Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Avoiding getting shafted but still being fair.

54 replies

daffidoodledandy · 20/03/2022 19:17

Looking for opinions on a fair split of house-selling proceeds.

Partner and I have reached the end of a hard relationship. We bought the house jointly about 7 years ago, just under £250k. Partner put down £90k deposit from his previous house, I was a first time buyer. He chose not to ring-fence his deposit.

The mortgage was calculated on my salary only because his wages were/are irregular. I paid moving costs, fixed his old boiler and simple redecoration on the old house to get it ready for sale, and bought new appliances for the new house. Over the years, I've also replaced the windows, had a new boiler, gas line and heating put in, and bought a new oven and washing machine.

On average, I pay £1000 into the joint account each month, though that sometimes goes up to £1500. He is meant to pay £400, but sometimes misses a month. In 2017, he didn't pay anything for the year when he was struggling with mental illness.

We don't have children. Not married. The house is estimated to be worth around £390k now.

How can we work out the best/ fairest way to split the money when we sell the house?

OP posts:
SallyLovesCheese · 20/03/2022 19:32

Hang on, missed off that you covered his £400 on the times he missed it.

So... You paid £12,800 to cover his missed months and then £16,800 in 2017, so your total is around £103,600. So he gets £10,200 then the rest 50:50.

So maybe just split in half!!

SallyLovesCheese · 20/03/2022 19:27

Tricky.

So in 7 years he's roughly paid around £24k (6 years x average of £4,000 a year (£400x 10 to account for missed months)). Add that to his £90k deposit, so £114k. You've paid £84k, then, say £8-10k for new boiler and windows etc? So around £94k. So he gets £20k back, then you split the rest in half?

Not sure if that makes sense!

SarahProblem · 20/03/2022 19:26

50/50. Has he suggested otherwise?

RealBecca · 20/03/2022 19:23

I'd go 5050.

You pay at least £1100 per month more.

1100x12 = 13,200 per year. Times 7 years = 92,400 (greater than his deposit).

Sounds like you didn't make a formal written agreement on the deposit, nor the boiler costs, moving fees etc.

So to avoid legal fees I'd go 5050 and consider that a costly lesson for the future.