Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to be a parental carer in future?

190 replies

janeseymour78 · 20/03/2022 20:57

My mother has been a carer for the last ten years to her parents. She partially did this so that my grandparent could stay at home. At the beginning it was very hard and time consuming and she said 'if I get I'll like that in future please just put me in a home'. I would argue she has done barely anything with her life aside from this in that time.

The other day she said that homes are terrible places because anyone that goes there dies within months of arrival. She also commented on how much costs had been saved by keeping grandparent at home. So this change of tune makes me think she now expects me to give up my life in a similar way if need be.

I have always had a complicated relationship with my mother - she wasn't a great parent due to her own issues and acknowledges this.

Recently I have started thinking she is getting older and I should consider talking to her about if/when she gets ill in future. About how we would handle it. AIBU?

OP posts:
alwayswrighty · 22/03/2022 08:27

I'd personally rather go to dignitas than go in a home or be a burden on my husband or son.

My Mum and Dad have spent their entire retirement looking after my Nan. Both parents have deteriating health and are still looking after Nan. They have categorically told me they do not want me to look after them.

Dad thinks he is going to die before Nan. They deserve some happiness.

Useranon1 · 22/03/2022 08:23

@iklboo

You employ carers.

Who don't come free of charge. They're not cheap and costs can escalate hugely depending on what you need them to do. Not an option for everyone.

They're funded by the council in the same way a home is.
kittensinthekitchen · 22/03/2022 08:19

I haven't read the whole thread so apologies if I am repeating.

The most important thing to consider is POA. This needs sorting out well in advance. So many people leave the mistake of leaving it until they see obvious signs of mental decline, in which case it is often too late. This needs to be organised whilst the person you care for, or are involved in the care of, is lucid and capable. Don't leave it too late.

floofycroissant · 22/03/2022 08:15

I worry about this. My DM is pretty ignorant to ageing and refuses to commit to the basics, like a will or a funeral plan... She doesn't seem to connect the dots that it's just more work left to her children. Definitely doesn't have the funds for a home/care. It's a scary prospect. She did start to drop hints about granny flats and the like, but I ignored them. I feel like I need to have this conversation

There's a big difference in popping in to help occasionally, and having to be there 3, 4 or 5 times a day to physically take someone to every bathroom break, clean them and their home, cook and deal with the emotional burden. Which I have seen happen second hand.

Frankly it's selfish. Parenting doesn't end. It's a job for life and if a parent doesn't make plans for the end of theirs that considers the impact of their children, then it shows a parents lack of care and frankly bad parenting.

Once a degenerative disease takes hold it is like managing an entirely second life, with the carer sacrificing their own to some extent. A child doesn't owe a parent that, regardless of how good/bad their upbringing was.

I wish we would talk about death more openly as a society.

Finallydoneit20220 · 22/03/2022 07:53

I cared for my mum at home when i was 22 and dd was 1 . She got cancer and refused to go into hospital after it came back. She would scream at me for calling the gp or anyone else. She suffered incontinence but refused a pad or slip. She needed nursing care for her surgery wounds but expected me do it. I made a promise to my dd and then my other two dc

that they would never have to care for me. Any good parent will want their dc to live their own life.

thenewduchessoflapland · 22/03/2022 07:47

@geekchicz

That’s what happened to us FilbbertyGiblets. Also people don’t understand what dementia is - there’s a whole spectrum between grandma nodding gently in the corner reminiscing about the past and people needing to be sectioned at the later stages . People do “ manage “ with dementia in the early stages but it goes on for years . My mother regularly believed she was living a duplicate house right down to the carpets, pictures etc . She was angry and regular took her frustration out on me as her world shrunk and shifted like sand She could at that time just about make a cup of tea and knew who the prime minister was . Dementia is a devious disease. 1 in 4 of us will get it . My mother had a small stroke in her mid 70s and it all stemmed from there . I started off organising online shopping and right at them end I was doing intimate care with professional paid carers because of the Pingdemic and the awful situation we were in

A friend's housemate had her elderly mother move in with them for a few weeks whilst they found an alternative care home for her (there was some serious issues with safeguarding with the former care home).

My friend helped her housemate with care as they both worked.The elderly mother had dementia;she needed constant supervision,had no concept of night or day and didn't sleep for more than 2 hours at a time.She would have flashbacks to the past including traumatic events in her life;unfortunately these flashbacks were as real to her as if she was actually living those moments again.

thenewduchessoflapland · 22/03/2022 07:33

I won't be providing care for my parents;I owe them absolutely nothing.Not after the way they treated me during my childhood.

The only thing I will be doing is providing care for my brother with additional needs when my parents aren't able to anymore.

freshcarnation · 22/03/2022 07:33

With Alzheimer's the person often will get to a stage where they don't are their child anymore. I looked after mum, took her out for trips in her wheelchair twice a week shopping, for meals etc til very near the end, but she didn't know who I was. I was a carer to her. She remembered my siblings and would buy presents and cards etc for them, but when I said it was my birthday soon she said 'why would I care about that, I only care about my son'. Caring for an elderly person can be a total headfuck.

JudgeRindersMinder · 22/03/2022 07:28

@PinkFluffyUnicornSlippers

Personally I think you’re being selfish but then again I love my mum 🤷‍♀️ I just want her to be safe in her old age.
How very fucking DARE you imply that a relative going into care means they’re not loved

There’s a hell of a lot of judgement on this thread and it’s not very nice.

Both my parents ended their days in a card home due to Alzheimer’s disease combined with other physical issues. My dad needed to go into the home when me moving in with him combined with carers visiting 4x a day just wasn’t enough. I’ll never forget being in the taxi with him looking back at the house he’d built with my mum and knowing he wasn’t going back there.

I lost most of my children’s childhoods to looking after my mum, as the situation was very complex due to her having Alzheimer’s so young,. We’. never get that time back, and hell will freeze over before I’d allow my children to do the same for me.

It’s only since my dad died almost 2 years ago that I’ve had any kind of a life and got my mental health back. I’d never have not done it, but my god it came at a price.

Walk a mile in my shoes before you make pronouncements about “of course I will, I love them”

Melissa1771 · 22/03/2022 07:23

I am really hoping that when the time comes for more care, they will be able to move in with us and we can buy in some extra home help and adjust the house to be more safe. (Assuming the needs are not severe). I do see it as selfish when an older person wants to maintain their independence and their own household, but actually has become very dependent and their kids are running around doing errands that could be saved by just living together. Nothing wrong at all with being dependent (we all are sometimes, it’s part of life) but I hope they are humble enough to admit they’ve reached that point.

TillyTopper · 22/03/2022 07:18

Unless your mum is incapacitated now and needs help why do you think you need to talk to her about it? If she can't look after herself, doesn't wash, doesn't remember to wear clean clothes and skips meals then I understand, but her just talking about it doesn't mean it's anywhere near decision time.

My mum is now in a care home and actually she loves it - it is one with the same ethos as her religion though. After my dad died we did try having her to live with us but it was extremely difficult in all sorts of ways. She expected a lot of attention as my dad had given her and we both work full time, she wouldn't go anywhere else to meet people so she was often by herself and her strict religious views clashed, especially with one of my DCs. She always said she didn't want to go to a home, but I honestly believe she prefers it there, we couldn't live up to her expectations of how we should be!

RidingMyBike · 22/03/2022 07:11

Start the conversation off re what she (not you, she) is going to do. Mine presented me with a key to her house 'in case of a fall' and I had to point out that, given I live two hours away and travel all over U.K. for work, the chances of me getting to her house on the same day as a fall were fairly remote. I've suggested she also give a key to a couple of her local friends. Whether she will is another matter "I wouldn't want to bother them!" Hmm

Porcupineintherough · 22/03/2022 07:00

Unless your mum has 60k a year just sitting around to pay for a care home, just "going I to a home" wont be an option for her. She'll only be admitted if she is unable to manage at home with carers, and even then you may need to fight.

I think you'd be better off starting as you mean to go on (not taking on caring responsibilities)

freshcarnation · 22/03/2022 06:59

My FIL stayed at home with only my DH looking after him until he died two years ago. My mum died two weeks ago at home. She had Alzheimer's and was bed bound and non verbal at the end. I had looked after her long with a carer for decades.

Mum never looked after her own parents, but expected me to look after her. I think I'll probably need counselling at some stage soon as I'm not in a great way now.

It will be a cold day in hell before I allow my kids to look after me.

cptartapp · 22/03/2022 06:47

Surely no parent worth their salt would be selfish enough to allow their busy adult DC in the prime of their life with jobs and families of their own to become their carer?! It's what we 'scrimp and save' for all our lives isn't it? To buy in care and help as needed and let our DC live their own opportunities after they've had theirs.

My DM ended up on antidepressants and BP meds running round after my GM. It certainly tainted their relationship and left unpleasant memories at the end. I would sure feel a lot less of any parent that expected this of me.
We all have choices OP. Just do what you want. You don't actually have to do anything.In fact, letting a crisis develop is often the best way to force resistant change.

montysma1 · 22/03/2022 06:33

"I don't want yo go in a home" isn't passive aggressive.
Its an expression of her wishes which she is entitled to make.
I imagine in 30 years you will be expressing the same wish

ProfessorScarlett · 22/03/2022 06:14

Yanbu. This is why all should be paying into a private pension, so that they can afford decent care when old.

YanTanTetheraPetheraPimp · 22/03/2022 05:51

@knittingaddict

Some of the posts on here are making me Angry. Have a bit of empathy for those with less than lovely parents FFS.
Exactly. My parents expected me to do a 35 mile round trip any time of the day or night every time one of them was incontinent. Dad refused to pay for Carers and cancelled any care package arrangements made on hospital discharge or by me. ‘You’re a nurse, you’re used to cleaning up people’ was my mother’s attitude. The fact my 2 sisters lived within a mile or so but ‘didn’t like clearing up shit’ was fine. Resentment? You bet. My parents had more money than I will ever had and could easily have afforded carers 24/7 if necessary. Eventually both had to go into a nursing home, they should have gone months earlier.
GiantHaystacks2021 · 22/03/2022 05:09

Sounds like she's earmarked you for her care, all right.

If she's anything like my relatives, she could be very ill, immobilised and bedridden for a long, long, long, long time, I'm talking decades here, before she dies.
And then if she deteriorates badly, she will need lifting and carrying, feeding, intubation, changing pads, turning in bed etc.
That needs professional care and more than one pair of helping hands.

SquirrelG · 22/03/2022 03:18

Hell would freeze over before I'd put my parents in a home. I've done the caring before and yes it's awful, but its better than knowing they are being ignored for long periods of time and possibly mistreated and wasting away, as I've seen happen.

Surely if someone is going to put their parents in a home then they do some research and choose a good one? My friend had carers coming to her DM, plus help from her, and the best neighbour in the world who was in and out all day checking on her. She then broke her hip and ended up in a home - and my friend can't believe the difference in her. She has put on weight and rather than dying in a few months, as my friend expected, she is doing really well. My friend was very reluctant to put her DM into a home and now sees that it was the best possible outcome.

I don't live in the UK, but are care homes there really as bad as some posters suggest? Any here which I've had experience of - my own DM was in two, and thrived in both (the first one closed due to low numbers), and all the homes in my town have good reputations.

expat101 · 22/03/2022 03:15

My DM has been in a care environment for over 6 years, so she hasn't fallen into the gap yet...

You can only do what you can. I too find Mum incredibly needy, have been told she was a better daughter to her mum than I am to her etc.

it hurts like hell, and i know I am a good person but there is such a thing as self preservation too....

Weatherwax13 · 22/03/2022 02:35

@geekchicz that sounds nightmarish Flowers

Italiangreyhound · 22/03/2022 02:17

Does your mum own her own home. My mum did, she got dementia and sold her home to fund her care. There was no way me or my sister could have looked after her at home. She needed a lot of care we could not give. She lived for some years in the care home at the end of her life.

I really think having to look after elderly relatives is very hard, especially if it is a full time job leaving no time for other things. I don't expect my kids to look after me.

Please do not feel guilty, your mum made her choices, maybe she felt she had no choice, but I think you do.

Thanks
MangyInseam · 22/03/2022 02:09

I don't think the issue is that people don't understand that caring is hard. It's just that in the end, it's often non-negotiable. Barring cases where a child won't get involved at all - and there are valid reasons to do that - even if you do place a parent in a home, there are significant care demands in many cases. People get old, someone has to care for them, and the options may not be great whether it is at home or in a facility.

While venting or discussing these kinds of stresses can be helpful, I'm just not sure how helpful it is to frame it as something we want or don't want. I want my parents to die like a friend of min's dad - he went for his daily walk, sat down on a bench, and was found dead still sitting there two hours later. But chances are like most other people they will be in need of significant support for some years.

Cameleongirl · 22/03/2022 01:12

@geekchicz. That’s such a sad story and unfortunately, it’s the reality of caring for many people. 💐