Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To what extent would you say the UK is a racist country?

457 replies

VladmirsPoutine · 20/03/2022 13:40

Bear with me on this. This thread is a culmination of some of the other threads I've been on and don't wish to derail. But thinking about for example ChildQ and the extent to which what happened to her was racially motivated, considering say the treatment of MM in the press which had a private school girl ostensibly painted as being 'straigh outta the hood'. I know that the UK is highlighted as one of the most racially tolerant places in the world, if not Europe. But just on the face of it I wonder, do you think the UK has a 'race problem'?

OP posts:
WeDontTalkAboutBrunoNoNoNo · 20/03/2022 23:53

@sst1234

Two examples of post racist society in this thread. Both of which are almost as bad as racism itself. Poster says that black cabinet minister is a bidder for the PM and that’s why she doesn’t get hate, implying that she’s not being a good little Black MP by playing identity politics enough. Another poster says implies that minority students don’t have the ability of to write long essays so the education system is institutionally racist. This is the kind of liberal racism that flows so easily, ironically from those who are trying to save the oppressed. This is the kind of racism we need to call out.
You are absolutely hell bent on twisting my comment to fit your own agenda. If you managed to extract that out of my comment, thats about your projection, not my words.
Anon778833 · 20/03/2022 23:40

@sst1234

Two examples of post racist society in this thread. Both of which are almost as bad as racism itself. Poster says that black cabinet minister is a bidder for the PM and that’s why she doesn’t get hate, implying that she’s not being a good little Black MP by playing identity politics enough. Another poster says implies that minority students don’t have the ability of to write long essays so the education system is institutionally racist. This is the kind of liberal racism that flows so easily, ironically from those who are trying to save the oppressed. This is the kind of racism we need to call out.
You’ve twisted the first example - that’s not what I read into that post at all. Your second example, I agree.
sst1234 · 20/03/2022 23:32

Two examples of post racist society in this thread. Both of which are almost as bad as racism itself. Poster says that black cabinet minister is a bidder for the PM and that’s why she doesn’t get hate, implying that she’s not being a good little Black MP by playing identity politics enough. Another poster says implies that minority students don’t have the ability of to write long essays so the education system is institutionally racist. This is the kind of liberal racism that flows so easily, ironically from those who are trying to save the oppressed. This is the kind of racism we need to call out.

Ilovegreentomatoes · 20/03/2022 23:31

Prime example was a news report about a blind man who filmed his journey on the tube to work with his dog every morning. How him and his dog got treated were shameful.

Ilovegreentomatoes · 20/03/2022 23:29

The worst abused in this society and in general are the disabled. We as a country do not facilitate them even half as much as we should including lack of public facilities, less job opportunities, lack of adequate public transport and how we view them in general. Yes racism is no doubt still an issue but it gets far more coverage and media attention than the disabled do.Sorry if it comes across as derailing the thread but I feel there are many more issues like this that get brushed under the carpet.

WeDontTalkAboutBrunoNoNoNo · 20/03/2022 23:06

We also need to change the way in which we mark and assess university courses in the UK because we know that written assignments (2000-6000+ words) is not always representative of POC's abilities.

This is bullshit.

Is there racism in academia? Absolutely. Is it because "POC" can't write properly? Not even a little bit.

ldontWanna · 20/03/2022 23:05
  • 2.18 Over the same period, 25 children under the age of 18 were subject of ‘further searches’. 19 were male and 18 were handcuffed during the process. The reasons for search primarily related to suspicions about drugs (20), followed by weapons (4) and stolen property (1). 22 (88%) of the searches were negative with an outcome of no further action recorded in 20 (80%) of the cases. In terms of ethnicity, (as per the codes used by the police), 15 (60%) of the children searched were Black, 2 were White, 6 Asian and 2 Arab or North African.*

Nothing to see here either.

Thoosa · 20/03/2022 23:03

[quote Burgoo]@Wedontcare123

Can you not read? I am unsure how I can be clearer.
Universities are already looking at changing how they assess knowledge based on the fact many students aren't as adept at writing down their thoughts and are just as intelligent and knowledgeable in their subject. Oral exams have shown to booster attainment in that respect.[/quote]
Second attempt at asking. Do you have any references for your assertion that POC aren’t as good at written assessment?

ldontWanna · 20/03/2022 23:01

@moanriver

I think the UK is judged extremely harshly as being obscenely racist - when those people are living in a bubble of having not actually experienced the very consequential and severe obscene racism in most countries in the world. Yet the UK particularly likes to naval-gaze about it. Really, I think people in day to day life are mostly getting on with it and rubbing along. Only media and some strata of society are so obsessed with labelling and colouring everyone. Of course not denying that some shocking examples exist, but why the UK is made out as some fascist racist breeding ground is just simply not true.
Nope. Nothing to see here.
To what extent would you say the UK is a racist country?
headspin10 · 20/03/2022 22:49

I think the U.K. is very racist and needs huge change.

Try reading 'White Fragility' Truly shocking.

Wedontcare123 · 20/03/2022 22:41

Can you not read? I am unsure how I can be clearer

Yeah i can read thank you. You as much as said black people can't write essays then try and dress it up with language that you think makes you sound clever or like you know what you're talking about, with no evidence to back it up. I also read your other post denying that a clearly racist incident was racist. Which makes you... What exactly?

gogohm · 20/03/2022 22:36

I saw the global scale chart thing just the other day, we are considered pretty good, but that's probably more a reflection on how bad most countries are!

We shouldn't be complacent for sure and we need to ensure that we treat everyone equally, no hidden inequalities that are racist in origin. And in the 21st century we need to be on the look out for reverse racism too (I wasn't hired for an accounts job because I didn't speak Hindi I was told, it wasn't on the job spec at all, but they felt I wouldn't be happy??? Why who knows

Thewindwhispers · 20/03/2022 22:34

Depends what you’re comparing it to. Is the UK racist? Absolutely yes, especially towards black people. (I’m white, but notice a definite difference between how my black colleagues are treated as opposed to how my Chinese or Indian colleagues are treated.)

Is the UK as racist as America, Middle East, Eastern Europe, and most of Asia including China and India? I’d say UK is nowhere near as racist as those areas.

I also think that police behaviour has got dramatically worse in the last couple of years: covid lockdowns with constantly changing and unclear laws created a real “us vs them” mentality where the more weak-minded officers have experienced being able to stop and fine basically anyone they liked for anything. The power went to their head.

moanriver · 20/03/2022 22:31

I think the UK is judged extremely harshly as being obscenely racist - when those people are living in a bubble of having not actually experienced the very consequential and severe obscene racism in most countries in the world. Yet the UK particularly likes to naval-gaze about it. Really, I think people in day to day life are mostly getting on with it and rubbing along. Only media and some strata of society are so obsessed with labelling and colouring everyone. Of course not denying that some shocking examples exist, but why the UK is made out as some fascist racist breeding ground is just simply not true.

Rummikub · 20/03/2022 22:30

@Burgoo

I also argue that social media and even the MSM massively distorts the actual scale of racism. Your average person isn't half as racist as those stirring up division on social media. We only get a snap shot of extremist views.
I’m basing it on personal experience
ldontWanna · 20/03/2022 22:27

[quote Burgoo]@IdontWanna

If that is how you read it. I suspect you didn't engage my post with any kind of intellectual curiosity. Which is to be expected when people can't critically think and show some nuance.

I did, quite clearly, suggest that racism IS a problem and the reasons why I felt that way. But you ignored that... I wonder why?[/quote]
Because you started it all by mentioning an incident that was clearly racist and was found to be so in a review and questioning whether it really was . Not to mention the statistics that show that children (including under 12) that aren't white have been strip searched in much higher numbers than white kids.

That kind of mental gymnastics and denial is racist in itself, so yeah it made the rest of your post redundant.

Siameasy · 20/03/2022 22:21

It’s human nature to stereotype based on something you have experienced eg…I see a young black male in dark clothing with a hood up….I’m wary….I’ve been mugged three times (this was London in the 90s) each time the assailant fit that description.

How is it that I’ve met a zillion more nice young black men over the years than those three baddies but it’s still not enough to 100% erase that little bit of “unconscious bias” I still have. Will it ever truly be gone? My subconscious probably thinks it’s helping me to stay safe; doing it’s job. (Incidentally, around this time we were also scared of “Russians” - society loves a bogey man)

I’m not far off 50; I remember the Brixton/Tottenham riots. The news made young black men seem terrifying. Winston Silcott’s face staring out; the papers would often report in a scaremongering way too eg “she woke up to find a black man in her room” - that’s an actual quote I’ve never forgotten because it frightened me at the time. Now I can see his being black was added as an “aggravating factor”, this was deliberate. We were and are conditioned. Is it a surprise people are biased against black people based on this type of reporting?! How could you not be? Young people now may say “oh I wouldn’t have been taken in by that”. Don’t count on it.

I now suspect we were intentionally told very little about important parts of our history in order to keep us all divided and also because a lot of it is shameful. I have made a point of learning what was never taught and also teaching my DC about it.

Burgoo · 20/03/2022 22:17

I also argue that social media and even the MSM massively distorts the actual scale of racism. Your average person isn't half as racist as those stirring up division on social media. We only get a snap shot of extremist views.

Burgoo · 20/03/2022 22:16

@Wedontcare123

Can you not read? I am unsure how I can be clearer.
Universities are already looking at changing how they assess knowledge based on the fact many students aren't as adept at writing down their thoughts and are just as intelligent and knowledgeable in their subject. Oral exams have shown to booster attainment in that respect.

Snoozer11 · 20/03/2022 22:13

[quote Easymeasy]@snoozer11 what about the birth announcement with the monkey that was in the newspaper? Do you have an excuse for that too?[/quote]
Doesn't need an excuse. It was one man's tweet. Not the mainstream media.

I love how you're using someone who was offered the best healthcare money can buy, best education for her children, a 35 million pound taxpayer funded wedding, a mansion, great food, a wardrobe of clothing, jewellery worth more than the average person earns in a year, and a life free of bills or financial worries as an example of how we are all oh so racist.

Especially when the person in question was raised in a white neighbourhood by a white father, privately educated in a predominantly white school and lived an entirely white western lifestyle.

Burgoo · 20/03/2022 22:12

@IdontWanna

If that is how you read it. I suspect you didn't engage my post with any kind of intellectual curiosity. Which is to be expected when people can't critically think and show some nuance.

I did, quite clearly, suggest that racism IS a problem and the reasons why I felt that way. But you ignored that... I wonder why?

Thoosa · 20/03/2022 21:55

[quote Easymeasy]@snoozer11 what about the birth announcement with the monkey that was in the newspaper? Do you have an excuse for that too?[/quote]
I think - as a point of accuracy- that was a tweet from a revolting radio host, who was quite rightly sacked for it (and still wouldn’t stop whinging away about it).

The tabloids weren’t the only guilty ones in that saga. SM was appalling.

WeDontTalkAboutBrunoNoNoNo · 20/03/2022 21:40

@sst1234 I didn't forget anything, I said what I said. I gave an explanation as to why there is a disparity between the treatment of her and Diane Abbott. Kemi works for Johnson. She regularly denies racism in the same way Jonson does, hence "doing his bidding". Literally nothing to do with her "acting white", everything to do with her being a shit Equalities minister.

ldontWanna · 20/03/2022 21:32

@HRTQueen

Oh maybe not enough people have heard of Beverly Hills that must be the reason…
Took me a while to figure it out 🙈
Guineapigssweak · 20/03/2022 21:29

As every country is. Some whites hate blacks, some blacks hate whites, some Muslims hate Jews , Some Muslims hate non Muslims, Some blacks hate Jews blah blah blah. To me colour and religion is intertwined. Humans mainly only stay with their own kind and culture. It's ingrained. It won't change.