise how hard it is. I shop and do appointments with my MIL she is lovely and we get on great. I can't do anymore and she was making hints about moving in with us. I work full time, juggle childcare for a 5 year old, husband works all weird hours and very much does his share picks up 50% but his hours spread over six days. She won't have homecare, won't consider residential care !
There is no way I could cope with trying to work from home, keep her entertained and be able to have any continuation of our lives. We go for long walks at weekends she would always be alone. Half the time I think it's just older age insecurities talking but when she starts to push for moreI have to be firm with what I can manage. I think people have unrealistic expectations. We are living in an age where often two people need to work and that doesn't work well logistically for caring foe older people.

AuntieJoycesPurpleSlacks · 21/03/2022 17:36

@Clarabe1

Having once worked as a carer I think some people have a romanticized view of what caring actually is. It’s not even IF you want to do it it’s that you might not be physically capable. Lifting people around is not easy. Most homes are not set up for hoists and lifts and all the paraphernalia you need if someone is immobile. Dementia can change a person from a loving and caring to nasty and aggressive. Sometimes people have no choice but to seek professional help. The mental and physical burden caring brings should not be underestimated.
This is a very good point. My parents say they don't want a stranger bathing them but I would not be physically able to lift them myself.
Ganymedemoon · 21/03/2022 17:35

It's an individual choice for a whole range of reasons. My 87 yr old mum lives with me. I consider me to be a part time carer. We have a carer every morning, I see to the rest. But as mums needs get greater we will probably increase the carers she gets. So it does not have to be all or nothing. However I appreciate not everyone wants their elderly parent moving in with them! For me looking at the state of homes during the last 2 years with covid I am very grateful Mum is with us.

WhatHaveIFound · 21/03/2022 17:32

I am not, under any circs sacrificing years of my life to protect my sibling inheritance.

I'm currently trying to steer my parents into accepting more outside care as they expect me to run around after them more and more plus take them to all medical appointments whilst my sister can't even be bothered to phone them.

I am grateful for everything my parents have done for me but I draw the line at personal care for them both and my dad wouldn't want me to do it for him either.

If that means that there's no inheritance for me or my sister then so be it.

AuntieJoycesPurpleSlacks · 21/03/2022 17:28

My parents put both grandparents in homes and didn't do any caring - but I have already been told by them both directly that they don't want to go into a home themselves

It's good enough for other people and not for them and I find that a big ask to to honest. Especially when they didn't do it for their own parents.