Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To what extent would you say the UK is a racist country?

457 replies

VladmirsPoutine · 20/03/2022 13:40

Bear with me on this. This thread is a culmination of some of the other threads I've been on and don't wish to derail. But thinking about for example ChildQ and the extent to which what happened to her was racially motivated, considering say the treatment of MM in the press which had a private school girl ostensibly painted as being 'straigh outta the hood'. I know that the UK is highlighted as one of the most racially tolerant places in the world, if not Europe. But just on the face of it I wonder, do you think the UK has a 'race problem'?

OP posts:
Thoosa · 21/03/2022 16:46

@Saku I think you’re getting an unnecessarily hard time here because your (perfectly excellent) English clearly isn’t your first language and it’s coming through subtley in your mode of expression, but it’s perfectly clear what you mean. You were trying to understand the background to the incident before you responded to it or made assumptions and you were shocked that the poor kid hadn’t reacted. You weren’t blaming him. Just surprised. I get it. Victims are often shocked into silence, too, though.

SenoraMiasma · 21/03/2022 16:42

@aspargusaubergine

I come from upper class. My parents monthly income is higher then my whole husband’ family and extended family yearly salary combined.

You have equated class with income/money and that doesn’t gel well with our society.

I also think that some people are acutely aware of your background and sense that you make them feel inferior and are just making sure they get in their first. That’s when British society all of a sudden becomes a paragon of equality and meritocracy.

But international class definers don’t work here as subtly they are trying to remind you that there is a latent class system based on other things that prevails here.

You didn’t place yourself within those definitions and that’s what they are recognising. I think if you had said you went to a certain school/university/lived in a certain area it would have had more clout.

But then who wants to live in a world where people only gain respect because their parents earn a huge amount of money? It’s crass and shallow to define yourself this way.

aspargusaubergine · 21/03/2022 16:40

RedWingBoots That’s because I live in England.

I forgot to mention, I’m mixed race. Brown skin and natural straight hair.

RedWingBoots · 21/03/2022 16:38

@aspargusaubergine it's interesting you say "English" not "British".

aspargusaubergine · 21/03/2022 16:35

I am a foreigner married to a British man.

British husband comes from middle class family. I come from upper class. My parents monthly income is higher then my whole husband’ family and extended family yearly salary combined.

However I am looked down because of my accent and also not having a perfect English (of course it’s not my mother tongue).

People just assume I come from a poor place (I am from a developing country), I’m uneducated and came to England to survive. My MIL, knowing the extent of my family’s wealth, still look down on us. Whenever someone asks about my family they get shocked.

My personal experience is yes English people can be racist and look down on foreigners. Unless is some very poor person, so they can feel better trying to “save” them.

SenoraMiasma · 21/03/2022 16:27

@Comefromaway

I really think the media has created this polarised view of how the world works that scapegoats POC by aligning them next to structural problems. It’s as though there is a benign message being fed through to us the whole time which we absorb and it’s only once people have the headspace to think outside it they recognise the incredulity of the messaging. But if you are white and privileged, I think it ends there as ultimately you are not identified as being responsible for the problems whereas this subtle, drip feed of negative messages implies that POC are.

I watched for the first time the Oprah interview with MM and cannot understand how people could be critical of her and Harry yet the papers/media at the time had really got into that space with people and polluted it with negative suggestion.

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 21/03/2022 15:39

@allBeingATwatItsABingThing you are imagining that I already knew the history behind it when I reached there.
Think when you are walking on the road with music, suddenly one boy was being pushed. You don't know if they knew each other.
When I saw it first I didn't expect actually that will be a racial issue at all. I thought it may be 2 boys some rivalry or may be taking revenge thing would be happening(like some one insulted someone then other day their big brother comes for revenge).
I asked many things because I just wanted to know who started it all, like the situations in the park if children fight. When the boy told that he doesn't know him shock then I realised that it was a racist act.
Knowing already that it was a racist act and then asking him "did you do something to him?" would have been victim blaming ..... but here I don't see it.

There are many ways of determining what has happened without resorting to victim blaming. When dealing with school issues (I’m a teacher so do this a lot) and a child has pushed another child, I don’t ask the victim what they did to provoke the pusher. I ask what happened, from their point of view, to lead up to this event.

I wouldn’t ever berate someone for not shouting out after a random attack on them. That’s victim blaming.

Ask yourself:

Would you ask a woman what she did to deserve being sexually assaulted?

Would you ask a child what they did to deserve being physically abused?

Even if this attack hadn’t been racially motivated, what could the boy have possibly done to deserve being shoved over by an adult?

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 21/03/2022 15:05

If you'd witnessed a man punch a woman in the street and then run away, would you ask her if she had done something to deserve it?

Comefromaway · 21/03/2022 15:04

The emergence of openly racist views and actions from people I thought were intelligent, open minded people. Turns out the racism was always there but now it's become more acceptable to express those views in public.

The Black Lives Matters movement really brought it to the fore.

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 21/03/2022 15:03

This wasn't children fighting in the park though, it was an adult assaulting a child. And even after you realised it was racist, you still asked him why he didn't stand up for himself, and how he expects anyone to help him if he won't stand up for himself.

Agrudge · 21/03/2022 15:01

@Comefromaway

Just a few years ago I would have said that the UK on the whole is not overly racist apart from a few extremists.

How wrong could I have been (although I do think things have got markedly worse in recent years). I feel the country has gone backwards.

What's changed for you to feel like this
Saku · 21/03/2022 14:35

@JesusInTheCabbageVan

I saw a white boy 19-20yo old was on his bike with Deliveroo backpack. He pushed a 11-12yo black boy while riding past him in very fast speed from behind....I reached and asked "Is he OK and If he said anything bad to that boy, why he pushed him?"

You asked a 12yo whether he said anything bad to an adult who came from behind him, at speed and assaulted him? And then you blamed him for not standing up for himself. That poor boy.

Honestly, I think your post answers the Op's question, but not in the way you think it does.

@allBeingATwatItsABingThing you are imagining that I already knew the history behind it when I reached there. Think when you are walking on the road with music, suddenly one boy was being pushed. You don't know if they knew each other. When I saw it first I didn't expect actually that will be a racial issue at all. I thought it may be 2 boys some rivalry or may be taking revenge thing would be happening(like some one insulted someone then other day their big brother comes for revenge). I asked many things because I just wanted to know who started it all, like the situations in the park if children fight. When the boy told that he doesn't know him Shock then I realised that it was a racist act. Knowing already that it was a racist act and then asking him "did you do something to him?" would have been victim blaming ..... but here I don't see it.
Comefromaway · 21/03/2022 14:23

Just a few years ago I would have said that the UK on the whole is not overly racist apart from a few extremists.

How wrong could I have been (although I do think things have got markedly worse in recent years). I feel the country has gone backwards.

JudgeJ · 21/03/2022 14:21

I’m not sure why people think you can’t have experienced racism if you’re white?

Because it doesn't fit the agenda designed by the judge, jury and executioners.

EmpressCixi · 21/03/2022 14:10

@Burgoo,

Your racism definition:
The new definition that Merriam-Webster have suggested includes:
"Racism is prejudice combined with social and institutional power"

Isn’t from Merriam-Webster at all.
www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/racism

The current definition of racism suggested by Merriam-Webster is

  1. : a belief that race is a fundamental determinant of human traits and capacities and that racial differences produce an inherent superiority of a particular race

  2. a) the systemic oppression of a racial group to the social, economic, and political advantage of another
    b) a political or social system founded on racism and designed to execute its principles

LondonWolf · 21/03/2022 14:02

@headspin10

I think the U.K. is very racist and needs huge change.

Try reading 'White Fragility' Truly shocking.

Robin DiAngelo is herself a massive racist trying to convince others they think the same at as she does. And all the while charging multiple thousands of dollars to conduct seminars where she says the same in person to stupid white liberals. Not to mention the sales of her ridiculous books. That racist white woman sure is getting wealthy on the back of black people.
SenoraMiasma · 21/03/2022 13:02

*Without not within

It goes without saying that this it is the media’s message that perpetuates these arguments with sensationalist headlines. It creates the dissension.

SenoraMiasma · 21/03/2022 13:00

I think there might be a problem talking about structural issues and not addressing other groups that experience disadvantage, eg travellers. Not because people want to dilute the issue of racism but in our society, I think we identify areas where change is needed and look at the most serious/extreme first. I don’t agree with that but we are constantly sent a message of ‘lack of resources’ and priorities. In comparison, we have a lot of media coverage around POC and their communities and the message that comes across is that 1) there are still problems 2) we have tried all these different things and they still don’t work.

The sub context here is that ‘we’ ( the authorities, the experts, etc) have done al the right things therefore the problem lies within the communities. I think that is the subtle message that people absorb and then internalise so their response when discussing these things is based on a flawed premise.

Regarding the Jewish and traveller communities, both of which are deemed white but actually may include people of colour, there isn’t so much media coverage. Except online and then you really see the extent of people’s hate.

I think what I trying to say is that I don’t think we can talk of structural issues within recognising other communities as they interact, form and shape those structural issues from positions of privilege and disadvantage. Sometimes, when people reject a perspective a person of colour is sharing, it is what seems like a failure to recognise the bigger picture that they are rejecting, not the underlying experience or feeling.

Abhannmor · 21/03/2022 12:38

@Burgoo

RE: The racism against white people part of the conversation

Black (and a small, vocal number of white) scholars have apparently changed the definition in recent years (probably the last 20 or so).

It has now encompassed a power element. It used to be:

"The belief that different races possess distinct characteristics, abilities, or qualities, especially so as to distinguish them as inferior or superior to one another."

The new definition that Merriam-Webster have suggested includes:

"Racism is prejudice combined with social and institutional power".

So basically if you have prejudice it is just that. However if you have prejudice and you have social or institutional power then you are being racist. Which leads to the conclusion that you can't be racist against someone in power because they haven't got the potential to oppress you.

Do I agree? Its hard to say. I think it is helpful to notice a power dynamic and at the same time I think that if we just ignore that these things are a two way street it can be a tad messy. I mean, if your boss is black or Asian, would it be fair to say that you cannot be racist toward them? Even though they have the power in that dynamic? No of course not. That would be nonsensical.

I always find it a little dubious when it comes to social or political movements changing the definitions of words to fit a narrative.

Interestingly I must admit that I have read SO much on this issue since the BLM explosion a few years ago. Including:

White Supremacy and Me - Layla Saad
White Privilege - Robin DiAngelo
Back to Black - Kehinde Andrews
Biased - Jennifer Eberhardt
Why I No Longer Talk To White People about Race - Reni Eddo-Lodge
The Black Friend: On Being a Better White Person - Frederick Joseph
Natives - Akala

I found only Eberhardt's work to be nuanced and balanced and really respected her ability to combine evidence with her own personal narrative. Akala certainly has an impressive ability to explore the subject. Saad was perhaps the most sickeningly disgraceful piece of work I have read and DiAngelo loves cashing in on the suffering of black people. She then claims to be enlightened whilst using a circular (and rather gas-lighting) narrative that if you deny being racist then you have white fragility and this shows you are, in fact, racist.

Many of these works now add a power and oppression component and I am always curious as to why people feel the need to change definitions.

Intersectionalism innit. From those wonderful academics who brought you such gems as ' men can become women if they feel they are' etc. But ..is London a separate case? Separate country almost , some of my black mates thought so. I haven't lived there for a while but it seems genuinely multicultural or a plural society as we used to call it. I'm not sure how recent white immigration will affect that balance if at all. And whether language , rather than skin colour , will become the more important signifier of British identity?
HobgoblinGold · 21/03/2022 12:32

@Burgoo

Really interesting viewpoint and thanks for the book recs - I've taken a note.

I think the definition has to change because we understand more now - right?

Not that I don't think you're aware of it! But simply because you didn't mention it in your post - there's also the dimension of unconscious bias. The fact that no one is colour blind and we all make snap decisions on people before they've even spoken! I try to just be mindful of this. Keep myself in check so-to-speak.

Fimofriend · 21/03/2022 12:19

It is hilarious that so many people say that you can't experience racism if you are white. I am white but my hair is dark brown. But you are saying that it isn't racism when (mainly blonde) people call me the N-word, the P-word, or say that they "know I am lying" when I say I am not Jewish? Or when they assume that I had an arranged marriage?

I have had other white people with darker hair than me be racist and/or xenophobic towards me.

So it hasn't happened to you. Good for you. BUT THAT DOESN'T MEAN THAT IT NEVER HAPPENS!!!! And it is not exactly polite of you to claim that. It is neither woke nor politically correct either. It doesn't exactly make you an ally of people who experience racism that you deny many incidents of racism.

OneTC · 21/03/2022 12:16

I don't really care how it ranks against other countries, it's plenty racist enough. the fact it's better than some other place widely described as very racist isn't much comfort

I'm a white immigrant, OH is brown british. We are frequently treated very differently in the same situations

Quincunx · 21/03/2022 12:12

I now suspect we were intentionally told very little about important parts of our history in order to keep us all divided and also because a lot of it is shameful. I have made a point of learning what was never taught and also teaching my DC about it.

I don't suspect this, I know it. Not sure what decade it was that we all surrendered control of our children's brains to the likes of Mr Williamson and the basement extender, but recent events should have made everyone look at state education in a new light.

HobgoblinGold · 21/03/2022 12:10

@CremeEggThief

Agree with what you've said except I have not said nor do I feel I am a victim of racism here.

Burgoo · 21/03/2022 12:04

RE: The racism against white people part of the conversation

Black (and a small, vocal number of white) scholars have apparently changed the definition in recent years (probably the last 20 or so).

It has now encompassed a power element. It used to be:

"The belief that different races possess distinct characteristics, abilities, or qualities, especially so as to distinguish them as inferior or superior to one another."

The new definition that Merriam-Webster have suggested includes:

"Racism is prejudice combined with social and institutional power".

So basically if you have prejudice it is just that. However if you have prejudice and you have social or institutional power then you are being racist. Which leads to the conclusion that you can't be racist against someone in power because they haven't got the potential to oppress you.

Do I agree? Its hard to say. I think it is helpful to notice a power dynamic and at the same time I think that if we just ignore that these things are a two way street it can be a tad messy. I mean, if your boss is black or Asian, would it be fair to say that you cannot be racist toward them? Even though they have the power in that dynamic? No of course not. That would be nonsensical.

I always find it a little dubious when it comes to social or political movements changing the definitions of words to fit a narrative.

Interestingly I must admit that I have read SO much on this issue since the BLM explosion a few years ago. Including:

White Supremacy and Me - Layla Saad
White Privilege - Robin DiAngelo
Back to Black - Kehinde Andrews
Biased - Jennifer Eberhardt
Why I No Longer Talk To White People about Race - Reni Eddo-Lodge
The Black Friend: On Being a Better White Person - Frederick Joseph
Natives - Akala

I found only Eberhardt's work to be nuanced and balanced and really respected her ability to combine evidence with her own personal narrative. Akala certainly has an impressive ability to explore the subject. Saad was perhaps the most sickeningly disgraceful piece of work I have read and DiAngelo loves cashing in on the suffering of black people. She then claims to be enlightened whilst using a circular (and rather gas-lighting) narrative that if you deny being racist then you have white fragility and this shows you are, in fact, racist.

Many of these works now add a power and oppression component and I am always curious as to why people feel the need to change definitions.