Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does she have to pay this?

67 replies

cantthinkofabetterusername · 20/03/2022 20:33

DD is 17, in September she started work for a well known clothes shop. She took time off due to MH and they effectively didn't keep her on as she'd only been there a few weeks.
She received her final wage in October which was a normal wage and stated she had sick pay on there.
Fast forward to this weekend they've sent her a letter saying she was paid in error and she owes them £600 which they want back in 2 weeks!
DD is currently waiting for her DBS to come back and awaiting a start date for a new job so has absolutely no means of paying it, neither do I.
OH says to ignore it, it's their mistake and it's been months but I don't want them to take her to court.
Does she have to pay it?

OP posts:
BoredZelda · 20/03/2022 22:58

There’s a good chunk of your Sunday evening you’ll never get back.

😆😆😆

Hankunamatata · 20/03/2022 22:56

Surely you can see if she has been overpaid from pay slips. October would have been statutory sick pay at the most if she is working in retail so £96.35 a week so £385 ish for the month of October. Yes she will need to pay it back

MichelleScarn · 20/03/2022 22:35

@TheRealityCheque would they not just have to say, here's the breakdown, you got paid for 8 weeks, you only worked 4.

TheRealityCheque · 20/03/2022 22:12

@middleparking

Lol. It took less than 2 minutes. And practically guarantees you won't hear from that company again.

MiddleParking · 20/03/2022 22:05

@TheRealityCheque

"Dear CF company,

Due to the wording on the payslip, I was unaware that an error has been made.

I have accepted the money in good faith, believing it to be correct. The money has since been spent and as I am currently not working I have no way of repaying anything.

Furthermore, you have not produced amy suitable breakdown of how you perceive an overpayment has been made.

If you wish to provide me with a detailed breakdown of how you believe an overpayment has been made, I will engage the services of a professional payroll specialist to confirm this.

As any error would have been made by yourselves, If the specialist agrees then I will arrange a payment plan to return any monies owed to you, less the cost charged to me of the specialist. Please also note that if the cost of the specialist exceeds the vhe of any monies owed by me I will instead invoice you for the difference.

You sending me the detailed breakdown will constitute your acceptance of these terms.

Regards

Me"

There’s a good chunk of your Sunday evening you’ll never get back.
TheRealityCheque · 20/03/2022 22:01

"Dear CF company,

Due to the wording on the payslip, I was unaware that an error has been made.

I have accepted the money in good faith, believing it to be correct. The money has since been spent and as I am currently not working I have no way of repaying anything.

Furthermore, you have not produced amy suitable breakdown of how you perceive an overpayment has been made.

If you wish to provide me with a detailed breakdown of how you believe an overpayment has been made, I will engage the services of a professional payroll specialist to confirm this.

As any error would have been made by yourselves, If the specialist agrees then I will arrange a payment plan to return any monies owed to you, less the cost charged to me of the specialist. Please also note that if the cost of the specialist exceeds the vhe of any monies owed by me I will instead invoice you for the difference.

You sending me the detailed breakdown will constitute your acceptance of these terms.

Regards

Me"

cantthinkofabetterusername · 20/03/2022 22:01

@Pyri she had a full months wage at the end of September

OP posts:
Pyri · 20/03/2022 21:58

@cantthinkofabetterusername

The wage was the same wage she usually got and as it stated sick pay on there she assumed it was right
Given she only worked there for a month I’m surprised she could count on the wage she “normally” got!
cantthinkofabetterusername · 20/03/2022 21:55

[quote BeanStew22]Agree with PPs, the money can be legitimately reclaimed but the company need to be reasonable on timeframes : see below from ACAS

www.acas.org.uk/reclaim-money-owed-by-an-employee[/quote]
Thank you

OP posts:
cantthinkofabetterusername · 20/03/2022 21:53

@Nightdancer

Wow. A few shitty responses here. Yes OP, if she was paid in error she will definitely have to pay it back.

Firstly, who at 17 knows all about employment law and sick pay? She's 17 fucking years old. Even adults might not be well acquainted with the ins and outs of sick pay. It could be that they've just never abused the system - doesn't mean they don't have a fucking job.

Thank you so much. I work 2 jobs, my OH works full time. None of us take time off sick so I'm not clued up on sick pay but in my main job I get full pay for 6 months. Just because I don't abuse the system doesn't mean I don't work! Quite the opposite in fact.
OP posts:
cantthinkofabetterusername · 20/03/2022 21:49

@Spud1130

So this happened in October and they've now just noticed and given her 2 weeks? 2 weeks until what happens?

Have they contacted her about this previously and she's ignored it hoping it'll go away?

No yesterday was the first we've heard from them
OP posts:
Nightdancer · 20/03/2022 21:45

@rainyskylight 👏 absolutely! If personnel/wages can't get it right, why should a young person, who could possibly be in their first job, know whether their payment is correct? At 17 I would've well been hitting the town on that wage Grin

rainyskylight · 20/03/2022 21:39

agree with @Nightdancer. reading payslips is not straightforward and it takes time and experience to know how to spot an error. further, the OP's DD reasonably thought that her well-known clothes shop employer would know what the hell they're doing.

DysmalRadius · 20/03/2022 21:39

She could offer to pay it back £5pcm for 12m if she's on low pay. A court would only expect payments that are reasonable and affordable....

That would take 10 years to pay back!! Surely it works be better to pay it off as quickly as possible?

Nightdancer · 20/03/2022 21:37

Wow. A few shitty responses here. Yes OP, if she was paid in error she will definitely have to pay it back.

Firstly, who at 17 knows all about employment law and sick pay? She's 17 fucking years old. Even adults might not be well acquainted with the ins and outs of sick pay. It could be that they've just never abused the system - doesn't mean they don't have a fucking job.

Spud1130 · 20/03/2022 21:33

So this happened in October and they've now just noticed and given her 2 weeks? 2 weeks until what happens?

Have they contacted her about this previously and she's ignored it hoping it'll go away?

BeanStew22 · 20/03/2022 21:18

Agree with PPs, the money can be legitimately reclaimed but the company need to be reasonable on timeframes : see below from ACAS

www.acas.org.uk/reclaim-money-owed-by-an-employee

cantthinkofabetterusername · 20/03/2022 21:13

@Booboobagins thank you

OP posts:
cantthinkofabetterusername · 20/03/2022 21:10

@BuanoKubiamVej

If it's a legitimate debt then yes she would need to repay it sooner or later. But not in 2 weeks. If she had no way of knowing that it wasn't just her wages that were due then it's entirely her right to have spent it before they told her their mistake. So she can offer a repayment plan. Even £5/m would mean that it wouldn't be worth the company's while to take her to court because the court would just say she has to carry on paying the £5/m and eventually the debt will be paid. They can't charge interest as any interest would have to be agreed in advance.
Thank you that's what I meant when I said none of us can repay it, not in 2 weeks. DD is happy to set up a payment plan when she starts her new job but we don't know when that will be
OP posts:
BuanoKubiamVej · 20/03/2022 21:08

If it's a legitimate debt then yes she would need to repay it sooner or later. But not in 2 weeks. If she had no way of knowing that it wasn't just her wages that were due then it's entirely her right to have spent it before they told her their mistake. So she can offer a repayment plan. Even £5/m would mean that it wouldn't be worth the company's while to take her to court because the court would just say she has to carry on paying the £5/m and eventually the debt will be paid. They can't charge interest as any interest would have to be agreed in advance.

Orchidsonthetable · 20/03/2022 21:07

But op you said it was normal pay? Your company pays full wage for a month if you’ve only been there a month? That’s very generous and highly unusual.

Booboobagins · 20/03/2022 21:07

@cantthinkofabetterusername

Just to add, if she owes it we will obviously pay it back I was just checking if she had to
They can't require payment in 2 weeks how ridiculous.

She could offer to pay it back £5pcm for 12m if she's on low pay. A court would only expect payments that are reasonable and affordable....

Def check what she should have been paid - you can look up sick pay values on line and just do some approx maths. Alternatively ask her ex employer to break it down for her then you can take a look. She will need revised payslips as the data is reported to HMRC and her record needs correcting.

cantthinkofabetterusername · 20/03/2022 21:06

@Orchidsonthetable

She can’t have thought she’d get full pay when she’d been only there a month? Surely not, do none of you work?
Yes I do thank you OH works full time and I have 2 jobs.
OP posts:
cantthinkofabetterusername · 20/03/2022 21:05

@Wannakisstheteacher

So you thought she’d be paid, in full, for a whole month when she was off sick, after being there for 4 weeks?
No. Her payslip stated sick pay and some companies do pay sick pay with a sick note even if you've been there a few weeks mine does.
OP posts:
SolasAnla · 20/03/2022 21:05

If she was paid money outside her contract in error then yes she has an obligation to repay the money she received.

NB she is only obliged to repay the nett cash amount

If the £600 was the amount before deductions (tax NI etc.) then only the cash transferred must be repaid.
She should agree a repayment schedule based on what she can afford to pay out of the wage from her new job.

Also if she ceased employment she should check what payroll data has been filed with HMRC.