Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this isn't normal re DS 12

381 replies

Deereemer · 20/03/2022 18:13

Ds got a tech ban this weekend due to unacceptable behaviour yesterday. The bam is for 3 weeks as things have been getting out of hand with how he has been, increasingly rude, shouty, downright aggressive at times.

He is in his bed crying and i mean wailing because he will miss the new fortnight update. When he stops crying he just stares at the wall and doesn't do anything at. All.

I am worried this is a sign of gaming addiction or depression, i don't know.

Any advice welcomed

OP posts:
underneaththeash · 21/03/2022 18:21

@Deereemer he shouldn't have a computer in his room anyway.

Lennybenny · 21/03/2022 18:10

It is a sign of addiction. He has also, like the rest of them had a strange 2 years. My ds addiction was fifa. That resulted in very bad things happening....however after putting rules in place and broadband apps switching off wifi, things changed. Both my dc are gamers...we still have rules though. A time to finish is key. A warning and then off. It takes a while but having the rules in place now will make all the difference when they're 16. No matter how bad things got they both remembered the rules and automatically did them even though they hated it when I stopped them from gaming till 1, 2 am because they were convinced all their friends were(they weren't)

JeepSleeHack · 21/03/2022 17:50

@Deereemer

Just agog at how many posters are in some way permissive about abusive swearing by their sons.
This post is very telling. Abusive? Are you prone to escalation OP?
Wrinklefree · 21/03/2022 14:13

@StScholastica

3 weeks, Jeez, you get less for murder these days. How bad was his behaviour?
That’s what I thought 🤣 you also need to realise that some of his attitude and cheek maybe down to his hormones, he has no control over that.
Stompythedinosaur · 21/03/2022 11:54

I think the punishment is excessive. 3 weeks is a very long time.

I imagine he is upset because of the social exclusion linked to missing the update. Or perhaps he has just been looking forwards to it. I wouldn't be jumping to calling him manipulative like some pps. I think boys should be supported to be able to express feelings.

I don't think harsh punishments are generally the answer.

WhenISnappedAndFarted · 21/03/2022 11:46

@EarringsandLipstick I think the PP meant more that it will be everywhere at school on their friends phones etc which you can't protect them from.

SafeMove · 21/03/2022 11:14

I completely understand that you are having a tough time OP. I would be curious on how that has impacted on how proportionate and understanding you are around your DS's needs. You seemed more intent on writing about the evils of tech and gaming and lashing out at 'lazy parents' than talking about how distressed you son is. It sounds like you are directing your rage outwards, at people on the thread who disagree with your reaction and at your DS. Instead of trying to figure out what the actual, underlying issue is and wonder how to deal with his distress. Him weeping and staring at a wall sounds like emotional dysregulation and might be a bit beyond typical parent responses. Just removing the console/game for three weeks isn't going to create long term change is it? Have you asked for help from anyone else?

He is a long way off adulthood, has experienced recent trauma and you seem to be expecting adult behaviour and adult choices from him and punishing his (typical for this developmental stage) reactiveness. You are being quite reactive yourself. Maybe it is fear? Maybe it exhaustion? Maybe it is a lack of understanding about what is important to both of you? I hope you get it sorted out as it sounds very difficult and if it has reached that level of difficulty I think an objective, outside intervention might help?

Maves · 21/03/2022 11:14

3 weeks! Tbh yeah he was rude but that's pre/teens for ya. To that age gaming can be important so understand the wailing and shit as he's missing out 3 weeks though is ridiculous. I'd have took the controller for a day or two.

EarringsandLipstick · 21/03/2022 11:08

Thanks for calling me (and my DH) failures as parents

Apologies Justilou. I didn't mean to imply this. It was a reaction to a child not alone accessing content but deliberately circumventing your agreed rules but I expressed it badly - sorry.

EarringsandLipstick · 21/03/2022 11:01

@MangyInseam

Dear God. I'm far from a perfect parent but I'd recognise I had failed pretty badly if I had to resort to these measures to stop my young child watching adult content that I'd already attempted to block

You are being very naive. Watching porn very commonly starts right around 11 or 12. It's just so easy to get at it, not at all like back in the days when they might happen to find an father's stack of magazines in a shed or something. It's easily accessible and designed to keep users coming back. Boys that age don't have a lot of defenses against that, there is a reason it's the number one money-making part of the internet.

Not naive. I have a 10 yo & 12 yo boy as well as an older DD.

They do not watch porn. I'm well aware of its availability and when they are older, the challenges around their access to it will increase. At the moment, they have no access to porn or anything else unsuitable and it's something I take very seriously.

EmpressCixi · 21/03/2022 10:50

[quote nomoremsniceperson]@EmpressCixi

if the child's dad has addiction issues, then the child is more likely to be prone to addiction himself.

Tech addiction is real, I've had it. The last thing OP's son needs is to cope with his feelings by using tech. He needs to properly process his emotions and not run and hide from them in a computer game.

Proper parenting is where you do the difficult thing for the child's own good, not where you let them develop bad habits for the sake of an easy life.[/quote]

  1. there is very little evidence that addiction has a genetic component vs socialisation.
  2. even if the child were addicted to tech, the OP’s method of 3 week ban as punishment is actually the worst way to deal with a tech addiction in a child. And will not work.

I agree poor parenting is about the easy life. It’s easier for the OP to get angry and impose an OTT punishment than it is to actually connect with her child and support him towards healthy emotions and mental state over the loss of his father in his life as well as healthy boundaries in the use of tech.

Knittingchamp · 21/03/2022 09:25

I feel for.you OP, I do really feel for your son, it must be awful for him experiencing what is happening with his dad. Maybe Fortnite was a much needed distraction to disappear into.

We don't allow Fortnite, we just let.him play one game and it's quite a tame one, though all my son's friends play Fortnite. That's because we are worried about the addictive and behaviour change element. What we do is make sure I always get involved in doing stuff together every day after school and weekends though that really isn't so practical for a lot of families and he does watch YouTube too. 3 weeks if you do allow it sounds like a majorly long time, I wonder if it could be lowered and then time you both spend together doing a new hobby maximised? Sounds like he is struggling a lot and might benefit hugely from that.

nomoremsniceperson · 21/03/2022 09:23

@EmpressCixi

if the child's dad has addiction issues, then the child is more likely to be prone to addiction himself.

Tech addiction is real, I've had it. The last thing OP's son needs is to cope with his feelings by using tech. He needs to properly process his emotions and not run and hide from them in a computer game.

Proper parenting is where you do the difficult thing for the child's own good, not where you let them develop bad habits for the sake of an easy life.

nomoremsniceperson · 21/03/2022 09:17

@Deereemer sending Flowers - what a difficult time you all must be having.

I too am quite shocked at how blase some parents are about tech. It's a massive experiment on kids, to let them have so much access to screens at such a young age. It has a terrible effect on kids' systems, on dopamine, on brain circuitry. It IS addictive, badly so.

And if your son is experiencing a difficult time with his Dad, then he will be seeking out gaming as a way to mask bad feelings. This means he will learn that negative emotions are something to run from, not something to come to terms with and process, which is the healthy way to handle them. You need to try to explain to him that running from negative thoughts is an attractive option, especially when it is something as awful as dealing with a parent with unresolved mental illness, but that he can do it. He CAN cope, he CAN process his feelings, he CAN come to terms with how his father is. That's how we build resilience - not by running away, but by facing the things that upset and frighten us.

Good luck OP.

Darbs76 · 21/03/2022 09:12

I’m a fairly liberal parent but when it comes to rudeness I am strict. I have 2 teenagers (17 & 14) and they would never say that to me. If they did they’d definitely be on a tech ban. If you don’t stop it when it starts you end up with 6ft teenagers shouting in your face. Kids need to respect their parents and tolerating being told to get the f*ck out of their room is not on

YanTanTetheraPetheraPimp · 21/03/2022 09:06

Not that my DCs would have been able to access adult only material here in the first place.

YanTanTetheraPetheraPimp · 21/03/2022 09:04

@Deereemer

He told me 'get the fuck out of his room'

Incredible that hes getting it back in 3 werks.

Feeding children addictive games makes parenting easier though doesn't it.

That would earn him a further 3 week ban in this house.
Thirkettle · 21/03/2022 08:43

It's a baby tantrum. Just ignore.

EmpressCixi · 21/03/2022 08:40

I’ve read the updates to the thread and it’s worse than I originally thought. The 3 week tech ban punishment is much more draconian than it initially appeared in the context of the boys home life.

The boys father is struggling with addiction, is medicated and living away in supported housing, so the boy is grieving for the loss of his dad.

And the OP admitted that this grief was part of the reason why he told her to “F off out of his room”. The punishment shockingly harsh parenting. The boy need understanding a communication, not having his entire hobby removed and to be ostracised from all his friends (support network) by missing out on the rare game update that is the biggest event in years.

It’s ridiculous for any parent to expect a child struggling with the loss of a parent to living away to behave perfectly all the time and not slip up at all. The word “fuck” coming out a 12yr olds mouth is hardly shocking behaviour for an almost teen. I’m not saying zero consequences or to permit it, but to have a heart and have that discussion with him about why swearing at a family member is wrong and that everyone is going through a tough time, then apology and perhaps an extra chore or something. But a three week ban? It’s so harsh it is counter productive and honestly could tip his MH- already under immense stress from losing his father- into a clearly vulnerable category.

NewtoHolland · 21/03/2022 02:29

That's a hugely difficult context that you're all living through. It feels like this thread has been used in quite a goady way...but gaming is such an emotive area anyway as it's one of those big parenting guilt things. I think with so many boundaries and consequences it's the way stuff is delivered rather than what you put in place. It's that underlying emotional warmth and whether is a cold, harsh reactive/vindictive punishment, or a firm consequence set with a bit of understanding and love beneath it.
Hopefully he's got the message that speaking to you that way is completely unacceptable.

MangyInseam · 21/03/2022 01:55

Dear God. I'm far from a perfect parent but I'd recognise I had failed pretty badly if I had to resort to these measures to stop my young child watching adult content that I'd already attempted to block

You are being very naive. Watching porn very commonly starts right around 11 or 12. It's just so easy to get at it, not at all like back in the days when they might happen to find an father's stack of magazines in a shed or something. It's easily accessible and designed to keep users coming back. Boys that age don't have a lot of defenses against that, there is a reason it's the number one money-making part of the internet.

Niahm · 21/03/2022 01:52

As a kid (and this happened to at least 3 of my friends around the same age too) my Mum used to give me overly harsh punishments for minor things and cut off all my support networks when I really needed them. After a while I just lost all trust and respect for her. The more she punished me the more distant I became, and the more distant I became the angrier and more desperate she became. She eventually became completely unreasonable so I just stopped listening to her altogether, and moved out on my own at age 14.

Hopefully it won’t be such an extreme case for you but PLEASE just get him to counselling and try communicating and helping him learn how to deal with his emotions properly instead of kicking him when he’s down🙏 (I know that wasn’t your intention)

MangyInseam · 21/03/2022 01:48

This kind of behaviour with kids who have tech - and specifically social media and games - taken away is not that unusual - completely disproportionate reactions.

It's amazing after a time of being away from it they become much more like themselves, with better mood regulation among other things. But it does take several weeks to get there, so I wouldn't back off on the 3 weeks myself.

musicviking1 · 21/03/2022 00:46

Three weeks is too long, my 12 year got a ban recently for three days leading up to the weekend. She was annoyed but not devestated.

Aria999 · 21/03/2022 00:39

DS is only 6 and so it's quite different but we definitely have a similar reaction to a 24h iPad ban (our iPad use crept up a lot during lockdown and it's hard to pull back).

However I think the iPad ban is good for him. It normally kind of resets his behavior, gets him to spend more time interacting with us and generally makes him a nicer kid. (It would clearly be good to have a bit less generally but he is very keen and works hard to be allowed it).

I hope the 3 weeks break will be good for your DS. In some ways it's unfortunate that it's at an important time in the game for him but it might be good for him to have to handle that.

As an aside I have used discord and it must really depend on the setting because the groups we ran with were just talking about tactics for beating the game.