Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to be a parental carer in future?

190 replies

janeseymour78 · 20/03/2022 20:57

My mother has been a carer for the last ten years to her parents. She partially did this so that my grandparent could stay at home. At the beginning it was very hard and time consuming and she said 'if I get I'll like that in future please just put me in a home'. I would argue she has done barely anything with her life aside from this in that time.

The other day she said that homes are terrible places because anyone that goes there dies within months of arrival. She also commented on how much costs had been saved by keeping grandparent at home. So this change of tune makes me think she now expects me to give up my life in a similar way if need be.

I have always had a complicated relationship with my mother - she wasn't a great parent due to her own issues and acknowledges this.

Recently I have started thinking she is getting older and I should consider talking to her about if/when she gets ill in future. About how we would handle it. AIBU?

OP posts:
Wellthisiscrapeh · 22/03/2022 13:36

It’s not like when they are in a home, thats it, you are free.

The worry, the emotional pain, the turmoil of dreading each visit because you just don’t know how they will be that day is sometimes debilitating. I still can’t enjoy my life, it’s still all consuming.

So don’t assume even a care home is the easy option.

Nothing about having elderly parents with dementia or other diseases is easy.

freshcarnation · 22/03/2022 13:34

@Wellthisiscrapeh You're a good daughter. You are keeping your dad safe. And keeping other people safe from his actions. My mum stayed at home with dementia. I wish I had been able to get her transferred into a home after her last hospital stay, but sadly she was returned back home to die. It was awful.

SockFluffInTheBath · 22/03/2022 13:25

@Wellthisiscrapeh I don’t know what to say, that’s so sad and awful for you all. You’re not evil or selfish, I hope you do know that.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 22/03/2022 13:17

I did it for 20 years and whereas I did it mostly willingly it stole a large chunk of my youth (I was a late in life child).

Look before you leap and beware the slowly boiling crab.

Wellthisiscrapeh's story is the reality.

Wellthisiscrapeh · 22/03/2022 13:11

This thread makes me so sad.

My father has been in a care home since December. I’ve known that he’s had some form of dementia for a couple of years. No one would help me. No one would listen.

I lived two hours away after I had no choice in moving as I couldn’t afford to live where we were anymore. Last year things got so bad that he was a danger driving. he was bashing his neighbours cars parking, he was going out at all hours of the night thinking it was daytime. he would call me screaming and disoriented and was hallucinating.

I had to call an ambulance in the end, one day when he was just screaming saying he was going to drive away and not come back, and he was admitted to hospital, I couldn’t get to him as I have a young baby and there’s no one else to help.

The hospital said he was fine, even though when I got there he was telling them all he was on a cruise ship or a space ship. He was just talking absolute nonsense as usual, hallucinating, social worker and consultant just wanted him gone and into my care.

I brought him home with me. He wasn’t safe alone.

He was shouting day and night, agitated. He threw his lithium hearing aid batteries all over the floor - if I hadn’t had have my eyes on my 12 months old all the time, the worst could have happened and she could have swallowed one.

He kept trying to get out the house, he kept trying to use the kitchen in the night, he could have burned my house down. He refused to wash.

A GP told me to lock him in a room (I didn’t, and yes, I complained).

Social services assessed and sent a carer once a day to wash him. He refused to be washed so nothing they could do.

All the time I was dealing with him and my three children and my husband was trying to work from home, taking calls with my dad shrieking in the background.

He fell and ended up in hospital. They called me 12 hours later saying he was fine to go home. I got there and he was hallucinating again. Telling people my hat JFK was sitting next to him with his gun shot wound and needed help. But apperently, all was fine.

I basically staged a sit in and said i wasn’t going anywhere until someone assessed him for dementia. Long and stressful story, brain scans showed vascular dementia.

Still they wanted me to take him to my home. I refused. I just couldn’t take anymore after 8 weeks of hell and my children upset and confused.

We tried home care. But he was distressed at having to pay for it. refused even though he didn’t have a choice, I have POA. He kept trying to drive his car. when we moved his car, he’d call car dealers to buy another. He barricaded the door so they couldn’t get in.

The care home works better. He’s got enough for two years self funding when he sells his house.

It’s still not easy for me. he’s in one near me. He comes to visit a day each weekend and all he does is talk about his money. Where is it, i want to go to the bank, where is my money going. You are stealing my money. I want to buy a new car. Take me to buy a car now. It doesn’t stop. It’s very stressful and it’s making me ill. But it’s worse if we don’t see him or take him out.

He didn’t want every thing he had to go on care . He wanted to leave what he had to his grandkids, this causes him distress too. And believe me, I’ve got nothing so an inheritance would have been great - but to what detriment? My marriage? My children, my mental health?

He doesn’t understand he’s got dementia. He thinks he’s fine. He blames me for putting him in a home. That’s when he knows where he is.

I visit him with my 8 year old on a Wednesday eve - when he sees us again for the day on a saturday, he doesn’t remember we came and accuses me of abandoning him.

But he’s being washed now. he’s eating well.

But, As someone so helpfully said upthread
that’s just existing. What’s the alternative? Sitting unwashed starving himself to death as he was doing before? Or living with me and putting my children at risk?

And he can’t go out in a car and kill someone.
He can’t burn his house down or wander off in between care visits.

I’ve been told i’m selfish. I’ve been told I’m evil. But these last few years when I knew he was ill and no one would help have broken me. Those 8 weeks he lived with me, my children were at risk from harm. He was at risk from himself. i hardly slept. Me and my husband were at breaking point.

My dad had me later in life, my mum died 30 years ago. He’s 87 and I’m 41 with my youngest child still a baby, we have no other family.

This whole situation is killing me. I wish he was dead for all our sakes, most of all his because his life is a living hell.

Looking after someone with dementia is terrifying. It’s not like having your nice old grandad sat in the corner with a paper. People have no idea what it’s actually like and therefore, they have no right to judge.

bebanjo · 22/03/2022 11:35

May things are at play.
Firstly as a career iv seen family’s tear themselves apart keeping loved ones at home, because we promised never to put them in a home.
Family homes are not built for hospital beds, commodes, hoists and stand aids. There is never enough space and families get very upset when told they have to move things out of the way, it’s there home, but it’s also someone’s work space.

As a society we find more and more ways to keep people alive longer and longer, I’m sure over the next 30 years there will be more living wills refusing treatment.

The care crisis, cares are not payed well enough for what they do and the stupid split shift system in place at the moment. But no one wants to pay more, everyone wants to look after there inheritance.
Until things improve for carers there will be massive waiting lists for care, 10% of nhs beds are being blocked keeping people from all kinds of treatment and surgery’s.

RidingMyBike · 22/03/2022 11:32

It used to be a lot easier to get someone into residential (rather than nursing) care but it barely exists now unless you can pay for it. Three elderly relatives in council housing went into residential care and lived there for years. That freed up two council flats for other people. One of them who lived a lot longer (more than 15 years!) was assessed periodically by social services as she kept getting flagged up as not needing nursing care but they'd rock up and then realise how frail she was and that she just wouldn't cope on her own in a flat with carers coming in.

That was a really positive move for them- none of them had children or anyone to visit more frequently than once a week so they'd have been very isolated if they hadn't been in a home. And those homes had a good 'feel'. They didn't stink of pee as soon as you went in. They didn't have a room full of people staring vacantly at a loud tv. The food was lovely!

For my elderly frail distant relative who went into residential care 3 years ago it really made a difference - she'd got very very anxious living on her own and was struggling with food (was having the Wiltshire Farm Foods deliveries but was getting past the point when she could prepare them). She had a cleaner and gardener but would have struggled with multiple carers coming to the house - it takes quite a bit of organising. So residential care was a really positive move for her (but she could afford to self-fund). She was very well looked after thru the pandemic whereas if she'd still been at home with carers it would have been a nightmare

iklboo · 22/03/2022 11:27

It’s the responsibility of the person who organises the funeral to pay the bill. If there are no funds then the local authority has a statutory duty to bury or cremate “destitute dead”. Sorry for the brutal term, but that’s what it’s referred to as.

It was me paying the bill on both occasions. As I said, luckily they had insurance. But thank you for the info on the local authority duty, that's really helpful for future reference. It is a brutal term but that's government for you. ☺️

Patternmagic · 22/03/2022 10:21

The upshot of having a shitty father is that I don't have to give a shit about him and when he decides he actually does need us in his life, they'll be no one there. Boo hoo.

My mum on the other hand has been everything and more and is a carer herself (to a friend) and absolutely does not want any of us to care for her. How that will actually work out when/if the time comes, who knows. It's easy to have a plan but best laid plans and all that!!! Especially if money is an issue.

JudgeRindersMinder · 22/03/2022 10:08

[quote iklboo]@JudgeRindersMinder - my parents' bank didn't. I have to wait for probate to be granted. Luckily they both had insurance to cover the costs. Also, what if there's no money in the bank, or insufficient funds? [/quote]
It’s the responsibility of the person who organises the funeral to pay the bill. If there are no funds then the local authority has a statutory duty to bury or cremate “destitute dead”. Sorry for the brutal term, but that’s what it’s referred to as.

Ganymedemoon · 22/03/2022 09:56

When my aunt died 3 years ago her bank realised £5K max for the funeral. The cost was £6.5K so had to pay that and reclaim it when funds were released a year later. She did have a funeral plan which included a quite expensive service. But I imagine like everything funeral costs will be going up and unless the banks have started increasing the amount they release for a funeral people will have to pay some costs up front.

iklboo · 22/03/2022 09:46

@JudgeRindersMinder - my parents' bank didn't. I have to wait for probate to be granted. Luckily they both had insurance to cover the costs. Also, what if there's no money in the bank, or insufficient funds?

OfstedOffred · 22/03/2022 09:40

You helping her isnt the only option. Getting some paid help in at the right time can help people live well in their own homes for longer. My grandparents had cleaners etc which reduced the likelihood of them falling which can accelerate care needs. You can also help a lot remotely for example by ordering shopping deliveries.

floofycroissant · 22/03/2022 09:34

I wasn't necessarily just thinking about the cost. It's the organisation too: cremate? Bury? What location? Who needs to attend? What would she have wanted? All whilst grieving.

I get it's often the norm with unexpected deaths, but it doesn't hurt to have a rough plan that could help family members

JudgeRindersMinder · 22/03/2022 09:17

@iklboo

a will is important - I can't see the point of a funeral plan though unless are much better off than your children (but even then I thought the costs would come out of the estate rather than children having to pay upfront).

Unless you have insurance the children have to pay for the funeral up front. Probate can take months, even with a will. They can reclaim from the estate, but very few funeral directors these days will act without payment.

Absolutely not the case. Banks release money for a funeral bill
NeedleNoodle3 · 22/03/2022 09:11

My DF’s bank said they’d release the money for his funeral early but it was only 2k so I paid it and then took it out of the estate when probate was issued 4 weeks after his death.

iklboo · 22/03/2022 09:06

a will is important - I can't see the point of a funeral plan though unless are much better off than your children (but even then I thought the costs would come out of the estate rather than children having to pay upfront).

Unless you have insurance the children have to pay for the funeral up front. Probate can take months, even with a will. They can reclaim from the estate, but very few funeral directors these days will act without payment.

HotPenguin · 22/03/2022 09:00

The most common solution these days is for elderly people to stay in their own home and have visits from social services carers to help with dressing, meals etc. It's actually quite hard to get a funded place in a home. If and when your mum gets to the stage of being eligible for a home it may well be impossible for you to care for her at home anyway. That's the case for both my relatives who have gone into homes. They started wondering at night, refusing to go to bed etc.

Jobseeker19 · 22/03/2022 08:54

I have observed how they do things in my husbands culture with regards to parental care.

Firstly, I believe this is why they have a lot of children. To spread the burden.

My grandmother inlaw went partially blind from diabetes but was mobile she would spend 3 months in each child's house being looked after. All of the other siblings would help going to whoever house is was.

It didn't look too strenuous, most people had children and she would become another fixture in the home. The adults also seemed to be in competition trying to be the best host, having parties etc it never seemed depressing. By the end of the 3 months though you could tell the host was fed up but then she would move on. (I knew this from my mum in laws turn)

This would even take her across different countries as a lot of her children lived abroad.

This is in a culture where care homes don't exist so I'm guessing its not a choice its just something they are expected to take on.

When it got too bad and she became immobile she spend most of the time at her home with a paid for carer but then all of her children would take turns staying with her and keeping her company and taking her out.

I like to think that I would do that for my mum but my mum only had 3 children and what if she has complex care needs?

Is there a hybrid system of care, where you can have a carer part time if needed?

I also think about myself, what do I want when I'm older? Will I burden my children ?

My own grandmother was looked after heavily by my mum whilst my auntie didn't really do anything. It seemed like she needed a lot of care and me and my sisters would often take her to appointments etc.

After a while she moved into a care home and was 'out of the way'. I would visit her but not often and shamefully it was because it was boring and depressing.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 22/03/2022 08:44

You can plan all you like but to be honest, it's never how you think it's going to be and you just have to deal with it all when a crisis happens.

berlinbabylon · 22/03/2022 08:36

This is why all should be paying into a private pension, so that they can afford decent care when old

expensive does not = decent, unfortunately

berlinbabylon · 22/03/2022 08:35

My DM is pretty ignorant to ageing and refuses to commit to the basics, like a will or a funeral plan

a will is important - I can't see the point of a funeral plan though unless are much better off than your children (but even then I thought the costs would come out of the estate rather than children having to pay upfront).

and in my post above I mean her not you ;)

MrsSkylerWhite · 22/03/2022 08:34

ProfessorScarlett

Yanbu. This is why all should be paying into a private pension, so that they can afford decent care when old“

Marvellous. Wish everyone had thought of that.
Minimum wage, struggling to cover the spiralling bills, eating 15p noodles, kids school shoes too small. How exactly do these millions of people take out a private pension?

berlinbabylon · 22/03/2022 08:33

As pp's have said, there is a massive difference between helping out with shopping or lifts to hospital appointments, maybe gardening or cleaning/laundry to actual personal care.

If I lived closer to my mother I would be happy to help you with the shopping etc, I'd pay for gardening and cleaning, but any personal care needs to be done by professionals who have training in how to lift people etc.

My father lived in sheltered accommodation so he managed on his own with a cleaner and me arranging online shopping until six months before he died, and then he was in a home. It took two people to take him to the toilet. Those of you who think caring for elderly people is so easy need to do some research.

MrsSkylerWhite · 22/03/2022 08:29

Gwenhwyfar

"My two siblings have no children so I would think they should be in line before me! "

WTF? You chose to have children.“

Absolutely this.