Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To what extent would you say the UK is a racist country?

457 replies

VladmirsPoutine · 20/03/2022 13:40

Bear with me on this. This thread is a culmination of some of the other threads I've been on and don't wish to derail. But thinking about for example ChildQ and the extent to which what happened to her was racially motivated, considering say the treatment of MM in the press which had a private school girl ostensibly painted as being 'straigh outta the hood'. I know that the UK is highlighted as one of the most racially tolerant places in the world, if not Europe. But just on the face of it I wonder, do you think the UK has a 'race problem'?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EllaVaNight · 24/03/2022 11:59

Some people seem to fall over themselves to say how tolerant the UK is compared to other countries (not you, OP as you made a wider point). These people seem to think a vague hint of equality deserves a bloody parade. Equality doesn't deserve a round of applause. It should be the standard.

Personally, as a black woman, yes the UK is very racist. I work in elderly care and quite frankly prefer the elderly people referring to me affectionately as the nice dark girl etc much less offensive than the covert racism in every day life.

There is also a huge problem with white people telling me what I should be offended about and why, and accusing me of racism if I don't agree with them or my lived experience doesn't fit with their theory.

CremeEggThief · 24/03/2022 11:13

It doesn't matter of that girl was in possession of millions of pounds of Class A drugs. This should never have been allowed to happen.

EmpressCixi · 24/03/2022 09:37

In addition the child was at the wrong type of school to be a dealer/peddle drugs.

From what I know, every secondary school has a drug dealer or way to access drugs. I don’t think any type of school is exempt or safe.

That said, I’ve been strip searched was also on my period and had to remove my sanitary towel. They literally also cut my bra to pieces to ensure nothing hidden in it. It is very traumatising and I was a 39 yr old adult. I can only imagine how much worse it would be for a 15yr old and then be expected to take an exam! There was definitely racial bias in choosing her to search. And racism in making it a strip search, it never should have been a strip search as she is a child.

EmpressCixi · 24/03/2022 09:32

@Polyanthus2

In fact there is research out there that shows the people who use drugs the most aren't black people.

They are middle class white people - and the Gov and eVERYONE else just nods and ignores -
the teens who deal or work county lines are often black - the problem is imv that we all accept that there should be this drug trade with no recrimination for the drug users - whilst the youngsters get embroiled in gangs etc.
The police get the blame for stop and search etc but what are they supposed to do? the problem is all of us accepting that drug use should be allowed thus giving them an impossible task.

It's the kids that suffer.

This is true in that dealing/selling illegal drugs is considered to be a worse crime than using drugs. So the police naturally prioritise the worse crimes by going after the sellers/dealers of drugs rather than the users of drugs.

Most sellers/dealers of drugs are working class and most users are middle class. Working class is majority white but has disproportionately high % black people as well. Whereas middle class is also majority white but disproportionately low % black people.

So the justice system by prioritising the dealing/sale of drugs over the use of drugs as criminal offences is indirectly racist towards black people. Indirect discrimination is much harder to unpack and prevent than direct discrimination.

The stop and search statistics are direct discrimination/racism because the police are in working class areas and yet decide to search a disproportionate number of black people than white. They’re not doing stop and search in the naice middle class and upper class areas of cities.

ToiletPoster · 23/03/2022 13:13

@Polyanthus2

In fact there is research out there that shows the people who use drugs the most aren't black people.

They are middle class white people - and the Gov and eVERYONE else just nods and ignores -
the teens who deal or work county lines are often black - the problem is imv that we all accept that there should be this drug trade with no recrimination for the drug users - whilst the youngsters get embroiled in gangs etc.
The police get the blame for stop and search etc but what are they supposed to do? the problem is all of us accepting that drug use should be allowed thus giving them an impossible task.

It's the kids that suffer.

This is some backwards logic. Drug use is already illegal. If a police officer finds you in posession of illegal drugs, you are at the mercy of the judicial system. The reasons why there are so few prosecutions of drug users is because it's difficult to identify and, because there is generally no "victim", it will always be a low-priority crime, and rightly so. You could recreationally smoke a joint every evening without anyone apart from you knowing about it, unless you told them. Compare this to something like a mugging, where there is a clear, social vested interest to isolate the perpetrator from society. The vast majority of associated harm comes from the very fact that drugs are illegal in the first place. You can't make them more illegal. You can increase the punishments, but that doesn't seem to do much to curb usage.
Polyanthus2 · 23/03/2022 12:38

In fact there is research out there that shows the people who use drugs the most aren't black people.

They are middle class white people - and the Gov and eVERYONE else just nods and ignores -
the teens who deal or work county lines are often black - the problem is imv that we all accept that there should be this drug trade with no recrimination for the drug users - whilst the youngsters get embroiled in gangs etc.
The police get the blame for stop and search etc but what are they supposed to do? the problem is all of us accepting that drug use should be allowed thus giving them an impossible task.

It's the kids that suffer.

RedWingBoots · 22/03/2022 21:54

@MangyInseam the police target people based on skin colour. It is well known which is why your reliance on charging and sentencing statistics are bullshit.

In fact there is research out there that shows the people who use drugs the most aren't black people.

In addition the child was at the wrong type of school to be a dealer/peddle drugs.

If you aren't aware of these basic things which you can easily find out then it isn't surprising posters won't engage with you.

Trainbear · 22/03/2022 20:32

@ButtockUp

I do think the UK has a long way to go with regards to combating racism.

The media including tv programming and advertising is bending over backwards to be seen as NOT racist. Hence so many adverts depicting a white person with a black person.

Dramas where the main protagonist is black and their partner is white.

Yet many many black couples , Indian couples , south East Asian couples, eastern couples, Arabic couples also exist but the media seems to want to 'blend' white and black.

It's like these household named companies want to 'be seen ' as being not racist when they're only trying to appeal to as many people as possible.
Yet still appeasing white people.

I gather there was a backlash against a supermarket just two years ago which attracted a backlash over featuring a black family at Christmas.

I live in a part of England that supplies huge volumes of soft fruit as well as orchard fruit to the supermarkets.
These farms are completely reliant on Eastern European pickers. Many from Ukraine!
The level of hostility towards them is absolutely shameful.
Interestingly a number of these fruit farms have ceases to trade as the Eastern Europeans feel no longer welcome, thanks to Brexit. Hence fruit crops have been left to rot.
These pickers would spend months in draughty cold tents or substandard caravans just to provide the uk markets with 'locally sourced' fruit/veg.

Yet the white middle class keep espousing the ' locally sourced' mantra, particularly on MN .

As regards the first part I agree totally. The UK as a whole is 83% white, 13% non white and of that 13%, 4% black. Adverts do not reflect this. Ask the average person on the percentages and it is likely to be greatly different to the actuality. I can see why a company will want a black, a white and as few people to pay, so a mixed couple is the ideal solution. Likewise there appears to be a protocol of "black cannot be baddies" which causes angst. Locally a number of Syrians were housed in a nearby island.locald were told by police, council and media "don't even question this decision by the Scottish government or we will prosecute you as racist. As it was the Syrians were generally welcomed by the more affluent retired middle class residents. As for the local working class who were on the doorstep, they were under scrutiny to be good....
lovelyluvvy · 22/03/2022 20:29

...and not meaning to stir things up, but wanted to mention the taxi drivers were Pakistani though, not white.

lovelyluvvy · 22/03/2022 20:21

Can I say that although I've lived in a few countries and see the UK as less racist than most, I am really sorry to hear of some of the things people have experienced on this thread. I totally believe everyday racism happens, but of course if you're white you just don't see it so much. It's not necessarily wilful ignorance, although it can be, but mainly I think it's lack of awareness and not experiencing it for yourself. I think as white people we can only be prepared to listen and be supportive, but we just don't experience the same things. I remember when I was dating a black guy and he'd tell me about a racist comment someone had made about us while we were out, or the taxi wouldn't take him home at the end of the night. It was an eye opener - it's not that I wouldn't have believed it could happen, I'd just never experienced it before. When you mix in circles with people who are generally accepting and would never behave like that, it's shocking when you come across it.

Spooked102 · 22/03/2022 19:22

Yep I’m white british / Romany and the hate and racism towards gypsies is shocking.

SenoraMiasma · 22/03/2022 13:53

@Riverlily

I am very sorry to hear this. I don’t know what to say as I think most of us thought this was in the past.

RiverLily · 22/03/2022 06:59

@SenoraMiasma In Oxfordshire

MangyInseam · 22/03/2022 01:51

@Comefromaway

The racial makeup of that area is diverse, but the strip search stats don’t correlate. I haven’t got the figures to hand but I think it is maybe 40 odd percentage white British population in that area. (Though the stats are out of date as they are from an old census)

And a very high proportion of the searches produced no evidence/no further action taken.

The question though you have to ask is not about population - it's about who is doing whatever it is that they are searching for, which may not be the same proportions as the population.

In this case it seems like most of them are about looking for drugs. So the information you'd want to compare it to is what the racial backgrounds are of the kids in the school involved in drugs. Which might be quite difficult to find I suspect, you would probably have to try and get at it indirectly and sometimes that can mean you can't really get good data at all.

But people actually do I think intuitively understand the principle - no one seems to be saying the searches are sexist because almost all are of boys - people understand implicitly why that might be the case. A disparity does not always come out of direct discrimination.

The element of many not producing any evidence is worth noticing and would be something that I'd think could warrant more investigation, if for no other reason than it seems they aren't very effective at what they are trying to accomplish.

MangyInseam · 22/03/2022 01:43

[quote ldontWanna]@MangyInseam yeah sure. Whatever you say..
I'm too tired today.
The context is wrong.
The stats are wrong.
The review is wrong.
Nothing to see here, it's all a big conspiracy/coincidence.

Happy now?[/quote]
If you are too lazy to dig into the context around statistics, it's no use looking at them. That's just how statistics work. Telling people they are idiots or bigots for asking the question that anyone who works with data would ask is not being a good anti-racist, no matter what anyone says. It just makes it look like you are more interested in proving a point than actually understanding the problem.

Those numbers might be perfectly reasonable to use the way you intended, but you can't tell just by looking at what you posted, and you don't seem to have gone any further.

The purpose of looking at numbers like these should be to see where something is going wrong, and do something about it. That won't ever happen if you don't take the time to really understand the information.

BessieFinknottle · 22/03/2022 01:29

I'm so sorry you've gone through that RiverLily.

I don't see what living rurally vs in a city has to do with it SenoraMiasma? It's shocking and abhorrent behaviour anywhere.

SenoraMiasma · 21/03/2022 22:45

@RiverLily

Please tell me you are not in a city here. That’s awful.

X

RiverLily · 21/03/2022 22:33

I grew up in Apartheid South Africa and have experienced more racism in my 12 years here than I ever had before. It's mostly when I'm on my own. Men have said awful things to me. A lady spat on me. It has calmed down since having my child but there are still occasions. Now I have to have to prepare my mixed race child for what is to come.

SantaCarlaCalifornia · 21/03/2022 22:28

@VladmirsPoutine

I think one of the more surprising elements are the white people of whom make up the majority who are they themselves not racist and wouldn't ever conceive of being as such but who also don't see the every day racism that happens all around us.
I think you might be underestimating just how white most of the country is outside cities. White people that are hardly ever around other races due to proximity just aren't going to get it, in an ignorant way rather than a racist way in my opinion.
WeDontTalkAboutBrunoNoNoNo · 21/03/2022 21:54

It's also pretty clearly what the poster you were climbing aboard was saying.

Climbing aboard?

Let's see.

A poster says something that I deem to be a poor choice of words.

I explain why I disagree with the wording based on my lived experience of being on the receiving end.

I very clearly explain the difference between being colour blind and educating children about difference

You come along, decide that I must be wrong. Reiterate the same thing I said but because it's come from you in all your superiority it's far more legitimate than my commentary.

In amongst this, my lived experience as a black woman who was the black child in the hypothetical situation outlined by the PP is completely disregarded.

Seems very familiar....

Trainbear · 21/03/2022 20:14

According to Google and Wikipedia and a number of peer reviewed surveys.

MidnightMeltdown · 21/03/2022 19:57

@VladmirsPoutine

I think one of the more surprising elements are the white people of whom make up the majority who are they themselves not racist and wouldn't ever conceive of being as such but who also don't see the every day racism that happens all around us.

I don't think it's surprising that people don't see it when they aren't confronted with it. I'm mixed race, and although I was well aware that racism existed, I didn't realise the extent to which it still existed until I dated a black man. This might be partly because I have lived in predominantly white areas.

Also, it's only really over the past few years that I've realised that people who don't know that I'm mixed race, tend to perceive me as white. This is strange to me because I don't perceive myself as white, but it probably explains why I didn't experience the same racism.

phoenixrosehere · 21/03/2022 19:52

While annoying and also a little crazy if you think about it, this is very much the result of being told that anyone white needs to not have an opinion and ask "PoC" what they think about any and all issues that pertain to race and ethnicity.*

Or is it because for centuries, POC have always been seen as monolithic before such discussions were even had. A massive chunk of European and British history is mass genocide and enslavement of natives for the sake of land and resources. That also includes putting POC in zoos, experimenting on their bodies (with and without their knowledge/consent), and assuming ridiculous things because POC look just a bit different from them.

Comefromaway · 21/03/2022 19:42

The racial makeup of that area is diverse, but the strip search stats don’t correlate. I haven’t got the figures to hand but I think it is maybe 40 odd percentage white British population in that area. (Though the stats are out of date as they are from an old census)

And a very high proportion of the searches produced no evidence/no further action taken.

DamnUserName21 · 21/03/2022 19:38

Yes, the UK is a racist country. This can be overt or covert. But, as noted upthread, Brits are NOT alone in their racism. I do feel things have improved compared to previous decades. There is more diversity and far more mixed-ethnicity families.:)
I do feel that white folks can experience racism or prejudice (for instance, certain parts of Africa. Not to mention xenophobia.

As a child of the 80s/90s, I was called 'pki,' 'n' half-caste, darky, coloured. We had excrement put through our door and windows broken.
Now I receive far less blatant racism--I get asked a lot 'where I'm from?' even though I have a very clear British accent. I've been told to 'fuck off back to my own country' and been mocked with an Indian accent.

But none of this is as bad as the experiences of the black guy I dated a few years ago: he was spat at, he was verbally abused, he was assaulted, he was stopped multiple times by police when driving.

The UK has come far but there is a long way to go.

Just to addI detest using the term 'race'-there is only one race. There are multiple and diverse ethnicities. I also dislike the terms BAME (talk about lump a diverse bunch of folks into one box!!!) and PoC (what colour would that berainbow??!!)

Just my two cents!!