Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband and toddler dinner time battles

115 replies

babyandthelion · 20/03/2022 18:24

I have a 14mo DS.

Every evening our routine is that I go take a break for an hour while DH feeds him his dinner. Every day it ends in hysterical child and stressed our DH.

I have a knack (probably cos I am with him all day) of getting Ds to eat and I can normally get him to finish his breakfast or lunch. Yes he does throw some on the floor but I'd say 80% goes in.

DH has little tolerance for DS throwing food and he will simply remove the plate and then hand him tiny bites of food which then upsets DS. I just hate listening to them have this battle every night.

Why is it when I feed ds I can manage to get him to eat and he's happy and full at the end but when DH feeds him it ends up like this?

He asks me to not give him tips or advice as he needs to find his own way which I appreciate but it's becoming a real battle and difficult to listen to and I also think he sleeps better after a full dinner (which on the occasions I feed him he does have).

Is it possible that DS just eats better for me?!? I dread dinner time every day :-(

OP posts:
MaryShelley1818 · 20/03/2022 21:41

You really need to look into the importance of family mealtimes and eating together.
I could not even contemplate making my children eat on their own every night, just awful.
I'm a SW (Child Protection and now Fostering) and it's just basic parenting, not only are you modelling good table manners and eating different foods, it's also social and hugely beneficial for children.
Obviously for some families it won't be possible to do this if working patterns don't allow, but if we are home together, we eat together. Time for you both to put the child's needs above your own preferred routines.

Kdubs1981 · 20/03/2022 21:05

@twinsetandpearl

Honestly if my husband said to me to sit and "observe" whilst I feed my child the "right" way I'd think what a condescending so and so not to mention knocking his confidence

Your child is acting out because he knows he can and because he probably wants you to feed him

I'm afraid you are demonstrating extreme ignorance of the cognitive abilities of a 14 month old. He is a baby, not Machiavelli. He simply doesn't have the ability to manipulate OP's husband in this way. He sounds tired and stresse
Kdubs1981 · 20/03/2022 21:01

Your husband really needs to stop. The end. It will lead to massive anxiety and disordered eating

Dramaticpenguin · 20/03/2022 21:00

I aim for dinner between 5:30 and 6 for us all to eat together, better for children and less stress for me mostly. Occasionally if we're having pizza or similar he has something else (like a toddler ready meal -
I'm not cooking twice!) and then just a bit of that, otherwise it just gets mashed up and not eaten. He's just turned 2 and hardly throws food down at all now but I'd agree with others in that if he throws it all, he's done, get him down nicely, no big deal and he'll soon stop throwing it if he still wants to eat. This is my 3rd boy, plus I childmind so I have fed alot of toddlers. It is incredibly frustrating, but I think the trick is to not let them see, you have to stay unruffled, I got my husband more on board by linking him to some articles, Janet Lansbury's unruffled is a great one to find on FB, and kidseatincolor too x

Caspianberg · 20/03/2022 20:28

Ds is 22 months. Since 6/8 months dinner is together, same meal as dh and I. We all eat together around 6.30pm. Bed at 8pm.

He very rarely throws anything now, but when younger we generally just ate ours and ignored. If on floor, pick up and give back. If again, remove.
At 14 months he had just spoon and fork and made a bit of a mess with hands, now, several months on he’s fairly good with cutlery and uses toddler knife for some bits too.

Booboobagins · 20/03/2022 20:22

Mobbie

Booboobagins · 20/03/2022 20:22

@ILoveYou3000

Your child is acting out because he knows he can and because he probably wants you to feed him

A 14mo literally does not have the capacity to be this manipulative.

OP, why is it more important to your husband that he get his own way rather than making sure your baby is fed? He says he wants to do it 'his way', this isn't working, so he has to change his way.

Doesn't have the capacity to be this manipulative, are you kidding? It's a skill we all learn from birth!

But I don't think he's manipulating anythin, he's responding to hiw your DH is feeding him and frankly you need to leave them be. They will sort it out without your help.

Go for a run or if you're in tge house put music on if yiu can even if it's vua earphones. Tell DH what you're doing and to call your mibbuw if he needs you. Job done.

Wink
Skyeheather · 20/03/2022 20:19

Is your DS actually hungry at dinner time? Mine usually eats all his breakfast and lunch plus has a snack mid morning and mid afternoon and will bf in between if I dare sit down! At dinner time he'll eat a mouthful then throw the rest on the floor.

He seems to eat the most at lunchtime so this is when I now give him his main meal of the day and I just make toast or cheese and crackers in the evening. Mine just seems to full by dinner time and looking forward to his bedtime bf.

Maybe your DS just isn't hungry at 5.30?

AliceW89 · 20/03/2022 20:16

The food throwing phase is awful. It won’t last forever, but it was months and months for us. We did everything suggested - don’t give it attention, pick things up twice then don’t give back, try and redirect their hands…but honestly I think the main healer was time. Never happens now at nearly 2 now.

We can’t eat all together until 6pm so that’s what we do. DS just has a decent snack after his nap and is fine until 6. Eating all together reduces everyone’s stress as your less focused on what DS is eating.

I agree it’s important for you to get a break but mealtime doesn’t seem to work for either you or DH. Can he do the time post dinner instead?

Underfrighter · 20/03/2022 20:16

Also we used to have the bowls and plates that stuck down. We always gave a spare bowl and said if you dont want it, put it here, and they learnt pretty quickly

Tilltheend99 · 20/03/2022 20:16

Do the whole routine an hour later and all eat together.

It doesn’t matter if DS is eating everything you give him at this age. As you are giving him a bedtime breastfeed he is not missing out on any nutrition and, if he is still hungry, he will just take more milk.

Maybe it is also just too exciting having daddy around and if daddy spends the hour you have off playing DS will be more ready to settle for dinner.

Lindaloo08 · 20/03/2022 20:15

Your DH is only getting in from work and is straight away into a feed so his patience is going to be a lot shorter esp. if the mess stresses him out anyway. If you all sit and eat together, get your DC down for 7.30 you have the rest of the evening to relax/go for a run etc. On DH days off, you all eat together and alternate breakfasts with lie ins.

Cleothecat75 · 20/03/2022 20:15

I remember the horror from dh that I was trying to change his mealtime so we could have a family mealtime. Dd was probably around 1 at the time. Honestly, the drama! So I told him I would eat with dd at 5.30 and he could microwave his at his leisure. Dd is 16 and we still eat around 5.30-6 now and have never really varied that. We tend to have pudding later on if we want it (not anything particularly planned, yoghurts/fruit/home baking/tinned custard type Stuff. It works for us and meant the tidying was done much earlier. The times when I’ve worked longare hours, I’ve spent time at the weekends batch cooking, making big lasagnes, shepherds pie, bolanaise sauce etc so we could still eat together that bit earlier.
It’s been lovely to eat together as the dc have grown up and something I look back fondly on (I am well aware I probably have rose tinted glasses on about how lovely a family meal was, but I think it was important that I got dh onside with eating earlier).

Underfrighter · 20/03/2022 20:12

Your husband needs to realise that playing with food, just getting some of it in the mouth but getting a load of it elsewhere and on the floor is developmentally completely normal. Its literally how they learn about food. We had a big wipe clean mat under the high chair that protected the floor and had to change the position when we got beetroot thrown at the wall.
It's a really bad idea to turn mealtimes into a stressful environment and punish your child for his behaviour by removing food. This is harming his development around food and could cause lifelong issues.

I think it's ok to do things his way but not when his way can result in harm to your child and isnt actually achieving anything.

HardbackWriter · 20/03/2022 20:10

[quote elbea]Your husbands behaviour is going to cause long term problems. Parents rigidly controlling the eating process is the number one way to give your child issues.

This organisation is set up by world leading experts in weaning, paediatric occupational therapists, paediatricians. All of their advice is backed by peer reviews literature and signed off by doctors - solidstarts.com/baby-or-toddler-throwing-food-on-the-floor/[/quote]
It sounds like they're both being controlling about food, though, if you read OP's description of what 'her knack' entails.

WalkingOnSonshine · 20/03/2022 20:09

DS is 14 months old and we eat with him when we’re back from work/nursery at any time between 5.30 and 6.30. He’s normally asleep between 7.30 & 7.45.

He’s always wanted to feed himself and we were never able to spoon feed him, but he did go through a throwing phase & still occasionally will now when tired. What helped was giving him smaller amounts but having the rest in his eyeline so he could see that he could have more & anything that he threw, to pick up without a fuss up to three times and encourage him to put it to one side if he doesn’t want it.

Anything more than three times was moved out of his way. He learnt pretty quickly.

RowanAlong · 20/03/2022 20:09

Yep I’d eat at 5.30 - all together. Then you get your break while DH does bath, and you’ve got a free evening from 7.30.

schnubbins · 20/03/2022 20:08

Can't believe that such a fuss could be made about eating.Unbelievable.Just all eat together as a family .Its worked for centuries.

justasmalltownmum · 20/03/2022 20:06

Can sh do breakfast instead?

I find my Lo is happier at breakfast so maybe an easier meal for him to do.

tkwal · 20/03/2022 20:04

Why wouldn't you feed your child when you know he will eat for you. The whole thing will be over and done in a few minutes as opposed to ages . It must be impossible for you to relax anyway when you know this struggle is going on. Is there any reason why you couldn't hand him over to your husband once he's fed ?they could then spend some bonding time reading a book or telling made up stories, playing with suitable toys ?I'm not suggesting it should be a permanent change , just until things settle down. You could use the father/son time to bathe and do whatever else you need to de stress

Unsure33 · 20/03/2022 19:59

The most important thing is for you both to be “ singing from the same hymn sheet “

I agree, have a chat . Try eating together and have a plan .

Totally ignore throwing the food on the floor , both of you .

Relax a bit .

Then agree to try something different after a month if it does not work .

stimpyyouidiot · 20/03/2022 19:55

[quote babyandthelion]@AnneLovesGilbert so we feed him at 5.30pm, bath at 6.15 ish and then a breastfeed at 7pm and normally asleep by 7.30pm.

DH and I then sit down and eat our dinner.

5.30pm just seems really early for us to sit and eat? I guess we just aren't used to that. I'd still be full from lunch (and then probably starving at 9pm!)

Is that what everyone else does? [/quote]
I eat with dd at 4:30-5 most days. I just adjusted. She's hungry after school and I'm not cooking and cleaning up twice.

Happyhappyday · 20/03/2022 19:55

We all eat together at 5:15, it’s early but it’s important to us to eat as a family and there is good research showing this helps kids develop good eating habits. We also don’t “make” DC eat. Food on the plate, small amounts to start and then refill as she eats. We offer, she chooses, if she chooses to eat very little, that’s ok. We don’t offer food outside of set meal times & snacks and she rarely asks. When she’s hungry she’ll gobble up what’s in front of her, when she’s not she just messes around and plays. Knows that if she throws food on the floor dinner is all done. It’s worked really well for us and meals are never a battle. She has always been steadily tracking in the weight centiles so not worried if she has a tiny dinner occasionally, I know if you have a history of feeding concerns it can be harder to let them just get on with eating.

elbea · 20/03/2022 19:54

Your husbands behaviour is going to cause long term problems. Parents rigidly controlling the eating process is the number one way to give your child issues.

This organisation is set up by world leading experts in weaning, paediatric occupational therapists, paediatricians. All of their advice is backed by peer reviews literature and signed off by doctors - solidstarts.com/baby-or-toddler-throwing-food-on-the-floor/

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 20/03/2022 19:54

I wonder if your DH is struggling so much because you're treating DS as being much younger than he is?

Maybe you need to meet in the middle somewhere with how you're doing mealtimes, with both of you there to help.

Swipe left for the next trending thread