Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friends cat catching birds

82 replies

bagpuss90 · 20/03/2022 14:22

Okay -so I know cats hunt and it’s hard to stop them … However AIBU in thinking my friend should not have a bird feeding station in her garden when her cat is catching and killing a bird practically every day -three in one day a couple of weeks ago . It just sits there in wait . It’s like they’re being lured to their deaths. She won’t put a bell on the cats collar so the birds have half a chance . Don’t get me wrong-I love cats. But she says herself the cat is slowly but surely wiping out the bird population of her garden

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MrsSkylerWhite · 23/03/2022 20:02

PinkSyCo
I just don’t not understand why cat owners don’t just put a bell collar on them. Anyone?“

Most cats have them off within hours.

AnastasiaRomanov · 23/03/2022 18:40

Mine has had the same collar for months. Probably a year. It’s a quick release one.

GrolliffetheDragon · 23/03/2022 10:43

I had a cat who would lose a collar within 24 hours every time, and others who would come in with their front leg through it or it around their lower jaw.

I've had cats for getting on for 40 years. The number of birds I've known them to catch, combined, works out as less than one a year, and they've all enjoyed bringing their prey home. I estimate that just under half were alive and appeared uninjured, in that they flew away on being released.

I don't regularly feed birds though. It's mainly jackdaws and magpies, and I do put food out occasionally in the winter, but keep the cat in until it's gone. Cat is terrified of corvids anyway, they don't take any shit from cats and they appear to deliberately mock him for their own amusement.

Ikeptgoing · 22/03/2022 17:30

I just don’t not understand why cat owners don’t just put a bell collar on them. Anyone?

Because my cats spend every waking moment after having a collar put on in the urgent enterprise of removing said collar. Strategies include almost strangling themselves on branches of our Laurel bush to lever collar off.

When we kept trying collars before, smug cats simply jreturn without them. They are effective sneaky blighters - but I stopped after twice (different cats) hearing this desperate yowling to find idiotic cat dangling trapped itself on low branch looking very angry and sorry. Quite scary if I hadn't heard ...

Ikeptgoing · 22/03/2022 17:20

Yanbu
I have cats. They kill birds and mice maybe once a month

(We have many lovely birds visit our garden who sensibly stay high up in the trees! )

But I sure as heck am not luring the birds to their death with a reachable bird table for a waiting lip-smacking cat!! That's cruel

BridesmaidPanic · 22/03/2022 15:54

@PinkSyCo

It takes me longer to get a collar on my cat than it takes for her to remove it!

Haha that made me laugh! Grin

Grin She's a little cowbag, honestly. Fights me when I try and put it on, then one swift paw under the collar and snap, off it comes!

I've given up now!

Typically, she's the hunter too, so we could really do with about 10,000 bells on her to stop her catching all the mice (where do they all come from?!).

incognitoforthisone · 22/03/2022 10:33

If you have a cat you should absolutely not have a bird-feeding station. It's literally just putting out bait, ffs.

Bells on collars don't make any difference really. They're nowhere loud enough to disturb a feeding bird.

I don't dislike cats at all and totally accept that people can't stop them from killing birds, it's just one of those things. But putting a bird feeder up if you have a cat is actively encouraging it to kill them, which is a very different thing.

NellGwynne · 22/03/2022 10:30

The cat needs a big noisy bell on its collar and the bird feeders need to be somewhere with no undergrowth beneath where the cat can hide.
I got some big noisy bells for our cat from Amazon. She has two on her collar.

OfstedOffred · 22/03/2022 10:29

We have two cats. No bird feeders, and we have bells on cat collars to make it vaguely more of a fair fight. I only take the collars off (temporarily) if we see rats or mice anywhere near the house.

CounsellorTroi · 22/03/2022 10:27

I’m wondering about our bird feeder and table now. We have no cats but there are cats in the area who we occasionally see in the garden. The table isn’t near a wall or anything. There’s a sparrow hawk in the area too. Saw it eating a wood pigeon the other day.

Lellochip · 22/03/2022 10:21

@PinkSyCo

I just don’t not understand why cat owners don’t just put a bell collar on them. Anyone?
They're incredibly annoying Grin
SleeplessInEngland · 22/03/2022 10:11

Your friend has to decide if she's a cat lover or a bird lover. She can't be both.

KittenKins · 22/03/2022 10:09

I've placed my bird feeder up high in a tree opposite my living room window. This way when my kitten goes out the back he is less likely to come across it, plus the height stops the neighbors cats who walk past from reaching the birds either.

If only I could encourage this darn pigeon from using it as an all you can eat buffet.

MrsSkylerWhite · 22/03/2022 09:51

Agree. We don’t have feeders because of our cats. Stop them accessing neighbours’ gardens too.

Gonnagetgoing · 22/03/2022 09:50

For those saying about collars. I had cats years ago who wore collars at first but then I caught the female trying to get it off on concrete!

My current cat doesn’t have or need a collar.

Old cat did have a collar but he wasn’t that impressed either. In fact when he got him which was young he had a collar but soon took it off him as had scent of his mum on not.

Bogeyes · 22/03/2022 02:00

Very cruel

AryaStarkWolf · 21/03/2022 23:44

Having the bird table in her garden is pretty gross of her

Voice0fReason · 21/03/2022 22:37

I just don’t not understand why cat owners don’t just put a bell collar on them. Anyone?

They are a complete waste of time!
Our previous cat had one. She was happy to wear a collar. The bell didn't bother her in the slightest, she was perfectly capable of stalking and killing her prey without dingling that bell once.
Cats stalk without moving their heads. By the time they pounce, it's too late for a bell to make any difference.

But I wouldn't use a collar now anyway. We were lucky that ours never got caught.

HRTQueen · 21/03/2022 20:22

Cats are the most intelligent hunters putting a bell on their collar most will learn how to move without the bell ringing

You can put things around bird tables to stop cats jumping up. I think it’s not fair of yours friend. But a prolific hunter like her cat is likely to find another easy spot for hunting

Has she got young children? My car became a mass murderer of mice when ds was small it was when he started to crawl he was teaching him to hunt. Now when a friend comes over with a young child the cat will bring them a present (mouse) he is very old but still has that instinct

Forgothowmuchlhatehomeschoolin · 21/03/2022 20:19

@PinkSyCo

I just don’t not understand why cat owners don’t just put a bell collar on them. Anyone?
Because the cat is in charge! If they don't want it, it ain't happening🤣
Mothership4two · 21/03/2022 20:05

@PinkSyCo

I just don’t not understand why cat owners don’t just put a bell collar on them. Anyone?

As others have said the old fashioned collars can be dangerous (I rescued our pet cat caught inside a bramble bush as a teen). Modern quick release collars are OK. Yes, the cats can get them off eventually. However, I buy them in bulk and add two extra 'loud' bells and keep replacing them - this seems to do the job as my large and feisty tom hasn't caught any birds in years. He has been wearing his current collar for six weeks now, which is long for him, usually it's two to three weeks and 48 hours is his record. They probably come off accidentally and not through him deliberately pinging it off! Some people think that a cat constantly being aggravated by a bell is cruel, but having observed him and our other cats, personally think they get used to it pretty quickly and it doesn't seem to bother them. My qualm is that the small clip part of the collar is plastic and not very eco, but we balance that against trying to save our local bird population. We have hedges and trees in our garden and tons of sparrows and many other garden birds.

Gonnagetgoing · 20/03/2022 21:53

@Onlyforcake

Sure. That's why the aim is to rid fragile ecosystems of these menaces, in more than one country.
@Onlyforcake - that’s a bit harsh!

My cat never catches birds, to my knowledge. She does catch wood mice in the garden but even so, less than expected. The cats which do catch rodents do a good service anyway.

MurmuratingStarling · 20/03/2022 21:49

FFS what is wrong with the bloody stupid woman? Shock

WE have bird feeders (and cats) but the feeders are way up where the cats cannot reach, and we throw stuff on the garage roof too. Result: birds get fed, and not ONE bird has been caught by our cats OR anyone else's!

I would legit be reporting her to the RSPB to be honest. Silly cow. Those poor birds. Sad

waitingpatientlyforspring · 20/03/2022 21:41

Our cat hunts. I hate it but DH encourages (he gives him a treat if he brings something home). I would never lure birds though so no bird feeders or bird baths etc.

Shmithecat2 · 20/03/2022 19:14

Sorry, I meant aren't, not are Blush